Saw this place in Yelp and wanted to eat before driving home. It is a rather unassuming storefront, directly across from a micro hotel and near several other eateries. The menu is pretty standard pizza shop fare - pizza, burgers, Stromboli, etc. We were intrigued with the Grandma's Pizza offerings and decided on the Trio - with one-third Cheese Lover, one-third Margarita, and one-third Meat Lover. This is a rectangular pie with three slices of each. The price seemed a little steep, but it's pretty common these days to pay $15 a person for a meal. The counter man informed us it would be 30 minutes. I appreciated the head-up, but we had no where to go...and it meant the pizza was being made fresh! It was actually done in about 20 minutes. Gorgeous to look at, and loaded down with toppings. There was no skimping here. The edges of the pie were crispy without being crunchy, and the dough underneath was soft but still could stand up to the weight of the toppings. Somewhat reminiscent of a Detroit-style pizza, but leaner and, IMO, tastier. We are half the pie, trying each type and packed the rest for home. I expect it will reheat well. Total with drinks was around $30. You could feed a family of four on this pie. Excellent! read more

Papa Joe's - Grandma's Trio pie - Pizza Near Me - Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Called ahead to see if they sold only whole pies or also pizza by the slice since it was just me for dinner. They confirmed they sold it by the slice so I drove over. When I got there, there was a single slice of dried up cheese pizza sitting on the top of the counter. It looked like it'd been there for days, all dried up and starting to curl. Not even under a heat lamp. They told me that was it and they weren't making anymore for the day. I just left. Wish they'd have told me "We do, but we're out and not making more today" and saved me the trip. Did they really think someone was going to actually pay for old dried up slice? read more

The meat lovers pizza slice was awesome. They warmed it up in the pizza oven as I waited so the temp was great. The food was great as I mentioned, the atmosphere was blah, nothing really to look at but I was there for the food and not the scene. Lots of to-go orders took place while I was there. That seems to be the majority of their business. I was in town for work and stayed across the street, super convenient and again, the pizza was spot on! read more

I ordered mild buffalo wings. I got six I ordered a fry. I got a fountain soda, and I got their tiramisu. The workers were very kind and answered all my questions. It's really nice and spacious in there. I enjoyed their lighting in their light fixtures. It's way bigger in there than I thought. Pulled right up in the front to park. read more

See all

Back to 5 stars. Can't argue about prices and quality food. It's fairly priced and excellent. Service has improved greatly and I now feel more welcome. I guess they read my previous three star review? Grandma pizza is the best around and I often get a cheesesteak special for lunch. Wings are awesome too. Highly recommend Papa Joe's! read more

See all

My son and I found this pizza place after walking around Bass Pro. Located in a plaza walking distance from several hotels (including long-term stay lodging), parking abounds. Warm and inviting with nostalgic Italian decor, we felt at ease immediately upon entering. All employees provided friendly greetings. We got the special, 2 large pizzas and a 2 liter bottle beverage. We chose 1 cheese pizza, 1 sliced tomatoes on cheese pizza, and a Barq's root beer. Our pizza was delicious, each piece cut into 8 hardy slices. The sauce was spiced flavorfully, cheese melted to perfection, and crust ideally baked. Veteran status garnered a military discount and a thanks for my service. We can't wait to return to this terrific dining establishment. Carryout may be an option for some visits. read more

Papa Joe's - Large cheese pizza with sliced tomatoes. Divine! - Pizza Near Me - Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

See all

We had a very large order, one of the pizza's came out wrong BUT the amazing ppl at Papa Joe's made us a fresh one and delivered it! So many options to choose from! Definitely recommend! Staff is very nice and friendly! Pizza perfectly done, crust was nice and crispy! read more

Great pizza joint. They have by far the best highest quality food for a pizza place. Menu is large. Service is quick and efficient. Places to sit inside. read more

