Do not walk, run to this place! Absolutely amazing drinks and even better tacos!! The bartender Hunter was amazing! I will be back to try even more! read more

Agave & Rye - Indianapolis - Menu - New American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Had never heard of this place until someone suggested hosting a surprise party here. They did a great job accommodating a large party of 25 people. We were able to choose different options from what I think was a preset menu for the event. An appetizer: Elote or Brussel sprouts, an entree--two types of giant tacos or a big chicken salad. I loved the Brussel sprouts and salad. My husband said the Birria tacos were as good as they looked! Dessert was phenomenal! The biggest slice of chocolate cake I've seen in a while. The carrot cake and tiramisu were also delightful. Drinks come in fun skull glasses with cheeky names. I enjoyed the artwork and eclectic vibes. Our server was all smiles and super friendly. Would recommend having Agave & Rye for hosting a party. read more

See all

Agave & Rye grabs your attention before you even walk through the front door. Between the adorable patio, bold artwork, colorful décor, and free arcade games, there's something interesting to look at in every direction. It's one of those places where the atmosphere is part of the experience. The hostess immediately set the tone for our visit. She was incredibly welcoming, walked us through the menu, and genuinely got us excited to be there before we even sat down. Service started a little slower than expected--we waited about 15 minutes before our server stopped by--but once he did, he was friendly, knowledgeable, and clearly passionate about the menu. He was especially helpful when explaining the different tequilas and whiskeys. I ordered the birria tacos after hearing everything was made from scratch. They arrived surprisingly quickly, were loaded with meat, and definitely didn't skimp on the cheese. They looked absolutely incredible...which made it even more disappointing that the flavor didn't quite match the presentation. For my taste, they were a bit bland, even after adding the crema and dipping them into the consommé. The fresh pico helped brighten things up, and I still managed to finish one taco. The bourbon peach punch, however, was a winner. Even though the birria wasn't my favorite, I'd happily come back to try something else--I've got my eye on the ghost pepper salsa next time. Between the fun atmosphere, outstanding hospitality from the hostess, and an adventurous menu, I have a feeling there's still a lot left for me to discover here. read more

I had the queso and chips, it was really good. It's kind of my regular. I tried some different kind of shrimp tacos and they were good not great. The service was quick friendly, knowledgeable about the menu. I enjoy the Debbie and general atmosphere of this restaurant.. read more

So glad I found this place. What a fun vibe and delicious food! Our server was nice and somehow remembered everything in her head, which was very impressive. I don't think you can really go wrong with the tacos, and the flights are a great deal that let you try things in a smaller portion (4 inch in the flight instead of 6 inch for a single taco) for a lower price point. I think my favorite was the Jackpot (jackfruit carnitas with BBQ sauce). Appreciated that they had veggie options! If you're gluten free, one thing to be aware of are the taco shells - for the epic tacos, the standard is a crispy corn shell inside of a soft flour shell. I got the Crabby Patty which had a "guacamole cushion," which I learned meant there was guac between the two shells. If no cushion is mentioned, it's just the two shells. IF you or a friend ask for gluten free, it's TWO layers of crispy corn shells. Lot of crisp. Corn fritters were also tasty. Everyone I came with was happy with their meals. :) read more

See all

Great dinner here on a Monday night, especially given that it was day 1 of their new menu! We hit happy hour for margaritas and the passion fruit margarita with a tajin rim really hit the spot. For my meal I ordered 3 tacos- the standout was absolutely the new brussel sprout taco. I have been thinking about that taco for a full week. The other 2 tacos (carnitas and a beef) were both good, but the sprout taco was so fresh and flavorful. I would definitely return! read more

Agave & Rye - Indianapolis - New American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

