Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    1925 At The Mayo

    4.1 (11 reviews)
    Open 4:00 pm - 10:00 PM
    Updated 3 months ago

    1925 At The Mayo Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - 1925 At The Mayo

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Jared G.

    Atmosphere 1925's space is gorgeous. A dark interior (including the lighting) accented with gold strikes a balance between elegance and comfort, while modern light fixtures blend smoothly with Roaring Twenties touches. The music fits the theme without overwhelming conversation, making the room feel stylish yet inviting. For a hotel restaurant, it succeeds in creating a destination of its own. Service Service was handled by a team and was steady overall. Glasses stayed full, plates were cleared promptly, and our group's complicated bill split was accommodated with ease. A few missteps--like a server stumbling over menu items such as foie gras--stood out, but these are issues that time and training will resolve. Attentive and flexible, the service supported the experience without intruding on it. Dining Jumbo Lump Crab Cake ($28) A meaty crab cake opened the meal, resting on a bright white anchovy rémoulade. The first bite delivered clean notes of crab before giving way to the sharp, tangy salt of anchovy and a touch of acidity from the sauce, finishing with the faint licorice snap of fennel. It's a triple-C thick crab cake--generous in portion, rich in flavor, and well executed. Butter Poached Beef Carpaccio ($27) A stunning carpaccio. Each bite bursts first with the richness of beef, then eases into the creamy, tangy lift of mustard horseradish from the aioli, before finishing with the briny pop of caviar. Beautifully balanced and full of flavor, this is carpaccio at its best--simplicity elevated to a wonderful level. Lobster Fritto ($29) Each bite of the lobster fritto was dense, lacking the airy texture the dish calls for. The batter flavor overwhelmed the delicate flavor of the lobster instead of highlighting it. The accompanying aioli offered a touch of tang, but overall the dish felt heavy and bland. Black Cod ($34) The cod was cooked well, with clean flavors that paired nicely with the buttery notes of beurre blanc. But the addition of salmon roe created an imbalance. Warmed by the sauce, the roe pushed the dish into overly salty, fishy territory, overwhelming the delicacy of the cod. Wild Mushroom Bolognese ($27) Rigatoni rested on a whipped mascarpone and ricotta cream, but the components never came together cohesively. The whipped mascarpone was heavy in portion yet bland, offering little flavor and muting other flavors on the dish. The bolognese leaned sweet from reduced red wine but lacked depth, and the mushroom element was barely noticeable. Dry Aged Pork Tomahawk ($$$) A standout of the evening, the pork special was cooked to perfection, delivering rich, savory notes balanced by a bright, herbaceous sauce. The polenta was well-seasoned and silky, tying the plate together. It was easily the most cohesive and well-executed dish of the night and should absolutely be a staple on the menu! Cheesecake ($15) The Basque-style cheesecake carried a traditional flavor profile, complemented by a fig-walnut jam and burnt orange sauce. The sauce brought bitter citrus notes balanced by sweet fig and the earthy depth of walnut, making for a bold accompaniment. Unfortunately, the cheesecake itself was frozen in the center, creating an abrupt temperature and texture shift that undercut the dish. Dark Chocolate Torte ($13) The chocolate torte was grainy with an almost metallic note. While the chocolate itself came through, the topping of hazelnuts, coconut, and seeds created an airy, gritty texture that distracted from the base. The anglaise added some creaminess underneath, but overall the dish missed the mark both texturally and in flavor.

    See all

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 month ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 3

    4 months ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    2 days ago

    Good and drinks are great! Service is awful. Lady was rude, uninviting and seemed like she hated working here.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Jared G.
    11
    79
    963

    10 months ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Dave M.
    3
    158
    71

    4 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    4 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 2

    Ask the Community - 1925 At The Mayo

    Review Highlights - 1925 At The Mayo

    I always have low expectations for Valentine's Day, because restaurants are super crowded and restaurants are stretched thin.

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bars 3,000 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Vault

    The Vault

    4.0
    (730 reviews)
    0.3 mi
    $$
    Private events
    Locally owned & operated

    I went here with friends back in February for our first time and we all loved it. Both service and…read morefood were wonderful, and I thought the prices were very reasonable. I ordered apricot iced tea, the vegan fried chicken sandwich, and pineapple upside-down cake. I don't normally like chicken sandwiches that much, but this was really good. And the highlight was getting to choose any of the salads on the menu as the side salad that comes with it. I had the hearts of palm salad with vegan cheese instead of the usual parmesan. It was delicious! I also got to try the cauliflower wings and a bite of the Korean BBQ tofu sandwich. I liked that sandwich too, but not as much. I do like the way they fried the tofu, but it seemed different than what was described on the menu. It seemed just deep fried, but not battered. My only complaint is the layout of the building and the lack of directional signage. I didn't park in the parking lot, so I didn't know to enter from the back and I ended up on a long confusing walk both outside and inside the building before I finally reached the dining room.

