This place was located near our Airbnb! It was very good. The barbecue is delicious. Service was outstanding and very friendly staff.

It's just okay. Judging by the line of this place you would think it was top notch. Let's talk about the pros. It's clean considering how busy it is. Portions were good sized. Food was good (not the best I have had in New York) Cons. I absolutely hated that I waited in line just to order for 30 mins. Then I found a table just to wait at least another 45 for my food. I have never waited this long for BBQ. You serve your self to get your drink and bbq sauce since they don't add any sauce or put any out on the table like most bbq places. This day they only had one sauce out. The honey mustard. Both the original and the hot bbq sauce were empty. I told the bartender and still nothing. This was a big disappointment to me. This place is a one and done for me. I don't feel I need to go back. read more

The food was amazing!! My corn was kinda cold but flavorful. The mac and cheese was some of the best I have had of course the meat was fantastic. I had a combo with ribs, brisket and sausage. The service was great. We had never been here before the bar tender took the time to explain everything and all the options with acting like it was an inconvenience. This is more a bar with some tables but was very clean and comfortable. read more

Smokin Petes - Street corn, mac and cheese, brisket, ribs and sausage - Barbeque Near Me - Geneva, New York

I finally got to try Smokin Pete's! Delicious BBQ with a wide variety of sauces. Clean and comfortable inside with fun decorations. Versatile and expansive outdoor area. The service was very friendly and fast (around 2pm on a weekday), although I have heard there can be a wait if you go at a busy time. Brisket and ribs were falling apart, the beans were pretty good, the broccoli salad was perfect to lighten up the meal. We also got tots on the side and the bartender recommended Alabama white bbq sauce to go with them - the combo did not disappoint! I had a bourbon drink as well which was delicious and, in my opinion, similarly priced to other alcoholic beverages in the area. I hope to go back very soon! read more

Smokin Petes - Tater tots w Alabama white BBQ sauce - Barbeque Near Me - Geneva, New York

See all

Smokin' Pete's is a great spot for American BBQ, and our European guests really enjoyed it. It's a bit pricey, and I wish the portions were a bit larger. In hindsight, it would've been smarter (and probably a better value) for our group to order one of the larger platters to share, rather than getting several small combos. You order food at the counter and drinks at the bar. Plenty of seats indoors. We ordered the Kashong Cowboy Smash Burger ($22), Chopped Brisket Sandwich ($18), and the 2-Meat Combo Plate ($25), which includes two sides and cornbread. We picked sliced brisket, pulled pork, tater tots, and campfire beans. The brisket was the best! Super tender, flavorful, and had that melt-in-your-mouth quality. The campfire beans were also a hit. But I love BBQ beans. Pulled pork was also solid. The cornbread was fine but a little too plain; it could use more butter or moisture. The tater tots were too crunchy (dry). We ordered a 1/4 lb of turkey since there's no kid's menu and that was devoured easily. All meats are available by weight (¼ lb, 1/2 lb, etc.), if you want to order it this way. They offer a few different condiments (OG BBQ, Hot BBQ, Honey Mustard BBQ, and Ketchup), but the OG BBQ was the only one I liked. The honey mustard BBQ was too heavy on the mustard and didn't balance well. The vibe inside is awesome. Big Bills fan energy, with dollar bills hanging from the ceiling and tons of football memorabilia throughout the space. It's got a lot of character and makes for a fun, casual dining experience. read more

See all

The food at Smokin' Pete's was fantastic! We came right at dinner time, around 5:30, and the line was long. We waited about 15 minutes to order. After we ordered, we got a table right away. The place was packed but it was a nice night so there were tables inside and tables outside around fire pits and fire tables. The ambience was awesome. Their tap list was great too. I always appreciate a tap list with local beers. Sauces and drinks were self serve so we were able to wash down the spicy sauce with as much soda as possible. It wasn't cheap but prices were average for barbecued meats. We will definitely return! read more

