Caretti's has amazing customer service! We placed a to-go order on the phone and went to pick it up a short while later. When we arrived the order was getting boxed up. We paid and were on our way. A short while later we were called by Caretti's and informed that the Calzone we had was mixed up with another one and not what we ordered. They offered to remake our order and bring it to us. Unfortunately, we were not very close at that time, so, they offered us a free Calzone the next time we come in. This is the way good service should be. Thank you, Caretti's! And, the small Sicilian pizza was delicious! read more

See all

Service AWFUL!!! Called in an order, verified I was calling the correct place not once but twice... Told 20-25 minutes. Ok I kill some time and when I Get there, there's no ticket. Hmm so guy says we can make it.. like he's doing ME a favor. I still gave him the benefit of a doubt he said it'll be about 10 to 15 minutes. I said sure I'll wait again... Why not? Ive only been working for the past 8 hours. So I ask for a discount because of the inconvenience but nobody seems to be able to offer it so you know what, with all the pizzerias in town I don't need your pizza!!! you need me, I don't need you!!! read more

It was take out we ordered a Stromboli.. loved it I will be going back there again, The Stromboli was thinner then most stromboli we generally, I loved that read more

Got my order wrong and there was a bug at the bottom of my water cup drink. Wouldn't recommend. Edit: look how wonderful the manager is owning up to their mistakes. 0/10 will never recommend. read more

very friendly atmosphere, great pizza it tastes amazing, affordable, the wait wasn't to long, tastes authentic, great for a night meal

Food was amazing. I was visiting from New Jersey and looking for dinner to be delivered to my hotel I started with the Harvest salad which was fresh, loaded with apple almonds and cranberry's Soooo Delicious!! Then I had the wings as an appetizer. There were 10 wings. They were huge, meet was juicy , I only ate 5 because I also ordered the Chicken cheesesteak. OMG it was so good!! DELICIOUS!!! Delivery was fast food was still hot and everything sooo fresh. Next time I'm going to visit the restaurant and eat in It really was AWESOME!!! Next time I'll take pics read more

Huge, marvelous food!!! I ordered a small calzone, and it's deliciousness was great for two meals. The crust was wonderfully crispy, and the filling was marvelous. And everything is reasonably priced. This restaurant is a great choice for lunch. Highly recommend!!! read more

Caretti's Pizza - Calzone and marinara - Pizza Near Me - Chambersburg, Pennsylvania

Had ordered takeaway last fall when on the road to SC, and it was delicious, so tried again ... not so delicious. A Chicken Parm grinder was pretty good, but the bruschetta, which was a star last time, was disappointing. Oh well, still far better than most places. Delivery was fast. Inexpensive, just not as good as the first time. Second dates can be that way. read more

Back in the day you couldn't order $47 in food got my chicken cheese steak it looks like they took a chicken breast chopped it up on a large sandwich seriously sad too bad I have to at least give him one star so I'm going to post a picture so you can see exactly when I go right in the trash.... read more

Caretti's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chambersburg, Pennsylvania

Good pizza. I got the 2 slice with a drink for $4.99. Huge pizza slice. Perfectly crispy and thin. Husband got the ham calzone. Also huge. Cooked perfectly with lots of cheese. Almost too much to eat. Great place for lunch while we traveled across Pennsylvania. read more

Caretti's Pizza - Ham calzone. - Pizza Near Me - Chambersburg, Pennsylvania

Had delivery to our hotel. Ordered bruschetta - holy moly. Very different from the traditional and a real eye opener. Just great Also ordered the chicken Parm and it was also great. Came with a nice, fresh salad and a pretty large loaf of garlic bread. It was a very pleasant surprise and I would highly recommend. Great value as well. If we are back in Chambersburg, we know where to go. read more

If you enjoy food poisoning and all the discomfort that comes with it, than this restaurant is for you. Since moving to the area, everyone recommended this restaurant to me (they meant the other location by Walmart...oops). I did not see anything special about this place from the moment I walked in. Not one of the staff were friendly, they were all rather rude. I purchased the stuffed shells. I was so hungry from a long day I ate half of the plate before I noticed a rancid, rotten egg, garbage smell under the piles of cheese. I opened the stuffed shell and confirmed it was the stuffing. This had to be rotten, way past the expiration date of dairy to cause such an offensive odor. This is a smell that one would notice making the food, which makes it quite apparent that this location doesn't give a f*ck about it's patrons and would rather save costs than use fresh ingredients. I was so sick I couldn't hold anything down for almost two days. After this experience, I WILL NEVER PATRONIZE THIS LOCATION AGAIN!!! Definitely value my healthy a lot more than to come back here and willingly poison myself. I spoke to my coworkers who recommended Caretti's to me, they confirmed I am not the only one they know who has gotten sick from this location. They all know this one as "the shady, nasty Caretti's." TO THE OWNER: WHY SHOULD I CALL TO TELL YOU YOU'RE USING SPOILED, ROTTEN OR EXPIRED INGREDIENTS???? Shouldn't you pay attention to your business and care about quality not costs????????????‍‍‍‍‍ read more

