Whenever I visit a new town, I am finding myself trying new pizzerias I was in Chris' hometown for the wedding and it just so happened to be Father's Day. Myself and Chris, along with his two brothers and niece decided to hit Tommy's. Apparently its a childhood spot for them and a favorite. It was a very every busy Sunday with orders to-go as well as guest inside and outside enjoying the experience. We ordered pepperoni pizzas and a dozen buffalo wings. I had a hard cider and two delicious slices. The race car matches were on the tele, and everyone seemed to be enjoying the nice sunny day. I love smelling food from the outside of an establisment whenever I arrive or leave,, haha. That speaks volumes! read more

Tommy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Look at this cheesesteak. The amount of beef was a joke. For $12!! The onion fries were pretty good but that cheesesteak should be taken off the menu. read more

Tommy's Pizza - The skinniest cheesesteak I've ever seen. Ever. - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Wow! The sauce! It's a tangy,cooked sauce which usually doesn't go together. The crust was fluffy and golden crisp. We loved it! read more

Tommy's Pizza - The Logo - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

I was told this is the best pizza in Gettysburg. Is it the ONLY pizza in Gettysburg?! It was pretty bad. It seemed like frozen dough that was barely even cooked the whole way through. It was very greasy and overall just unappetizing. The wings that were supposed to be "sweethot" tasted straight up like a bottle of mustard. Yuck. And for ranch , they just hand you a packet of Ken's. read more

Eh. Pizza is like frozen store pizza. Very crowded and noisy not sure why cause the food ain't that good. Service is super super slow. I won't go back. read more

My wife and I ordered a large 1/2 pepperoni and cheese pizza and fries. The pizza was good. It reminds me of Pizza Huts pan pizza buttery crust. The cheese is a little too much and the sauce is kind of thick. It's a greasy one but hey you're in Gettysburg not New York City. It was $24 for a large pizza with 1/2 Pepperoni and fries. That's reasonably priced. The parking lot could get filled quickly so that could be an issue. I'm giving 5 stars because the order was hot and we had a good overall experience. The large pizza size did seem smaller than other restaurants but fed the two of us. The restaurant was clean inside and the staff were nice. read more

Tommy's Pizza - 1/2 Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

The pizza was very, very good.... That's where it positive words stop. Service was only mediocre and it took the a long, long time to get it.... I waited about 35-40 minutes and it was not very busy. read more

We ordered a couple of mushroom slices. It took fifteen minutes to get two slices that weren't any better than frozen pizza. The crust was doughy, the sauce was too sweet, and the mushrooms were obviously canned. read more

Seriously YUMMY!!! The Greek pizza did not disappoint! Our first visit, but definitely not our last. We'll be back! read more

Tommy's Pizza - Large Greek pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

What happened to the trademark sauce???? We had a pizza last night .... what happened to their spicy sauce?? It was boring and tasteless

Tried Tommy's for a late lunch/early dinner on a Thursday around 330-4pm. You order first at the counter and then seat yourself until your number is called to grab your food from the front. We had been recommended both the pizza and the cheesesteak. We asked for only meat, cheese, and sautéed onions on the cheesesteak and the pizza was all extra cheese with half bacon. The staff were pleasant and easily understood the order. It was about $35 including a bottle of water. The seating area has both booths and tables with a variety of seating capacities. The tables were mostly clean, a few crumbs here and there. The food was out within 15 minutes and was piping hot. The pizza was my favorite. Both the cheese and the sauce had great flavor. I loved the crust. The roll of the cheesesteak was toasted, which was fine until you got to the butt end of the roll and it's hard as a rock/inedible. read more

See all

Slightly overrated for being the best pizza in town. I ordered a Caesar Salad and got only the dressing. Pizza was extremely doughy but I am giving this restaurant 3.5stars for catering convenience on a busy touristy area. Atmosphere was very very casual and cannot comment on staff since the place was self served. read more

See all

A group of us went after eating at another pizza place, and Tommy's did not disappoint! Great crust, sauce, and the Meat Lover's was top notch! A great pizza place overall! You can't go wrong with Tommy's! read more

Tommy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

We were finally able to get in to this local pizza shop. It's almost impossible to get inside on the weekends. You can't even park! (They do have a drive thru window). When you go inside you order at the counter then they'll call your number when your order is ready. I remember this was part of the reason we also left before because it was extremely crowded and people were standing everywhere. So if you don't like that sort of thing then the weekends aren't for you. We went during the week and about 4 pm. It wasn't crowded at all. We walked in and ordered immediately. The staff was very friendly. We noticed a sign on the wall saying they've been around since 1972. We ordered their large pizza and an order of fries. We were surprised that their largest pizza is 14". The price was over $14. That surprised us because most pizza shops are selling 16-18" pies. We ordered plain cheese so we could taste it without extra stuff on it. It's good. I wasn't wowed by it but it's definitely good. We both areed the fries were amazing! I'd definitely ordered those no doubt!! They have a great location right in the tourist section of Gettysburg. If you're on a tour and looking for pizza, I'd definitely give them a try. read more

