We normally order pizza, subs, and wings but decided to try a stromboli and bring it back to the condo. Wow! So amazing: delicious crust, tons of ooey-gooey cheese, ham, ricotta and two sides of sauce. Our favorite bolis were made at the now-defunct Mancini's Italian Delight in Newville but since they went out of business, Napoli is our new favorite ... And why not? Everything else they make is delicious! read more

See all

Stopped by on a road trip, great stop. Placed our order, food was done quickly. Had the typical pizza shop feel. Nice staff. Pizza was great. Cheesesteak was really good as well, roll was made in house. Cheese hoagie was enjoyed by my wife. We all had a great time. read more

Had a delicious regular sized Stromboli last week. It had ham and pepperoni, and lots of mozzarella cheese. The dough wasn't too thick, and it was nice and crispy. It comes with a little container of thick, tasty marinara sauce. It was cut into 4 pieces. Thoroughly enjoyed! read more

Napoli Pizza - Regular size Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

This was my first time ordering from Napoli Pizza. I saw that they have gluten-free pizza, and thought I'd give them a try. I ordered their 12" gf pizza with pepperoni, onion, and mushrooms. Also ordered 12 piece buffalo wings with Cajun seasoning. The chicken was cooked perfectly but I could've used more Cajun flavor. The pizza was delicious. The crust tasted good and was a good consistency, but was rather dry on the bottom. Maybe need to brush it with olive oil before baking in the oven? We plan to order from them again! read more

Napoli Pizza - Gluten Free 12" pizza with pepperoni onions mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

I enjoy the pizza here. It's an ideal mixture of sauce and cheese. Owner is a bit brusque, yet he does open up once you talk with him. The crust is perfectly done. Price for a large pizza is good. Located in an easily accessible plaza and in a somewhat walkable locale, this is a pizza joint worth visiting! read more

The customer service was top tier greeted upon entering. The place was very clean. And the medium boli i got today was top tier and the price was not bad at all I got a bacon ham and pep boli extra cheese and it was so good I smashed it down in ONE SITTING! read more

See all

I've eaten here a few times now and the food has always been great. The service is fast even when busy. The interior is like most typical pizza shops with Italy pictures hanging on the wall. Very clean every time even during the times of bad weather they keep the place spotless. read more

We got the white pizza with sausage added, to go, and it was terrific. So, so good. Our friends even raved about the leftovers, eaten cold. Too bad we're two states away. read more

Great service, friendly staff. Easy parking, and great pizza. What else could you need! Definitely give it a try.

Very good! Good value pizza, will visit again. pizza was done in 20 minutes Zzzzzzxzzz read more

A good solid, old-fashioned pizzeria. Prompt friendly service in a timely manner. wish I could've given them a 4.5 or even a 4.9 but I cannot and the pizza was not a full blow 5. Still recommended when nearby. read more

Amazing food. Really quality service. This place has become a staple for us every other week or so. Can't get enough!

It's ok. We had chicken tender with fries which were pretty good. Tuna sandwich & chicken cheese steak sandwich were just mid tasting, a bit skimpy & skinny for what they charge. However, where they drop the ball is in their customer service. The passive aggressive tone from the young man that works there caused them a star & a customer. The last thing someone wants when ordering food is feeling like an overwhelming favor is being asked. read more

First of don't let the outside (strip mall) or the inside (cozy and order at front) fool you into missing out on this sleeper. I have been craving a good Stromboli because they are hard to find. Well Napoli exceeded my expectations as it was excellent from the dough to cheese and filling ratio, excellent dough. A nice sweet but not too sweet sauce along with a just right bake on it. Their salads are huge and the house dressing is superb. Their gentleman working the counter and the people making the food were all very nice and you could tell they have a ton of regulars come in. Price was great as well. Will go back again and again and try more of their menu if I can hold myself back from ordering the Stromboli. read more

Very good! My family split a small supreme pizza while in the area traveling through! It was really good and perfect for our family of 4!

