Along this highway in Farmingdale, you will find an Italian deli that serves quality ingredients. I only went there to support local businesses, and I will say that I do not regret it. Brand: 5/5 Tenth and Willow is an Italian-themed deli located in Colts Neck Plaza in Farmingdale. The logo has the Italian flag emblazoned in the background. The solid aesthetics on the website of the sparkles and shining rays perfectly represent the brand. When it comes to the interior, I will say that they deliver on all they promise, for you will find many Italian food and ingredients throughout the establishment. Website: 5/5 It brings you immediately to an image of a sandwich, which makes a good first impression on anyone coming to the site. Scrolling down, you encounter the backstory and the menu with many selections from beverages to wraps to heroes. You will find at the bottom a regularly updated blog section filled with fun facts of Tenth and Willow. Wait Time: 5/5 I experienced no delay or disruptions during the time I waited for my order. Ambiance: 4/5 The establishment housed plenty of Manhattan Specials of varying flavors throughout the aisles. You will also find plenty of cookies and treats upon racks, including meats and cheese hidden behind large glass counters. The aisles and the space between them and the deli did feel cramped with no tables or seats available. Food: 5/5 I ordered the Maple Ham Hero, which considers maple ham, fontana cheese, lettuce, tomato, and balsamic glaze. The maple ham had a sweet taste, as expected, which complements well with the sharp fontana cheese and the lettuce. The balsamic glaze had its own strong taste. The bread held well and had a decent amount of crunch, without becoming stale. Everything in the hero stayed in place while it also had a rich, thick taste. Service: 5/5 The staff managed to get my order without any issues. Worth The Money?: 4/5 The selection of meals, such as heroes, definitely reflect the brand of Tenth and Willow as an Italian market-and-deli. While I did not have a problem waiting, it did feel cumbersome in a cramped area for my order. Nevertheless, the ambiance of exploring around the establishment did not have an issue with me, especially as I got to see the delicacies from the cookies to the marzipan. As for the Maple Ham Hero, the appropriate wait time matched the quality of the food. The organization of the food shows that the staff care about their ingredients. They make it clear on their website that most of their partners provided locally sourced ingredients. If that is true, then this establishment deserves more attention, and I can see how Italian restaurants would rely on this deli for their ingredients. While the website does not scroll down with silky speed, it does provide a sense of welcoming ambiance with its deep, green color. I will say ultimately that the price of the Maple Ham Hero and the experience going to Tenth and Willow was worth it. Rating: 5/5 Stars I have hope that Tenth and Willow will continue to have relevance in Farmingdale, and among those who prioritize Italian cuisine and ingredients. Recommend To... Anyone just starting an Italian restaurant and is looking for key ingredients, since you would be supporting local producers while propping up your local business, thus creating a network of local businesses that help the community through the local multiplier effect. I also recommend to anyone looking to add more to their Italian-inspired cuisine and need suggestions about which meats, cheese, or spices to use. If you like Manhattan Special, then I would also recommend this establishment to you. read more

Tenth And Willow - Tenth and Willow sign - Delis Near Me - Howell Township, New Jersey

See all

There used to be a barbecue place in this little plaza that is no longer there, so I stopped in Tenth and Willow for a sandwich. I never tried this place before. I had a tuna wrap (spinach wrap). The tuna was flavorful. My only issue was the spinach wrap. It took a little effort to bite through so I don't know if that means it wasn't as fresh. They had some other things I would like to try and will. As for the wrap, I would just call it a one off. read more

I stopped by for lunch and I'm so glad I found this place! Everything tasted homemade and full of flavor. You can really tell they put care into their food. The service was just as good-friendly and welcoming! read more

some of the best sandwiches in Monmouth County reasonably priced and an Italian specialty store the breads are magnificent. The staff and owners are friendly and a pleasure to do business with catering menu is wonderful and they carry the things to your vehicle. I tip them always and appreciate them for what they do. Great stop for a day off from cooking or just any day. read more

