Divine. This place is really divine!
Came here on Saturday night with wonderful Yelper Cherie O. since it was on both of our to-try lists for a while. I made a reservation for 7:30pm and everything went smoothly.
Our server, Darius, was really nice and was great at explaining all of the menu specials. They have 3 tasting menus, two different wine flights, and various a la carte items. He was not condescending or rude at all and when I inquired about the extra $5 for the tagliatelle option, he said "don't worry about it" which was really awesome of him.
I decided to get the seasonal tasting menu, and so did Cherie. I uploaded photos of all the stuff we ate since I noticed that Yelp was lacking in photos from Acero.
My first course was bruschetta with salmon and goat cheese. It was really delicious and the flavors paired quite nicely. Cherie had some type of mushroom soup. We tried each others and we both agreed mine was tastier.
Second course was (homemade) tagliatelle with mushrooms for me, and for her, she had the polenta with red sauce on top. I liked the texture of my dish better..the pasta was very soft and thin but not overcooked or mushy. But it seemed to lack flavor. Her dish had great flavor but we were both iffy on the texture since it was kind of mushy.
Third course (entrees) were rainbow trout with spaghetti squash for me, and for her, the sea scallops with mushrooms and I think potatoes... I reallllly liked her dish when I tried it. Mine was okay but not as amazing flavor-wise as hers. Also I didn't quite understand why they served my fish upside-down. Appearance-wise, it looked really unappetizing, but when I flipped it over it looked better. Maybe it was to keep the meat of the fish warm before serving? Either way, the trout was very good. It had the great flavor I love of rainbow trout without being too "fishy" and the spaghetti squash (one of the few veggies I really love) was a perfect pairing for it. I think if I were to return, I'd go for the sea scallops instead.
For dessert, I had this AMAZING chocolate torte. Oh god, it was so good. I liked that you could pretty much pick from any dessert you wanted no matter which of the two tasting menus you chose because all of the desserts are the same price. I would seriously come back to Acero again for the chocolate torte alone. It was so fantastic! The inside was soft and gooey and HOT and the cold ice cream melting all over it was the perfect combination. It's like the molten chocolate lava cake at Brio/Bravo restaurants only 10x better. It was rich without being too rich and it was dark chocolate without being too bitter. I picked this over the bread pudding (because the b.p. had raisins in it, ick) and I am SO glad I did. Cherie had this odd little combo of an espresso shot with a scoop of what tasted like almond-y flavored icecream (but I couldn't tell exactly) and it was kinda gross in my opinion but I think she liked it. I'm not a fan of coffee-flavored desserts, though, unless it is tiramisu!
I had the cheaper of the two wine flights and while all of the wines paired beautifully, I kind of wish I had gotten more for my money.
Anyway, to sum things up, Acero was great! I shudder to think of how many calories I consumed on Saturday night but oh well. *blush*
I don't think I'd compare this place to Niche unless maybe if their grand chef tasting menu is more "inventive" than the seasonal menu. The flavors were put together nicely in almost every dish but I feel like they lack that "shocking" or "innovative" feel that Niche has. That's not to say that Acero isn't a good restaurant, I think it's probably now one of my favorites (if only for the dessert alone!) it's just different. If you like Niche, true, you might like Acero, but for other reasons. I'd recommend trying Acero either way. You can even order things a la carte if you don't want to commit to the prix fixe prices, although I think they're a good deal if you aren't sure what things you'd like to try, it's a great sampler if you have a notion (e.g. prefer seafood, etc.)
Also Cherie informs me these prices are much lower for prix fixe meals than in, say, Chicago, so that's probably another under appreciated aspect of St. Louis--cheaper food. Also the portions were just perfect so I wasn't still hungry or immobilized with a "food baby" afterwards.
My only gripe is that certain menu items like the tagliatelle are "extra" dollar amounts added onto the price. If you're going to have a prix fixe menu, make the prices uniform! Hence the term PRIX FIXE. If it costs more to make a dish, then make the portions for the prix fixe smaller. It is, after all, a sampling or tasting type of menu so the portions are not intended to be full sized anyway! Just my 2 cents. read more