We came here after seeing a broadway in Indianapolis show. It was nice to find a great restaurant that was open late on a Sunday. We ordered a great variety of tacos, the chips a three drippings (guacamole, salsa, queso) and margaritas (made them skinny - without sugar). The waitress was very fun too. The restaurant itself is close to Gainbridge fieldhouse and is decked out in a fun way with a bar area that has some cool arcade games, a dining area and a cool vibe all around. The only issue was the check. We could not get our check for a while and then it was hard get someone to take our payment. I felt trapped and really needed to leave. We were trying to pay for an hour. The table next to us seemed to be getting a lot of attention, but something was up and we got home super late. read more

See all

We stopped by because I had vaguely been told about this restaurant and we were really craving Mexican food/street tacos after a very long drive back from an event. The restaurant is sleek and has a cool vibe, but we immediately realized it was not going to be what we thought of when we saw "street tacos" mentioned during Google search. It's more of a metropolitan American Soul fusion place, with a heavy emphasis on loaded, uniquely flavored tacos instead of traditional Mexicana. The server was wonderful in explaining their menu and gave multiple recommendations, which I went with all of her great suggestions once I told her what I was craving. My husband didn't enjoy his appetizer, saying it tasted too sweet instead of savory for him, but the server was great at being aware of our plates and took the appetizer off our bill when she noticed he wasn't eating it without us even mentioning it. I got three different tacos, and the only one I didn't enjoy was due to the Mac n cheese that was stuffed in it. It just didn't taste or feel right having a taco with macaroni that was pushed in so densely that it became a sponge. The other two were great! My husband gave his burrito a 3/5, as he felt it was too much one note. Overall, don't come here if you're looking for upscale Mexicana, but instead want to enjoy interesting fusion flavors and fun cocktails. Great place for a group outing or celebration! read more

See all

We came back for the first time since the previous review. We came before a Fever game in the middle of the week. The restaurant didn't seem necessarily full, but the service this time was very unsatisfactory. The waitress we had, was very kind and apologetic for the slow service, she comped our chips & salsa and gave us a free queso (after she forgot we ordered it alongside the chips). The queso was delicious, the salsa was spicier than i remember and the chips were entirely different and many of them were still undercooked and soft. My bang bang taco was in special, and it was as delicious as I remember! The alderman however, had a good taste but I truly hated that the corn was ICE cold. It threw everything off for me, but my husband was fine with it. Overall, everything was fine. The free appetizer and delicious taco made up for the extremely poor service and uncomfortable seating (the space of the booth was uncomfortable. There was so much extra space!) Anyway, not quick to return, but I'd give it another go. Third time's a charm right? read more

See all

A fun spot a bit out of the hub so it was quieter and with plenty of seating. We were greeted warmly and got a booth quickly. We were there in time for the happy hour which offers drinks and food! We had some delicious queso and chips which were plentiful and crispy. We also ordered the crispy cauliflower bites which were amazing! I would eat those all day long as they weren't heavy and the sauce was light and tangy. Perfect! My epic taco was fun and delicious but way too much for me. The flight size was better as it was more typical street taco. Next time I would either do the flight and share or not get appetizers...just too much food and so good you didn't want to miss a bite! Overall a delicious menu and yummy food. We would go back and fun to try their taco Tuesday or other specials. read more

Agave & Rye - Indianapolis - Epic taco - New American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Been here twice now and definitely would return. The tacos are very innovative and are LOADED. The nacho tray is a must order. Honestly one of those places you can probably order anything and it be solid. I love 'The Bomb' taco - must order. Very nice bourbon & tequila list as well and the drinks here are great! read more

Agave & Rye - Indianapolis - Top to bottom - gangsta, bomb, crown jewel - New American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I sat at the bar and had a quick and delicious experience. Awesome and unique tacos! A few people told me not to go there because their "service", but I had no issue at all. The food is choice. This would be my second Agave and Rye (first was Columbus, OH). Service was quite fast, and the bartender was awesome. Definitely get some great food here and would recommend it. read more

Agave & Rye - Indianapolis - New American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

While in the area decided to visit here for the first time. We were warmly greeted and seated right away. Our server, Addison, was incredibly friendly and quick to explain the menu. The decor was unique and fun to examine. I ordered a strawberry lemonade, chips and queso for the table. For my entree, 3 mix and match tacos. I really enjoyed the gangsta taco. read more

