Cancel

Open app

Search

All Star Bagels - New Prospect

3.5 (18 reviews)
Loading...

All Star Bagels - New Prospect Photos

ALL STAR BAGELS - NEW PROSPECT ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Good for kids
Good for groups

You might also consider

More like All Star Bagels - New Prospect

Recommended Reviews - All Star Bagels - New Prospect

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Typical bagel shop
Nicholas G.

This place has been here as longer as I can remember. It is a small little bagel shop with a hometown vibe to it. They have the usual suspects here in terms of bagels and breakfast items. I went with the sesame bagel with cream cheese and a plain with egg and tomato. The bagels were pretty good. It was soft but had a little crunch to it with the crust. They also had a clean bathroom in the back if you are dining in. I would come back here for a breakfast sandwich. The prices were extremely reasonable and it is always nice to support a local business.

a bacon and egg sandwich

Sandwiches were a joke. Barely any cream cheese and the bacon, egg and cheese was pretty much bare. Save your money and go somewhere else.

Dozen Bagels

See all

7 years ago

Helpful 5
Thanks 0
Love this 3
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Nancy S.
3
232
485

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 11
Thanks 0
Love this 14
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Delicious chewy bagels and quick service. Lox was fresh and pork roll sandwich was delicious. Also love their pumpkin bagels!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Phil G.
71
79
7

13 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Anne C.
40
32
13

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Good food and nice staff. Never going to Rosko's again because they're rude and over priced, keeping my business here

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Freshest in town! Friendly owners and new management. Baked daily and lost of options.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - All Star Bagels - New Prospect

You might also consider

King of Bagels and Subs - #9. Famous Club Sandwich

King of Bagels and Subs

4.0(48 reviews)
2.2 mi
•$

I LOVE their Black Russian bagel. It's so delicious! The Owner and employees are very nice here…read more They seem to have great lunch specials. Would love to try one of these days.

In Howell Plaza, you will find a little spot where you can find bagels, subs, sandwiches, and…read moremuffins. Brand: 4/5 Outside, the sign outside the business did not reflect the logo used for the brand, which has an updated look. Despite the outdated sign, I will say that I like the new logo, since it has that western aesthetic that maintains a sense of classiness. Inside, the classic brown tiles of the floor have an inviting vibe, along with the glass counters showing the food. Website: 3/5 It welcomes you with the standard Slice theme that comes with restaurant website, but only at the bare minimum. Because it typically applies to pizzerias, this red-and-green theme works against the website, since it could mislead the consumers. Also, none of the menu items have any images accompanying them. Ambiance: 4/5 The television did blare a little bit, and the table we sat at was near the cleaning area, so that sink smell kept coming. Nonetheless, I did think that the chairs felt comfortable enough and the tables had a large enough space between them. The waiting counter has a wide enough space to bring anyone's order into view without it becoming a nuisance. Service: 5/5 The staff went through great lengths to ensure we had an accommodated experience. Wait Time: 5/5 We experienced no interruptions during our wait time, and the orders came quickly. Food: 4/5 I ordered the Italian, which is essentially an Italian sub with salami, ham, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, onion, tomato, mayonnaise, vinegar, and oil, with orange juice. The ingredients and the buns had a fresh, natural preparedness. The buns held their form even as the ingredients started to pour out. I will say that the flavor resembles the Italian subs from other restaurants, though in this case, the mayonnaise had the most profound flavor which complemented the sub well. I did think that it had too much grease on it. A rule of thumb of mine is if I need to use multiple napkins to wipe my hands, then the food is too greasy. Worth The Money?: 3/5 Concerning food, I think that it reflects the internal conflict of the establishment's identity. Is it Italian-based? Is it diner-based? A strong recommendation I can make is to provide some menu items so unique they set King of Bagels and Subs apart from the other eateries into its own niche buffer zone. Hybrid eateries do exist and I can see a bagel-and-Italian diner working, but I just do not see it with the website. The food works with the ambiance, since it will offer you many options with a clear space. Likewise, the meals had the appropriate amounts of wait time and service. I did not have to worry about waiting, since the staff care about their customers. I do think that while the logo does have a good design, it only works so much, since I do not know how much the business itself reflects off the theme, especially if the menu appears pretty standard. I would recommend including that logo into more spaces, including even the sign if becomes possible. I will say that the menu items can have a high price. Is the price ultimately worth it? Not unless you wish to support local businesses. Other than that, any issues beyond principles will not entice you to go to King of Bagels and Subs. Rating: 4/5 Stars I can see how this establishment could become the King of Bagels and Subs, with the Howell Plaza as its demesne and the consumers' happiness as its regal mandate. For now, I do not see it. Recommend To... Anyone who works around Howell Plaza and need a quick bite at any time of the day. I can easily see how the King of Bagels and Subs could serve someone three courses in a single day, whether breakfast, lunch, and/or dinner.

Photos
King of Bagels and Subs - French toast bagel

French toast bagel

King of Bagels and Subs - King of Bagels and Subs brochure

King of Bagels and Subs brochure

King of Bagels and Subs - Black Russian toasted with scallion cream cheese. It is UNBELIEVABLY DELICIOUS!

