Cancel

Open app

Search

All Star Bagels - New Prospect

3.5 (18 reviews)

All Star Bagels - New Prospect Photos

ALL STAR BAGELS - NEW PROSPECT ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Good for kids
Good for groups

You might also consider

More like All Star Bagels - New Prospect

Recommended Reviews - All Star Bagels - New Prospect

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Typical bagel shop
Nicholas G.

This place has been here as longer as I can remember. It is a small little bagel shop with a hometown vibe to it. They have the usual suspects here in terms of bagels and breakfast items. I went with the sesame bagel with cream cheese and a plain with egg and tomato. The bagels were pretty good. It was soft but had a little crunch to it with the crust. They also had a clean bathroom in the back if you are dining in. I would come back here for a breakfast sandwich. The prices were extremely reasonable and it is always nice to support a local business.

a bacon and egg sandwich

Sandwiches were a joke. Barely any cream cheese and the bacon, egg and cheese was pretty much bare. Save your money and go somewhere else.

Dozen Bagels

See all

5 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 5
Thanks 0
Love this 3
Oh no 0
Photo of Nancy S.
3
233
491

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 11
Thanks 0
Love this 14
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Delicious chewy bagels and quick service. Lox was fresh and pork roll sandwich was delicious. Also love their pumpkin bagels!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Phil G.
71
79
7

13 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Anne C.
40
32
13

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Good food and nice staff. Never going to Rosko's again because they're rude and over priced, keeping my business here

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Freshest in town! Friendly owners and new management. Baked daily and lost of options.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - All Star Bagels - New Prospect

You might also consider

Harvest - Entrees 6/25

Harvest

4.5(329 reviews)
6.5 mi
•$$

I can't believe I waited so long to come back to Harvest. What was I thinking ?…read more We went out for lunch to celebrate my friend's birthday and Harvest turned out to be a great choice! The location is a little further than we would normally travel, but it was worth it. I loved all the farm to table foods they have. They even nicely promote all the partners they use right on the wall of the restaurant, so you know where all your food comes from. Everyone loved their meals! I had the Thai chicken sandwich and it was so flavorful and delicious. It came with a side and I picked baked sweet potato wedges that were really good and so memorable that a week later I am still thinking about them. Other dishes ordered were the chicken salad and strawberry salad which my friends both enjoyed. Our server was very good and didn't rush us as we were just chatting up a storm. The restaurant suggests reservations which are a good idea, especially for dinner. I will definitely be back and can't wait to put Harvest on my restaurant rotation. Sorry no photos this time... the food was just so good and we were hungry!

**Not a food review** Bad management. They would not honor a…read more$50 gift card from the prior owners. Looking at the prices, I'm sure I would have had to add money to get 2 dinners. So, they lost a chance to get a customer and receive a bad review.

Photos
Harvest - Cherry bread pudding very good!

Cherry bread pudding very good!

Harvest - TOP DISH Cioppino OUTSTANDING!

TOP DISH Cioppino OUTSTANDING!

Harvest - Red velvet cake

See all

Red velvet cake

The Skillet by Sal - Buttermilk Belgian Waffle with Berries

The Skillet by Sal

4.3(273 reviews)
8.3 mi
•$$

Genuinely not a single complaint about this place. The vibes inside AND outside are 10/10. I went…read morewith a friend in the fall, and sitting out on the patio was wonderful. This is definitely a popular spot, so be prepared for a potential wait. That said, we put our name on the waitlist for two on a Saturday during brunch and were seated in under five minutes! Also if you DO have to wait, there are a ton of shops in the area that you can browse. The service was incredibly friendly and attentive. Our server recommended several dishes to us, which I really appreciated. The price point is also extremely fair for the amount of food you get, especially considering how good the food is. The portions are generous, and everything we had was phenomenal. Highly recommend the s'mores iced latte, any of the skillets, and the toast sampler. I will absolutely be coming back!

The buzz finally got the best of me and I had to stop in and try The Skillet…read more The verdict? Worth it! While they are known for their giant stacks of pancakes and coffee flights, I was really only craving something savory and more lunchy to go with my latte (which was delicious) so I ended up, at my waitresses suggestion, getting the Mediterranean bowl. It was one of the healthy options (a section of the menu) but was absolutely delicious!! It came with a green sauce that I could have had by the bottle, was massive and hit the spot. Come with friends and get a little bit of everything, maybe even a table pancake, so you can make your way through more of the menu. They were swamped on a random weekday afternoon, so I can't even imagine how busy they must get on the weekends.

