The Slices & Portion Size The slices are notably small and narrow--a detail where the deal loses points. While $7.75 sounds decent on paper for two slices and a drink, the modest portion size leaves a lot to be desired if you're looking for a genuinely filling meal. The slices offer a classic, well-browned mozzarella top with visible caramelized spots and decent cheese pull. The crust has a firm, golden edge that supports the toppings well without flopping, though the thin, small footprint makes quick work of both slices. A straightforward, traditional combination of sweet tomato sauce and salty browned mozzarella--classic neighborhood slice flavor, just in a skimpy portion. read more

See all

First night in Gettysburg and ordered pizza from here. Very good pizza, a bit greasy but not bad at all! Good flavor and did amazing with extra cheese. We did delivery and it was quick and easy! Definitely recommend. Will say Lg pizza was a little smaller than expected. read more

Below average pizza. Missed toppings. Veggie pizza didn't have many veggies. One poor guy working all parts. Old dilapidated facility. Tommies is much much better (they were closed today) read more

The best pizza and great service. I've loved their pizza for 52 years! We drive a great distance just for this pizza. It has the right combination of sauce and cheese on a flaky, delicious crust. read more

Pizza was light and yummy. Found this place near the Gettysburg College  and we were glad we did! Good old fashioned pizza place, friendly service and the pizza is delicious! read more

Pizza House - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Unfortunately the pizza was forgettable, and disappointing. We're going to stick with La Bella Italiano.

Good pizza and friendly customer service . They have many different topping choices and have other items like sandwiches. Very convenient if you're on the Gettysburg College campus read more

Great pizza. great subs. I love their Salami sub. Eating a pizza house sub is wonderful. I went to Gettysburg College. The subs remind me of being young and happy. Go visit. It is worth a trip. read more

Always loved this place but a bit concerned going there recently and cook came to register without a mask and took my order then handled payment and then proceeded to grab the food and start making my pizza with out mask, gloves or even washing hands after our exchange or even given his re- entry from the back for that matter. I only went through with the order because of the high heat involved in baking. But this is not a good practice (handling toppings without gloves or hand wash) - covid days or not. read more

For 4 years I consumed a large pepperoni pizza from this fine establishment almost every night during swim team season 1983-1987. Servo was ok, but not enough calories. We called it "fat Jacks" then (everyone from that era knows why) but it's Pizza House. Sometimes I had a pie even after having a cheesesteak from Robbie's (RIP). It's not NY/NJ quality but very good. Location is key for college life. And they delivered back in the day (still do?). read more

I got the cheese pizza and just one bite, everyone knows the rules. I give it a 5.7 it wasn't bad, just incredibly okay

It was ok. Was tired and hungry. It did hit the spot. Sort of like a frozen pizza hots the spot when you are hungry.

Growing up in Gettysburg Tommy's was always the place to eat and honestly never even considered Pizza House, then last summer a friend from high school posted her nephew purchased it and I thought why not give it a try. The pizza here is GOOD, and to me tastes like Toimmy's USED to taste. Add to the fact it is much cheaper and tastes so good Pizza House has a new customer. Instead of Tommy's now when I am in town going to Pizza House! read more

I'm shocked with how good this was. Pizza house pizzas aren't the typical New York style pizzas you get just about everywhere. It's a thicker, richer, almost more buttery pizza. It actually reminded me a lot of Tommy's pizza, but with a little less sauce and grease, and a crunchier, sturdier crust. (The crust is amaze balls). Plus it's less expensive. This might be my new favorite pizza place in town. Awesome prices and amazingly delicious. read more

See all

I go to the college so I always stop here after a night out. The pizza is very good and so are the chicken bacon ranch fries. Also it's such a cute place, I would recommend to anyone stopping by in Gettysburg. read more

What a pleasant surprise after the disastrous pizza from Tommy's! This pizza was outstanding and making me wish I'd gotten a large instead of a small. The crust was perfectly cooked, light and airy. The sauce had a nice flavor and the cheese was baked just right. I ordered a pepperoni pizza and it was not too greasy. We ordered it to go and the employees were all super nice. This will be our new pizza place whenever we're in town. Good pizza and good prices! read more