See all

Just don't. My son described the pizza perfectly, "Cafeteria", The subs were so dry and terrible. "Grilled chicken breast" for the chicken parm sub is deli style lunch meat. AWEFUL!!!! Save yourself and just don't. read more

Pizza good. Lil sweet. Cheesesteak needed cooked about 20 minutes less. It's not that hard. Put the whole patty on let it cook chop it once. Not 15x shoot a little bouillon w butter mixed in cheese it up w pan top over it and Shazam moist good ass cheesesteak,, it's not cook chop cook chop cook chop cook. Ur close enuf to Philly to know better,, please no excuse for a dry balled up cheesesteak. 1 wit please read more

Tommy's is hit or miss. It's a local favorite that is mostly built on reputation not currant status. There are much better pizzeria 's in the burg Antica comes to mind but Tommy's has the reputation. Don't believe the hype there is much out there. read more

Wonderful servers! The pizza is out of this world. I like the yummy pizza sauce. And I must say the sauce to cheese ratio is abundant. :) I often get the black olive & hamburger or the black olive & onions. Their Steak & cheese sub is super yummy, I love their fries! Their onion rings are tasty as are their salads. I enjoy the Greek salad and the club salad myself. :) I seriously crave food from this place. You can get to go or carry out. It's quite a popular place. When I was there today there was a little girl there having a birthday pizza party. Go! read more

Pizza was superb. Service was quick. Parking was not too good, but was able to get in a spot and had time to eat and get back to my meetings. read more

This is one of the best pizza place I have had great staff and service the pizza is awesome we get some to take home 3 hours away cozy place to talk and watch sport if u choice to. read more

Heard great things about this place. However I am disappointed with my experience. The pie came out scorching hot and burnt the roof of my mouth like a chimney. The pie was also the most greasy thing I've ever eaten. Wouldn't recommend. I will not be coming back. read more

Havnt been here in about 6 years bought a small sausage pie.... pretty tasty but spongy crust, undercooked dough. should be crispy not spongy. I saw 4 employees wipe their faces and noses ( one cook sneezed) he had gloves on blew his nose but never changed gloves. Very unsanitary for employees working with food. They don't need my business their doing very well read more

Me and My Husband came here after what are ghost tour Farnsworth house. We ordered a large pepperoni pie and mozzarella sticks. If you want a quick bite to eat and some decent pizza with the price, there's nothing to beat. My Husband loved the pizza, the mozzarella sticks could've been warmed up better but for the price I didn't expect more. I recommend this for a quick bite. The service was nice and timely and the ambience was a nice family pizza restaurant. read more

The best pizza in Gettysburg, in my opinion at least. I honestly have only had the pizza and few sides like fries and wings but that's because it's that good. I don't need to try anything else. I don't live near here anymore so any time I'm in town I have to get a pizza. Decent amount of parking on site for Gettysburg. They also have a drive thru window which is nice. They are always busy when I'm there so you know it's good. Staff are always nice and the food comes out quickly, they know what they are doing and how to handle a crowd. read more

Pros- Good tasty pizza Decently priced Cons- Closes early No medium pizza, only small or large If you know me then you know that I am from Philadelphia originally and can be very critical of pizza, so with that said I am going try and seperate myself from the pizza that I grew up with and review this pizza for what it is. We came in 20 minutes before closing, Google said they close at 10pm but they actually close at 9pm. I felt the gentleman at the counter was truly irritated that we came in so late (8:40) despite that I apologized 5 times. The resteraunt itself was pretty clean, I did not explore the menu because we wanted pizza. We ordered a small pizza with sausage, green pepper and onion, I like plain or pepperoni but my wife likes all the veggies. At first bite I tasted a really good sweet sauce with the right amount. The pizza had a nice crunch to the crust with a good airy and tasty inside. The toppings were fresh and had nice crunch. Im not sure what people are complaining about, it's not the best pizza I've had but it's good tasty pizza. I'll be back again. Bottom Line- good tasty pizza read more

Tommy's Pizza - Small Sausage, green pepper & onion pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Boggles my mind to see this place isn't 5 stars across the board. Their pizza is so damned good. It's legitimately so good we drive up from DC pretty regularly to enjoy it. The poor reviews complaining about no parking or that it's too busy? It's Gettysburg, not NYC. Plenty of parking nearby or walk from your hotel. And too busy? That's not a problem to rate a business for, rather to congratulate them! I know we'll be there for Christmas festival weekend but hope to make it up a couple times before then too. Top quality food and the team busting their butts behind the counter are all super nice! Thank you, Tommy's Pizza! read more