    Dinner with family last night. Staying at a hotel a few blocks away. Great choice!…read more Variety of cocktails. Great slightly dirty chilled martini with lots of olives, as requested. Seated promptly without a reservation. Nice vibe, retro theme. Tyler, our server was wonderfully engaging, made good food recommendations, really appeared to be a good human, and made a good meal better ... Salmon cakes appetizer were a nice start, the salads were memorable -- fresh and refreshing -- and my crusted salmon was a completely satisfying entree and I loved the crunch (good portion size, great sauce, and accompaniments). And, Tyler made a great pot of coffee ... strong, rich flavor. I thought it was excellent value. Thanks Tyler!

    Photos
    The Vault
    Signage
    Signage
    The Vault

    See all

    Shuffles: Board Game Cafe

    Shuffles: Board Game Cafe

    4.3
    (105 reviews)
    0.5 mi

    We dropped by to spend a Saturday afternoon here on a weekend getaway. We were greeted and had…read moreeverything explained. We were sat at a table for two- that was the only thing I didn't love, we played a game that took up a lot of space and between that and the food and drinks we spread to the table beside ours until the place was packed. I get why, they were busy and needed to manage tables. Our server was very attentive- and the service was fast. The drink menu is huge and has a lot of fun themed sections. I appreciated the large section of mock-tails and non alcoholic options. We tried several things and it was all great. Great atmosphere and set up- some of the servers stopped by and chatted about the game we were playing, and we chatted with the other couples playing around us. Super fun vibes, they have a large game library with lots of options, set up to be easy to browse. $7 a person to stay as long as you like is a steal as a way to spend an afternoon.

    Look, for the most part the games and the venue were great and I love the concept. Some of the…read morestaff were very kind and helpful in finding games to choose as well. The lack of 5 stars is tied to 3 main factors: 1 - shoving virtue signaling in every corner of the store with pride flags and trans woke reminders does more harm then good. I'm all for love for everyone but why are you singling out trans and gay? It's virtue signaling and it's not needed to run your business. 2 - the $13 cocktail I ordered may have been 2-3 shots worth of liquid, basically it was so tiny and not worth the cost even remotely. 3 - the food is heavily focused on fried food, bread, French fries, i realize it's quick to cook but some healthier options would be nice. In general, I'm a fan of businesses thriving and standing out by shining through their product or service and not by shoving ideologies in peoples faces and virtue signaling. Until that changes, my family and I do not plan to return.

    Photos
    Shuffles: Board Game Cafe
    Sweet Potato Fried with Sea Salt
    Sweet Potato Fried with Sea Salt
    Shuffles: Board Game Cafe

    See all

    McNellie's

    McNellie's

    4.0
    (493 reviews)
    0.5 mi
    $$

    went to the downtown location for dinner. good food,…read moregenerous portions. my waitess was very good, courteous, thoughtful, professional, and checked often to see if was ok or needed anything. also, in the past, they had given me free slice of cake, cause it was my birthday. since, went in again near my birthday, asked if they still offered free slice of cake for birthday, even though it was not the same day, as my actual birthday, they said they still did. so was able to enjoy a free slice of their delicious carrot cake. also just cause it was free, might think they would be stingy about the free slice of cake. not at all, I was pleasently surprised the slice was huge, so had to get a to-go box to take it home. also the waitress herself, and several other employees were very kind and went out of their way to wish me a happy birthday. that was very thoughtful, and special of them to do that. (also there is one day of the week, not sure if it's on tuesdays or wednesdays they offer a "special discount burger deal") thank you again for the very thoughtful "happy birthday wishes", and free slice of cake for my birthday. had been very tough week, and their thoughtfulness and kindness was an unexpected, and very nice surprise. really needed some kindness that day. thank you, I'm very grateful. give them a try and bon appetite. doc

    11 years in the game with visiting McNellie's. From Burger Night to First Friday to late night…read morevisits... It's been very consistent with everything I've order & with customer service. From a recent visit on Valentine's Day due to a spot having their kitchen close early (my pops was performing across the street so when they were done, we came over here), I'm glad we ended up eating here. We came in, got greeted instantly & even got a table the moment after we got greeted. I find it wild that we usually get seated by the stairs in the middle, not in a bad way, I really like that table & we end up there a majority of the time when it's just us two. I wish I remembered our server's name, she did an excellent job. I went with the Whiskey Burger & it was incredible. The wait on the food didn't take long at all. The whiskey chipotle BBQ sauce stole the show. The burger was perfect. The sweet potato fries went well with the burger, I got honey mustard as my dipping sauce. I was so hungry that I ran through my whole plate in a snap of a finger. I enjoyed that night, no complaints whatsoever. Side Note: The Olympics were going on & Curling was on the television on my right. I actually looked up how the sport takes place & I learned something new that night (outside of the fact that Curling always intrigued me).

    Photos
    McNellie's
    Reuben Sandwich
    Reuben Sandwich
    Reuben Sandwich with Mom 's Sweet Potato Fries

    See all

    Reuben Sandwich with Mom 's Sweet Potato Fries

    1925 At The Mayo - bars - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...