I went to the college in the mid-seventies, and this restaurant was the closest to my dorm room in Stine Hall. At the time it isn't an understatement to say that the cafeteria was horrible, so a pizza from here was like heaven. Back then they made a great pie, and when I'm in town this is usually my first stop. It's still a great pie- easily the best in town and is true to what was served way back when. Truth be told, this place hasn't changed much from the seventies, and that's a good thing. You seriously can't go wrong here. read more

Since the new management has taken over the people who work here are SO nice! The food has always been FANTASTIC, but it tastes even better now that they got rid of the mean bitch that was there. It has always been a 5 star Pizza place! So glad there are only super nice folks there now!!! read more

I stopped in Saturday evening and had a small cheese and pepperoni and a soda. The pizza was quite good, slightly crispy, not really doughy. Price was good, about $9 and they even gave me a large soda for the price of the small. Service was friendly. It only took about 15 minutes to get the pizza. This is a very basic no frills pizza joint. With a fair amount of seating inside. I would eat here again. read more

How can I be the first to review this instutitution of higher education pizza establishment? Just off of Gettysburg College's campus sits "Pizza House." Good, cheap, greasy, and quality never varies. The staff never varies just ages. Good pizza, good subs, good prices. Cheese that slides off the pizza in a pile, crust that never dissapoints. As my body ages I am able to eat less and less pizza house, but I continue to crave it. read more

I have read on some other sites some pretty bad reviews of this place, saying the staff is rude or claiming something wrong with the food. We live here and order from here usually once a week. We have never had issues with the staff, and , to us, the food is amazing. We usually get pizzas, and the crust is the best I've had. Even delivered, it gets there so hot its like right out of the oven. The toppings are always fresh, and generous. We have also tried a few subs here, and the bread is great and the subs are tasty. Now, as to the inside. Its old, its divey, its a small pizza place in a college town, but its got personality. With two pinball games hidden away in a small corner and limited seating made up of 80s style booths, and small tables, it reminds me of being a kid going to the local pizza joint. Pirces are good, and I recommend this place a lot. read more

Their pizza is really good i have been to Pizza Hut, Little Caesars, and other top pizza places and i think this is better than them the sauce has good spices and the cheese is evenly cooked and the crust is crispy, airy and not burnt, read more

Found this place near the Gettysburg College Campus and we were glad we did! Good old fashioned college pizza place, friendly service and the pizza is delicious! read more

See all

Hard to give this place even one star. Pizza was mediocre at best. Canned commercial pizza sauce with way to much sugar and little taste. Can't see how this pace gets better reviews. I also had the same health cate concerns. Only one staff member who did everything. Never wore a mask and never once did he wash his hands from dining up sakes, making chance, preparing the pizza, not once. Does the local health district ever inspect this place as it should be shut down. However from they very few customers in the establishment I don't expect them to be in business much longer. Made a mistake and also ordered a salad if you can call such. shredded lettuce that you would put on a sandwich and a very few tomato pieces on the lettuce and they called it a salad. Overall avoid this place at all times read more

I am quite the pizza eat as their sign says I only eat pizza I'm days that end in Y! I have been a patron to all the pizza places (except Tommy's pizza) in town over the past 5 years at least. It wasn't until more recently I frequented pizza house fed up with the inconsistence of the bigger franchise places. I was tired of having to call dominoes because they messed up every order! Here I have had only two wrong orders in all the times I've ordered here! The best part is the consistency you won't see anywhere else. Their pizzas are not too seasoned and I enjoy a fairly plain pizza! The crust is cooked great never burnt! The service is mostly friendly and they know me pretty well by my orders! They offer free delivery and you must pay cash for the deliveries. All deliveries after 4 pm I believe. read more

Best pizza in southern Pennsylvania. Period. New owners seem to have kept the original recipes.