See all

Black Russian toasted with scallion cream cheese. It is UNBELIEVABLY DELICIOUS!

Bagel Bistro - Sausage, Egg, & Cheese with Salt & Pepper on a Toasted Plain Bagel

Bagel Bistro

3.1(77 reviews)
8.9 mi
•$

Bagel Bistro has been my breakfast stop on the way down to the shore for my weekend fishing trips…read morefor many years. I've been getting a wide variety of bagels with cream cheese and they are always stuffed with cream cheese. This year I dipped my toe into getting bagels with bacon, egg and cheese and I was never disappointed. The bagels always have plenty bacon and are dripping with melted cheese. I am also grabbing bagels for my father where he's putting his own butter or cream cheese, and he's also a huge fan. I see complaints that some people feel the bagels are tasteless and I don't get that. I've tried almost every one they offer and have always been satisfied. Weekends I'm looking to get in and out quickly and their service is always great. They have my order and in a few minutes I'm grabbing a crumb bun and I'm gone. While I'm looking for quick exit there are also plenty of tables to sit down and spend time to enjoy your food. They also offer a variety of sandwiches and sub that I have just never tried.

Enjoyed bagels from bagel bistro! The French toast bagel was huge, fresh, and delicious. My…read morebreakfast sandwich was great as well, though luckily I checked my order in the car because it was incorrect and was missing 2/3 things i ordered. Small shop with a couple tables. Customer service was fine!

Photos
Bagel Bistro - This is my $13 veggie omelette "platter" - I should've checked but come on...no potatoes no toast...do better.

This is my $13 veggie omelette "platter" - I should've checked but come on...no potatoes no toast...do better.

Bagel Bistro - Porkroll egg cheese sandwich

Porkroll egg cheese sandwich

Bagel Bistro - Bagel dozen

See all

Bagel dozen

Bagel Country on 9 - Toast

Bagel Country on 9

4.1(46 reviews)
3.1 mi

Route 9 Northbound in Howell, NJ, has a number of small commercial strips, including this one that…read morecontains Bagel Country on 9. The store is laid out in a whimsical fashion, with decent bagel assortment to curry favor with most tastebuds. I stopped in before a meeting nearby, and enjoyed a fresh Onion Bagel with Veggie Cream Cheese. It was good, but not my favorite texture. It was more or less the same softness throughout, rather than a hard shell with airy pockets within. Plenty of onion flakes, though, and a broad breakfast and lunch menu for customers so inclined. Service was friendly and accommodating. My bagel was delivered to my table within minutes. Not a bad place to start the day. Four Bagels seems about right.

A wonderful little bagel shop right on route nine, you might even miss that it's there! Great…read morebagels, people and comfy indoor seating. I've lived in Freehold a long time and never actually knew this bagel shop was here. I don't know how. I was en route nine and needed a quick bite and found it using Yelp. What a great find! Small place very nice indoors area, great bagels, and happy friendly service. Starting with the bagels, I got egg and cheese on a pumpernickel bagel I thought it was great! They were very quick as well. I like this kind of Bagel. Very good for a sandwich. The indoors though really impressed me, they have areas for kids to play. Great place if you're bringing your family out to get a bagel. It felt really friendly and kind of like someone's home and walking inside. I really loved it! Recommended for anyone looking for a bagel shop on Route 9 on the northbound side in Howell!

Photos
Bagel Country on 9
Bagel Country on 9 - Delicious bagel.

Delicious bagel.

Bagel Country on 9

See all

Brooklyn Bagels and Deli - Whole wheat everything bagel

Brooklyn Bagels and Deli

4.2(61 reviews)
9.2 mi
•$

Decided to try this place after my go to (Eli's) sadly closed & got taken over by Bagel Nook. (Hate…read morewhen instagramableness beats quality & authenticity in the business game.) Well anyway I tried this place because it was close by & seemed to be a classic deli, which I trusted for bagels. The bagels are pretty good: large, they don't skimp on the cream cheese, & they're a great price!! They also have a few pastries, sandwiches, soup, snacks, & a variety of drinks. I def want to try a sandwich from them one day. There's always customers inside & the 2 people who work the counter (I think they might be the owners?) are genuinely kind & I always see them making conversation with their patrons. Love when a business tries to build a community. There's also a cute seating area outside. The only thing is that they seem to run out of bagels quickly, even on weekdays. I've been there twice now around noon & they didn't have a regular everything bagel (which is fine I just go for a whole wheat everything) but that's something to note... Make sure you get there early, sorry to all the not morning people! I think this will be my new go-to bagel spot, even though I'll miss my Jewish bagels New York bagels will fill the whole in my heart.

I absolutely loved these bagels. The owner was so friendly and the types of bagels were so unique…read more We tried literally about 6. My favorite was the original-- it's a mix of a bread roll and a plain bagel. I've literally never had anything like that before. I can't wait to come back to try more of the fresh options.

Photos
Brooklyn Bagels and Deli - Bagel with cream cheese

Bagel with cream cheese

Brooklyn Bagels and Deli
Brooklyn Bagels and Deli - 6 foot subs.  No party is complete without one.

See all

6 foot subs. No party is complete without one.

All Star Bagels - New Prospect - bagels - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...