Smokin Petes - Two meat plate with ribs, brisket, Mac and cheese, and broccoli salad - Barbeque Near Me - Geneva, New York

See all

A most amazing BBQ Dive bar joint! We stopped in for a quick drink since some friends had mentioned that they had an incredible selection of bourbon. They do. Incredible actually. We got a shot of Kentucky Owl and a Maple Bacon cocktail. Both were perfect. It helped that there was a Buffalo Bills game on the TV that they were winning. There's nothing like cheering for your team with a group of strangers. Anyway, the food smelled delicious, but we had just eaten dinner at Brewery Ardennes. Next time, we will stop in for BBQ and bourbon. read more

Where has this place all my life? We were on a drive and took a different route. Driving past this cute joint, we decided to make a u-turn and so glad we did. You walk in the place and the BBQ smell wafts right through your brains, enticing as hell. Making it our go-to BBQ! Very important too - great, kind service! Laid back spot where you can sit outside, even with your dog. We will make this a new regular!! read more

See all

This was our fourth trip to the establishment. So after four times trying this BBQ spot, I can safely say... it's great! The atmosphere is chill with a bar type feel. The service is pretty decent considering how busy they are, and the food is pretty good! I have had BBQ from Terry Blacks in Austin, this is definitely a close second. The brisket is consistently delicious, the sides are tasty, the appetizers are great (get the tots with brisket). If you're looking for Texas BBQ in NY... run here, don't walk.... Run! read more

Smokin Petes - Brisket dinner - Barbeque Near Me - Geneva, New York

See all

Prompt service and adorable BarBQ decor, from cute cowhide booth seating to a bar made of Pennie's. They also have Picnic seating in the back of the building. I had the maple bourbon bacon wings and they were deliciously perfect. They were very satisfying and so I saved the Portabella Swiss burger and smoked Gouda Mac n Cheese. They were equally delicious the next day. My friend enjoyed her two meat plate filled with chicken, ribs, beans and the salted potatoes. read more

See all

Was there on Saturday afternoon because friends asked us to join them. It wasn't very welcoming but I gave it the stars because the wings were good. Tots were bland even though they said they were seasoned. Could have used some more carrot and celery sticks. It was a one time visit for me. read more

See all

According to my foreigner friend, "This place has completed my authentic American experience." This was the best BBQ ever. We ordered the 3 meats combo: brisket, spare ribs, and pulled pork. We were extremely impressed with how juicy, flavorful, and tender the meats were. We loooved the cornbread and kale coleslaw. Again, both were the best we've ever had!! We were blown away. We were bummed that the dessert pies were sold out, even before 7pm! The staff is super friendly, recommended us different beers, and the atmosphere is spacious with both indoor and outdoor seating. It's a good place for small or big groups of people. Though it's far from where we live, we would definitely come back again. read more

Smokin Petes - 3 meat combo: brisket, pulled pork, and spare ribs with cornbread, kale coleslaw, and macaroni salad - Barbeque Near Me - Geneva, New York

Meats were off the charts good. Tots were steller, good beans. Coleslaw and cornbread were bland. It's an order and serve yourself place with a large bar. read more

See all

We were staying on the lake for a week during the summer and we found smoke peas. Great food! Went inside to order takeout in the weight was not very long. Staff was nice when we went to the counter. Great place if you're looking for ambience as well! read more

See all

First time going there today! ABSOLUTELY AMAZING PLACE AND FOOD!!! The owners are friendly and welcoming!! Felt like we had known them for a long time!! We are both speechless regarding the food, all of it was just outstanding! The BBQ sauces were all awesome too!!! This is our new place for BBQ now!!! read more

This place is amazing: its a mix of a hole in the wall with a local bar that has everything. I ordered full rack of ribs, and would order it again and again. Sauces? No need, taste is perfectly balanced and just the right amount of dryness. Beer is fast and cold. Prices are reasonable. If you are driving past - plan a stop read more

