Sent my Son and Daughter in law for their wedding gift. Needed repeat reservations…read more Please phone 585-415-8252. Susan M Ambrogio Former Education and Youth Coordinator Coca-Cola Systems. Thank you so much susanambrogio31684@gmail.com

Stonecutter Tavern at Belhurst Castle: Come for the view. Don't expect dinner…read more We were told there'd be a 20-30 minute wait, so we spent the time enjoying the beautiful grounds overlooking Seneca Lake. We came back 30 minutes later to find the restaurant nearly empty. We were seated immediately, handed menus... and then completely forgotten. Twenty minutes. No server. No water. No drinks. Nothing. The tables around us started asking us if we'd seen a waiter. When someone finally asked the hostess what was going on, her response was, "I have no idea and I can't really help you." For a destination restaurant that markets itself as a special occasion experience, that's simply unacceptable. Beautiful castle. Beautiful lake. Spectacular setting. Zero hospitality. We got up and left, as did the other two tables.

We came here while driving around visiting wineries. The grounds are absolutely beautiful. It's…read moresuch a nice view of the lake. This place has a lot of history to it and it's interesting to learn about. We had lunch outside. Our waitress was extremely friendly. She overheard us talking about how it was my mom's birthday and she surprised us at the end with dessert, which was really nice and delicious. The food was very good and we all enjoyed our meals great place if you want some sandwiches and to sit outside in the gardens.

Drool worthy view of the lake! Very classy at our menu price prices. I love that they offer…read moreSaturday sangria specials. Perfect for a Saturday afternoon. If you're super lucky, you'll get to watch a wedding party out the window.

A superb culinary experience! We had an amazing experience! After a private tour of the winery…read moreexpertly led, a 5 course creatively prepared gourmet meal paired with wines and explained by Cordon Bleu Chef Scott at the "Ravinous Table". The second course appetizer was a bacon cocoa Bird nest served among beautiful oak barrels with a tasting directly from one of the barrels. Highly recommend!

We had such an exquisite experience that I can not wait to get back! The tasting lunch is something…read moreI would suggest any couple or family do for a unique dining experience. It was beautiful and I enjoyed meeting new people. Ravines wine is also the best I have had on Seneca Lake. Dryer and more robust. Can't wait to come back!

This was by far the worst restaurant I've been to in a long time. Our waiter was extremely sweaty…read moreand rushed us into ordering all of our food and drinks at once. He only gave us a chance to order one drink, and when he did bring the drinks he brought over my husband's drink wrong right off the rip. Then the food came my pasta tasted like a five-year-old made it. It was two garlic. All the butter was at the bottom. The pasta itself was dry and my chicken look like someone just shredded it up and threw it on top. The chicken was wicked dry too. My husband's pot roast was OK but it didn't blow my pants off for the price that it was. To top it off our sweaty waiter, then brings over a cheesecake that I didn't even order. I said I might be interested in it and he just brings it over. I didn't want it. Two different couples left their tables and left the restaurant without even receiving food. All upset we should've left with them. Do not go to this place. It smells like cat piss. Super disappointed because we're on vacation and we were looking forward to this very romantic night I should've read the reviews so if you're thinking about going to this place, do not go

We recently celebrated a very important occasion at Edgar's Restaurant at Belhurst Castle and…read moreunfortunately left extremely underwhelmed and disappointed. Despite making our reservation months in advance, our table was not ready when we arrived. Once seated we then waited over 15 minutes before anyone greeted us, and after finally getting a waiter's attention, we felt rushed into ordering both drinks and dinner at the same time because service had already been so delayed. Throughout the evening we repeatedly had to ask for basic things, including bread, which we were told was coming but never arrived. The wait for food was extremely long, drink refills took far too long, and meals came out in stages, leaving some of our party's food getting cold while waiting for everyone else to be served. By the end of dinner, we chose to skip dessert and after-dinner drinks because we had already been there nearly an hour and a half. Our plates were never cleared before the check arrived, and while we understand an automatic gratuity was added for a large party, it was frustrating to pay such a significant tip after receiving poor service and a noticeable attitude from our waiter once he realized how unhappy we were. The property itself is beautiful, but the disappointing service, underwhelming food, and lack of concern from staff made this a very disappointing experience. Sadly, we will not be returning for another celebration or special dinner.

I've been here about three times; my mother's family has been from the area for over 50 years. I…read morehonestly think the service has gone downhill; it feels slower, although the staff is very friendly. The champagne was very tasty and delicious. My burger was cooked well, so I would rate it 4 out of 5. The seating area outside is pretty good also decent. The hand-cut French fries were very good, so I give them a 5 out of 5. The salad was good, and the chicken was amazing, but overall, the salad was quite ordinary, so I would rate it 2 out of 5. My mothers cocktail was alright decent but not amazing.

We went here for Easter 2025 and the buffet was very nice; it's a small place but they had the…read morestations in various places and they kept the food coming. The service was attentive and nice. The decorations and ambience were sweet and festive. We didn't stay in the premises so really enjoyed the grounds and views.

