Tasty food and great service. Erin was tending bar and the only waitstaff. We always felt taken care of and appreciated for being there.

-- One star for the food, and one for the fact that I apparently got promoted to employee halfway through dinner. Our waitress was impressively absent. We asked for plates THREE separate times. Apparently plates were either on backorder or required managerial approval, because they never came. Eventually, I gave up and went behind the bar and got them myself. I'm still waiting to find out when my first shift officially starts. Then there was the ice situation. No ice. At a restaurant. Not "we're running low on ice." NO ICE. Apparently frozen water is now considered a luxury item. The real highlight was the manager, who seemed completely unconcerned that the service had gone completely off the rails. No urgency, no attempt to make things right, and seemingly no interest whatsoever. I've had better service at a self-checkout, and at least the self-checkout has the decency to thank me for doing everything myself. If you decide to eat here, bring your own plates, a bag of ice, and maybe an apron--you may be working a shift before dessert. read more

MUST Check your bill carefully before paying. Based on our experience, you're getting overcharged! RIPPED OFF We've dined here four times, and every single time our bill was overcharged. Even after we caught the mistake and asked for it to be corrected, there was somehow another "error" on the bill. This is NOT ERROR. At this point, it's hard to believe these are simply innocent mistakes but intentional. The restaurant gets busy, people are enjoying themselves, and most customers don't take the time to carefully check their bill. read more

Went in for lunch at 11:55 about 10 customers and it took til 1 pm to get an undercooked pizza and a sandwich that was all lettuce. Food quality is horrid. read more

Cold meatballs and lukewarm, reheated chicken wings. An order of pizza with eggplant produced an eggplant salad. The waitress sincerely apologized for an honest mistake and offered to take the Pizza off the bill. We insisted on paying anyway and she returned with a mushroom pizza. We stopped insisting to pay for the wrong order. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Z - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, Pennsylvania

Ordered food for 1145. Was ready at 1220. Horrible service. Got there at 1140 told me 10 mins. Kept making excuses.

Really great lunch special going this summer. Available for dine in or carry out. Highly recommend!! Tons of good food for a fabulous price. Food and a soft drink for $10+ The pizza has great flavor. Thin crispy crust with a good amount of cheese. The Stromboli is thick and juicy but not over the top. Our waitress was very nice and helpful. It was dead inside when we were there but she wasn't overbearing which is great. read more

See all

there was no basil so I went back in and asked nicely for it to be fixed and the kid went to the kitchen and said "nothings wrong with it he asked for bazel" the other kid complained looked at me and threw two pieces on, all in all they were just insanely rude and disrespectful. The pizza was also horrible. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - The Square Margherita 16" - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, Pennsylvania

Although I realize wood ovens cause the crust to burn, my pizza itself was tasty but the crust was burned black in several places. Just a bit over done for me. The wings were meaty and delicious. read more

Food was good as always, however the service was not very good to say the least. I mean the oldest person working in there must have been 18, felt like it was Anthony's Cold fire Lord of the Flies ‍ read more

This is my 2nd time coming to this location and it's still just as awesome. The waitstaff is so friendly and well organized. We didn't need a reservation and got seated very quickly. The hostess apologized for the 7 min wait, which was so sweet because that's really no wait time at all. Our server Izzy/Lizzy?? was so kind and provided awesome service. This place never disappoints. Even though they are known for their "well done" pizzas, they have many other favs, like wings and eggplant Parmesan dishes. Totally recommend this restaurant. read more

See all

Not a good experience at Anthony's Coal Fire Pizza in Wayne. Although the food and service was acceptable, my problem was with the check. My check for the food was approximately $33.00. After I left a 25% tip, ($8.25), the total check amount was $41.25. When I looked at my credit card statement several days later, I was surprised to see a charge for this dinner in the amount of approximately $73.00. It seems someone at Anthonys adjusted the tip amount and changed the tip from $8.25 to $41.25. I went back to Anthony's to speak to the Manager about this and although he acknowledged that his staff should have never did this, he refused to refund the "overcharge." Instead, he said he would have to check with his accounting office and that he would get back to me. He took my contact information but he never made any effort to contact me. In my opinion, this changing or adjusting of the tip was totally unscrupulous, if not illegal. Not once during my conversation with the Manager did he offer any type of apology for this disservice. My only recourse was to dispute the charge with my credit card company, which I certainly did. Although I have regularly patronized this establishment, I refuse to give my business to a restaurant that I feel is untrustworthy. read more