Great vibes and great wings! These wings came off the bone nicely and weren't stringy. I'm not a big wing person but these flew me away. Great restaurant design of ordering when you come in and picking your food up at the window when the buzzer rings. read more

Smokin Petes - Maple Bourbon BBQ wings - Barbeque Near Me - Geneva, New York

See all

What a great place. Took a few minutes to get bearings but the food was just amazing. The salt potatoes and macaroni salad was so good. Mac n cheese- great!! BBQ was just amazing. Cornbread was the only disappointment- dry batch maybe. Will be back in the summer when the outdoor scene is rocking!! read more

For being so far from bbq country this place is amazing. Brisket is perfect and the turkey is amazing. Drinks are great. Service was excellent . Cool vibes and good atmosphere . read more

Smokin Petes - Maple old fashioned - Barbeque Near Me - Geneva, New York

See all

Great place to get some barbecue. Everything we had was really good. You got to wait in line which is usually outside the building, but they're pretty quick. You order your food pay up front and then go find a seat. Once things are ready your little buzzer goes off and you go up to the counter and get your food. They have a nice assortment of drinks. A good selection on the soda machine and a lot of sauces. And anything else you would need to eat barbecue. The inside was loud and crowded. We ate outside at one of the picnic tables and was visited by the local stray cat and had a great time. read more

You order when you arrive before you sit. Like Panera. You get a buzzer to let you know your food I ready for pick up. Drinks are serves to you while your ordering. First come first serve indoor and outdoor seating Just chose this place on a whim and it ended up being a delicious bbq experience. The fact that the place was full of locals made us know we chose well. A large bar with lots of beer, whiskey, and bourbon selections!! We ordered ribs (by the bone), chicken wings, corn bread, and loaded tots with brisket!! Our food was flavorful and cooked perfectly. Their signature sauces were on point. Loved the cornbread and sweet butter. read more

See all

Smokin Pete's is an awesome BBQ restaurant and bar. I had the 2meats with brisket and ribs and my wife had the pulled pork over crispy tater tots and both were delish!! Ribs falling off the bone and everything fork-tender. Flavor was amazing. It is a bit pricy but definitely worth the trip along Seneca Lake. read more

I ordered the pulled pork sandwich along with tots and both were delicious! Service was efficient and fast.

This place has the absolute BEST bbq! Bar none. My husband gets the chicken and/or brisket and I love the juicy smoked turkey. We love this place. Great service and bonus they love the Bills has much as we do! See you again soon. read more

The food was awesome! The atmosphere was very friendly, a great start to our weekend away read more

See all

Fantastic, great flavors, great atmosphere, friendly staff, this will be on our list of stops next year, thanks and keep up the great smoking! read more

Smokin Petes - Definitely worth a sample - Barbeque Near Me - Geneva, New York

After seeing a friend's post on FB and pics of his birthday meal here I knew we would stop one day. We had decided to make a trip from Liverpool to Watkins Glen for a hike down the Gorge trail on a beautiful sunny fall day with leaves about 60% fall colors. Smokin Pete's is on Route 14 which happens to be on that route so we stopped about 1:30 for lunch. I chose brisket dinner which comes with a slab of brisket and burnt ends corn bread pickles candied jalepenos pickled onions and two sides. Everything is homemade. The Parmesan salt potatoes were butte try and tender and cheesy oh my! The brisket was perfect smoke juicy and tender and the burnt ends were so juicy inside crispy outside flavor burst in your mouth good. We love brisket and things the best in CNY. The ribs were also tender moist flavorful and pulled easily off the bone. Seating inside and out but it does get busy. By the time we left we understood why there is a sign out front says the line forms here. I'll make that drive just for the brisket!! You order to the right just inside the door at the closest end of the bar and then wait for your tracker to beep. It is loud you won't miss it. Pick up across from middle of bar at the kitchen window. Doesn't take long very friendly staff condiments etc all next to the window and plenty of indoor seating as well as outside. Was a beautiful fall day so we went out. read more

See all

Authentic barbecue! Love the corn bread and macaroni and cheese sides. Excellent service. Friendly people.