Burgers are AMAZING. Specialty pizzas are AMAZING. There's nothing else to say. I've been going here for years. I travel 20 minutes to pick up a pizza with no problem. Chicken bacon ranch and the buffalo pizza chicken pizza are the best in the city and the burger is top notch! I just finished eating a burger so I want to rate it #1 because I can't think of a better burger in Harrisburg, but I'm going to play it safe and say top 3 since my taste buds are trying to take over this review. Workers and owners are cool too. Love this place! Go giants! read more

In town for work. Late arrival and few options open near the hotel. I arrived around 50 minutes before close. The staff was pleased to take my order for a pizza and a salad. I was the sole dine-in customer, but there was a decent to-go stream. The dining area is well-used and seen years of customer service, but it was very clean (tables and floors). The salad was quick - within minutes - and the pizza was maybe 12-15 minutes, just enough time to enjoy my salad and get the soda syrup switched on for a fresh fountain. This pizza blew my mind! Despite the butcher block meaty moniker, this was not a greasy gut buster. To be clear, plenty of meat, cheese, and crushed tomato sauce. This was probably 3-4# of pizza, but perfectly balanced flavors and textures. When I am in town, this will definitely be on my list of spots to re-visit. Great job, guys!! read more

Papa Joe's - Grandma's Butcher's Block - the whole deal - Pizza Near Me - Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Got a LARGE ITALLIAN BOLI, the ends had no ingredients, they were empty!! There was no flavor to it at all. Wont be going back anytime soon!! read more

Ive only ordered takeout pizza and it did not disappoint. Perfect cheese, sauce, crust ratio. Sauce is tasty but not overpowering. The cheese blend is spot on. I look forward to the next time I'm in the area. The employees were on the ball and very polite, offered things like plates and utensil without me asking. Will definitely return. read more

Papa Joe's - Large, half pepperoni/mushroom, half cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

All the times I have stayed in the hotel cross from it and never tried it man I was missing out. Not only was the pizza good they got the order right which in this day and age doesn't happen often. Thank you read more

I stay at a particular hotel (tons to choose from right here) when I'm in on business just so I can eat here. Service, ambiance - you name it. All around amazing. read more

Twice I have used Papa Joe's to support Company functions and twice they have failed miserably. Today they were 20 minutes late and this is after I called this morning to emphasize the importance of being on time. And they could care less. You will never receive anything from Papa Joes including an apology. I always try to support local business but never again will I give them the opportunity to fail. Save yourself the frustration and go elsewhere is you have an important event. read more

Way better than it appears from the outside! Went as a group of 6 to dine in. Staff were very friendly. Order at the counter for limited service but we had a ton of food between us (pizza, 3 strombolis, wings, salad, tiramisu, fountain drinks) for under $100. Food was made fresh, fast, and very tasty. Will return! read more

The food was delicious! I ordered a meatball sub and everything was great! The bread was delicious and the meatballs tasted homemade. I ordered takeout and the food was ready when I arrived. The place was nice some where I'd come back to and eat inside. It feels safe and homey in there. As I was leaving the workers were saying goodbye to costumers by name which is a nice touch. read more

Papa Joe's - Meatball Parmigiana Sub - Pizza Near Me - Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

You absolutely have to get a Grandma styled pizza from this place. It was AMAZING! From the flavor of the sauce to the cheese it was all so delicious! We got the butcher's block....SO GOOD! read more

Food and service is very good for a Pizza place, definitely one of the best places in Harrisburg.

So the atmosphere wasn't too bad not crowded for a Sunday. So the cake display I happened to grab a tiramisu cake slice and in the icing on top had a long hair piece. Got a taco pizza didn't know a debate about sour cream being on the side would cause a huge issue with the kitchen. The man making the pizza was mad and didn't accept if someone in my family has a allergy to sour cream don't have the pressure be on the man at the register and for him he told us it won't be a issue but the pizza guy gave us dirty looks up and down sorry I spent close to $70 dollars and usually having a allergy like that isn't a issue but felt very uneasy about it. The hair found in my cake to avoid conflict I spit the hair and cake piece out and I decided didn't say anything. I chose not to because the tension was already bad and didn't want to create any more issues. So if possible can we not make the people who have certain food allergies feel so uncomfortable and find a way to accommodate it and not give them attitude. read more