I miss the buckets of meatballs! They are so good I paid for the recipe and made them myself. Too much work for one meal so I freeze them. Please bring back the buckets! read more

Used to be a solid 5/5. Hope they can fix the operation. Takeout orders always miss items now. Dine in is disorganized, dirty tables, overcooked pizza and wings and slow service. read more

Well if you love burnt pizza this is the spot! Both times that we ordered pizza To go the bottom had been so burnt. Honestly the worst pizza I have ever had. read more

Stopped in for a mid week pizza. Food was decent. Ordered a pie, half shrimp scampi, half Paulie's Pie. I like Anthony's pizza because it's thin, and they char it. The pizza could have actually been cooked a little more. Service was lacking. Never checked in once during the meal or refilled water. Only stopped by when the pizza first got placed on the table, we hadn't even eaten yet. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, Pennsylvania

Undercooked pizza, overworked and or dough not risen properly. Way too much cheese. Wings tasted boiled in a puddle of buffalo sauce. Way too much salt. Shame on management for not getting the kitchen in order. read more

The service was great as well as the food, everyone was so friendly and they answered all my questions .

waited 30 minutes after they told me 10 minutes. I'll never go back. Yhe place was empty and still had me waiting over a half hour. I asked for a refund. read more

great coal fired pizza oven wings and onions too sit at the bar super friendly staff / service interior is really nice overall a strong contendor for the area with lots of options read more

See all

We did a carryout from Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza as part of my birthday celebration gift from my lovely daughters. The food was delicious. The person taking the order over the telephone got some of the order wrong, but was gracious and gave us a complimentary dish. read more

See all

Hands down one of the most miserable dining experiences I've ever had. Here's how it went down- I walk in this place for lunch and there are ZERO people in the restaurant, not even at the bar. I ordered two items off for lunch menu, wings and a pizza. The wings come out with ONE napkin (the waitress eventually brought more napkins when my pizza arrived three days later). Looking around at all the empty tables I saw that there were no napkins on any of the tables. Must be the owner's way of trying to skimp and save money. Wings were mushy, slimy with no good quality about them whatsoever. We get it, you "oven bake" your wings, but there is no reason to have them coming out like that. "Bake"them longer if need be. Finished with the wings now. Ten minutes go by. 15 minutes go by. 20 minutes go by....where is the pizza??? Again , there is NO ONE in the restaurant. After over a half hour my small, lunch special pizza comes out. Not even close to being worth the wait. Crust and dough were terrible, cheese and sauce barely passed as average. I will never understand why a pizza would come out 1/2 hour after I finished those wings. First off, why wouldn't they serve everything at once?? These are two lunch special items; I'm not siting at some fine dining restaurant with a group of people ordering appetizers expecting to wait on entrees...is this how simple brained the cooks and staff are? Even if that was the case, why would you not even start to make my pizza until my wings were finished?? The whole thing lasted over an hour. Bottom line- AVOID THIS PLACE if you don't want to waste your money in time! read more

Wayne, PA 11/30/25..take out horrible. their pizza may be great but we went 0-4, no pizza. Meatballs were not cooked thru (imagine biting into a meatball that's not cooked??) ....garlic knots....need to see the picture...they were biscuits drenched in garlic and oil. Vile. Literally...uneatable!! Tossed them. Eggplant..no sauce..its sitting in a plastic pan on an island. absolutely worst sorry, loved Anthonys in Wynnewood, PA...in Wayne...Chick filet is next door and a better option. read more