Agave & Rye - Indianapolis - The Bang Bang The Gangsta - New American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

My family is never going to let me choose the restaurant (or the movie, but that's an entirely different story) again! Devour Summerfest 2025 is in full swing and I, my daughter, my cousin and my aunt always get together to celebrate our love of food. We often times end up at the same restaurant, but we've been trying to venture out, and this go-round I chose Agave and Rye. 3 out of 4 of us love Mexican food and cocktails, so why not?! Upon our arrival, 2 of our 3 vehicles lucked up by getting primo parking spaces right in front of the entrance, but I could see parking being a potential problem. Our 3rd parked somewhere near The Y. My cousin was waiting for us and had been sat in the God-awful booth that had a television inside of it, taking up the entire wall. You could literally hit your head on it during your meal. I immediately, went to the host stand to request alternative seating. I was met with some resistance, and informed that half of the entire dining room had been reserved for a private event (hosted by Eli Lilly). Eventually, we were moved to the bar. The decor is top-tier. It is very elegant meets street. Throughout the night, I noticed that the bartender (who was also our server) was "doing his big one" mixing and making all of those drinks! He was the only one behind the bar, and at times drinks were lined up and waiting for servers to come and retrieve them. He had good energy and checked on us often. My cousin ordered their Ghost Pepper Salsa and we were given fair warning regarding the level of heat. It was not an exaggeration...that mess was HOT! I only had a chip or two. The Devour Menu didn't have pricing on it, so I inquired and was told that it was $27 for the three courses. It was also Margarita Monday and their house margs were 1/2 off. I was told by the guests that got the frozen margs that they were really strong. I got mine on the rocks and it was quite the opposite. I tasted zero alcohol. Now for the food. Three of us got the Buffalo Chicken Dip for our first course. 5/10 - not at all what we were expecting. It was queso with a few pieces of the honey-chipotle grilled chicken floating in it. Nothing "buffalo" about it. Also, the house-made tortilla chips were much too thick in my opinion. Two of us had the Taco Flight for the entree. 0/10 - One person sent theirs back and opted for the burger instead. One person just let their tray wither and die on the table. The feedback was that the toppings were too cold, or the food had just gotten cold in the window waiting to be picked up. Also, the meat was tough. My cousin wrestled with a piece of steak and lost! I ordered the Cheese-Filled Enchiladas topped with Birria. 2/10 - The cheese filling was cold and hard and the birria was dry. It had good flavor, but it lacked moisture. I took it home, hoping that once reheated, I might be able to add some sauce to the birria...but alas, it sat in the fridge until I tossed it last night. Today is our trash pick-up. The highlight of the meal for me was the Strawberry Cheesecake Dip with Churro Chips. It was a nice, sweet treat, but they use the same thick tortilla chips, so I only had a few. I was later informed that my other cousin didn't come because he said "that place is booty!" I wished I'd been informed sooner! LOL I could see maybe returning for drinks (the frozen ones) and the vibes. read more

See all

***not sure what's going on Yelp*** I have typed out a review 3 times but it's gone. Great service every time, always friendly and quick no matter the crowd. Awesome drink deals all week and a happy hour. Free arcade games too. Beautiful doesn't describe it, it's stunning place, your eyes never rest. read more

Agave & Rye - Indianapolis - Expect margaritas - New American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

The restaurant is really beautiful inside and conveniently located right across The Alexander. If you're looking for unconventional tacos - this is the place. For example, you can get Mac and cheese + lobster tacos, which come with double shell - both soft and hard. They have lots of other options that you won't anywhere else, and they're really good. Definitely a great place if you're feeling adventurous. The staff was also very friendly and the kitchen was quick. 10/10 would recommend. Bonus - they accept InKind for payments. read more