We were there for take out tonight it's a Wednesday night.Ordered two subs to go a meatball parm and a chicken parm.waited 45 minutes and finally asked where our sandwiches were and they were on top of the oven for who knows how long.Got back to our Hotel room down the street and my wife's meatball sandwich had 4 tiny meatballs on it and the bread crumbled apart like crumbs from being well done.my chicken cutlet parm was like sliced deli chicken with some cheese and the same dried out bread as my wife's..Horrible.And the sign says since 1973.i don't know how if the serve food like this.I seen a pizza being sent back also while we were there and it was burnt to a crisp and they still served it to the customer.We are here on vacation and thank God we Don't live here bc and have them as our local pizza shop.Two thumbs way down and I'm still hungry 25$ .It was 40$ if you count the 4 pack of beers in cans .i read more

Tommy's Pizza - Proof of purchase - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

We were staying at local campground. We tried to csll order in but no one answered the phone. So we drove there. There is on-site parking. First time trying. It was Saturday evening, very busy. We ordered 2 pizzas, cheese and pepperoni along with hot and mild wings. About 15 minutes wait for order. Not bad. We walked across the street to Bantam Coffee for drinks. Order done on time. Pizza delicious. Flavorful. I preferred regular wings over the hot ones. They had more flavor. Glad I tried them. Not on my top 10 for wings but good. read more

Our table was filthy, as were the restrooms. No soap. The Reuben I ordered was ham, very soggy and cold. The manager did not offer any resolution, do not recommend. read more

such a insult to the Italians. chicken Palm was sliced deli meat with cheese. I would never go back.

I got a pineapple Stromboli and my husband got the meat lovers. They were amazing. They offer containers of garlic and other seasonings which is nice. Order at the counter then sit inside or outside and they call your number. Baked fresh but didn't take forever. They have a parking lot but it's small. Within walking distance of a lot of hotels and B & B and in this historic area. Clean bathroom. Serve yourself fountain beverages that you can refill (nice on a hot day!). Nice, efficient people working there. read more

Tommy's Pizza - Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Tommy's is my favorite spot for pizza! I have been coming here for many years for my pizza fix. I no longer live in Gettysburg but I still make the trip in to Tommy's when I'm in the area. Awesome craft beer selection, delicious pizza, and friendly staff. read more

Tommy's Pizza - Hawaiian pizza with great beer! Cheers! - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

I have wanted to try this place for years. We finally decided to take the plunge and try it out. It was very busy, which is a good sign. My husband and I each ordered subs. He got the bacon cheeseburger. He said it was great. I got the turkey and mine was good as well. The french fries were nothing special, but they were manageable. The star of the visit was the super nice lady at the drive-through window. She was so sweet and 100% would be why I would come back. We had our pup with us and she gave her a treat. I can't say enough about her customer service. In today's entitled world, this is not the norm. She really made me feel like a valued customer. I will definitely return, if for nothing else than the customer service. read more

The meat lovers I ordered for delivery took over an hour, and was not only cold when I received it but it had apparently been extremely overcooked before it was boxed up. The hamburger meat was dry & hard and crunchy and tasted more like wood coals than beef. The woman who delivered it apologized it took so long because of traffic & the person who took the order gave her the wrong phone number. No paper plates, no grated parmesean & no discount or credit for the cold, overcooked/burnt & gross "food" that took twice as long as promised to deliver. It appears whoever sent this out after scorching it to ash either didn't notice, doesn't know how to cook pozza, or didn't care that they send out such a terrible product representing their establishment; whichever I have no tolerance for paying good money for something that isn't edible. I suppose Domino's still guarantees delivery in 30 minutes. read more

Tommy's Pizza - Charred hamburger & bacon with hard cbercooked cheese on top of ham. Entire pizza covered in these large black ashy bubbles of burnt sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Word of mouth. Will be going next week for lunch. Can't wait to taste this delicious food that everyone else has had. All good reviews!!! I will get back after my lunch read more

Great pizza! Very casual pizza place with friendly staff. I would love to come back soon! read more

Pizza is a bit salty but otherwise it tasted well. I liked how they put a reasonable amount of tomato sauce on the pizza.

Amazing pizza top notch staff grade a++++++ always a must when visiting Gettysburg they are just printing money at this joint

Web site says open till10 walked across street 845 to order guy said were closed Was on the road for 15 hours really would have liked a pizza read more

Visiting the National Military Park and posted on Reddit for suggestions from locals where someone suggested Tommy's. It has an order at the counter style and not full service. Pretty good. I got their speciality chicken ranch pizza. Portions of cheese and other toppings were generous and the sauce good. I'd definitely bring my family here before any chain if you're visiting Gettysburg read more

Tommy's Pizza - My chicken ranch pizza to go. I ate half of it before thinking about writing a yelp review lol - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania