Pizza Man

All food is really great. And their cheese....YUMMY. Good selection of plants in their nursery.read more

Very good experience, food was good and staff treated us well…read more The restaurant is clean, comfy and welcoming.

Unusual petunia plant I brought home.

See all

Jersey Mike's Subs

4.8(6 reviews)

1.3 mi

I was on my way to West Virginia to help the needy and me and the boys stumbled upon the greatest…read morejersey mikes of all time. When I walked right in the man slicing up the meat was probably one of the most friendliest people I have ever met. He was full of energy and jokes that I almost peed my pants!!!!! The next lady who put my condiments on was also just so friendly and kind! She told me I looked really good today and it just made my day!!!! The guy who rang me up was another outstanding young man. He was soooo friendly and could not stop making the funniest jokes. They were a perfect example of what I want to see when I walk into jersey mikes!!!!!!! When I started eating my sub (mikes way) it was so amazing. They put just the right meat and condiments on and it was perfect. The most important thing I felt like the sub was made with love which is what I loved most about it!!! Great job jersey mikes of shippensburg you outdid yourself!!!

We were traveling to Shippensburg university for a baseball game when we stumbled upon Jersey…read moreMikes. Store was clean and the service was quick and friendly. I had the #7 (turkey and provolone) and my husband had the #8 (club hoagie). Both were fresh, beautifully sized and delicious. We beat the lunch rush by just a few minutes but everyone moved through the line quickly. Great find!

See all

Monterrey Tacos

4.5(19 reviews)

0.2 mi

Amazing food and always my craving go to over azteca etc. simple and quick service so definitely a…read moregood spot for those solo trips too when you want to be antisocial. Open floor plan with a uplifting bright atmosphere hidden away in center shippensburg!

The food was wonderful and the service was great! It's so awesome to find amazing tacos in our…read morearea! What a gem!

Quesabirria Torta

See all

Churros and Quesabirria Tacos

University Grille

3.5(91 reviews)

0.3 mi

I hadn't been here since it's been the University Grille, so I decided to take my GF here for a…read moreSaturday night dinner - we made reservations for the dining room ~8pm, but it turned out that we were the only ones dining in - the patio & bar were hoppin' however! Service was good as we had the room to ourselves - like the SU themed decorations on the walls. We both ordered 8oz Sirloins & Sweet Potato Fries. Sirloin was good, but i think it actually may have been accidentally salted twice.... easily rectified by dumping a little water on it to wash the salt away (I'm easy to please;) - was perfect after that! Sweet Potato Fries were AWEsome! Trying to watch carb intake so good sweet potato fries are always a treat;) Would like to return here ...maybe even sit outside on a slightly cooler night;)

Sat at a bar table and waited 15 minutes until someone came to take a drink order. Not super busy…read more Ordered the strip steak. Terrible steak for $31. Ordered mr got mw. I finally asked someone to wait on me and a random waitress took my order that did not have the section I was sitting in. I will say, the waitress was super polite and apologetic. Still would not go back though.

Portobello Pappardelle Pasta

See all

Art of Pie Cafe

4.3(23 reviews)

0.2 mi

Service was good and the place is cute. A lot of cakes to pick from and some pastries and other…read morefood. The iced latte was watery and not good. The cake was good. But pricey, I got 1 slice of cake, 1 latte and 1 breakfast sandwich and it was $19... seems like a lot. The breakfast sandwich was small and only had 1 piece of bacon it on it.

Great little coffee shop in a town full of history. Large selection of goodies, cookies, cake and…read moreplenty more.

Storefront

Pies!

See all

Redemption BBQ

4.0(50 reviews)

0.3 mi

Dropping my daughter off at college and we went here for dinner. While it's not the greatest bbq…read morewe have ever had, we thought it was pretty good. The amount of food was insane though. We ordered a tray, nachos and a pulled chicken sandwich. We thought we ordered the half nachos but did end up with the full. The amount of food could have fed 8 to 10 people. The atmosphere I thought was great. The staff were friendly and fun, and the prices, to us, were crazy low for the amount of food you received. I have no doubt this will be a regular for the college kids, and we will definitely be back when we come visit.

I stopped in today for lunch and based on the quality of food I have to drop my overall rating to…read morethree stars. Today I ordered a brisket sandwich. I knew the brisket was pulled and not sliced when I ordered. The brisket was the driest least flavorful brisket I have had in a long long time and I regretted my meal choice instantly. The sandwich was large and overstuffed which would have been great, except it meant I had to eat a lot of the dried out meat on its own. Even worse the amount of sauce provided was pathetic. If I had a decent amount of sauce it may have hidden the poor meat. Overall I give the brisket sandwich 1 star and do not recommend it to anyone. Another point that was a bummer was neither my sandwich or Mac and cheese were hot. Eating half cold food that's dried out is ok at a backyard bbq but when paying $15 for lunch I am looking for something of higher quality.