I like the peculiar decor and the ambiance was wonderful. The music was diverse and good and there are just so many little details throughout the restaurant to captivate you. Additionally the restaurant is very clean and the staff is friendly. However, our server was a bit slow and we didn't get water until after about 15 minutes. The queso was average and my kangaroo taco was horrible. The Mac and cheese balls tasted undercooked and like raw flour but the other tacos were delicious. I enjoyed the birr read more

Amazing date night or girls night spot! The tacos here are out of this world. They have street tacos too if you don't like the OTT ones. And the margs are so fun and tasty! read more

See all

We were so excited to see this spot-we've eaten at an Agave and Rye in Chatty and it was fantastic! We were immediately greeted by super friendly hosts and shown to our seats. However our server did not continue that same attitude. We definitely felt like she had other places to be. We ordered an app and our food, which all came out quickly. Hubby ordered a beer which finally arrived as we were finishing up our meal. The food was good-but not as incredible as we had experienced before. Hosts were super friendly on our way out. The decor is amazing! read more

Agave & Rye - Indianapolis - Taco Flight (3) - New American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Agave & Rye was the perfect girls' night spot--fun, lively, and cute enough for pics while still feeling relaxed. The Happy Pappy was bold and flavorful with great balance from the pickled onions/cilantro, and the Quesabirria was a standout: crispy, cheesy, and even better dipped in the consommé. The Bourbon Peach Punch was the MVP--smooth, peachy, and strong without being too sweet. Overall: great vibe, two taco wins, and a drink worth coming back for. read more

See all

Enjoyed a nice dinner here with a small group. We tried a few different things, including the mac and cheese donuts, guac and chips, and multiple tacos. They have lots of unique items on their menu and everything was well made and quite tasty. Our server was friendly and helpful and everything we ordered arrived quickly. read more

See all

Two must gets: Brussel Sprouts & Bang Bang Tacos I know, this place does boast veggie life, but trust me, their veggies are delicious! The Brussel sprouts appetizer has almonds and the Brussels cone roasted and swimming in sauce. It's so good! The tacos are very unique and come loaded with toppings. I've tried quite a few of their signature tacos and my favorite by far is the Bang Bang which is a cauliflower and corn fritter taco. It works! I wouldn't recommend this spot for hard core authentic taco seekers, but if you are interested in trying tacos with a twist, give this spot a try. Best thing is they have a happy hour so some tacos are on special most nights. Check their website for the weekly specials. I also enjoy the drinks here. They range from cute to plain, but they are all tasty! read more

See all

We visited Agave & Rye for a team lunch on a weekday. Not too many customer so we got a 12 seater table in no time. I knocked off 2 stars cause the nachos were stale, possibly fried a day earlier. I then ordered shrimp Rangoon bites and a taco flight both which had so less salt and spices. It didn't just taste good, just something missing. I am someone who really takes my reviews seriously but for a weekday and no customers, plus with all the hype the food had to be better read more

Agave & Rye - Indianapolis - New American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Fun, tasty tacos! Where else can you get a taco with fried rice on it? The egg rolls, especially the carne asada one, will be craved from here on out. Great value for all the ingredients you get piled on the taco. The Palace of Versailles meets Miami interior is worth the visit in of itself. Food came out, quickly and hot with a very attentive server. Great experience, will be back! read more

Agave & Rye - Indianapolis - Taco Flight (3) - New American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

The food was pretty tasty. I liked the different vegan options. The service was decent. The ambience was fun and eccentric. Didn't like that the parking lot I found probably was price gouging because there was some kind of Disney event going on... I paid $30 for an hour but that's really not the restaurant's fault. Felt like the cost of the food might've been a little pricey compared to other spots I've tried in Indy, but the quality was up there. I liked that they had mocktails. I did steal the pineapple and jalapeño from my husband's real version to put on my own... I think they should make the non-alcoholic one that way. Once I've tried the other Mexican type places on my list for the area, I'll definitely circle back to this one. read more