The pasta and canoli were okay, but the pizza was lifeless. I thought I'd be blown away based on the reviews but was just disappointed. Thin was a weird texture and overall the pizza was like something from a grocery's frozen aisle. read more

We ordered a Sicilian pizza for dinner...couldn't wait to tear into it only to have it burnt and completely dried out! Was so disappointed. This should have never even been sent out of this restaurant and sent home with a customer! Will definitely not be ordering from here again read more

My wife and I are from the Philadelphia area. When we moved out this way it was impossible for us to find good pizza. We looked and looked. We would get pizza that was not crispy at all, no flavor, just bland sub par pizza. Then we found Napoli. The pizza here is not like back home, but it's solid. This place has a very good Sicilian pizza and I'm not a fan of thick deep dish pizzas, but man this one hits the spot and will leave you full. Friday night is pizza night in our house and we usually go here. I would recommend you give it a try and see for yourself. read more

What a great place on yelp to eat!! Got a pepperoni pizza and an antipasto salad with their Greek dressing that was the best ever. Definitely a repeat when we are in this area. read more

Five freakin stars all day long!!!I I ordered a simple large cheese. And let me tell you, it was the best Cheese pizza I've had in years. The sauce is tasty but not spicy and certainly not bland. The cheese combination they use is excellent! I got delivery so I can't comment on interior ambiance or cleanliness but the food is definitely 100% on point! I also ordered the bone in buffalo wings. They were spectacular! Crispy yet meaty and tasty. The sauce was not too hot. Although you can order it that way if you want. Delivery was quick and under 30 mins. Fast, polite professional epic service. Best food hands down since I've been staying in Carlisle! Try it! You won't regret it! read more

Napoli Pizza - Slice of the best cheese pizza I've ever had!! - Pizza Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

Based on the hotel clerks recommendation I decided to try Napoli. This is a small sandwich pizza shop located in a strip mall. First thing I noticed when I walked in were all of the construction guys. I took that as a good sign. Having been a a construction guy in a previous life they tend to eat at places that have filling food at good prices. We ordered the cheesesteak sandwich with sauce. The bread is made in house. Very soft and fresh. The cheesesteak was super satisfying comfort food. Very cheesy please and the fries were piping hot and soft with just a little bit of potato skin. Really good overall. read more

Napoli Pizza - Cheesesteak sandwich with sauce - Pizza Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

We had a small pizza and a chef salad. The salad was quite tasty. Not a lot of frills but a good basic salad. Pizza was very good. Beats any of the chains as far as we are concerned. Will be back when we are in the area. read more

Had the Napoli Italian sub. Very good with Capitola as one of the meats. The bread was excellent with little crunch to it. Personable owner. No problem having extra hot peppers. read more

Fairly good pizza ordered the Sicilian comes in squares . Only downfall was wishing the bottom was a little crisper , had no crunch. Overall would order it again read more

Great meatball sub. Huge. Salad was fresh and crisp. Everything I wanted for a quick, enjoyable meal.

I had the cheese steak Stromboli tonight along with a dinner salad. Both were excellent. The Stromboli had plenty of meat and cheese was well baked and hot. The salad was fresh and delicious. I have ordered here many of times and have not gotten any thing I didn't like. One of my favorite pizza places!! read more

We eat here every time we come into Carlisle to visit our daughter and her family. This time I had the manicotti and it was fabulous. It came with a salad and garlic roll. The salad had too many black olives and peppers for me but the son in law gladly ate those. The garlic roll was great but then so was the cheese bread on the side. I definitely recommend them! read more

We had a great hero late Sunday nite before MLK Monday holiday after 8PM ALL other places were closed. they were open until 10:30PM. The hero and bread was delicious read more

I ordered 2 dozen hot wings asked for extra blue cheese dipping sauce receive 2 little cups for 2 dozen wings beside the fact that it was 41.00 . When I called they said dips are extra cost and sorry they forgot the extra and they would send more out at an additional fee. Guy was very rude. I'm basically upset because I order from this place often and have never been so poorly treated and terrible service I will be speaking with management tomorrow read more

If you want AAAmazing pizza from a local Italian Hero, consider flooding Napoli Carlisle with your business&&Art read more

Napoli Pizza - Pizza that challenges the Gods. - Pizza Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

We ordered pizzas, Stromboli and subs. Everything was absolutely delicious, fresh/crisp, not chewy even with it being delivered. 10/10, we will definitely be ordering again! read more

