Benny's Pizza

Stopped by on a road trip, great stop. Placed our order, food was done quickly. Had the typical…read morepizza shop feel. Nice staff. Pizza was great. Cheesesteak was really good as well, roll was made in house. Cheese hoagie was enjoyed by my wife. We all had a great time.

I enjoy the pizza here. It's an ideal mixture of sauce and cheese. Owner is a bit brusque, yet he…read moredoes open up once you talk with him. The crust is perfectly done. Price for a large pizza is good. Located in an easily accessible plaza and in a somewhat walkable locale, this is a pizza joint worth visiting!

Pizza that challenges the Gods.

Cheesesteak with mushrooms and sauce.

See all

Nonna Ilva

4.3(48 reviews)

4.5 mi

New location in Carlisle!!!! Awesome to sit and eat Amazing flavor dishes !!!!…read moreWe could reserve big group(15 people) to have whole room ourselves as well. Very cool place in Carlisle to have wonderful food

On the positive side: Delicious food!…read moreLarge portions of pasta! Friendly staff. Decent prices. Nice music and atmosphere. The negative? Very bright lights. We went for Sunday lunch. It was very busy and they were definitely overwhelmed. We waited for a long time to get drinks and a long time for food. Hiremore staff for the busy times!

Dessert

See all

Nonna Iiva in Carlisle PA

Navarro’s Pizza

4.5(4 reviews)

0.4 mi

Incredible pizza!! Excellent service!! they have super delicious desserts. I wish we could've eaten…read moreone, but we over ate our pizza and couldn't fit anything else in our bellies. Thank you so much for the excellent service.

Other half come here to eat after work -- today we met for supper. This used to be Anile's and…read morethey're still using the old menus until, our server told us, the new ones arrive. We had the same spaghetti with meat sauce, hot bread (which was great) and the side salads. Our meals were ready quickly and we had the restaurant to ourselves until the end when an older couple came in. Lots of take-out business. I'm sure we'll head back at some point. Thanks for a good meal!

New sign for Navarro's

Chicken Cheesesteak

See all

Gigantic calzone

Antica Napoli Pizza

4.6(179 reviews)

22.9 mi

We are from out of town and went with the Yelp recommendation. Not far from the town center ,…read moretucked away at the side of the building. Meat lovers was great, crispy crusty... quick service, clean and the staff was very nice!

Their pizza is great and the lady at the counter is very nice. Really great pizza stop in…read moreGettysburg.

Restrooms positive!

See all

Chicken Parm Hot Sub

Seve-N-Dots Publik Pizza Place

4.6(187 reviews)

4.4 mi

We ordered take out and they had it ready right on time. I say this is classic style pizza on a…read morethinner style crust. Less cheese than other places which I appreciate because I can actually taste the rest of the toppings! Not greasy at all and so much flavor.

Sorry it just isn't good pizza, like no flavor, very little sauce, very little cheese. Just super…read moredisappointed with the lack of flavor. Service was great, nice people, but..

Inside

Buffalo chicken cheesesteak

See all

Marcello's

3.9(182 reviews)

5.4 mi

Randomly looking for a new place to eat yesterday, we came upon Marcello's Ristorante, Pizzeria, &…read moreCatering in Carlisle. It was absolutely amazing. Best Chicken Parm I've ever had anywhere. Everything is made to order, and you definitely taste it. Garlic bread is pulled from the oven for the table, which is great. My "side" of Fettuccine Alfredo was amazing and more like a main course since there was so much. We can't believe we've never been here before, but will definitely be at the top of the rotation now. Amazing.

I really enjoyed the food from here! The lobster ravioli is very very good! Very large portions! I…read moreordered a medium stuffed pizza, and I can't imagine what the large looks like! It is huge! I also ordered the breaded mushrooms and it would've fed 3 people! How are they making money with portions this big! The service was top notch also! I can't handle spicy food, not even pepperoni, and I have a hard time speaking some times because I had a full laryngectomy but the young lady at the counter was very kind and patient with me, and helped me find some substitutes and they didn't charge me anything extra! The place had a nice vibe going on, everyone in the kitchen was busy, but all seemed to be enjoying what they did! I'd highly recommend this place if you're looking for top notch Italian cuisine! Very tasty!

Dining area

Bruschetta

See all

Personal Red Bruschetta Pizza with added mushrooms and pepperoni

Miseno Pizza and Ristorante

3.7(37 reviews)

5.3 mi

The staff was amazing! My team went here before our game and the environment was open and clean!…read moreThe food was warm, and came out fast! Would come here again, thank you guys! You all did great!

This might be okay for eat-in, but ordering delivery is a crap shoot. I ordered a pasta dinner & a…read moresub. They called to say the chef wasn't in today, so they are not cooking dinners. Fine. I cancelled the dinner & kept the sub. They missed their first 3 arrival times(per Yelp, they are a 7 minute drive from my location). They were 20 minutes late from the first estimated arrival time & the person who answered the phone when I called offered no help.