Smoked Mac and cheese

Cheese fries

See all

Smoked wings in their BBQ sauce.

Diffy's Family Restaurant

3.2(23 reviews)

3.2 mi

So yummy in my tummy. There were no ants. The food was amazing and they let me eat as much salt as…read moreI wanted.

Its sad, I grew up loving diffys. For over forty years I would prefer them over anything less in…read morethe area. But lately there food changed, like they changed food providers. Now it just boring bland food, sucks like everyone else in shippensburg area!!!!

Outside Sign.

See all

1/4 of the broasted chicken (breast) and cottage cheese

Knute's Tap Room

3.4(30 reviews)

0.2 mi

This restaurant is the most inaccurately rated restaurant I have ever reviewed. Its current rating…read moreis completely inaccurate and in fact you should eat here, its very, very, good. As I understand it is under new management and ownership but is being held down by old ratings. Please only pay attention to the new ratings. My experience started with the fact the place is very cute, quiet, romantic, and quaint. I really like the lights and the local postcards on the walls establishing a sense of place. I had the cheese steak which had some unique cheeses and other ingredients including horseradish aioli and peppers. It was a very tasty new take on a classic. Could use a bit more aioli and seasoning. But it was very good and the portion was huge. My wife had the soup of the day and enjoyed it. we also had a Ceasar salad.. and that is what it is. I LOVE them but you can't really rate such a standard. The service was amazing and the waitress and all other staff were completely on point. The food came out quick, and if I am in town again I WILL eat here again. I would love to try some of the dinner entrees.

Another wonderful meal, arrived at 6pm waited 10 minutes and was seated and greeted and Maddie was…read moreour waitress, awesome service she is great. The seafood bisque was very good. We had boom boom chicken wrap and a smothered chicken sandwich. Both wonderful and the entire meal was great.

Stop in to check out our specials offered daily and our new upstairs calling 15 west! 21 and Over uptop

Thirsty?! Check out our microcraft draft selection

See all

Alfredo's Pizza

3.3(55 reviews)

1.2 mi

Very good food! The food was seasoned well. Um Um good! First day I got white pizza, delicious!…read more The tomatoes and broccoli seasoned with garlic on top of the mozzarella and ricotta cheese, hit the spot. Second time bought the Grilled Buffalo Chicken Boli. Very tasty. The drizzle of hot sauce with chicken and cheese brought it all together! Keep it up Alfredo!

We were staying at the local Holiday Inn and there were several menus in the lobby from Alfredo's…read more There were plenty of choices for us to each get what we wanted, so we decided to try Alfredo's. My husband got a pizza and I got the cold sub. Big portions and tasty. This place has counter service with plenty of tables and booths and did a big pick up business. Glad someone left those menus in the lobby!

Grilled chicken salad !

Penne alla Carbonara

See all

Arooga's

3.0(122 reviews)

0.3 mi

First time trying Arooga's. We placed a delivery order. I recommend the Sampler Platter. The cook…read moreand flavor of the cheeseburger sliders were perfect. Honestly, everything in the sampler was enjoyable. We also ordered 10 wings and were not disappointed. Lastly I ordered the Arooga's chopped salad. Presentation and taste were very good. This won't be our last time ordering. Good job Arooga's!!!

Went here for homecoming as I hadn't been to Shippensburg in years. The waitress was completely…read moreoverwhelmed and scattered. I for the life of me couldn't understand why they didn't have more staff on deck. The food and drinks were ok, the main thing on their side is affordability

Late Dinner

Nashville Faux Chicken Sandwich

See all

The bar

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Climbin H.

12 years ago

Arguably the best pizza in town and it's a college town. Pizza places are not hard to come by.

April B.

8 years ago

Will never eat here again.... If I could have given it zero stars I would have, not worth it

Joshua N.

Elite 13

144

346

16 years ago

Great pizza. Enough said.

Chad B.

14 years ago

Best pizza in town.

