Very good food! The food was seasoned well. Um Um good! First day I got white pizza, delicious! The tomatoes and broccoli seasoned with garlic on top of the mozzarella and ricotta cheese, hit the spot. Second time bought the Grilled Buffalo Chicken Boli. Very tasty. The drizzle of hot sauce with chicken and cheese brought it all together! Keep it up Alfredo! read more

We were staying at the local Holiday Inn and there were several menus in the lobby from Alfredo's. There were plenty of choices for us to each get what we wanted, so we decided to try Alfredo's. My husband got a pizza and I got the cold sub. Big portions and tasty. This place has counter service with plenty of tables and booths and did a big pick up business. Glad someone left those menus in the lobby! read more

Alfredo's Pizza - Sausage/pepperoni pizza (14"). Italian cold sub - Pizza Near Me - Shippensburg, Pennsylvania

Great food and service! Food is always hot and there's a lot to choose from. They also deliver.

Eh it wasn't bad New York pizza is better. We got a veggie lover's that was ok & got Sicilian which was much better. The young girl (17 or 20 years old)that was there blew my mind when she couldn't count the change that I gave her & when I had to tell her how much that I got back she literally was going to count out 7 cents in pennies until I said you can give me a nickel & 2 pennies back instead of what she was going to do. read more

Food was ok, very rude last time there, haven't been back since. I live less than 3 minutes away but I'll drive to Caretti's to get pizza.

Breaded cauliflower. $6.99 not including tax, delivery fee and tip. Not impressed at all. I've had family order this before and they got enough, three people could have shared it. Won't order it again. Bummer Update... I received a reply from the owner today as he was out of town when I messaged him about this. He is giving me a credit and apologized. New fry cook apparently didn't know the portion size. I realize mistakes happen and we are usually happy with the food we order here, so I'm satisfied and will recommend this restaurant. read more

Alfredo's Pizza - Breaded cauliflower. $6.99 not including tax, delivery fee and tip. - Pizza Near Me - Shippensburg, Pennsylvania

I love their Tuna Melt sub. I don't have a picture because I ate it. I don't have time for reviews when I'm hungry.

In one word terrible. This place is terrible for the following reasons Bland pizza reminded me of old school pizza hut deep dish. The sides were soggy and flavorless. The signs on the outside reflect their everyday values with many signs having mailbox stickers over the prices to reflect the price increase. In most cases it was from 18 bucks to 28 bucks. Never again I would rather starve to death read more

Garlic parmesan wings were almost the best I ever had!! Such a great sauce! I asked for well done wings and they were cooked perfectly. I will definitely order these wings again. The other food in the order was good and cooked properly and very good quality! read more

This place is super unclean. During dinner, I noticed a female worker drop a cleaning cloth on the floor. She then picked up the cleaning cloth from the dirty floor and "cleaned" at least 3 tables. I was cursed at by her coworker for pointing out her error. Save your time and money by eating another place. read more

My husband and I were in town for a camp meeting and will, we were hungry. Decided to try Alfredo's and was not disappointed. He ordered the cheesesteak and said he believes it is the best he has ever had. He said the bread was just the way you would want it and the meat was more than plentiful, the fixing just right. He will definitely go back next time we are in town. I ordered the lemon pepper rings which is a dry rub seasoning. Very delicious and I will definitely get them again. So good. read more

It's pretty hard to mess up pizza, but Alfredo's did it flawlessly. Here out of town for a sports tournament and was starving....should've know better when I saw the pizza by the slice behind the counter that looked three days old. Huge huge disappointment read more

please clarify on your menu what is on your items. Ex, the roast beef, cheese, and gravy states that it comes with lettuce and tomatoe. Upon receiving the order, it also comes with onions, mushrooms, and mayonnaise on it. I'm allergic to onions and mushrooms, so fortunately I was able to swap my sandwich for my wife's. her meatball sub was fantastic though read more

Some friends at work recommended I try this place so I finally did. First time I order, they mess up a simple two topping pizza order. Pineapple instead of pepperoni? They did offer to make it right when I called but "first impressions" and all that. Too many other places in town that make a quality product to be making rookie mistakes. read more

Our first time eating at Alfredo's. My family wasn't disappointed. The food was delicious (fettuccini alfredo, bambino pizza, bacon chicken ranch wrap, lasagna). It was our waitress' second night and she did fine. We did have a problem and it was immediately fixed- all you have to do is say something and the owner will make sure it's corrected. We really appreciated the owner coming out to not only make sure the problem was fixed but took the time and talked with us. My twin 10 year old girls really enjoyed talking with Mr. Sal. We will definitely be back to have dinner or lunch at Alfredo's again. #supportslocalbusiness read more