Photos
The Skillet by Sal - Chandelier

Chandelier

The Skillet by Sal - Coffee Flight

Coffee Flight

The Skillet by Sal - Patio seating

See all

Patio seating

Brownstone Pancake Factory - Oreo Blast & Vanilla Shake

Brownstone Pancake Factory

4.2(177 reviews)
7.2 mi
•$$

I really wanted to understand the hype, but unfortunately this one was a miss for me. I'm honestly…read morenot sure why there are consistently such long lines to get in because, based on our experience, the food was definitely underwhelming. First, the menu is HUGE. It actually reminded me of Cheesecake Factory, you open it and there are so many options that you're not really sure what the restaurant specializes in. Yes, everything is centered around pancakes, but even within each section there are so many choices that it becomes overwhelming. Sometimes, less is more!We decided to take some of the server's recommendations and went with the Fried Oreo Cheesecake Pancakes. Unfortunately, these were just way too sweet for us and didn't live up to the hype. There was so much going on that the flavors didn't really come together for me.My daughter ordered the strawberry shake, which was absolutely massive! I will give them that, the portion was impressive. But again, it was extremely sweet, even for a milkshake.I ordered the Steak Frites and asked for my steak medium. Unfortunately, it came out much closer to medium rare, so it wasn't cooked to my requested temperature. Overall, there were some fun and over-the-top menu options, but unfortunately the food just didn't impress us enough to justify the wait or the hype. Would I go back? Probably not. There are just too many other places I'd rather spend my time and calories.

We came here on a Sunday around 12:30pm and it was busy. There was no wait but it was always a…read moresteady stream of people. The menu is extensive, think of Cheesecake Factory menu, but not THAT big. I love the Carnival / Circus type of theming and the small carousel inside that actually works! I ordered a fresh squeezed orange juice, which is always delicious, no matter where you go. My husband and I started with the Jalapeno Poppers which were delicious and typical poppers. For my husband's entree, he got the 'CARNITAS BREAKFAST PANCAKE TACOS' which was three buttermilk pancakes stuffed with scrambled eggs, melted cheddar, pulled pork carnitas, diced tomatoes, diced red onions and shredded lettuce, drizzled with chipotle aioli. All I have to say is holy cow! That thing sounds big and it was BEYOND huge. All the tables around us were in shock. This will last at least 3 meals. I ordered one of their new items which was 'Country Biscuits and Gravy with 2 Sunny Up Eggs and 2 Sausage Patties'. You really can't go wrong with that. It was very yummy and much less intimidating than my husband's dish. We definitely do not have room for shakes or desserts. Maybe next time! The service was great--our server was very attentive throughout our visit. Everything was quick, but never felt rushed. The only downside was the bathrooms. They had no toilet paper in the stall I was in and it was a bit dirty overall. I would still recommend this place and come back... especially for a fun celebration!

Photos
Brownstone Pancake Factory
Brownstone Pancake Factory - Caramelo

Caramelo

Brownstone Pancake Factory - Taco Pancakes

See all

Taco Pancakes

The Buttered Biscuit - Blueberry stuffed French toast

The Buttered Biscuit

4.4(981 reviews)
13.6 mi
•$$

The restaurant has relatively little but generally upscale decor. Our server was attentive and…read moretook care of us, although she also had an angry scowl on her face most of the time we were there. Our portion sizes were fairly large and the food was delicious. We ordered the honey vanilla pecan stuffed French toast, the lemon blueberry stuffed French toast, and the Bavarian cream stuffed French toast. All three of us thoroughly enjoyed our food. On this off-season Thursday morning, the restaurant was not busy at all. Contrary to what others had warned, we had no difficulty and no delay in being seated or served.

Came up to Jersey for a basketball tournament at Hoop Group Headquaters and needed a place for…read morebreakfast. The Buttered Biscuit had high reviews and was extremely close. This place is located on the corner and parking appears to be street parking only. I stopped by around 11:30 and was able to be seated immediately. They have bar seating which is first come first serve as well as tables throughout. Bar seating was much quicker. After about 5 mins my waitress came and took my order. Challah French Toast, Homefries and Bacon. 15/20 minutes go by and my food came. The Homefries are a good portion. They are seasoned well. The bacon was warm and crispy as well. The challah French toast was delicious. I enjoyed my meal overall. Overall this is a good place that met my expectations. The food was as expected and the portion size was good as well. They do charge a fee for using your card as shown on my receipt. A tad bit tacky to me but I understand.

Photos
The Buttered Biscuit - Dining area

Dining area

The Buttered Biscuit - Asparagus cheese omelette with home fries and a biscuit

Asparagus cheese omelette with home fries and a biscuit

The Buttered Biscuit - Nice open interior

See all

Nice open interior

All Star Bagels - New Prospect - bagels - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...