What a freaking gem. Stumbled on it on a work trip. Didn't know what I wanted so Alfredo made me this work of art-- mouthwatering. Best food in Carlisle, absolutely hands down. And terrific service to boot. read more

Napoli Pizza - a plate of pasta with chicken and spinach - Pizza Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

Having lived in Naples, Italy (best pizza in the whole wide world), we are definitely pizza snobs. This place is worth the 45-min drive for us as they have a few Neapolitan certified pizzas (dough and sauce ingredients and mozzarella di buffala). Staff is friendly and Sergio's quick. read more

Found this pizza restaurant from Yelp had the best ratings for Carlisle Pa in general. It was a stop over heading back to Charlotte and was a wise choice. I and my wife shared the house supreme pizza that was by far a great pie but made the old fashioned Italian style NYC style. The pie was thin crested and crispy the toppings were excellent. The sauce was the correct amount to the excellent mozzarella cheese was tasty and stringy. Being originally from South Brooklyn this pie was a treat and not a disappointment I highly recommend this restaurant and will make it a stop on my next trip back to NYC ! read more

Napoli Pizza - Pizza from Notalies - Pizza Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

This place has a really good NY/Neopolitan-style pie. I got one to take back to my hotel while on a business trip in Carlisle and was pleased. As a NY native, I'm picky about pizza, and this place is solid. I see they also serve a Sicilian pie, which I would try next time. I assume it's good as well. They were friendly and quick on my order. It's a legit slice shop, you can get slices as well as whole pies. I definatley recommend Napoli Pizza. read more

Napoli Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

First time visit to Napoli Pizza... Found it to be a very nice "hole in the wall" type pizza house. On that note, we find that most "hole in the wall" restaurants are in fact - GREAT places to eat. That being said, Napoli Pizza was FANTASTIC... Had a 12" cheese with green peppers. The flavor was superb... I have eaten quite a few pizzas over time. Most leave much to be desired in the "flavor" department, but Napoli Pizza was EXCELLENT beyond approach. Wife had a pasta dinner. This too was nothing less that SUPERIOR IN QUALITY AND TASTE... The crew was friendly and most helpful as we were unsure of the procedure. We would HIGHLY RECOMMEND Napoli Pizza for an OUTSTANDING plate of pasta and pizza. read more

Delicious pizza, fantastic customer service, clean, bathroom was totally clean. We got three different slices: Grandma Pizza (they call it Old Fashioned on their menu), Meat Lovers, and Cheese. All were great! Love the authentic New York style thin crust, the sauce is delicious, and the cheese is top quality. Their sauce is flavorful, and, word to the wise, it's a lot saltier than typical New York pizza sauce, so be ware of what toppings you choose. The Meat Lovers meat toppings are a bit of a sodium overload with their sauce (especially the ham, which is very salty) but this is not a complaint, just a good piece of data so you can make sure to tailor your pie to what you're looking for. Family owned, these folks clearly take great pride in offering great food at reasonable prices. And they are just SO nice, friendly, and welcoming, which puts them way over the top from 4 stars to 5+++! (Although honestly I'd give them 5 stars for the pizza even if their customer service was robotic, because it was just that tasty : ) ) Happily, although we don't live in the area, our normal travel route between our current home (Virginia) and family (New York City, hometown) takes us past Carlisle PA on Interstate 81, so we will make it our business to stop at Napoli Pizza anytime we need a meal while traveling this way. Looking forward to trying their Eggplant Parm, Chicken Parm, and just about everything else on the menu. read more

Napoli Pizza - the front of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

Excellent pizza and subs and sauce. Good people! Just a good place to to. Always happy to serve you with a smile. You drive in parking lot at one end and Napoli's is at the other end. read more

Unironically the best pizza I have ever had! I am a truck driver from California and have eaten my fair share of pizza but nothing compares to what I had last night at Napoli's. Napoli Pizza proved a point showing that PA is where the good stuff is at. read more

Napoli Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

When you are driving in a different state and staying in a hotel, you are never quite sure where to eat... until you look it up on Yelp. We wanted a quick pizza and I was thrilled that they had gluten-free, too. The place was clean and the service was good. Pizza was tasty! read more

See all