See all

Tuscany's Pizzeria

4.6(31 reviews)

32.8 mi

YUM!! Loved that it is a family-owned business, two brothers!…read more We stopped after mass and tour of St. Elizabeth Ann Seton's Basilica and Shrine. A spiritual haven! We were fortunate to come upon this wonderful pizza place on the main street in Emmitsburg! They have parking in the back and we witnessed people walking out carrying two-three boxes of pizza to their cars. They said it was the best! Well, they were right!! We ordered a large pie with mushrooms and onion. Fresh mushrooms (not canned) and plentiful. The sauce and cheese were delish! Nice thin crust (they also have Sicilian and other dishes and subs). The service by Justin was top notch and very friendly. We will DEFINITELY be back as we travel from PA back and forth to visit our family. Sorry we forgot to take a picture, it smelled so delicious, we dove right in!!

This local pizza joint serves very yummy pizza! We are visiting the area and decided to check it…read moreout. We were greeted immediately by Kaitlyn who was attentive, knowledgeable and friendly the entire visit. Got the meat lovers gourmet pizza and it didn't disappoint. Granted, we ingested way too many calories, but if you're looking for crispy, perfectly done pizza that's not too thick, I highly recommend.

Sicilian Style

See all

Cheese pizza slice

Mazzone's Pizza

3.8(50 reviews)

5.8 mi

We were looking for a reasonably priced pizza place on the way to Hershey Park…read more We had a salad, a Stromboli and some pasta. The portions were good, but nothing special. It was what we wanted and what we were looking for at the time. We would stop again, but not go out of our way.

Great local gem! Staff was super friendly and pizza was really good. The cannoli was probably the…read morebest I've ever had!

New name same owner

Meat lovers Stromboli

See all

Rigatoni bolognese

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

5 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Karensziti21 O.

0

1

0

5 years ago

i stepped up in the cut trying to have a nice time cause i always get a pizza from here n that shit goes hard. but today me and my homie came in and i was served by a bitchy trailer trash server who maybe spoke 10 words to me max. it took me 15 minutes to get one water refill trust me i'm no dickhead i get that food service can be ass ive worked it before but our waitress was just a str8 up bitch read more

Heidi D.

0

1

0

1 year ago

This is 1of the Best And Most Important Delicious yummy food doesn't matter what u order Absolutely excellent 10 star s !!!!!! Or more if i could read more

Amy S.

0

6

0

6 years ago

Great pizzza! One of my favorite pizza places in Cumberland County! The mozzarella sticks are the bomb too! Make sure to order 2 orders!

Kristen C.

0

12

5

5 years ago

Love this place! Always have always will! Service is kind and friendly! Food is always great tasting!!

Gman R.

0

5

0

12 years ago

Great place! ! Had a chicken salad could have been better, but over all nice, clean and friendly. ..

Benny's Pizza - pizza - Updated July 2026

People who viewed Benny's Pizza also viewed

Napoli Pizza

4.5

(117 reviews)

Stopped by on a road trip, great stop. Placed our order, food was done quickly. Had the typical…read morepizza shop feel. Nice staff. Pizza was great. Cheesesteak was really good as well, roll was made in house. Cheese hoagie was enjoyed by my wife. We all had a great time.

I enjoy the pizza here. It's an ideal mixture of sauce and cheese. Owner is a bit brusque, yet he…read moredoes open up once you talk with him. The crust is perfectly done. Price for a large pizza is good. Located in an easily accessible plaza and in a somewhat walkable locale, this is a pizza joint worth visiting!

Graziella's Pizza Subs & Italian Restorante

4.1

(16 reviews)

We have been going here about once a week for a year or so spending atleast $50 each time. The food…read moreis soo good, but now I doubt we will go back. We have been getting an Italian with half of what I want and half of what my husband wants for awhile now. Last week we called in and they said they can no longer do it that way because its too hard to put in the computer. Told me to order 2 kids subs that its the same price but half a sub with whatever we want on it. But to get 2 kids is $4 more. Its just so they can make more money. I wasn't so upset until the other came came from the back and said well they shouldn't have been doing it that way at all, a sub comes how it comes. Good luck!

Very Good local place for subs & pizza. They make their own sandwich rolls. CLEAN!! Friendly too.read more

Brad's Pizza

3.6

(22 reviews)

In my opinion the very best pizza in the area! Brad's sauce and crust are delicious, and he is…read morevery generous with the toppings. His food offerings are many and the restaurant always clean and tidy the many times I have been there for lunch.

Called in to Philly cheesesteaks and they were ready in 15 minutes. For a weekday, it was pretty…read morebusy and the ambiance seemed very chill and clean. Food tasted good, but a bit heavy on the grease.

