From start to finish, everything was excellent! The customer service was friendly and attentive, and the food was absolutely delicious. Red Rooster Pizzaria truly exceeded my expectations--I'll definitely be coming back! read more

Sub was average and the balsamic vinegar was a bit too much for me, as my roll got soggy quick. Pizza was okay, but also just mid range. read more

Red Rooster Pizzaria - Italian Sub - Pizza Near Me - Shippensburg, Pennsylvania

See all

I have dined in and stopped for take out numerous times and never disappointed. Today I ordered delivery and was very disappointed. Food was barely warm and soggy. The cheese was completely set and I only live 7 minutes away. I understand that delivery is not as good as eat in but this was bad. I won't stop eating their food, just won't do delivery again. read more

Well besides screwing my order up and waiting for 50 minutes then being told they never put my order into the kitchen. Or she said the computer was the problem. I've been going here for about 2 years. It's either bad or good. I've even witnessed the people working here worried about socializing with each other. Making customers wait or just flat out ignore you. This was my last visit to this overrated restaurant that needs to step it up or get out. Supposed to be new owners according to the sign. I wonder what they did before this? My thoughts are the clown dressed like he's Rod Stewart is the problem. Children running the prison is the future of destroying our country. Food is subpar and always a problem with my order. Go inside and judge these people for yourself before losing money. I've actually never seen an adult in there read more

It has improved so much since the new owners took over! Finally a great pizza and great service!

We've ordered here a few times and each time there seems to be an issue with the orders. I'm not sure if the cooks have a hard time reading the order slips but being a business owner myself I'd be firing and hiring new staff or at least bring it to their attention properly. You are a professional business Red Rooster.. as a customer the experience should always be great. If you can't get simple orders right that's failing your customer. Being that you're a small business you should take notice of this more seriously and improve upon it. You have great food and is usually always fresh but the orders always seem to be wrong even when it's correct on the slips. I'm not one to leave reviews like this but a few times of bad experiences doesn't sit right with me. Get better. read more

So excited to try this place after reading recommendations on Facebook. Even during this COVID-19, it was busy. Located on the outskirts of Shippensburg, it is has an inviting atmosphere with dining inside and outside. We ordered a Cheese Steak sub, a Meat Lovers Pizza and BBQ Spice Wings to go. All 3 were amazing! The cheese steak sub was filled with the perfect amount of meat, mushrooms, onions and cheese. The roll was soft and so good. The meat lovers pizza had lots of meat and the pizza dough had an amazing flavor and texture. And the wings, oh my! The wings are a must try if you are a wing lover. Two thumbs way up!! read more

See all

Staff is incompetent, 3 of us ordered food. Only 2 got our meals and the waitress didn't even realize I had no food. Never asked if everything was ok. When asked about 3rd meal, she blamed the kitchen staff and still didn't bring the 3rd order. Won't be back. read more

Red rooster is my new go to Pizzaria on this side of Shippensburg. The pizzas are very good and the subs are amazing. I think the sub rolls are homemade - very light and fluffy with crisp exterior. Today I had the cheesesteak and they didn't skimp on meat. Oh and it looks like they sell Windy Knoll ice cream there which is a major plus. Prices are very reasonable and staff are friendly. read more

Red Rooster Pizzaria - Cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - Shippensburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Absolute terrible pizza. Super dry, was below mediocre, and not the big of slices. Not to mention, the media and service was unbelievable! They got butthurt when asked about health precautions and decided to dig through social media profile. Thought that this was a business... read more

Very good food especially their traditional wings an pizza makes my mouth water just thinking about it!!! The only downfall is they are always busy on the weekends probably because their food is so good!!! So be prepared you probably will have to wait a little bit longer than normal for your food especially when it comes to delivery but rest assure it's definitely worth the wait!!!! read more

Pizza was below par taste, the best I could describe the flavor is a toaster oven pizza or pizza you'd expect to get at a concessions stand. Could be improved if pizza provided a more flavorful sauce and crust. read more

The first time we ordered pizza, we were blown away! The larges are humongous and loaded with toppings!! Their cheesesteak pizza is our all time favorite. Their large Stromboli is massive and comes in its own pizza box. We thought they mistakenly sent us a third pizza! It fits corner to corner in a large pizza box. Great customer service and awesome food! read more

After a couple days on the Appalachian Trail we thought this little pizzeria was the perfect place to grab some food before heading home. Think again....the workers (kids) running the joint were incredibly obnoxious - fooling around loudly and using foul language actually to the point of discomfort. Then to top it off they got our order wrong and didn't get the pizza on the order. After waiting 20 minutes we got up and asked about the pizza and they said you didn't order a pizza. We did get the boneless wings which at order time the one girl input 20 and the other girl said no, it's 12 doncha know what 12 is?! The wings were very hard crunchy swimming in buffalo sauce. When we left they staff gave us this "rolling eye" look, no goodbye or nothing. Unbelievable. They can keep their pizza and their attitude. read more

The very first experience at Red rooster was one that had horrible customer service. Then after we had heard that things got better, we decided to go back. Unfortunately, there were discrepancies from what was advertised on the their window to what was in the menu. Instead of honoring the price, they argued the menu portion. Normally this isn't a big issue for me because I love a small businesses but integrity is a big part of getting me to return. read more

We called for Pizza last night and the service and pizza was Amazing. Give them a try.

I have been here twice. The first time I ordered 2 large pepperoni pizzas. The total was around $28 for pick up. Everything went smoothly got the pizza sat it on the passenger seat. When I got home most of the cheese had moved to one side. You will ask if the seat was angled and yes it was slightly. But I've picked up Pizza Man, Dominos, Pizza Hut, Papa Johns, and others setting them in that exact seat and never experienced this. But, my mistake for putting it on a 3 degree angle. Next time I ordered it was 4 large pepperonis. My total was close to $60. I wanted it delivered to avoid the previous issue, but they said it would be over 2 hours. So, I instead said I would do pick up which would be 45min. I showed up 45min. later and still had to wait another half hour. In talking with others in the community this seems to be a common issue. I ensured the pie stayed flat this time. I no longer had the cheese movement. Now, the pizza. It is okay... the sauce is a bit thin and the crust was not dense enough in my opinion. It wasn't a bad pizza it just was not a $13 pizza. It would be a good $8 pizza. My expectations vary on price, my standards are higher for more expensive pizza. But, judging by the wait time it must be popular and I will just take my pizza cravings to a different location. But, I took a star for over priced "okay" pizza, and one for long wait times. read more

Great food and fast delivery service even to Walnut Bottom on a Friday evening! Food was made and packed exactly as requested. Yummmm!!!

I ordered a supreme stromboli. It was huge and delicious. Courteous staff. Fair price, considering the amount of food.