I went with a group of friends to try Rye Bunny, and sadly it was a very disappointing experience.
The set-up: You cannot make reservations and it is partially counter service. All guests must order all of their savory food immediately at the counter. However, after doing so they have a waiter and put in drink or dessert orders with a waiter. Why have a separate line that complicates the process and puts so much pressure on the party to decide in seconds everything they will want that night? We all found the model baffling and, in the case of a friend with a mobility issue, frustrating.
The interior: Beautiful, spacious, and well-decorated. There are a few larger tables (we were at one that seated 6), but for the most part it's better suited to small parties.
The staff: kind and helpful, albeit definitely stressed about getting us to decide what we wanted to order as quickly as possible upon entering. It felt like a poor set-up for everyone involved, both staff and diners, especially since dishes came out at a fairly desultory pace after that and the wait staff were around constantly and could have easily taken additional orders at the table. Really, why not just do full table service? I can't think of a single upside to the current model for anyone. Wait staff were attentive and so positive!
The drinks: my friend's cocktail was insultingly small. The picture attached is the full, untouched drink. None of us had ever seen a stingier portion for such an expensive drink. They frankly need to fix this - it started the meal off on a horrible note as we all looked at it being brought out and wondered what we were in for. Unfortunately, that feeling turned out to be accurate.
The food: The savory food tasted good, though it sadly wasn't outstanding or memorable, but the portion sizes were minuscule for the price. We were told the portion size increased as you went further down the menu, but that ended up not being true - particularly for vegetarians, this menu is not designed to have an larger plates; the only thing that goes up is the price. We enjoyed the cheesy potato pancake and the beets (but really, six tiny slices of beet on a plate for $19? Less than a single mouthful? These are not expensive ingredients). The wild greens ravioli was good but definitely missing something (a squeeze of lemon? Anything to make it less one-note), and again it was five (5) tiny pieces of ravioli for $28. The maitake mushroom was the worst offender of the night: $30 for one teeny bunch of maitake that you could have bought at the grocery store for $3. It was fine but again, not outstanding or memorable, and at that price and miniature size for the only vegetarian "large plate" it needed to be. The fried chicken tasted very good and had fantastic sauces, but for $29 there is simply no reason it couldn't have come with rice or bread or literally any starch to fill out the dish, which as it was was a tiny serving of chicken with nothing to complete it. Rice costs virtually nothing. Why serve unsatisfying dishes like this? However, we loved the flavors of the chicken, so there was that one redeeming feature.
The only bad food was the dessert. I'd seen early raves about the chocolate cloud cake and I honestly don't know what they ate, but it can't have been what we were served. It was objectively bad: the angel food cake was dry and had an unfortunate texture. It did not pair at all well with the sauce. The whipped cream tasted good, which is the only good thing I have to say about this cake. People at our table wondered if it hadn't maybe been baked earlier in the week and left to sit out for days to get stale. The creme brulee was overbaked and had, again, an unpleasant texture. All 6 of us were shocked at how bad the desserts were from a technical standpoint: they were significantly worse than even the quality of cakes you'd get at a grocery store. I forced myself to eat everything because it cost so much. I can't believe the people making them have eaten them, unless we were given the two flops of the night. I wish restaurants would think about last impressions when they put out a poor dessert menu like this, but then I'd hope they'd think about poor first impressions when they make cocktails like the one my friend was served.
Our visit started on a bad note with the cocktail and confusing hybrid counter service model, went through a rollercoaster of decent-to-good food at high prices with the tiny portions, and then ended with some of the worst desserts I've been served in a restaurant. This shocked me because I'd been to and loved Tail Up Goat, and I would have said their desserts were the standout. This restaurant was billed as a more casual, affordable version of Tail Up Goat, but it's equally expensive with much worse quality with a baffling and needlessly stressful counter-service model. Service and atmosphere are wonderful. I hope they improve everything else. read more