USA & I

4.4

(55 reviews)

I got an Italian sub. The bread was very good. The vegetables were very fresh and we enjoyed it.read more

Umm. Pizza burnt. Black on the bottom This is a continuous…read moreissue. Something is messed up. $17 for a small 2 topping pizza and it was burned. Called shop. No response or initiative to correct. You don't burn and item and not know it. They knew and sold it anyway.

Palermo's Pizzeria & Italian Family Restaurant

4.5

(214 reviews)

Brought my teen daughter and her friend here for dinner. My daughter had the baked ziti and her…read morefriend had fettuccine Alfredo. The meals came with salad and bread with big portions. The girls loved it and said five stars and that they would come back!

Looking for a good classic slice of pizza or something unique like stuffed pizza - you have to stop…read morehere. From salads to submarines pizza and more this place knows how to make great food.

Marcello's

3.9

(182 reviews)

Randomly looking for a new place to eat yesterday, we came upon Marcello's Ristorante, Pizzeria, &…read moreCatering in Carlisle. It was absolutely amazing. Best Chicken Parm I've ever had anywhere. Everything is made to order, and you definitely taste it. Garlic bread is pulled from the oven for the table, which is great. My "side" of Fettuccine Alfredo was amazing and more like a main course since there was so much. We can't believe we've never been here before, but will definitely be at the top of the rotation now. Amazing.

I really enjoyed the food from here! The lobster ravioli is very very good! Very large portions! I…read moreordered a medium stuffed pizza, and I can't imagine what the large looks like! It is huge! I also ordered the breaded mushrooms and it would've fed 3 people! How are they making money with portions this big! The service was top notch also! I can't handle spicy food, not even pepperoni, and I have a hard time speaking some times because I had a full laryngectomy but the young lady at the counter was very kind and patient with me, and helped me find some substitutes and they didn't charge me anything extra! The place had a nice vibe going on, everyone in the kitchen was busy, but all seemed to be enjoying what they did! I'd highly recommend this place if you're looking for top notch Italian cuisine! Very tasty!

Little Italy IV

4.3

(20 reviews)

Ordered hamburger bacon and Jalapeno. Got home it was pepperoni and jalapeño. Charged me at the…read moreregister for the pizza I ordered, so the knew what I ordered. Not happy

Food and service excellent. Hunting season starts getting cheese stk with gravy fries twice a week .read more

Davinci Italian Eatery

3.4

(125 reviews)

We have eaten here many times. I did not realize they also own Palumbo's…read more I feel that many times the service can be a little on the slow side. Our server last night was attentive, but did take a while to bring the bread and my side salad. Speaking of the side salad, it is a very basic salad with iceberg lettuce, sliced tomato, and onion. They were out of the house dressing, so I opted for the Italian, which was really a golden Italian dressing. As an Italian restaurant, I would have hoped for something different. For our main meals, I ordered the pasta Brunello, which is chunks of chicken with mushrooms, penne pasta in a creamy rosé sauce. It was delicious. My daughter did the create your own pasta with Penne pasta, marinara, and a side of Italian sausage. We think it sat in the window a little bit as the plate was hot and the sauce had adhered to the pasta. She still enjoyed it though. The garlic bread is fresh and hot, and they offer butter in addition to oil. The prices are reasonable. The decore could use some updating, but it is definitely a good neighborhood Italian restaurant.

Absolutely love this place whether you are craving quick pizza shop items like Stromboli, fries,…read morecalzone or good quality Italian pastas. You cannot go wrong with any items and don't forget to try their desserts!! Quick and great service as well.

Claudio's Pizza

4.5

(8 reviews)

Great variety of food! Staff is always so kind. I love trying new things on their menu!read more

Service here was good. I had gone here about a year ago and ordered a mexican style pizza and I…read moresort of didn't like it a whole lot. However, I believed that it would be unjust to judge their pizza based on a gimmick style pizza, so I decided to give them a try again today and ordered a normal pepperoni pizza with a greek salad. Few things worth noting. The pizza had almost no sauce in it. It felt like I was eating a cheese panini. Also, when I ordered the greek salad, I was asked what type of dressing I wanted. When looking at the choices, there was no option for greek salad dressing, which should have been red wine vinager, olive oil, and lemon. I've ordered hundreds of greek salads and never had I been ASKED what type of dressing I wanted, let alone not being given the choice of picking the right one. Lastly, there was some strange gunk in the salad, which we couldn't even identify what it was. One of the biggest issues with these types of resteraunts is that they try to do way too much! The menu is far too large, which means they either have to restock on a lot of stuff frequently or they serve non fresh foods occasionally. You want to be Italian, greek, and mexican? Fine, but learn how to do those things correctly and cut your menu in half.

Sorrento Pizza

4.2

(24 reviews)