Annabelle is a great restaurant despite the fact that not everything hit the mark every single time last night. It has the potential to be absolutely fantastic - a true home run - but there are just enough forced errors that I could not give it that coveted 5th star. Let's start with the basics. Annabelle looks and acts like a high end neighborhood restaurant - on the corner of Florida and R Streets NW. When I turned the corner and saw the building, it looked like a warm and welcome oasis in a residential desert. The inside lights shone with a warm golden hue, the outside lights twinkled like Christmas eve. The building is so cute and charming that it reminded me of walking to old world restaurants that I have visited in Italy or France - a diamond of a restaurant in a sea of old and dirty narrow streets cluttered with small cars I did not recognize. So too the inside is great. The dining room is smart, sophisticated and really top notch all around. Nora (the restaurant that previously occupied this space) had gotten tired and old - Nora's rustic interior hearkened back to an earlier era. But Annabelle has re-decorated the space to perfection. The wood on the walls is a very high end touch that looks great. The upholstery on the walls is not only visually stunning but it provides a quiet hush inside the dining room that is elegant. The decoration, from the tables and chairs to the inventive use of greenery, is simple and lovely. Whoever designed and decorated the place is truly gifted. Likewise, the staff is professional and highly skilled at their jobs. Friendly, knowledgeable and smooth - everyone from the hostess to the waiter to the bus people. So well done. Of course, the one place were Annabelle fails to attain the 5th star in my opinion - and it's not a loss, just a "you never quite made it there" - is some but not all of the food. Our party of 4 started out with the most scrumptious oysters I have ever had. The mignonette sauce (served on top of the oysters) was light and added without detracting from the flavor of the oysters themselves. Based on the 1st course, I had HIGH hopes! However, the next course was the grilled octopus. This was a near miss for me. The dish had all the right ingredients used in surprising ways - pomegranate sauce along with the seeds and just enough bitter greens to well balance it beautifully. Very well done on the concept. But the octopus itself was cooked too long and was slightly dry and spongy. That was a sad miss for me. My main course was tuna which was also cooked inconsistently. Some cuts were perfectly medium rare while some were well done. I know that is hard to get right every time and, if I was eating in my own home kitchen, I would not even mention it. But, when I go out for a nice and let me say it - expensive dinner - I expect more. Someone else at the table got the same entree and his tuna was almost well done throughout. Like the octopus dish before it, the tuna dish was inventive, visually beautiful, with obviously high quality ingredients, but the final result just missed the mark because of sloppy and/or inconsistent chef preparation. Don't get me wrong - I WILL DEFINITELY BE GOING BACK TO THIS PLACE AND PROBABLY MANY MORE TIMES THAN JUST ONCE! The attention to the building and the dining room, the high quality of the service and, yes, even the food, all conspired to create a wonderful evening out. Maybe it was the wonderful company I was with. Maybe it was the gin. But, all in all, I had a really great time and an enjoyable dining experience at Annabelle. I feel like this restaurant is one of those places that you can love in spite of the night's shortcomings. It is like being downgraded on your 7th grade math homework even though you came up with the right answer because you did not show your work the way your teacher wanted you to. In junior high math, you get down graded but - in real life - you overlook those small things because, in the end analysis, it is the totality of the experience that matters. OK maybe I have veered WAY off topic here - but, to me, I can forgive some problems with the food if the rest of the evening is excellent.
With Annabelle, I can see the time, energy, thought, hard work and yes even the greatness over the few shortcomings. Bottom line, life is complicated and a great dining experience is way more than getting every single detail absolutely perfect every single time. And Annabelle definitely delivered a great dining experience to me last night. So, those few minor details aside, I will go back to treat myself and I am certain that I will enjoy myself again as much as I did last night. read more