If you buy wine at the adjacent beverage store, there is no corkage fee! We brought a local…read moresparkling wine and loved it! The food here is really good! I highly recommend starting with the cheese plate. We only chose to do the single but the star is all the things that accompany it! For $12 a great value! For our meals, Schweety had the burger with a side salad and i had the Crispy Chicken entree. He really liked his! The salad portion of my meal was excellent, I would have preferred the chicken to be a little less crispy as it took away from the flavor of the chicken. Justin was a great server and gave some recommendation for our explorations in the area

5 stars for the service, 3 stars for the food…read more We visited for dinner on a Sunday evening and, thanks to our reservation, were seated right away despite the restaurant being quite busy. The service was excellent. Our waitress was friendly, polite, and attentive throughout the meal, making the experience enjoyable. The food was good, though it wasn't particularly memorable or outstanding. We both love poutine. The fries was good but the gravy was a bit too salty and it definitely need more cheese curds. Overall, it's a great spot for dinner with friends or family, especially if you're in the area and looking for a pleasant dining experience.

Delicious food and great service! We went twice on our recent visit to Seneca Lake. Make a…read morereservation!

We booked here because of the view of the lake. That was a misnomer, as there is a road and a…read morerailway line between the restaurant and the lake. However- the food was AMAZING!! I'll remember this experience for a long time.

I don't even know where to begin, this place was excellent. When planning our trip to Seneca Lake,…read moreSmoking Petes was the one restaurant that came up time and time again. It's a fan favorite on Reddit, and our hotel recommended the restaurant as well. When you drive past, there's always a parking lot full of cars for good reason. When you enter Smokin Petes, you place your order and they give you a pager. You can sit at the bar, there's plenty of indoor seating, but I definitely recommend taking advantage of their outdoor seating if the weather permits. Just based on the vibes indoors and out, you know you're in for a treat. Considering it was a Friday, the line to order and amount of cars coming in and out of the lot, our food was ready surprisingly quickly. For a starter we order wings in Alabama white. For our entrees we ordered their two meat combos, both opting for their brisket and ribs. For our sides we tried their mac & cheese, coleslaw, tater tots & garlic parmesan salt potatoes. Everything was excellent. The meat was cooked to perfection - the seasoning. On the ribs had a nice kick. The sides were fresh and definitely not diet friendly. The portions were decent, and we ended up taking home leftovers that made their way back to Long Island. By far one of the best, casual, places I've gone to eat.

Food is all so wonderful, corn bread tender and just the right flavor, pulled pork is tender and…read moredelicious along with the Turkey, sausage, ribs, chicken, brisket, my all time Favorite. The kids tried broccoli salad had a nice flavor but I had mostly the hard parts and not much the flurets. Mac and cheese was good, salt potatoes are assume. My husband liked the slaw, thou he likes it with pineapple. He was not overly thrilled with mac salad. Drinks I tried were the blueberry smash. Very tasty. Not that thrilled with the peach drink that was 25 dollars. But I drank it. Tastes more like a Ice tea drink. Service is good. They take your order at the bar with a designated area to wait in line. Give you a buzzer to pick it up at the window. They have a condiment area to get soda, utensils, sauce sides and so on. They have seating inside and out side. You can play with games they have set up. Inside it decorated with old and new signage. They have a book of bourbon selection. Bar stools chairs and tables,booths and high top tables. People clean up after themselves. Kid friendly. People are friendly. Most of the times we went they were busy or at least a steady flow of customers. If you get a chance to stop here to eat you will not ve disappointed!!

OMG!!! Deliciousness! We were lucky to get seats at the bar on a busy Saturday night, but MAN! I am…read moreso glad we did. Could be all the wine in me talking (though I don't think so from the way everyone was chowing down), but this was some Grade A BBQ! Pulled pork was laced with sauce - sweet, sticky, not the least bit dry... the spare ribs were so tender, Smokey and flavorful and honestly not a whole lot of fat... and the brisket, well it melted in your mouth. Honestly - just way too good! Drinks. Food. Service. Company - 10 for 10!

I loved the setup and ambiance, and the first-come-first-served policy (no reservations) is a great…read moreconcept. Coming in on a Tuesday night, the place was busy and the wait was about 30 minutes -- but there was free seating at the bar. Fair enough, not many restaurants were even open in Geneva on a Tuesday. The food was solid -- nothing extraordinary, but nothing to complain about either, and the presentation on those big plates is genuinely fun. The lady bartender had her hands full preparing drinks while also serving everyone seated at the bar, including food orders. It was sometimes hard to catch her attention, but overall she did a great job juggling it all. What really bothered me: the owner (CB) is one of the few Master Sommeliers in the world and a big promoter of the FLX wine region (which I love), so can anyone explain why a glass of FLX wine costs about 40% more than a glass of California or even Australian wine? That's not exactly "Think NY, Drink NY" -- despite those charming stickers around the restaurant (which I do love).

Great food, wonderful atmosphere! We've made it a part of our weekly routine to grab breakfast here…read moreevery Sunday morning

Great value! What a lovely brunch we enjoyed at the Water St Cafe. We didn't go more than 5 minutes…read morewithout a warm-up on our coffee. Excellent service. The portions were generous and food was flavorful. As a starter we enjoyed home fries loaded with homemade sausage gravy. That was a meal in itself! The coffee mugs were a hand-thrown pottery that was unique and beautiful. We stopped in on a Saturday and there was a local brewery offering their drinks, along with a volleyball team raising money for a trip. Lots of young people in the "team room". It was an engaging spot to enjoy food and we would definitely return! Good meetup place for friends.