The kitchen staff/cook needs to listen to what the client wants in regards to a food preparation order. I requested a delivery to my business with particular food preparation Instructions because I have an allergy. This is not the first time I have ordered from them and they completely disregard what I specifically instructed. This mom and pop shops thinks they can do whatever they want with my food. I will definitely discourage my coworkers from ordering from them. Not a Good idea to piss off a local distributor for your area. DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY HERE. read more

Where to start, ordered a spaghetti dinner w/salad and garlic bread, andca Stromboli for pick up. When I got home no salad, garlic bread was a sub roll not even toasted, the spaghetti was a huge glomp of hamburger on top dry enough sauce to make it look like BBQ, no sauce for spaghetti. I kinda pulled out the pasta and ate it. So at 11pm I'm awakened with a​ horrible stomach ache, setting her today and still not feeling well diarrhea stomach pain. Pretty sure it's food poisoning. Beware! read more

Alfredo's Pizza makes good pizzeria food, but that is not what this review is about. I came in last evening to pick up an order from Slice. There was a man sweeping under the booths and another man (fifties, greasy, thick glasses) standing around taking up air and space. The standing around man was talking to the sweeping man, and he appeared to be rating the looks of the other (not present) staff. He said, "You remember the girl who was kind of skinny, but had a really nice rack?" He then held his idle hands several inches in front of his chest to mimic breasts. The sweeping man then noticed me, a customer. As the sweeping man got up, the idle man said, "Yeah! Her name was (redacted)." When the sweeping man reached the counter, I gestured to the idle pervert and said, "Wow, He's pleasant." The sweeping man did not address my comment, but was very flustered and could not find my order for several minutes. I write this here because it is patently inappropriate behavior for a professional business and because I know of at least two underage girls who have worked at Alfredo's. If the people in charge there cannot stand up to a greasy fifty-something wearing coke bottle glasses and protect their staff, someone should say something. read more

So - the Hubs and I stopped at Best Western in Shippensburg and this restaurant was recommended by the desk clerk. I found their web site and ordered online. The ordering process was easy. Food was supposed to be delivered in under an hour but was 15-20 minutes late. No big deal - but - I ordered a Greek salad with house dressing. Great salad - but no dressing on it or included. I also ordered a veggie calzone. Got a great calzone with no veggies and full of meat. Hmm... Hubs had a bambino meat lover's pizza - very good, he said. He also ordered half a dozen hot wings - said they were ok. The food from this restaurant is really good food, hot & fresh...but I wish they had gotten the order correct :( read more

There are some restaurants that try very hard to produce good products, and still fail, for a myriad of reasons - overreaching ambition, cutting costs, ineptitude, etc. But usually you can *taste* something. At least they are trying. But there is nothing worse than a restaurant that doesn't give a damn. Alfredo's Pizza tastes like apathy. Like every other eatery in Shippensburg, Alfredo's specializes in bland-flavored food in large portions that fell off the back of a Sisco Foods truck. I seriously doubt they actually *make* anything that didn't already come in a package. If you enjoy large portions of sub-standard, pre-made Italian food at cheap prices - like most of the small town yokels in this Godforsaken backwater of a town - Alfredo's is for you. If not - keep driving the extra 20 or 30 miles in either direction, and never look back. read more

It's been a long time since I've order from here due to last bad experience. We decided to give them another chance. Ordered med pizza for delivery at 7:04, arrived at 8:52 cold. I asked for sauce,fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, neither was correct. How hard is it? read more

Great place! Amazing food! Great place for family / kids. Clean. Great service and good prices. I m def. coming back! read more

See all

Alfredo's had great food a few years ago and my husband and I would always try to find time to stop by. Lately all of the food there has been inconsistent. Sometimes the pizza is doughy and other times it's burned on the bottom. My husband ordered a cheese steak and the meat looked gray and almost uncooked. However, in the past he has had fantastic experiences with all of the subs. So what gives? read more

This is my kids favorite pizza place. There is literal disappointment if I say I'm going anywhere else in Shippensburg to pickup pizza

I can give you a good review because, well, I really liked their food, but all I eat there is a gyro and fries. Yes, i know, in many ways, I am a creature of habit. They have a HUGE menu... I just get what I like. Perfect fries. Perfect Gyro. Wife seems to like their spinach and ricotta calzone. At least she's ordered it the last couple times we've went. Restaurant was clean. Recently redone. Nothing fancy, just decent food and a tv on the other side, which drives the wife nuts because she thinks sports are a great evyil. Anyway, go here, you'll like it. read more

I had heard good things about the buffalo chicken pizza so I decided to give it a try. In fact it is a good pizza. The chicken chunks are HUGE and the buffalo sauce is very tangy and works well with the whole pie. I like the crust too, which I believe makes or breaks a pizza. The service was pretty fast for a busy Friday. Definitely a good pizza. The price might seem high, but you're getting a lot of foos. read more

Alfredo's Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Shippensburg, Pennsylvania

I had the stuffed pizza. It was delicious and very filling. A large pizza can easily feed 4 adults.

