We stopped at Grace Pizza Restaurant on a Saturday evening around 4:15pm because we were already in…read morethe Chambersburg area and needed a solid pizza plan before another event later that day. When we walked in, it was quiet quiet -- like, "are we early or is this a hidden gem?" quiet. We were maybe the 5th and 6th people in the place. I found Grace while panic-scrolling Yelp for a legit slice within a very specific radius, and it popped up right at the top. A bunch of reviews mentioned the mysterious "yellow crust," which immediately hooked me. Yellow crust? Say less. We were officially intrigued and fully on board for whatever adventure this was about to be. Then we saw it. The 4 Flavor Pizza. One medium pizza. Four different kinds. Two slices of each. For $17. Absolute genius. We didn't even glance at the rest of the menu after that. Our lineup: Hawaiian, pepperoni & mushroom, onion & sausage, and bacon & meatball. I have never seen a pizza shop offer this and honestly... why isn't everyone doing this?! We grabbed a Coca-Cola and a Diet Pepsi, bringing our total to around $25, and I asked if they could cut the slices in half so we could really maximize our flavor-sampling experience. Zero hesitation. No side-eye. Just a cheerful "sure!" (10/10 already.) The pizza came out quickly and looked fantastic. And yes -- the crust really is yellow. Not "kind of yellow." Not "maybe the lighting." YELLOW yellow. There was absolutely no hiding the fact that something different was happening here. Adventure Buddy immediately went into detective mode, cracked the case, and couldn't help himself -- he asked the person behind the counter to confirm his theory. And as much as it pains me to say it... he was right. EGG. Tons of egg in the dough. That's the secret. The result is a crust that's fluffy, slightly sweet, and completely unlike your standard pizza crust. Grace Pizza was a win for me. This is a very specific kind of pizza -- the kind you crave when you want something a little different -- but when that craving hits, I'll know exactly where to go. Plenty of parking since it's in a strip mall. Pro tip: check your directions ahead of time. Grace sits on a main road that is a real pain in the ass to turn around on if you miss your turn. Don't say I didn't warn you.

Service was great but it is really a Mexican restaurant. Also way too much cheese on the pizza.read more

It was take out we ordered a Stromboli.. loved it I will be going back there again,…read moreThe Stromboli was thinner then most stromboli we generally, I loved that

Got my order wrong and there was a bug at the bottom of my water cup drink. Wouldn't recommend…read more Edit: look how wonderful the manager is owning up to their mistakes. 0/10 will never recommend.

Great spaghetti and meat sauce lunch. portions are so large be ready to take some home…read more I was seated promptly after arriving 5 minutes after they opened for lunch. My prder was taken promptly with my drink and fresh hot bread and butter delivered to the table while I waited for my spaghett. The only improvement I could suggest would be having the person who delivered the food to the table take off the black latex food prep gloves he was wearing first. That gives a poor atmosphere.

I was getting worried. I moved here from South Jersey not too long ago and this is the 6th pizza…read moreplace I've tried after 5 duds. Didn't wanna get fancy the first time round so I just had the plain cheese and it was just like what I'm used to back home! Finally! Loved it! So happy to find you guys!

I don't think you could find a better cheese steak sandwich anywhere. Generous size, quality meat,…read moreperfectly melted cheese and a freshly baked roll. I've been there three times and the quality is consistent.

I seriously hate giving 2 stars cause the Food and Service is always good but unfortunately today I…read morewas disappointed. The Server who took my order was rude and disregarded my request to ask the cooks to leave my food in the oven longer to get crispy which is easier on my stomach but to avoid wasting my money I ate all of the extra grease which will make me ill for the rest of the evening. I'll eat here again but it won't be anytime soon. I still recommend this place but I told my Wife I won't do takeout anymore.

Best New York style pizza my wife and I have had in years. Great service. My wife and I had…read morestopped eating pizza because we could not find what we considered good pizza. Will definitely be visiting many times in the future.

Twice in a row now we have gotten pizza with crust like shoe leather. I messaged them and got no…read moreresponse. I'm not sure what has changed there but whatever it is isn't working. Very disappointed.

My boyfriend and I needed somewhere along 30 to have a quick late night dinner and Pat & Carla's…read morefit the bill. We made it in about an hour before close and the dining room was basically empty. The staff were friendly, though, and seated us and brought waters and menus quickly. Our server took a minute to come over, but when she finally did, she took our orders and had the food out quickly. I saw several people picking up to go orders of pizza while we waited. My bf had the big boy sub and I ordered the chicken parm sub. We split buffalo boneless wings an an app. Nothing was fancy, but the portion sizes were large for the price. I definitely thought we got our monies worth. I couldn't finish my sandwich and my bf barely did. The restaurant itself is nothing to rave about. It was clean and bright, but a little outdated. I did appreciate the Christmas tree and other holiday decor sprinkled throughout. Plus, they have a decent sized pavedparking lot located right out front.

We took it to go but wow the food was amazing, the only thing I didn't care for was the side salad…read morebut other than that everything tasted great!! The service was great everyone was welcoming and go our orders correct. This was my first time trying it and I will def be back again!!

Advertised prices don't match what you're charged…read more.. Ordered by phone and picked up in person. There are three different prices for the same special, depending on how you order: * Window sign advertises: 2 large, one-topping pizzas for $24.99 * Their own website lists the same special at $25.99 * Phone/in-store order charged $27.98 for the two pizzas (before tax/fees) At pickup, I was told extra cheese is a "topping that costs more," but on their own website ordering page, extra cheese is included the same way other toppings are for this special. That explanation still doesn't account for the higher price and directly contradicts how the deal is presented online. Even assuming both pizzas were simply one-topping pizzas, the price charged was still higher than both advertised prices. Receipt, website pricing, and window signage all show different amounts. The pizza itself was fine, but pricing transparency matters. Based on this experience, I won't be returning or recommending this place.

Stopped in for lunch and the restaurant looked very promising…read more However it was lunch time and there was not much traffic. They offered pizza by the slice and whole pies as well. I tried a slice of pizza and a steak with mozzarella, mushrooms and onions sub. The slice could've been heated longer to crisp up the bottom and I ask if the roll was heated and it was nearly heated so the roll was too soft for the steak and cheese. The roll used had no structure and did not work for me. The shaved steak tased good but they need to use the right rolls.

The atmosphere and the staff were second to none! From the hostess to the waitress to the busgirl,…read moreeveryone was smiling and pleasant. It wasn't the best Chicken Parm I've ever had, but wasn't the worst. Definitely worth a stop if you're in the area.

Food is always fast, hot, and tasty. Good service, fair prices. And the menu offers a wide…read morevariety of foods to choose from.

Excellent food...warm and friendly service...portions are very generous. The smell of homemade…read morebread is amazing!

Very disappointed. 3 times they have gotten our orders wrong. Was told if I brought it back in…read morethey would make it right; I live in Fayetteville!! Never again!