Little Italy V

Slightly off the beaten path since a mile from center of downtown Gettysburg, this is clearly a…read morelocal favorite. Very busy with folks popping in their pjs to pick up dinner. Generous portions of great food and reasonable prices. The gluten free hoagie roll was the best I have ever had, can't even tell it's gluten free!

Celiac friendly, gluten free . This place is a wonder. My wife is a full blown go to the hospital…read moreif I breathe gluten and this was a wonderful find. They knew all the precautions and knew exactly what was up. Gf homemade garlic bread and pizza. My wife the western pizza, very delicious. Thank you

Menu page 2

Menu front side

See all

Gluten free menu

Mamma's Pizzeria & Ristorante

4.5(13 reviews)

5.8 mi

Family-owned and very congenial manager & staff. In town for a soccer match, wife & I stopped in…read morefor early supper. She got the veal parmesan w/ spaghetti, which came hot and the veal perfectly cooked. My choice was what they call a "cheese steak hoagie", a truly flavorful and overstuffed hot sub on a wide, homemade roll. Couldn't eat it all, so took away half the meals. Huge menu of pizza, pizza pockets, strombolis, hot & cold subs, gyros, wraps, paninis, fish, shrimp, chicken, Mexican & Italian dinners, fajitas, & wings. Wish it were closer!

The staff was so kind and went out of their way to make conversation. The sub rolls were delicious…read moreand the pizza was fantastic!

Onion rings over cooked.

See all

Canoli's!!!!

Antica Napoli Pizza

4.6(185 reviews)

7.1 mi

excellent pizza and service! must go! run do not walk to Antica Napoli ! Arrived at 10 minutes…read moreto closing, they were happy to provide us with a pie!

My wife and I shared a Stromboli, very good. Dough was nice and crispy on the outside and soft…read moreinside. Great flavor.

Restrooms positive!

See all

Chicken Parm Hot Sub

Little Italy Family Restaurant

4.2(11 reviews)

9.1 mi

Love this place, local, drive up / pick up window. Feel…read morelike they have the best subs in the area, love the bread, everything always tastes fresh. I feel like I go there once a week! We also like the sicilian pizza there... but i found what i love there and dont get much else. i think they're doing really great considering the area. we've never had a problem with them! :)

I read in a paper, or in the local social media, that this restaurant was permanently closed…read moreearlier this year.

See all

Cheese fries are decent

Claudio's Pizza

4.5(8 reviews)

8.9 mi

good food! awesome food for a cheap price!…read morewould go again if i had the chance! my siblings enjoy there pizza a lot!

Great variety of food! Staff is always so kind. I love trying new things on their menu!read more

French Fries

See all

Mozzerella Sticks

Tommy's Pizza

3.7(369 reviews)

7.5 mi

Keeping in mind that Gettysburg isn't pizza central, probably nothing over a 5 on the Dave Portnoy…read morescale anywhere in town, but it is more than serviceable pizza. If you've already been here, you "get" the place. Somewhere between college town vibes, seventies Pizza Hut decor, location, location, location and flat out nuts busy on pretty much any evening, any day of the year. Now, my only ability to comment on the food is the pizza, that's all I ever get. Saucy, yes. Sweet, yes, but not as sweet as northeastern Pennsylvania styles. Gooey, drippy, yes, great if you like it that way. The entire family insists that we stop here, and they can be a picky bunch although the home area of southwestern Pennsylvania for most of them isn't pizza central either. Remember, this isn't gourmet, this isn't romantic, but it is more than enjoyable and the price, I feel, is within normal standards for these days.

Whenever I visit a new town, I am finding myself trying new pizzerias I was in Chris' hometown for…read morethe wedding and it just so happened to be Father's Day. Myself and Chris, along with his two brothers and niece decided to hit Tommy's. Apparently its a childhood spot for them and a favorite. It was a very every busy Sunday with orders to-go as well as guest inside and outside enjoying the experience. We ordered pepperoni pizzas and a dozen buffalo wings. I had a hard cider and two delicious slices. The race car matches were on the tele, and everyone seemed to be enjoying the nice sunny day. I love smelling food from the outside of an establisment whenever I arrive or leave,, haha. That speaks volumes!

Counter area

Large Greek pizza

See all

Seating area

The Upper Crust

3.3(323 reviews)

7.2 mi

World Cup Final wood-fired everything. Stopped by The Upper…read moreCrust in Gettysburg to catch the biggest match of the year, and this place came ready to play. Big open space, cold craft beers, free pool, Skee-Ball, basketball games, and enough TVs to make sure you didn't miss a single goal. The wood-fired brisket pizza? It was... okay. Solid effort, but it wasn't lifting any trophies today. The wood-fired wings with buffalo sauce on the side were a better play. The calamari was decent, but the heavy wood-fired flavor tackled it a little too hard. Now the real MVP? The Syrian gyro. Absolute world-class performance. If there were VAR reviews for sandwiches, this one would've been confirmed a goal every time. Final score: Syrian Gyro: Champion Wings: Strong second Pizza: Needs a halftime speech Calamari: Fouled by too much smoke. Sometimes the best player on the field isn't the one you expected... and sometimes it's wrapped in pita.