Caretti's Pizza - Health inspection violations. This place is a disaster - Pizza Near Me - Chambersburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Ordered 2 large pizzas and was told it would be ready in 15 minutes. They called me back 5 minutes later and told me they just received a new order for 20 pizzas and so they would be making them first and my order would not be ready for over 45 minutes. Why would you not make food in the order it was received? That's just basic business and good service. I was honestly floored by their response. I will never order from there again. read more

Lunch at Caretti's was two slices of pizza today. They have a few different varieties at the counter and I chose two that looked interesting. A few minutes in the oven and they were ready to go, nice and hot. One with chicken and broccoli, the other was a spicy chicken marinara that was messy but delicious. Interesting how one was bigger than the other but still a good value. Pepsi products at the fountain and ice tea urns. A cooler of teas and juices as well. read more

See all

Great place. I have never had any problems. Foid is great. Pizza, calzone, or Stromboli, they all are good.

Caretti's is FAIR! They're no better or worse than any other pizza place in the area. If you've had Pat & Carla's, you've had Caretti's! If you've had Cafe del Sol, you've had Caretti's! Good subs, fair pizza, fair dinners. The fried foods are the standard industry frozen they deep fry. No complaints, like I said, they're comparable to any other pizza/sub places in the area. read more

We ordered delivery, so I don't know about the actual place but the delivery guy was very polite. We ordered a large meat lovers, it was delicious. Big slices! Well worth the money. read more

The food is terrible the chicken wings smelled bad the pizza was frozen took forever to get here the owner is rude and so are the employees they said they were gonna give me back a refund I've been waiting three hours when are they coming back they refused. when I came there with my food they refuse to give me my money back is my first time in Pennsylvania the first meal I try to get it and this is the experience I got hung up on me and kept insisting that I'm trying to get free food I did not even eat the food read more

See all

I usually buy here when they have deals I called and they guy on the phone told me a large pizza would be 12 plus about 2 dollars per toppings. I just get one topping he hangs up before telling me the total. I get there it comes to $18 something when I asked why is I higher they said the topping was $4 something plus tax so yeah make sure you get your total before they hustle you! read more

Best pizza we have had in a long time! Thinner crust, perfect amount of cheese and sauce, and not too greasy. 10/10 recommend - we will be back! read more

Love everything about this place. First started ordering from them during the pandemic because they delivered. Everyone there has been outstanding from the person who takes my order to the delivery person! Also, I must say the pizza is some of the best I ever had and I love their hoagies too! I always have a difficult time deciding what to order but I can promise you that I am never disappointed. Please give them a try if you are in the neighborhood. read more

We came back because they don't disappoint, I had the Buffalo chicken Stromboli which was awsome with ranch. My wife had the posta Primavera which she was very pleased with. A must Go..... read more

The food is great when it's made correctly which is sadly not the case most of the time. Been here quite a few times and when the food is made right it's great especially love the parm subs and dinners, but sadly more often then not the food is inconsistent and not made right. The service is great, but management comes off as rude and not personable. Seems like it's an inconvenience to them when you call the store. Sadly this doesn't feel like a family restaurant when you go in and eat like it used to be. read more

Quick stop off of highway- we have. A long drive. Pizza was tasty and cheesy. We live in NY so we're critics. But it was pretty good comparably to other places for sure. Very friendly people who work there. Very clean. Nice large parking lot! Definitely recommend My kiddos ate it too. Always a plus! read more

Ordered special different pizza, no cheese all the veg they offer. Did a really good job. Crust was perfect and all the toppings were great. Staff was very friendly and prices are not bad at all. Will come back again, when they say New York style pizza that is 100% correct Great job guys, keep it up. read more

Caretti's Pizza - Hard at it making some good food - Pizza Near Me - Chambersburg, Pennsylvania