For along time I believed that places like Pizza Hut and Dominoes were the prime examples of what pizza should be, and boy was I wrong. Living in this relatively small college town I was thrilled to discover this excellent little Italian restaurant that not only has the best pizza in town but also serves the best pasta dishes in town. No more having to settle for cheap, franchised pizza. The food is delicious, the servings are large, and you can taste the difference in their handmade bread and dough! Its fantastic. It is certainly more expensive than places like Pizza Hut, id say an average of $20/pizza, but if your goal is to have authentic Italian New York style, handmade pizza you just cant get any better. I cant think of any pizza places even in Chambersburg that is better. Alfredo's is best in the area, period. Also, its BYOB, so If you plan ahead for dine-in you'll be able to enjoy even more. MMMM read more

Came here one time and never went back... It was really nasty, nothing is fresh, everything is frozen and the pizza was trash.

I live near this Alfredo's location and have enjoyed several traditional peperoni pizzas. Most recently, I decided to try the Buffalo Pizza which was so well reviewed here on Yelp. What a disappointment! First of all, this was a chicken and cheese pizza with buffalo suce drizzled over it (NOT a buffalo chicken pizza). They really need to marinate or toss their chicken pieces in the buffalo sauce -- as it is it the chicken was dry and flavorless. I also have to take issue with the fact that there was no dressing of any kind on the pizza or on the side. I really don't think you can have a buffalo chicken pizza without ranch or blue cheese dressing. They also also apparently no longer offer breadsticks (which I've had in the past and were quite good) or the people taking phone orders don't know the menu. read more

I love the food and being from New York, it tastes like pizza in New York. The owner is personable and from Brooklyn. The only place in the area that knows what garlic knots are! :) read more

After 3rd visit decided to draft a review. My wife and I have had pizza, strombolli and cheesesteak sandwich. Everything was very good. The service was very good. Lot of food for the money. We will be regular customers. read more

When they're on their game...best in town. Otherwise, over priced for the level of inconsistency. I mean...how hard is it to put lettuce, to mar and onion on a sub...every time the order says 'everything' on the ticket? Apparent very. And don't stray from standard ingredientsZ ask for hot peppers and...you might get them. Either way, Alfredo's has gone down in quality over the years. At these prices, and the rampant inconsistency...I'll spend it on gas and head to Chambersburg for one of several pizza/Italian places that are worth the prices they charge. read more

Everything I've ever had here is mediocre at best, basically just another place to eat in Ship. Standard Italian fare is in place, as well as other sandwiches, subs, etc. though they are still just mediocre. Not bad, not good, just there. Cheap is a plus though, and waitresses are always really friendly! read more

Never had an item that wasn't very good in 3 years we've lived here. Lots of pizza in Shipp. & I feel this is the best. Clean,good service, an engaged owner, Sal that exudes dedication to customers. Several upgrades over the last 3 years making for a pleasant dine in experience. But keep in mind, it's casual, and lots of take out patrons keeps the place busy. read more

Alfredo's is some of the best pizza in town. The staff is always nice, even when the place is packed. The food is AMAZING- from their white pizza, to their penne vodka, you can't go wrong. On top of the fantastic staff and food, they just provide an all around atmosphere that makes you feel like you're at home with family on a sunday afternoon. I always recommend Alfredo's to everyone I can. read more

Been awhile since we ordered from here hoping they got better. First they messed the order for the to go pizza up (Glade I checked it before leaving) no worries they wanted to make it right so they made us another pizza, got it right this time. Still disappointed when we got home and the crust was doughy probably because it was rushed. Had to put on a pizza stone in our oven to finish cooking it. Will give them one more try after this. Agree with others when they are on their game it is good food. Just sooooo hard to find good pizza in Shippensburg anymore. read more

The tortellini w/meat sauce tasted and smelled like it was just poured out of a can, but it's cost was similar to that of an authentic Italian restaurant. It was also ready 20 minutes late. I have yet to have decent pasta at a pizza restaurant. But the freshly made garlic bread was good. read more

I had a onion pizza delivered, first time buyer. Was one of the best pizzas I've had!! The delivery person was very nice as well.

I love this place!!! I am italian, and very pick with my italian food but this was amazing! I had the penne ala vodka and it was the best ever. Their prices are affordable as well. I would recommend this to anyone that has never been here before. The service was quick and amazing. I could possible eat here everyday read more