Pizza was awesome! I consider myself a pizza connoisseur and big traveler and this ranks up there with the best pizza in the country. We got thr chicken bacon ranch and the margarita pizzas. Our crew loved them. Even my picky eater took down a couple slices. Papa Joe's is awesome! read more

Great food. The kind of pizza I grew up thinking everywhere had. Fabulous tasty great. Quick service. Ambiance was that of a classic pizza joint. Ample space and outdoor seating. Parking was a bit narrow. Ordered a large half cheese half pepperoni; meatball sub; and wings. Partner said "woah" in that woah this is really good way after tasting the first wing. He hasn't had those in quite some time after living in the Midwest. Great visit east! read more

Huge, tasty portions of amazing Italian food is what you get at this conveniently located restaurant. I was able to walk over from my hotel, and I waited for about 15 minutes for my food. I ordered the veal parmigiana, and it was massive. The amount I ate barely made a dent in the dish. The salad had lots of peppers, which I wasn't expecting. Picked those out, and topped it with the packages of blue cheese salad dressing that was provided. The salad was a little disappointing, but I don't hold that against the restaurant. The veal was perfect, and the accompanying spaghetti was delicious. And huge. And the garlic toast was also great. A wonderful meal, and I would highly recommend it. read more

See all

For 15 years, Angelo's Pizza on Madison Avenue in Lakewood has held the crown for best pizza I've ever had. That is until I tried a Grandma's style pizza from Papa Joe's!! EPICALLY EXQUISITE!!! read more

Papa Joe's - Pizza Near Me - Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

See all

We were visiting from out of town and had a craving for Italian. The pizza, grandma-style, was amazing!! We pre-ordered for takeout and everything was ready at the promised time. We didn't eat in the restaurant but it looked clean and welcoming. read more

Read about this Yelp. It looked great in pictures. Sounded great in the menu. And the verdict is... awesome! Magnificent pizza! We got the Grandma's mozzarella and basil. Plenty big, and very tasty. Authentic Italian. And very good service as well. Top notch pizza. Also, outdoor seating if you wish. read more

Papa Joe's - Grandma's mozzarella and basil. Delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

This may be the best pizza and wings I have had. All special requests were perfectly done. Very friendly staff. Food was done in the time frame quoted. 10/10 would recommend. read more

I have been eating pizza once a week for the past three months at this shop. I live in zip code 17057 Middletown its hike to get there. I love their pizza it perfect NY style. I live near dominos, papa johns, Middletown pizza and tony's pizza 400 meters away and travel all the way to harrisburg I would give this shop 5 stars EASY the pizza is better than any major chain but I can not get beyond the no gloves. None of them wear gloves and I'm just gonna get pizza that I put back in the oven when i get home as insurance. I've entered the restaurant like today and seen them doing prep work and then take my money straight from perp...that is gross to me. The things I have done with dollars LOL I do not want that in my mouth. If they get gloves ill order food. Tony's pizza here in Middletown medium pep is 15.00 Papa joes pizza is 18.70. read more

Made a group order for my co workers and Each of us were pleasantly surprised and enjoyed there order that included subs, wings and pizza..I had cheesesteak 6inch sub combo with fries and it hit the spot today. May of givin me the full size sub not sure but i aint complaining..Scarfed it down like it was my last meal on Deathrow...Bread was soft as a babies butt like it just came out of a oven, veggies were fresh and the steak tasted good..Fries were good...Place was clean and pretty active with staff and customers..Definitely be a regular here since its close to work be back to try other items read more

Papa Joe's - Pizza Near Me - Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

One of our favorite places to eat when we're in the Harrisburg area! Delicious food and great prices. The staff is always very kind as well. Perfect spot for a quick family meal! read more

BEST pizza I've had in a long time. The chicken parm was also out of this world. Great staff so helpful and kind! Would 10000% come back:) read more