Service was great! Food was terrific Atmosphere is very nice and appealing to the eye as you dine. We both had nicely poured cold pints of Harps. Potstickers and a Hummus board with started the dining experience. Very good. I had the Prime Rib carver which included of course an ample portion of Sliced Prime Rib, caramelized onions, horseradish cream, baguette, & fries. My wife had an Impossible Burger with Muenster cheese, onion, lettuce, pickles, Marie Rose sauce, sesame bun, fries. I had to google for her what the Marie Rise sauce was...(a British condiment often made from a blend of tomatoes, mayonnaise, Worcestershire sauce, lemon juice and black pepper) She enjoyed it and we were both full so no desert for us. read more

I just stopped in here with my toddler. I stood there for about 10 minutes getting completely ignored by the guy behind the counter after 10 minutes. They kindly asked him where I can place my order since it seemed like I was being completely ignored. He told me to just give him one minute, so I did. I gave him actually more than one minute. He went ahead and helped someone who walked in right after me and took his order instead and continued to ignore me. This is horrible customer service. I don't know what is wrong with this guy behind the counter, but he clearly has a problem with women. He should be fired immediately and go and check your cameras if the owner is reading this. They will never get my business again. I've never felt so disrespected by someone behind the counter in my life. read more

Great customer service. Really great salads. Fresh food. Quality food that is priced well.

Didn't know this gem was here but glad I found it. Everything looked fresh. I loved the buffalo chicken tenders. Fresh and crunchy. The sandwich was also on point. Loved the turkey sandwich too. They had a ton of options and everything looked fresh. Bread is on point too. Will definitely be back. read more

See all

This establishment is nothing like a true italian delicatessen, vodka chicken parm sucked. Good soups. Good meats, good frozen goods.

We have been stopping here now for the past six months, have tried their meat as well as various deli items and everything has been delicious to say the least. It has become our go to spot for steaks which we usually do at home on a gas grill. Sort of off the beaten path in Farmingdale on Rt 33 but well worth the trip over there when you are looking for quality products at a fair price. read more

The food here is fantastic. The staff is very friendly. I especially love their chicken franchise sandwich on semolina bread. Their bread is fresh every day. They also have a lot of products from Italy to make authentic food. read more

Has changed over the past year. Should have kept the deli original. Expandition has ruined your quality. $$$ not worth it.

Review is based on the chicken cutlet sandwich. Quality was good and enough chicken to meet expectations. My only comment is that the chicken had no flavor whatsoever. Overall, very it was way too bland and had no taste. read more

This place was clean, the staff was friendly, the products were top notch, and all of the homemade food is outstanding.

We ordered take out a few nights ago but I never set foot in the establishment. I did not go there so I'm reviewing 10th & Willow solely on the food. My wife picked it up. I'm usually leery of only one review (it was 5 star) but because it was close and Farmingdale is in dire need of a good Italian deli, we gave it a try. My criteria for subs is pretty stiff; I'm picky. Too often you get them drenched in oil and vinegar and the bread becomes a wet sponge. Other times or even simultaneously its overloaded with oregano and that becomes the primary flavor. I'm also critical of places that use wonder bread baked in the shape of Italian bread. You will find none of the above here at 10th & Willow. The bread is really crusty and fresh. This is an absolute necessity if you want a quality sub, in my book. The ingredients were plentiful and very fresh. Lastly it was excellent. No reason to go elsewhere. I'm glad we found this place and will certainly be back. There's a lot more on the menu to try. read more

Very very good Food, outstanding service and very clean stablishment! I Will definetely be back. read more

Truly a gourmet market. I posted a picture of the boneless Buffalo wings. Super fresh with great heat. I think some sort of orange gets incorporated into the hot sauce but what do I know. Get their fried chicken cutlets for lunch. The best. read more

Tenth And Willow - Boneless Buffalo chicken - Delis Near Me - Howell Township, New Jersey

Food service and ambiance is a 10 We moved to Farmingdale three months ago to our surprise we have a place that has delicious food we've had two dinners. That was delicious. I love to cook for my family and since we moved in being pressed for time around the holidays setting up a new home we love across the street from the Tenth and Willow. We went were there, They have a lot of pasta jar food great refrigerator items prepare and cook food fresh Italian bread it has everything its like I don't even have to cook anymore. It's that good we have had two meals that we purchased reluctantly we were so surprised at how delicious food was.. I highly recommend this place. You won't be disappointed.. it's right on the corner of or close Colts Farm and 33. If you're driving by drive into the shopping center where they have Dunkin' Donuts Japanese restaurant a pizza place called doughboys, but this gourmet you have to try it stop in and look at their cook food and items, the have a small area kitchen items the refrigerator beverages for a deli. Has everything good cuts cooked items..It really so good it's superb.. I highly recommend this place. Don't hesitate if you don't have time to cook check out their prepared foods we did and we've been back three times already and we just moved in a couple months ago it's going to be my go to place when I don't cook! It's really good food that staff is willing to answer any questions you may have. It will be my go to place, for delicious food. And much more read more