Service was TERRIBLE ! The food I had ordered was DRY!!!! Ended up having to put more sauce into the platters I had ordered ! A couple of bits into it found a piece of hair that wasn't mine ! Tried getting a refund back for it and they did not wanted to meet me half way on it ! Got my fair share on this/from place ! Wasn't good like I was told ! What a joke ! read more

I love the sausage pizza and the wings with the onion oh my god if you haven't tried these wings you don't even know what you're missing. 10/10 highly reccomend. I Ubereats them religiously so can't comment on service or ambiance but they deliver quick and warm and it's worth every bite and penny. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Wings - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, Pennsylvania

Boring menu. Small salad was tasty and huge. Meatballs burnt. Meatball sub had very hot peppers in it. Food took for ever and came out for each person at different times. Pizza was fair. Host was nice. The waitress couldn't care less. With prices today we demand better. Frustrating. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - The bar - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, Pennsylvania

See all

Great service and great ambiance! Love the vibes in there. Only thing I would say is the pizza came out a little on the burnt side with lots of borderline charcoal along the entire bottom and outside crust. read more

Food great service great! We go several times a month. Tonight we walked out. Others did too. A table of 8 college aged kids (they said Nova) were loud and obnoxious. It went on for 20 minutes before we left. We told the servers, but no action. We all enjoy a good time with friends. After a while you know when you are too loud. Be considerate of your neighbor tables. Please Curb your friends. We will give them a pass from now on. Too bad. A polite word from a manager would have sorted this out. read more

We went here on Sunday night 5/25, and after sitting there for over 15 minutes with no service (and with a 5 year old child!), we got up and left. We didn't even get menus! We had to walk up the host stand and grab a menu ourselves. My husband went to the bar to let them know that we were leaving since no one was waiting on us, and they just stared at him and shrugged their shoulders like they couldn't care less. Horrible service. I waited tables years ago in my 20s, and one thing I learned is that if you at least bring people drinks, that buys you some time and forgiveness. We didn't even get that. read more

My 29 year old son & his girlfriend specifically asked about and ordered a 0 Zero Alcohol beer. They were served alcoholic beer!!! Management's first response is that their menu is made by cooperate and the item listed as Zero Alcohol is not served at their restaurant. Education & training is needed! Update your menu! Lastly the server nor management apologized to serving alcoholic beer to a person who is 5+ years in recovery!!! THIS WAS UNACCEPTABLE read more

Great coal fired pizza!! Wonderful Italian options like broccoli rabbe, salads, eggplant!!

Though I haven't been in the physical location to talk about the service or the atmosphere, I have tried the food. I did get their wings and garlic knots to try, as I am on the hunt for good wings. Looking at the pictures online, the wings did look good; however, when I got my wings they really sort of fell flat. I ordered wings with buffalo sauce, and the sauce was barely coated. Just tasted like regular chicken to be honest. The chicken was good but I wanted the spice which was not delivered or really pictured here. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - 8 Wings, 6 Garlic Knots, 2 Dips - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, Pennsylvania

Great Food! Great Service--Bry is awesome! Great Quality! Thin crust pizza is excellent--cooked perfectly, Great Flavor!

Food - 3 stars, pizza sauce and crust good but burnt, I like a black crust but not so much that my hands were black from the ashes, meatballs were good Staff - neutral was there for takeout Price - a little high Atmosphere inside 4 stars read more

I won't be back. Pros - Friendly waitress Cons - Lighting in restaurant is horrible. Bathroom lacked sufficient lighting in stall and soap. The pizza program I don't need to hear about. Hostess will not seat you where you prefer. (Too tough to figure out) Pizza is just okay. read more

I found the pizza here to be pretty perfect. I liked the thinner, crisper crust. There were three of us and we decided to get a six slice half spicy sausage and half mushroom. It came out fast and our server graciously and literally "served" us our first slices. We attacked it with vigor. I also liked the decor and ambiance. Great photos on the walls, large bar, open kitchen were you can watch the guys make your pizza and it seems like they have a cool happy hour where you can get a five dollar side chick lol. read more