Pizza Man - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Shippensburg, Pennsylvania Things to Do near Pizza Man

BEST of Shippensburg, Pennsylvania Restaurants near Pizza Man

BEST of Shippensburg, Pennsylvania Desserts near Pizza Man

BEST of Shippensburg, Pennsylvania Coffee near Pizza Man

BEST of Shippensburg, Pennsylvania Parking near Pizza Man

BEST of Shippensburg, Pennsylvania Breakfast near Pizza Man

BEST of Shippensburg, Pennsylvania Dinner near Pizza Man

BEST of Shippensburg, Pennsylvania Burgers near Pizza Man

BEST of Shippensburg, Pennsylvania Shopping near Pizza Man

BEST of Shippensburg, Pennsylvania Movie Theatre near Pizza Man

Best of Shippensburg

Things to do in Shippensburg

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Pizza Man also viewed

Alfredo's Pizza

3.3

(55 reviews)

Deliso Pizza

4.3

(82 reviews)

Slightly off the beaten path since a mile from center of downtown Gettysburg, this is clearly a…read morelocal favorite. Very busy with folks popping in their pjs to pick up dinner. Generous portions of great food and reasonable prices. The gluten free hoagie roll was the best I have ever had, can't even tell it's gluten free!

Celiac friendly, gluten free . This place is a wonder. My wife is a full blown go to the hospital…read moreif I breathe gluten and this was a wonderful find. They knew all the precautions and knew exactly what was up. Gf homemade garlic bread and pizza. My wife the western pizza, very delicious. Thank you

Tommy's Pizza

3.7

(367 reviews)

It has been several years since I visited on vacation in Gettysburg as lots has changed with known…read morethings from past aren't around anymore so sad but one thing Tommy's is still here and appearing to be going strong. Sunday 7/26/2026 returned for a vacation as arrived headed to Tommy's as We had an excellent pizza with mushrooms as ate outside at dining tables with our doggie dachshund Haleigh Ann with purchasing cold cut hoagies for the next day as they were great also. Very nice place to dine in or on the sidewalk in good weather. Tommy's has been around in Gettysburg for years with a nice location corner of Washington street and Steinwehr Avenue. You won't be disappointed with your dining experience. Good Job !!!! May you Keep your Business going Strong for many long Years !!!!

Everything went very well from the time of ordering and receiving our food and the food was great…read more The service was good and fast camp complaint

Pat & Carla's Italian Eatery

3.3

(24 reviews)

Pizza is good as are the salads, but I'm not a fan at all of anyplace that adds things to my food…read morethat is not listed on the menu or I asked for. Sadly, this place does both. It's been awhile since I have been here because of my busy travel schedule, so I figured today was the day to visit it again while I was nearby. I ordered two pizza slices with some veggies added (their slice pizza is always just cheese pizza that they add toppings to as requested. They don't have slice pizza already made with any toppings like many other places do, which is fine by me). I looked forward to eat nice, crisp, hot pizza with veggies added. Instead I was disappointed by the slices having added melted "mozzarella" on the slices. I didn't ask for or want extra cheese. I just wanted a couple of slices of normal cheese pizza with some veggies added on top. I refused the "heart attack waiting to happen" pizza slices. They were replaced by two slices the way I asked for them - cheese slices with veggies, not extra cheese. The server told me they "always add a little extra cheese on the top." But no where is that stated on the menu or when ordering. I also ordered 2 meatballs with sauce, an antipasto salad and the garlic bread it came with, but with just red wine vinegar, not any of the oil based vinaigrette, ranch, etc. dressings they offer. What I got was garlic bread and sliced meatballs in sauce, covered with guess what? "Mozzarella" cheese I didn't ask for and is not stated on the menu. The garlic bread was an oily mess because the cheese melted into its oily state and the only garlic they use is in the bitter I was told. No actual garlic on the bread was visible or tasted. The meatballs were sliced and covered with the gobs of melted mozzarella cheese too. What's with the fascination with adding cheese to melt on everything? The "mozzarella" cheese has no distinguishable taste, nor does the provolone in the antipasto. Possibly lower cost from the supplier so lower quality results. Have these folks heard some people prefer living life a bit more by watching calories and fat intake? We can actually do that by limiting the intake of bad stuff but still enjoy all types of food in moderation. I gave 2 stars because the pizza and antipasto are good or okay and the server was nice as well. But the fascination with melted cheese on everything and not saying it on the menu or checking with the customer first is not only unhealthy for people but wasteful and unwise when customers either return the food for replacement or simply eat it and never come back. I'm mostly vegetarian (technically a flexitarian) and enjoy Italian food which fits into that food lifestyle.