See all

Stopped in for dinner. The old fashioned cocktail was good. The strawberry drink was delicious. The queso and chips were also very good. The happy pappy I think with carnitas was excellent. The happy meal was ok. The pickles need to be buried more inside the taco since they just fell off. The service was fine. The place is nicely decorated with video games in the back for people to play. It is walkable from most of the hotels and will definitely try it again. read more

Need to feed your taco/marg craving? Try this gem. I love the decor, has a great feel to it, especially on a warm night on the patio. The bar can fit approx. 12 people and there are many tables and booths for everyone. There are a few arcade games to play, which is nice, especially if you bring kids as this is kid friendly. We just had a few apps, but the service was really nice and quick. We came on a Weds around 330 pm and it was hardly anyone there. There are two bathrooms, each for both men and women. Ok ay the food-chips and queso were great. The chips are homemade and they were literally perfect. Tasted like they were made to order. I also got the cauliflower appetizer that was really good. It's savory and a little sweet. I also ordered the little red corvette margarita. Please make sure to stir it!! It was so delicious, sweet and tangy. It was a big glass so I only drank one and trust me, that was more than perfect. They had some great music playing that we were vibing to. Mostly 90s and 00s music. I didn't order tacos, but i saw them and they were HUGE. So if you have an appetite, you may only need a couple. They also have flights as an option, which are smaller tacos. BTW...everything is VERY reasonably priced. My marg was maybe $15 but the glass is actually pretty big so it was 100% worth it-mind you I had the regular size and they have an "epic" size so I can only imagine what that's like. Really enjoyed this place. read more

See all

Specifically, we'd heard about their HUGE tacos. The server explained that if you get a flight you only get the smaller sized tacos. We wanted the big crazy ones, so we went with full size. There was a happy hour that offered $1 off each full-sized taco, so that was great. We split 3 tacos between us, with an appetizer and drinks. Every taco was amazing. The only annoying part was the complicated ordering process that the server explained a few times and we were certain she was misinterpreting the menu language, and it confused everyone. read more

After reading reviews and studying the menu my wife and I had high hopes for this restaurant. The decor was funky and fun. Everything was brightly colored and interesting to the eye. Starting with the good, the elote appetizer was amazing as was the chocolate cake for dessert. The cauliflower appetizer was good in flavor, but soggy in texture. We ordered two margarita flights, a total of six drinks. We ordered varying flavors strawberry, mango, watermelon, peach, prickly pear, and blackberry. Unfortunately, they ALL tasted like lime despite the chosen flavor. As for the tacos, much was left to be desired. We ordered a total of six tacos, all of which ranged from lukewarm to cold. They load the tacos with the carb first (mac n' cheese, rice) which in turns takes up the majority of the room so when they put the miniscule portion of meat/protein on top it's barely there or falling off with each bite. We likely won't be back which is a shame because the menu and ideas behind the meals was beautifully thought out, the execution just wasn't there. read more

From the ambience, the artwork, the Customer service, and most importantly the food and drinks it was a 10 across the board. My buddies got margaritas and I settled for a bourbon peach cocktail. Our server even though she said she was in training she didn't act like it and made sure we had everything we needed. From the tacos, birria, and elite devil eggs the food was delicious. And we never thought elite and devil eggs can go together but we learned something new that day and it is definitely an appetizer must have. Would definitely recommend or hit up this spot again. read more

See all

I was staying in downtown Indianapolis for the day and was browsing through a map of the nearby restaurants looking for someplace to grab lunch. There were plenty of choices but once I spotted Agave & Rye, I immediately knew that was the one I was going with!! I've been to the Columbus OH location once and the food was great! So my taste buds instantly started to dance and mouth began salivating at the thought of the delightful culinary experience I'd had before. It was cold out so I decided to place a delivery order. Online ordering was fast and easy. The menu was full of deliciously interesting choices...dozens of tacos, burgers, burritos, salsas, queso, salads, and nachos to name a few. All of them with a unique Mexican twist! I decided on the quasabirria tacos, the french fries duo, and 2 orders of chips and queso. My order arrived about 30 minutes later and was prepared exactly as requested. The 3 quasabirrias were filled with tender slow braised beef, cheese, cilantro, guajillo chillies, and onions with dipping consome on the side. The fry duo was a mix of both waffle and traditional cut fries topped with cotija cheese and cilantro. I preferred the taste of the traditional cut fries and will probably only order those next time. The queso dip was both slightly spicy and creamy with plenty of thick cut tortilla chips on the side. Everything was flavorful, fresh, and the portion sizes were adequate! Agave & Rye was definitely a hit and will be my go to spot while in Indy. read more