I can not believe I've never reviewed 10th & Willow! I have been here multiple times & loved it every time. The staff is always friendly & helpful. My first time here I was going to VA & stopped for lunch to go. I had a sub that was out of this world, fresh & delicious. Another time my daughter went to pick up food for dinner & had a problem with her debit card. The owner told her take the food & pay for it the following day. Who does that in this day & age??? I love this place & will continue to support them. Everything is fresh; you can't go wrong. So thankful it's so close. read more

10th & Willow has a great selection of prepared foods, and serves up some tasty made-to-order sandwiches. Everything I saw looked absolutely delicious - they had a variety of meats, pastas, sides, desserts and other dishes. Tempted to try everything, we opted for a chicken salad wrap, a breaded eggplant sandwich and salted caramel biscotti. We loved everything! It's impossible to have just one biscotti because they're that good. The bread on my sandwich was fresh, and the breaded eggplant wasn't too oily. The staff is super friendly. Will definitely be returning next time I'm in the area! read more

First timer today and I was somewhat impressed. I order the Store Baked Roast beef panini, which was Roast Beef Melted Cheddar Cheese, Carmelized Onions, Horseradish Mayo. The sandwich could have been better. The cheddar cheese was almost paper thin, and barely melted on the panini press. After reading it on the menu I had high hopes of it being a hot sandwich, with a decent amount of cheddar and onions. Instead it was cold roast beef, half melted cheddar and cold onions. Not saying I wouldn't go back, maybe I'm wishfully hoping they consider making it that way. Other than that, basic Italian market store with a few specialty items. read more

Amazing salads! I just found this place and love it. All the prepared foods look homemade. My salad was fresh and awesome tasting. I'll be a regular for sure read more

I love this place! I've had a bunch of things from here, but my hands down favorite is the seafood salad. Too bad it is only available once per week. It is so fresh. It's right next to where I live, so I can walk there. Michael is so nice to me and my mom! He has a customer for life. read more

I have been into this deli a few times and I am always greeted with a smile when I enter. They have a nice selection of prepared foods and frozen items. I enjoy cooking so I usually go in there for just some small items. The chicken salad is delicious. I usually get that for my daughter to bring for lunch in middle school. I have tried the beef barley soup which is outstanding and so flavorful. I am looking forward to trying something new each time I go in. I have my eye on the rice pudding that is next to the cash register to try the next time I go in.They cater as well. read more

We frequent 10th & Willow at least once a week, if not more. The food is excellent and we've tried just about everything. Their meatballs are just as good as mine. In fact, I stopped making them at home. Nice variety of pastas, sauces, subs and prepared dishes. Their butcher meats are top quality. While you do pay a little more than the grocery store, it is worth it! Mike and crew are friendly and attentive. So glad to have this gem so close to home! read more

Mike and his staff are friendly they all go above and beyond to make their customers happy! I highly recommend buying and catering from here. You will not be disappointed! read more

I love the place! They are friendly( remember your name) reasonably priced and food is delicious! They always make you feel like you are their priority! I recommend them to all my friends and family. read more

Great food, many choices, love the sandwiches. Fresh baked bread, Italian specialties. Mike is great

Had the most amazing stuffed pepper ever. It was the best tasting mixture of rice, meat and seasoning. I highly recommend.

Wow, what great sandwiches. Must admit I'm not a big eggplant fan but the #6 is fantastic. Well balanced, light sandwich with great bread. A must if you come to 10th and Willow. Another surprise, the potato salad, WOW, really good. You won't be disappointed. read more

Had my mother's retirement party catered from tenth and willow last night. The food was very reasonably priced, free delivery, and WAS DELICIOUS. Everyone was talking about the food and it was the best "typical" catered dinner I've ever had (chicken franchise, meatballs, penne vodka, and green beans almondine). Will definitely be using them for all of our upcoming events. read more