See all

I used to go to Anthony's in Ft Lauderdale when I lived there 15 years ago. Being new to the PA area, I noticed an Anthony's, which brought back good memories of the restaurant - so we went for pizza and wings. We sat at the bar and immediately noticed the 'fruit-like' flys. I've seen them before at a restaurant, and the new owner of that restaurant had to tear apart the bar to rid them. I sense something not right back there. Nevertheless, we sat and ordered a large margarita pizza and garlic parm wings. The pizza was no more than a cheese pizza with a very few basil leaves - very few. The pizza had a few extremely black burnt crust areas unacceptable and unedible even for coal-fired pizza where it is inherent and expected. The garlic wings were tasty, but not very temperature hot. All in all it was a disappointment and not the same place I remember. read more

This is the second time we've eaten at this location and it was really bad this time...we can usually force a bad meal down but we had to leave our meal and go across the street to chick fil a for dinner instead :( The wings were burnt and the Alfredo tastes like it came from a jar. The focaccia bread that comes on the side was also stale. We tried to eat it but it was really bad. read more

Anthony's pizzas are consistently good, especially the pepperoni ones. Their arugula pizza was the best but sadly enough, they don't serve anymore. Whenever we eat here, we end up always ordering the family salad and the wings. Their wings are insanely good and they can't be described, you just have to try them read more

My family and I made an impromptu visit to Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza on Sunday, May 12 ( Mother's Day). It was our third option as everywhere was pretty busy because of it being Mother's Day. My family and I had no plans on going out to eat but had some time to spare and decided grabbing something quick like pizza would've been a good idea. When we walked in Anthony's, we were pleasantly surprised to see that there was one bar guest, a table of two ( mother and son) and then my table of seven. I was shocked considering this was our third place because everywhere else has been so busy. Our server greeted us right away ( Izzy, I think her name was- beautiful girl, very pleasant and bubbly) she asked us if we have ever been to Anthony's before , we said no, she suggested trying a free sampler to try the app selections. We agreed and she offered to put two samplers in since we were a bigger table. We also ordered spinach dip, a lg Tony's hot pepperoni pizza and lg white pizza ( half ricotta/half without). Our spinach dip came out 15/20mins after we ordered with 6 pieces of bread to dip- we didn't even have enough bread for everyone at the table. The spinach dip was delicious and the bread they give you with the dip was also top notch. I did request to have more bread for our dip because we had so much dip still left. I also had to ask another server for refills ( we tend to not be needy but at this point we were already here for 40mins and only gotten our spinach dip and one round of beverages). Our pizza came out 45 mins after we ordered and at this point we were the only table besides the bar guest that was there when we first sat and ordered. Our white pizza was burnt, and not like a charcoal burnt. Like B U R N T - we didn't make a stink about it because we already waited so long for the pizzas and we were all starving at this point. The Hot pepperoni pizza was also very charred on the bottom but it was better than the white pizza. The white pizza was straight trash. The half that didn't have ricotta was hard- I even told my mom at one point that I thought I was going to chip a tooth. We also had to ask the host for napkins, and another drink for my dad, daughter and son. ( their second drinks- my mom, husband and myself got our second round when we ordered the spinach dip) What should've been a 45/60min dining meal turned into at 2.15min meal. I will say that we did arrive at a random time. It was too early for dinner but too late for lunch but the entire 2hours we were there.. we were still the only ones there and had to ask for everything. I totally understand we all have our good days and our bad days, and every girl working were adorable, happy and glowing. They were all super sweet and kind whenever I did ask for anything but it's the fact that I had to ask for everything. I also will not blame her for the amount of bread that came with the dip or how the pizza was cooked and how long it took; kitchen mistakes shouldn't fall fault on the server. This post isn't about the server- because again, we all have our days and maybe she was busy doing some kind of side work or other work. I get it, people get distracted and don't realize how much time has passed. I did write the company and got some standard HR message, which is also fine. I wasn't contacting them for something for free because I most likely won't be eating at that establishment again. If you like charred pizza, and waiting an hour for your food then this place is the place to go... if not, then find a mom and pop pizza shop! read more