Called for a delivery order of 2 large pizzas and an order of mozzarella sticks. After a long wait we called and asked why we had not gotten our delivery and the girl said one of our drivers were in an accident and they could not deliver our order. We were very concerned about the driver in the accident and the girl said he was OK but car was not. So we got in car and went to pick up our order. When we got there everything was cold. Our problem with this whole thing is that they never communicated anything to us. We would have gladly picked up a hot order earlier. When we voiced our opinion about the issue the other guy that was delivering was behind the counter and basically told us we were very inconsiderate for getting upset about our order. Needless to say we will never be ordering there again!! read more

Great spot in a pretty depressing shopping center. We came here a few times for lunch while in the area and this is as good as it gets from what we could tell. They have your typical Italian choices; however, they generally have this smoked turkey focaccia bread sandwich that is awesome! The focaccia was perfect and totally made this sandwich. The next couple of visits I went for slices and was totally impressed. They are hearty and the crust doesn't disappoint as is the case with some places. Grabbing the edge crust, a fully loaded slice stays firm - someone really pays attention to the dough here. A no brainer for your Italian fix in Chambersburg. read more

Caretti's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chambersburg, Pennsylvania

I have been stopping into this shop off of route 11 Chambersburg for years. I enjoy the clam chowder soup it's the best in the area. My next fav is a simple pizza or a good cheesesteak sub! I often call ahead and get take out. Highly recommend this very clean restaurant with quick service! read more

Our 2nd visit here was unforgettable. One teenager was serving the entire dining room. We got our sodas almost immediately but then a family with 4 small children got her attention. It took almost 10 minutes for her to come back. She brought my half sub & loaded fries but nothing for my husband. Another 5 minutes later, she brought his half sub, no fries. Said they would be right out. He ate slowly, while I finished my meal. She didn't come back to refill sodas or check on us. He was done his sub when she came back with the fries. He turned her away stating it was too late. When my husband went to the counter to pay the bill, he heard the cook tell the server to take our leftover, lukewarm fries to the other table. Yuck!! We will not be back. read more

Worst place ever! Was told to take my sub and "shove it up my ass" after asking where the meat was! This was via the Manager! Will never go there again! And the also told me "fuck pat and carlas"If it were up to me I wouldn't give No stars! read more

Caretti's Pizza - Cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - Chambersburg, Pennsylvania

They tell everyone it's fresh and it's all frozen. You can get the same thing in the same container from Pat and Carla's. The owner is rude and avoid doing business here. read more

Started with the Hot Wings (Great flavor and taste) then had a Calzone, (Sausage, Mushroom, Ricotta) just my thing.. again GR8 & finished up with a cannoli..... Great food I'll be coming back in June for business and and will definitely be frequenting this place!!! The staff are friendly and accommodating & family oriented.Thanks for the great meal, you have a great team read more

Caretti's Pizza - Found this place on Yelp, all I can say is their food is great!! Started with wings, the. calzone & had a cannoli for desert Gr8 food!! - Pizza Near Me - Chambersburg, Pennsylvania

Husband and I ordered 2 stromboli's yesterday. Both were great and large enough for leftovers. Delivery was timely and professional.

My family had a cookout and had two 3 foot hoagies 100 wings and 4 pizzas and everything was cooked perfectly and was only 232$ outstanding. Really advise everyone to order from here if they have a family get together or any party. Great food. read more

I am only posting this review because I have left the area. Caretti's was my little secret because it was SO GOOD. The Philadelphia Ave location is better than the Lincoln Way store, and the Philadelphia Ave location delivers to Wilson. (You hear that, punks? Stop ordering from fucking Dominos!) There is something magical about the pizzas here. I order a pie, sit down at a table, and am left looking at an empty plate 20 minutes later with no memory of the intervening minutes. Oh, Caretti's, I miss you so much. read more

Wow. We had food delivered to our hotel from Caretti's. We are staying in Chambersburg on our way to Connecticut. I must say that the garlic cheese bread was the best I have ever had. We also ordered an original calzone and a cheeseburger hero. Both of those were fantastic. The sauce that came with the bread was out of this world. So glad to have found this place while stopping over for the night!!!! read more

Old world family-style, in a strip-mall setting. Excellent, fresh food, always good, and served by happy, friendly attentive staff. Over sized portions on plated entrées, and the pizza is the best in the area. BYOB Edit to move up from 4-star. I initially took off 1 star for the corny decor (a couple of fake "old-world" statues with fig-leaves over the "privates", which I think is a little over-the-top, but...) For what it is... The food, the service, and ALL THAT REALLY COUNTS - it is 5-star! read more