If I could give 0 stars, I would. Orders have been wrong lately. Food has been cold. Quality has…read moregone down. They don't like when you ask for changes or substitutions and don't get it right when you do. They also use Ken's salad dressing in packets. That is like going to your great great aunties house and you want a couple ritz crackers but all she has are Wal Mart rounds and when you take the first bite they are moist.... In these uncertain economic times - if you are going to pay for take out - it's better to stick to Mario's or Rosalie's. They get it right every time and have better quality. Sorry Pat and Carl's you won't even get my poker night orders... it's that bad.

Little Vince's Pizza

3.4

(18 reviews)

There is an expectation by the staff that you tip them while you're ordering (even when you are…read moreordering for carry out) before you receive goods and services. The lady who took our order yelled 'no tip' to the kitchen staff after we signed our receipt. We don't 'pre-tip' before we receive goods and services. While my husband and I were waiting on food to be made, the kitchen staff and the lady who took our order were making extremely nasty comments about us in Spanish. My husband lived in South America for seven years and is very fluent in Spanish. As my husband and I left the restaurant with our order the lady along with the I kitchen staff were loudly mocking us in the presence of other customers who were waiting on their food. We ordered the chicken Caesar salad and the meat lovers pizza. I was very dissatisfied with the salad since the chicken wasn't prepared correctly and the bread that came with it wasn't fully cooked (the center was still doughy). The pizza was extremely greasy, tasted extremely bland. It definitely wasn't worth the money. ** Side note(s) to the restaurant staff: you shouldn't try to act coy and insult your customers in Spanish because some of us DO UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU ARE SAYING!! Secondly, tips are generally given AFTER the receipt of goods and services, not before hand especially when a customer comes into the restaurant and orders their food for take out. Lastly, your business is open to the public and is subject to the state's public accomodations laws, translation you shouldn't be harassing customers based on protected factors outlined in the Pennsylvania Human Relations Act.**

This is a great place for Italian food people should try it! I had shrimp scampi and it was great…read morealso the egg plant parm is very good.

Jasmine & Angelo's Italian Restaurant

4.1

(8 reviews)

Very friendly folks and nice clean atmosphere. And fast service. The food was delicious.read more

This restaurant continues to decline and has reached a spot with no where to go but up…read more I went in today at 12:30 knowing I only had 20 minutes until my next meeting and thinking I could get two slices off the hot bar. However, there was half a Supreme pizza and that was it. When I asked the worker he said "this late after lunch we don't make more". Again, it was 12:30. I left without lunch knowing there was no way food would be ready and I could eat it in time. This will be my final time giving this restaurant a shot. So sad to see how far this place has slidden in such a short time.

Antica Napoli Pizza

4.6

(185 reviews)

excellent pizza and service! must go! run do not walk to Antica Napoli ! Arrived at 10 minutes…read moreto closing, they were happy to provide us with a pie!

We are from out of town and went with the Yelp recommendation. Not far from the town center ,…read moretucked away at the side of the building. Meat lovers was great, crispy crusty... quick service, clean and the staff was very nice!

Mamma's Pizzeria & Ristorante

4.5

(13 reviews)

Family-owned and very congenial manager & staff. In town for a soccer match, wife & I stopped in…read morefor early supper. She got the veal parmesan w/ spaghetti, which came hot and the veal perfectly cooked. My choice was what they call a "cheese steak hoagie", a truly flavorful and overstuffed hot sub on a wide, homemade roll. Couldn't eat it all, so took away half the meals. Huge menu of pizza, pizza pockets, strombolis, hot & cold subs, gyros, wraps, paninis, fish, shrimp, chicken, Mexican & Italian dinners, fajitas, & wings. Wish it were closer!

The staff was so kind and went out of their way to make conversation. The sub rolls were delicious…read moreand the pizza was fantastic!

Cafe del Sol

3.9

(71 reviews)

Great service! They were very patient with our toddler. Took care of us and gave us extra of things…read morewithout hesitation. Came to this town for the state park nearby, and looked for a casual lunch before coming back home to MD. We got there last minute for the 12-4pm lunch deal and they still allowed us to order at 3:59pm, which is very kind and honestly it wasn't a problem if they don't let us, but it's to show they do care for their customers and not that strict with rules. To me, it's an extra points as a restaurant! Food was decent. I can't say it's the best but it's a great menu design with thoughtful tasting planning. Even if the chicken was dry, the flavors and sauce matching makes it work and still tastes good. Overall we will surely come back for lunches or even dinners. Thanks again waitresses! Y'all ladies are so nice and made us glad we came here for lunch!

Waitress was amazing! Very patient with my elderly FIL. Food was really good, especially the…read moreshredded pork bao buns!

Frank's Pizza

3.8

(17 reviews)