Agave & Rye - Indianapolis - Quasabirria tacos, fry duo, and queso dip. - New American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Went for lunch on Friday 6.6.25, my first time here. Decor is super fun and elegantly funky. Couldn't try the margaritas or anything on this visit, but we did have chips and guac and the brussel sprouts to start. So good! For our mains, there are taco flights! My friend had the bang bang, filthy fajita, and bees knees. (See my pics of menu for what is in those.) I had the Swipe Right (chicken), the Alderman (carne asada) and crown jewel (lobster, mac and cheese) and each was delicious. #yum #ReviewsByRL read more

See all

Place absolutely rocks. Great outdoor seating with great service. There massive chips are phenomenal. Mac and cheese donuts are to die for. Waitress was really good . Recommend this place for sure read more

Agave & Rye - Indianapolis - New American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Very cool setting in a more relaxed and chill part of downtown Indy! Excellent and large space for groups, or just the two of you! Really fun decor, interesting menu with some unique offerings (like gator and kangaroo)...fun and tasty drinks and a good variety! Really enjoyed the vibe here and the tacos were delicious and service was good! One of the best values and a way you can taste multiple things is to order a taco flight! Definitely recommend this fun restaurant for something different in Indy! read more

Agave & Rye - Indianapolis - Super cute interior - New American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Love the paintings and music in the restaurant! It's a really fun & colorful place to eat! The menu is like a full steakhouse but everything is on a taco or in a burrito! Ha I love it! Really good food & drinks and spectacular. A little on the expensive side but worth it. The "epic" tacos are HUGE! Also didn't know they started serving hot dogs, which I didn't try but plan to next time! read more

See all

We went out on a Friday night. It's a cool place with lots of taco and drink options. Service was a little slow. Overall it was a cool place and the food and drinks were good. read more

Able to walk in on a Friday evening, no wait for 2 people. We visited the downtown location so there was street parking and it's pretty cheap! (ramps are around, too, but street meter is better option imo). Friendly server. We ordered the Irish nachos which is basically made with fries instead of chips. Very tasty but it was an app and it came out after the tacos and was lukewarm. Tacos were very good! Ordered 2 each: Filthy fajita and the gangsta (not pictured) The rooster and the grogu Tummy felt a little wonky that evening/following morning so proceed with caution read more

Agave & Rye - Indianapolis - The rooster (top) and the grogu (bottom) - New American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Walked in and immediately thought the vibe was cool. Loved all the decor. The food was amazing. I chose a taco flight with the chipotle chika, the gangsta and the alderman. I couldn't pick my favorite of the three because they were all soooo good. Definitely recommend this place. read more

The food is pricey but it was worth it. Total was about $55 for both meals and drinks. Friendly staff. Its super cute and vibey inside. I couldn't get enough of the decor. read more

Agave & Rye - Indianapolis - Chicken quesa and cocktail - New American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

What a fun little cantina spot in downtown Indy and conveniently located right across the street from our hotel. We came in as a large group of 20 and had made reservations ahead of time. They provided a slightly pared-down menu, but honestly, the options were still great and everyone found something they enjoyed. The real MVP of our visit was our server. She was attentive, organized, and somehow managed to take care of our entire party by herself without dropping the ball once. She even talked us into trying the ghost pepper salsa delicious, but definitely not for the faint of heart! The service was exceptional and really elevated the whole experience. The food was ok but the drinks were great, which made for an overall enjoyable evening. When we're back in the area, this will be a spot we'd happily return to. read more