So, my job has me out of town for training. Now for anyone that travels more than 100 miles out from their job for whatever reason your employer bestows upon you, depending on where you are, one question always remains: Where can I find something good to eat? Now if you're like me, you almost never want to travel so far, only to dine at an establishment that you frequent regularly near your home. (Applebee's, TGI Friday's, Uno's, etc. etc.) And if you like me, you always like checking out the local establishments that are unique to that area. You know, restaurants that are only located in that town or city, and/or have been there so long they're rooted in the history of that town or city (think Ben's Chili Bowl and Washington, D.C., Nathan's and Coney Island, Chap's Pit Beef and Baltimore). So when my co-worker (who's been in this area many times before) recommended Caretti's Pizza & Ristorante, I gave it a shot...and to my delight, I was happily satisfied. Once you enter the Restaurant, you get that "welcome" feeling. The server greets you with a smile, actually welcomes you to Caretti's and asks how you're doing before even asking for your order. While this may have been a unique case or the usual, I must say I really appreciated it. Courtesy like that is lost nowadays so it's a welcomed treat (and that's before the food). Speaking of which, the smell of the place completely encapsulated me to the point that I could've stood there all day and indulged in the scent of each well crafted meal to mark them in my memory. Now this left me with a question of course, what do I try? There were so many items available, and on display by the way, that I was at a lost for where to start. There were calzones, and a variety of regular and stuffed pizzas to name a few. On top of that, I'd hate to pick a meal after that wonderful, engaging experience, only to be disappointed in the end. So I took a chance and tried a combination of two of my favorite dishes, Crab cakes and Italian pastas, and I ordered the Maryland Crab Ravioli (with the Red Sauce). Once the server presented it, which also came with house salad and garlic bread, I gave it a taste and, oh man was it good! It was an incredible dish, and they were very generous in my opinion with the crab stuffed ravioli. They were sizable pieces, nothing small, and the sauce was excellent It had a slight kick to it and as of this review, I still can't put my finger on what the spice is, but it was an added delight. It truly tasted homemade. Now the salad was a typical side salad, nothing really special, although I did enjoy the creamy Italian that it was paired with. The garlic bread was a bit of let down. It was like a toasted baguette with some run-of-the-mill garlic spread. (It wasn't even evenly spread across the bread). However, that is a small, insignificant blemish compared to what was overall a great experience. I am definitely going back to try another dish tomorrow, and if you're ever in Chambersburg, whether it's for work or otherwise, make Caretti's your answer to that age old question, "Where can I find something good to eat?" read more

We head to Caretti's Pizza every weekend for a pizza, it's a routine now. Don't let the depressing strip-mall area fool you, there's a little Italian gem smack dab in the middle! When you watch these gentlemen make your pie, you can see that it's a passion, not just a job. They put care into it, and that's what makes it really good. I'm lactose intolerant, but I can handle the cheese Caretti's uses on their pizza better than chain restaurants like Pizza Hut. That right there tells me it's a higher quality cheese. Toppings are plentiful when you order pizza, so be prepared to like whatever you order on top! The decor inside of the restaurant is interesting to look at, and makes it feel welcoming. The young ladies that work there serving food and taking orders are usually friendly enough, although from time to time they seem somewhat unhappy or rushed when they've taken my order. We always get our food to go. Caretti's gets your food to you as quickly as humanly possible. Even the time we went in and there was a bus full of teenagers on some kind of sports trip, we didn't wait a long time for our pizza. It was impressive how efficient they seemed at getting all of those different sandwich orders, plus keeping up with others' orders coming in. Caretti's has quite the menu, and if you're in the mood for something other than pizza, good luck choosing. Hot subs, cold subs, pasta dishes, gourmet salads, and a variety of sides. Lots to choose from. Some things seem a bit pricey for what they are, while others are very reasonable. I think pizza prices are very reasonable. So what makes a Caretti's pizza so good? Quality. The crust is generally very good, thin but not too thin and not hard. Sauce is full of Italian spices, not too sweet, and very fresh tasting. Cheese (as aforementioned) is of great quality. They always bake it perfectly, only once was it just a little over-done. They take pride and care in what they make, and you can taste that. Although we've never had it delivered, we've seen one of the delivery guys many times and he always seems quite friendly. This is certainly a great local place for Italian food or a tasty pizza. read more

Great Pizza GREAT WINGS! Staff is friendly and they do their best to satisify their customers. Can not expect more from these guys! read more