Ok, so went to see an old friend of mine today that passed away in 95... This place is so small, we almost missed it... Was hungry, food was ok, I now have the # 4 score on The Lord if the rungs pinball... read more

I ordered a sub and onion rings. Bad idea. As far as hang over food is concerned, this place might do the trick... Unfortunately I wasn't hung over at all. The onion rings were extremely over cooked... To the point of almost being slightly blackened. The sub was greasy and mostly inedible. I couldn't help but wonder if it had been dropped on the floor or if someone had wiped their ass with it. Worst food I've had in Gettysburg. Doesn't even deserve a star. read more

So I read some decent reviews on Yelp and Google about this place. I was initially intrigued because it reminded me of a pizza joint that I used to go to when I visited my friend at Frostburg State University in MD. Overall the pizza was good. Light crispy crust, flavorful sauce. I didn't care for the texture of the mozzarella or the flavor of the pepperoni. Customer service was lacking...it seemed that it was a bother that I ordered slices instead of a whole pizza. Not much ambiance. Seems like a good place to go after a hard night of drinking... read more

Amazing pizza. Could eat it every night. Very good pepperoni & cheese, not too much sauce either. Had a steak & cheese as well, had a slightly greasy taste. Just think they need to drain the steak better. But this is definitely our new go to Pizza restaurant! Yummy!! Edit: Attempted to order delivery & was told it was cash only? It's 2017 people, not everyone has cash on hand. The lady who answered the phone was also very rude about it & hung up on me. Changed my rating for poor customer service. read more

We have stopped there a couple times so far. This place is now "top dog" as far as Steak and Cheese subs go in my boyfriend's eyes! He's saying it's flavored right and tastes great. I've tried them and he's right. I also tried the pizza, it's okay. Better than Tommy's, but that's just my opinion. The only thing that took away the last star is the seating. Tight seating if you're heavy. read more

Pretty good. It's very what you see is what you get but all the pizzas and the wings are very tasty more so than what you would expect. But this is a more place you go for take-out when everyone else is closed. read more

I lived in this place from 1982 to 1986 when I went to Gettysburg College. No joke I had a large pizza there usually with a buddy 4 nights a week. Even got our Frat to start ordering pizzas there when our cook had the night off. Every time I come back to G-Burg (I live in Oregon now-the land of HORRIBLE pizza) I stop by. Prices are still great and the pizza still very good. Was sorry to see Fat Jack was no longer behind the counter! He was a fixture! Please enjoy the fact you Easterners have good pizza! I am trying to retire to Gettysburg if I can pry my local wife away from Oregon. read more

My family found the Pizza House as a "craving". When we are in town, it's a must stop at least once for the Pizza. The crust has a unique taste from the oven that's probably been there since they started. The Pizzas are not large but have a great taste in the crust, good tomato sauce and real cheese. My grandchildren when they come to visit want to go here than anywhere else. I inhaled half a Sausage Pizza in a blink. read more

This was the first time I ever tried their pizza....OMG! So good! Best crust ever!! If you don't try this place, you are missing something!!

A very low-key pizzeria that primarily serves the college community, since it is located about a block from the center of campus. The dining area is anything but fancy, but the pizza and subs are popular and equal to most of the pizza offerings in Gettysburg. And prices are modest. Informal. read more

Decent pizza for the price. Right next to campus so location couldn't be better. And they're open till late!

This is a hole in the wall classic off the main drag near the Gettysburg College. The inside is nothing special and it's strictly an order at the counter kind of place, but the pizza is very good. They deliver and I've never been disappointed. read more

Delivery was pretty quick. Pizza was ok, on the plain side. 3 stars because i ordered a cheese steak and cheese fries and the cheese used on both was odd. I wish i could think of another word for it but odd is about right. Bottom line is there are better and worse places to eat. 3 stars. read more

Overpriced, low quality pizza. I can't even believe this company considers themselves a pizza place. I grew up in Gettysburg and my parents used to order pizza from the Pizza House. When I was a kid, I ate it because I didn't know any better. Gettysburg wasn't exactly a hub for great pizza shops. Now you can find pizza shops everywhere in any town, many of which are at least decent if not pretty good. I rank Pizza House in my top three worst pizza places, right up there with Fox's Pizza Den (Dover, PA) and Little Caesars. Both Fox's Pizza Den and Pizza House charge too much for their pizza if you consider the quality and taste. At least Little Caesars only charged $5 for their crappy hot and ready pizzas. The pizza we got last night at Pizza House was very bland. You would think they used a cheap boxed kit or a fundraiser's pizza kit. Really, after all the years this place has been open and their pizza is that bad? I wonder if they donate money to Gettysburg College, because they should be thanking all the drunk and/or desperate college kids for all the business they get. read more