Go there quite frequently this place is the real deal for food and staff A+ thanks Smokin Pete's !

Stopped by on a recommendation from a coworker and wasn't disappointed. We got there just before noon on a Sunday and there were a few people in line in front of us, a few minutes later the line was out the door. It's counter service and the food was ready pretty quickly. We were a group of 6 and our selections covered the full spectrum; no one was disappointed, everything was great. Prices were reasonable and it's a great place to hang out. This will definitely be a regular stop. read more

There was a huge line out the door and it took a very long time to order. We were assured the wait would be worth it. It was NOT worth it. The bbq sauces were good, but the food was not worth such an incredible wait. It was honestly just mediocre. Not incredible, but just basic. I would go back if they figured out how to serve customers in a more efficient way, but as it stands now the food is just too basic and boring for me to want to stand in a line for so long. read more

My absolute favorite restaurant in the Greater Geneva area. They have a seasonal winter menu that is a bit different than their full BBQ menu, both menus are awesome, but do your research on hours and menus. There is a big bar with rotating taps. The outside is amazing for summer. I absolutely love their brisket, ribs are awesome, my husband loves the wings. All the sides are great. It is counter service with a buzzer and it can get really busy during peak summer day mealtimes, I have noted especially weekend holidays, which is great for them, not great when there is a long wait for great food with small kids. If you are just there to drink there is a separate ordering area for drinks only. I live less than 10 minutes away and always bring out of town visitors. This is my first pick for casual dining every time. read more

Smokin Petes - 1/2 American dream with 6 extra wings - Barbeque Near Me - Geneva, New York

Pulled pork & brisket chili tasty. Coleslaw was bland. Loved the mustard sauce. Service was fine. You place your order then pick it up at the food window. Decorated like a BBQ joint read more

See all

Authentic barbecue in the Finger Lakes region of New York. Always check to see if they're open because Yelp got it wrong. Best brisket EVER Best pulled pork and their sauces are excellent because you choose how much to use instead of the restaurants slathering everything so you can't see or taste the quality of the meat. These people are for real. The sides are tasty too! Especially the beans which have actual pieces of meat in them for flavor. It's not a fancy place by any means. It's rough and has a well stocked bar with everything. Highly recommended!!! read more

Very good food. Did takeout. They forgot to give us BBQ sauce. Make sure you ask for it!

This was one of the best barbecue restaurants I've ever been to, as soon as you walk in you can tell that the folks on the smoker know exactly what they are doing. We had the brisket topped tater tot's and wings with three sauces: Alabama White, Maple Bacon Bourbon Barbecue, and Buff-a-cue. Each item was delicious and perfectly cooked. read more

See all

I am SO glad we stopped at Smokin' Pete's for dinner when we were visiting the area. The bartender was super helpful and had great recommendations on food and drink options. Didn't mind the wait for the food because it was definitely worth it. The loaded tots and smokehouse tacos were amazing, as were the wings. They've definitely got a winning formula here, as was evident by the amount of people inside when we arrived. read more

Always amazing BBQ, sides, deserts, and service! Go to place when in the Seneca Lake/Geneva area. Best bourbon selection in the finger lakes hands down. Check out the special bar top! read more

See all

this spot had really amazing smoked meat and barbecue. I will definitely be coming back. They have a large menu with a lot of selections. They also have indoor and outdoor seating with games and it is very family friendly. The waitress who helped us was super friendly. read more

Smokin Petes - birria brisket tacos, brisket loaded tots, chicken wings - Barbeque Near Me - Geneva, New York

2nd time visit. 1st great, 2nd bad. Cold Pork sandwich and chicken wings very pink and not done. Was told by kitchen that every order would be the same and would not be able to cook any more. Did not eat wings. Under cooked and didn't want to get sick. Over priced at $48. Won't be returning. It's a tourist trap. read more