Papa Joe's - Grandma's Original - Pizza Near Me - Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

See all

We r at our office for a Few days ( truck drivers) and we finally looked for a pizza place. Thanx for the great reviewers. This place IS da bomb. The gal met us with a mask... yep... sign of the times! We could walk in to pick up and order to go. After giving the menu a good look thru we decided to order a Grandma's Butcher Block Pizza. Let me say I wasn't sure when I saw her cutting it. For one it was square which is wierd and it had soooo much extra sauce on top! Mmmm. But my fears disappeared after we got it back to the office and my first bite. That's all it took .... oh my!!! The flavor was spectacular!!! So the square pizza was ok!! We also ordered two sets of wings, Hanenõ mango & Garlic Parm. Bf had the mango ones and said they are realllllly spicy! He lives them and I wa afraid to try one after his lips were on fire. My garlic Parm were good. And boy I was burping garlic long after dinner. But delish. So the next time we come I'm a gonna try a round pizza !! And looking forward to it! read more

Papa Joe's - Grandma's Butcher's Block Pizza Yummy!!! - Pizza Near Me - Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

We tried three different kinds of slices of pizza and rhey were all very good. The staff is quite nice.

I have never heard of this place, but I saw the ratings, and fell for there signature pizza. Hot damn!!! Best pizza I ever ate! Absolutely beautiful! And it was delivered!! No pizza EVER looks this good delivered!! The crust was perfectly crunchy, the toppings were the perfect amount. I would easily give this place 10 stars! Not sure about the rest of the menu, but I don't care!! Every time I order from this place, I'm getting this pizza!!! EVERY TIME!! The girl on the phone was very polite, and made sure all the information was correct before saying goodbye. The driver was fast and took good care of my edible masterpiece!! My 2-liter soda was ice cold. STOP READING THIS AND PLACE YOUR ORDER!! read more

Papa Joe's - Absolutely a work of edible art!!! Possibly the best pizza I ever ate! - Pizza Near Me - Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

So delicious! On any given weekday this is hot spot for lunch. Thank goodness for excellent parking too! The pizza is great and reminds me of my favorite pizza spot in NY/NJ. You can grab fun specialty slices or a whole dang pie. So yummy! read more

The pizza at PaPa Joes is outstanding! I highly recommend stopping by if you're visiting Harrisburg! read more

Papa Joe's - Large pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

Nice spot that was across from my hotel, so it was an easy cruise over there. Have to start with the basics, the cheese pizza was pretty legit. Good balance of sauce and cheese, crust was thin but not too thin, overall a good pick. My favorite thing to get was the chicken parmigiana sandwich! I ate quite a few of these in my two week stay. The key is the fresh bread made in house, loved it! The service was good, everyone seemed friendly each time. I'd return if I'm back in the area again. read more

Homemade bread, homemade desserts, one of those new fangled coke machines and a good philly cheesesteak. Easy parking and located near the Harrisburg mall. Very good. read more

Papa Joe's - Cheese steak - Pizza Near Me - Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

This was my first visit, suggested by a friend that has been here before. We visited for lunch on a Tuesday around 11:30 and the place was dead (which didn't last long--about 15 minutes later people started pouring in!). They have a bunch of different personal Stromboli's and pizza ready to go under their glass covered counter. Everything looked very good. You place your order, pay and then they call your name when your order is ready. I ordered a steak & cheese personal Stromboli that they had in the case, which was maybe 7 inches long and my friend ordered a salad with grilled chicken. I got a fountain drink and she got an iced tea from out of the cooler and our bill was just under $20. My Stromboli was just ok. My friends loves the salad but it didn't look like something I would've ordered as it had soggy green peppers and a ton of mozzarella cheese on top--but that's just personal taste. Service was friendly and there was a lot of seating available. I would like to return and try their pizza! read more

Great variety of food and served hot. Cheese pizza and cheesesteaks subs delish. The French fries were crisp, hot and flavorful too. Outstanding service. read more