My worst restaurant experience :( It's such a big restaurant…read moreand it was super busy on weekend. We decided to stopped by to get a lunch and we ordered BBQ since we would love to try it out. We ordered the Medley meat BBQ and am not gonna lie, they were terrible, except the hot link that came with the BBQ set. The brisket were really dry and hard, the ribs were over seasoning and not much meat but fat, pulled pork or maybe chicken ( I'm not sure ) was really bad. I could taste a little sour like they had them meat for over a week. Will not going back. Sorry

The Margeherita, with tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese, and fresh basil.

The Arugula, Includes ricotta cheese, fresh mozzarella cheese, parmesan cheese, caramelized onion, and tender Italian guanciale.

See all

The Pepperoni with Upper Crust tomato sauce, ricotta cheese, fresh mozzarella cheese, parmesan cheese, and mild, smooth pepperoni

Mama's Pizza

4.3(3 reviews)

5.8 mi

We did take out on Mother's Day. Quick service, delicious food, and reasonable prices. We…read moreespecially liked the cheesesteak and gyro.

Great service and excellent food. The subs have the FRESHEST, most DE-LISH bread! Yum!!read more

See all

Little Italy IV

4.3(20 reviews)

15.5 mi

We just ate here last night baked ziti was amazing they for got the salad dressing but it was still…read morethe best

Ordered hamburger bacon and Jalapeno. Got home it was pepperoni and jalapeño. Charged me at the…read moreregister for the pizza I ordered, so the knew what I ordered. Not happy

Things to do in Biglerville

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Joy S.

1 year ago

We used to be frequent patrons; however, tonight marked our final visit due to the complete disregard shown towards the poor quality ribeye steak served, which was predominantly fat and gristle. We addressed this issue with the manager, who merely responded with an indifferent apology. I am astonished by the apparent lack of concern. I intend to share this experience across all my social media platforms, including my TikTok, which has thousands of followers, and I will encourage my friends and family to do the same. I am profoundly disappointed and shocked by this negligence. read more

Little Italy V - pizza - Updated October 2026

Best of Biglerville

People found Little Italy V by searching for…

People who viewed Little Italy V also viewed

Deliso Pizza

4.3

(82 reviews)

Mamma's Pizzeria & Ristorante

4.5

(13 reviews)

The staff was so kind and went out of their way to make conversation. The sub rolls were delicious…read moreand the pizza was fantastic!

Alfredo's Pizza

3.3

(55 reviews)

Very good food! The food was seasoned well. Um Um good! First day I got white pizza, delicious!…read more The tomatoes and broccoli seasoned with garlic on top of the mozzarella and ricotta cheese, hit the spot. Second time bought the Grilled Buffalo Chicken Boli. Very tasty. The drizzle of hot sauce with chicken and cheese brought it all together! Keep it up Alfredo!

We were staying at the local Holiday Inn and there were several menus in the lobby from Alfredo's…read more There were plenty of choices for us to each get what we wanted, so we decided to try Alfredo's. My husband got a pizza and I got the cold sub. Big portions and tasty. This place has counter service with plenty of tables and booths and did a big pick up business. Glad someone left those menus in the lobby!

La Bella Italia

4.0

(315 reviews)

Came for the carb-loading, stayed because I physically couldn't stand up afterwards…read more Stopped by La Bella Italia in Gettysburg, and let's just say the crew running this family-owned spot doesn't play around. Staff is ridiculously friendly and attentive--basically treated me like a long-lost cousin who hadn't eaten in a week. We kicked things off with their fresh, house-baked ciabatta paired with an herb-loaded olive oil and butter combo. The bread was so good I almost forgot I had actual food coming. The play-by-play: Fresh Calamari: Crispy, tender, and served with a killer marinara. Absolutely incredible. Braised Beef Ravioli: You only get four on the plate, but these bad boys are built like linebacker kneepads. Homemade pasta, packed with savory beef, and drenched in a sweet marinara. Spaghetti alle Vongole: Homemade spaghetti tossed with fresh clams in a rich red sauce spiked with garlic, white wine, and fresh herbs. Fantastic flavor. The Pizza: Hey, for Pennsylvania? Pretty solid backup options if you're not going full pasta mode. The best part? All their pasta is made completely fresh in-house, and the portion sizes are strictly "feed a Roman army" certified. Who knew Pennsylvania Italian food could punch this far above its weight class? 10/10, would willingly accept the inevitable food coma again.

