Slightly off the beaten path since a mile from center of downtown Gettysburg, this is clearly a…read morelocal favorite. Very busy with folks popping in their pjs to pick up dinner. Generous portions of great food and reasonable prices. The gluten free hoagie roll was the best I have ever had, can't even tell it's gluten free!

delicious food and nice workers. affordable food as well. they repainted the place so it looks…read moreextra nice.

Food was absolutely amazing, and Danica was a great server. Highly recommend if you are in the area.read more

Came for the carb-loading, stayed because I physically couldn't stand up afterwards…read more ​Stopped by La Bella Italia in Gettysburg, and let's just say the crew running this family-owned spot doesn't play around. Staff is ridiculously friendly and attentive--basically treated me like a long-lost cousin who hadn't eaten in a week. ​We kicked things off with their fresh, house-baked ciabatta paired with an herb-loaded olive oil and butter combo. The bread was so good I almost forgot I had actual food coming. ​The play-by-play: ​Fresh Calamari: Crispy, tender, and served with a killer marinara. Absolutely incredible. ​Braised Beef Ravioli: You only get four on the plate, but these bad boys are built like linebacker kneepads. Homemade pasta, packed with savory beef, and drenched in a sweet marinara. ​Spaghetti alle Vongole: Homemade spaghetti tossed with fresh clams in a rich red sauce spiked with garlic, white wine, and fresh herbs. Fantastic flavor. ​The Pizza: Hey, for Pennsylvania? Pretty solid backup options if you're not going full pasta mode. ​The best part? All their pasta is made completely fresh in-house, and the portion sizes are strictly "feed a Roman army" certified. ​Who knew Pennsylvania Italian food could punch this far above its weight class? 10/10, would willingly accept the inevitable food coma again.

Best pizza in town. Great sauce, toppings and crust in the right proportions. Nothing more…read moresatisfyning than taking a bite of Tommys pizza.

It has been several years since I visited on vacation in Gettysburg as lots has changed with known…read morethings from past aren't around anymore so sad but one thing Tommy's is still here and appearing to be going strong. Sunday 7/26/2026 returned for a vacation as arrived headed to Tommy's as We had an excellent pizza with mushrooms as ate outside at dining tables with our doggie dachshund Haleigh Ann with purchasing cold cut hoagies for the next day as they were great also. Very nice place to dine in or on the sidewalk in good weather. Tommy's has been around in Gettysburg for years with a nice location corner of Washington street and Steinwehr Avenue. You won't be disappointed with your dining experience. Good Job !!!! May you Keep your Business going Strong for many long Years !!!!

We are from out of town and went with the Yelp recommendation. Not far from the town center ,…read moretucked away at the side of the building. Meat lovers was great, crispy crusty... quick service, clean and the staff was very nice!

Their pizza is great and the lady at the counter is very nice. Really great pizza stop in…read moreGettysburg.

The Slices & Portion Size The slices are notably small and…read morenarrow--a detail where the deal loses points. While $7.75 sounds decent on paper for two slices and a drink, the modest portion size leaves a lot to be desired if you're looking for a genuinely filling meal. The slices offer a classic, well-browned mozzarella top with visible caramelized spots and decent cheese pull. The crust has a firm, golden edge that supports the toppings well without flopping, though the thin, small footprint makes quick work of both slices. A straightforward, traditional combination of sweet tomato sauce and salty browned mozzarella--classic neighborhood slice flavor, just in a skimpy portion.

First night in Gettysburg and ordered pizza from here. Very good pizza, a bit greasy but not bad at…read moreall! Good flavor and did amazing with extra cheese. We did delivery and it was quick and easy! Definitely recommend. Will say Lg pizza was a little smaller than expected.

We have ordered here 2 x so far and will continue to order. Each time, each item has been great!read more

Just happened to check this place out while wandering around the food court and I'm so glad I did…read more I saw the Italian slice pizza and was immediately intrigued. The service was fast and friendly. But most importantly the food was delicious and fresh. Never seen an Italian sandwich in the form of a pizza but it's so delicious. The crust was a garlicky focaccia style dough that was light and slightly crispy. But the shining star is the smoked provolone coming through with high quality tasting ham and salami. The right amount of lettuce and tomato to give a fresh and bright note to it to finish it off. I highly recommend it!

6/17/2026 We stopped on a whim here on our way to our Air B & B because husband wanted a 6 pack. I…read morefound the people working there to be quite friendly and personable. We grabbed a menu because we considered ordering for dinner. Well, we ended up ordering 2 pizzas, one cheese, one pepperoni, a cheesesteak and an antipasta. I really enjoyed everything. The sauce was very savory and I really enjoyed it. The food was ready when I arrived and it was hot and fresh. If I'm in the area I would definitely go back for sure! The place is small inside with a few tables and cozy. It is in a strip mall next to a tattoo shop.

This place is very good we got wings buffalo chicken, pepperoni and Sicilian. Very good and fresh…read more The guys running the place care and it shows!!!