Wow, to think it's been several years that we've now lived here right up the road from Benny's Pizza in Boiling Springs, it's almost impossible to think of just how many meals we've enjoyed from this place. Benny's has become a staple in our lives - it's a local landmark - and it's not just because it's the close/local pizza option. Benny's provides outstanding food, prepared by a consistent, personable group of guys who work day in and day out to deliver incredible dining experiences. Benny's always seems busy, but they always seem to have everything under control too. They manage a constant barrage of orders with ease, and never come across as too busy to be polite and friendly. This is primarily a take out establishment - there are a couple of seats inside (and one small booth), but it's not a sit down restaurant. That said, you'll feel right at home while waiting for your food - the guys make jokes and friendly small talk with you, and there's always a game of some kind on the TV. Their pizza is great (I'm a fan of their standard cheese or pepperoni, though their buffalo chicken is unreal too). There spaghetti with meat sauce is out of this world. I love their cheese ravioli. Their cheesesteaks are phenomenal as well. I can't say I've ever had a "bad" meal from Benny's. You won't be disappointed, trust me! read more

Pizza is mid, not bad if you are in a rush to grab something and go, prices are ok as well

Delish, true NY-style pizza at this pizzeria located just a few minutes from Boiling Springs Pool & Children's Lake. Tomato sauce had perfect balance of sweet & tangy; mozz was chewy, stretchy & flavorful; crust was thin & flexible. Priced well; personable staff; no-nonsense set-up geared to takeout. Worth the stop! read more

Benny's Pizza - Delish takeout--2 slices of pizza (1 cheese, 1 w/ham & pineapple add-on). Enjoyed it seated by Children's Lake @ sunset. - Pizza Near Me - Boiling Springs, Pennsylvania

Second review I've left. Had a great chicken parm sandwich that is easily more than a meals worth of food. This has been my fourth visit and everything has been consistently great. read more

Pizza is ok price is good subs are good place is alway busy so that's a good sign. Never had anything I did not like.

We love Benny's. It's our go-to Pizza, sub, etc place. We've always been happy with the food and the service. I don't know why it says it's closed. I just ordered, they are definitely OPEN. read more

Great Pizza and Subs!! Very consistent over many years always enjoy their food. Highly recommend!

Food is wonderful. Everyone is kind. A great place to go for pizza and other Italian meals

Bennys has really good subs. The only thing is I wish they delivered. I feel like they'd profit more if they delivered. Over all great food!! read more

Always great food and the friendliest people in town. We are never disappointed. Prices are very good compared to other pizza and sub restaurants. read more

Nothing fancy but the pizzas are very good and the Italian focaccia (harp music playing as I remember the experience of enjoying it) is heavenly. I'm not kidding. I had it a month ago and I still find l myself daydreaming about it. Friendly staff, no frills but well worth a visit. read more

On our way out to Boiling Springs for a soccer game, we took a shot on Benny's because it was on the way according to our map app. We were impressed! Our salads were affordably priced, loaded with all of the good stuff, and tasted amazing. The staff at Benny's was super friendly as well! read more

When I grew up in East New York, I was fortunate to live around the corner from Carmine's Pizzeria. Oh the best tasting pizza in New York, at least in Brooklyn. Carmine's was a small, unassuming place. A few tables and a small room in the back with arcade games. Benny's Pizza brings me back home. This place is small, unassuming and serves an amazing slice of traditional sauce thin crust pizza with all the ooey gooey cheese sliding down each hot slice as you quickly try to consume without burning your mouth. The pizza here is always on point. The service is fast. The prices are even better. Benny's may not be Carmine's, and that's a good thing--it's one of a kind, like Benny's. Stop in and grab a slice, or two. You won't regret it! read more

Focaccia pizza!! Literally an Italian hoagie in pizza form-but even better! It's soooooo good! Friendly guys in the kitchen! Love this place. read more

Benny's Pizza - Focaccia pizza large - Pizza Near Me - Boiling Springs, Pennsylvania

See all

Great pizza, especially like the crust. We also ordered the mini boli. Very friendly service and reasonable prices.

Great pizza. Amazing, friendly service. So glad I stopped for lunch. Highly recommend!

I've been coming here a ton since moving back to PA. Family owned and I've know the owners for awhile, great people! The food is also fantastic and fresh and the prices are always affordable. I'd highly recommend checking this place out if you are into Italian cuisine! read more

Really good pizza place!! They have GF buns for the subs and they are really good for being GF. Have been here several times and haven't had a bad meal at all. The family and everyone else I know loves the pizza. And they always have a good soccer match on the TV! read more

Good pizza, can be a little burnt in the bottom, just ask for light crust. Same with the bolis.

This is my go to pizza place since I moved to the area. It's take-out only and they have a pretty standard menu of pizza, stromboli's, subs and pasta. Their prices are pretty fair and I haven't been disappointed by anything I've gotten. Compared to Anile's down the street I think the crust is better, rolls are better, and sauce is better. All the locals swear Anile's is the best because it's been there forever, but if you give Benny's a try I think you'll be back for more. read more

Upon arrival the smell of this little Italian shop fills my with warm feelings. Amazingly low prices with the best quality Italian food I've had. Also really nice people who accommodate you and your needs. 5/5 from my personal Yelpself (: read more

Very great reasonably priced Italian restaurant. Pizza or pasta come on in. Great subs too. Not much of a seating area, but a great local take out joint. MUCH better than the alternative to the other pizza place here in boiling springs in my opinion. read more

One of my favorite pizza places near Carlisle. Living out in the rural areas it's difficult to find something this tasty, so we are thrilled with their hot bacon pizzas. Thanks for great take out! read more

Great little Italian place. Very simple and very satisfying. Yummy pizza, tasty, giant stroms, and great corn fritters. The service is really fast. There are just a few seats for on-site dining but it is comfortable for such a small place. Very good prices and especially large portions with great taste. read more

Great Pizza!!! We had dinner there tonight. Fast service. We like the pizza and subs. Prices are reasonable. I like the cheese steak subs and wife like the chicken parm sub. Kids love the cheese pizza. The 2 pizza special is a good deal read more

Great find in Boiling Springs! We stopped in late on a Friday night and the staff were very friendly. I had the eggplant sub, it was probably one of the best I've ever had. The family had pizza which was delicious. Lots of people were doing take out, there isn't a lot of seating. Recommend! read more

We have been buying pizzas here for the last 2 yrs. But today while watching football we ordered two pizzas and they were nasty...and if this wasn't enough I called Bennys and talked to the boss and he said if I didn't want to come back to the shop oh well and hung up.........w.t.h. read more

The closest that I have come to having Neopolitan cuisine since living in Italy. My favorite "go to" dish is the Carbonara, but the pizza and sandwiches are spot on as well (although a little Amercanized). Will continue as a customer, hopefully for many years to come, of Benny's whenever I need a taste of Napoli. read more