Pros: Great menu choices, nice portions, fresh food, great service…read more Cons: none. Our favorite restaurants in G'burg. Always clean, always your favorite itailian dishes and service is always great. Tonight or server was Caleb and our compliments to Caleb who was top end, very friendly and attentive. TonightbI had Veal Parmigana with Spaghetti. Being from Phill originally I love thier Veal Parm which has a lite crunch on the outside but tender and quick inside topped with the right amount of sauce and cheese. Was perfect. I also had a Canolli for dessert which has such i light and fluffy filling drilled with chocolate sauce, one of the best. Cya next time.

Tommy's Pizza

3.7

(369 reviews)

Claudio's Pizza

4.5

(8 reviews)

good food! awesome food for a cheap price!…read morewould go again if i had the chance! my siblings enjoy there pizza a lot!

Great variety of food! Staff is always so kind. I love trying new things on their menu!read more

Antica Napoli Pizza

4.6

(185 reviews)

excellent pizza and service! must go! run do not walk to Antica Napoli ! Arrived at 10 minutes…read moreto closing, they were happy to provide us with a pie!

My wife and I shared a Stromboli, very good. Dough was nice and crispy on the outside and soft…read moreinside. Great flavor.

Olivia's

3.9

(137 reviews)

New favorite Gettysburg-area restaurant! First visit, we tried BBQ Chicken & Shrimp and Seafood…read moreStuffed Scallops (awesome) & on the 2nd visit we happened in on Prime Rib Night (Friday) ...so you guessed it, we both ordered that (awesome again) Service was great both times & food came in a reasonable amount of time - Olivia's actually has an atmosphere you would want to linger in (had piano player on Prime Rib Night) Thoroughly enjoyed both experiences ..oh & the bread & hummus was good too;) If you haven't tried Olivia's on your Gettysburg area meanderings, I suggest heading out on the Pike and adding it to your dining rotation!

A shout out to Olivia's for making my 65th birthday very special! I had forgotten my birthday crown…read moreat home and upon hearing this, the staff there made me one! When I didn't order a dessert, they provided a surprise scoop of ice cream with a candle. The food was, as always, great! We highly recommend the garlic and Romano wings as an appetizer.

Pat & Carla's Italian Eatery

3.3

(24 reviews)

I'll be honest...I was concerned, walking into this place, on what to expect. It was empty (to be…read moreexpected, what with COVID and most people doing takeout), and the A/C condenser leaking water right by the front entrance. The paper placemat pointing out outdated facts about Italy wasn't promising, either. But our group went for the pizza and cheese bread. And you know what...it was far better than expected, we all thought. The sauce was flavorful, the crust was crunchy and chewy, and not greasy or burnt. The order came out fairly quickly, and price was reasonable. I like trying new pizza places when I travel, but I would still come back here on a whim, knowing that the food I received was good enough to warrant a second attempt.

Pizza is good as are the salads, but I'm not a fan at all of anyplace that adds things to my food…read morethat is not listed on the menu or I asked for. Sadly, this place does both. It's been awhile since I have been here because of my busy travel schedule, so I figured today was the day to visit it again while I was nearby. I ordered two pizza slices with some veggies added (their slice pizza is always just cheese pizza that they add toppings to as requested. They don't have slice pizza already made with any toppings like many other places do, which is fine by me). I looked forward to eat nice, crisp, hot pizza with veggies added. Instead I was disappointed by the slices having added melted "mozzarella" on the slices. I didn't ask for or want extra cheese. I just wanted a couple of slices of normal cheese pizza with some veggies added on top. I refused the "heart attack waiting to happen" pizza slices. They were replaced by two slices the way I asked for them - cheese slices with veggies, not extra cheese. The server told me they "always add a little extra cheese on the top." But no where is that stated on the menu or when ordering. I also ordered 2 meatballs with sauce, an antipasto salad and the garlic bread it came with, but with just red wine vinegar, not any of the oil based vinaigrette, ranch, etc. dressings they offer. What I got was garlic bread and sliced meatballs in sauce, covered with guess what? "Mozzarella" cheese I didn't ask for and is not stated on the menu. The garlic bread was an oily mess because the cheese melted into its oily state and the only garlic they use is in the bitter I was told. No actual garlic on the bread was visible or tasted. The meatballs were sliced and covered with the gobs of melted mozzarella cheese too. What's with the fascination with adding cheese to melt on everything? The "mozzarella" cheese has no distinguishable taste, nor does the provolone in the antipasto. Possibly lower cost from the supplier so lower quality results. Have these folks heard some people prefer living life a bit more by watching calories and fat intake? We can actually do that by limiting the intake of bad stuff but still enjoy all types of food in moderation. I gave 2 stars because the pizza and antipasto are good or okay and the server was nice as well. But the fascination with melted cheese on everything and not saying it on the menu or checking with the customer first is not only unhealthy for people but wasteful and unwise when customers either return the food for replacement or simply eat it and never come back. I'm mostly vegetarian (technically a flexitarian) and enjoy Italian food which fits into that food lifestyle.

Little Italy IV

4.3

(20 reviews)