New favorite Gettysburg-area restaurant! First visit, we tried BBQ Chicken & Shrimp and Seafood Stuffed Scallops (awesome) & on the 2nd visit we happened in on Prime Rib Night (Friday) ...so you guessed it, we both ordered that (awesome again) Service was great both times & food came in a reasonable amount of time - Olivia's actually has an atmosphere you would want to linger in (had piano player on Prime Rib Night) Thoroughly enjoyed both experiences ..oh & the bread & hummus was good too;) If you haven't tried Olivia's on your Gettysburg area meanderings, I suggest heading out on the Pike and adding it to your dining rotation! read more

See all

A shout out to Olivia's for making my 65th birthday very special! I had forgotten my birthday crown at home and upon hearing this, the staff there made me one! When I didn't order a dessert, they provided a surprise scoop of ice cream with a candle. The food was, as always, great! We highly recommend the garlic and Romano wings as an appetizer. read more

Food was very good just pricey. We sat outside on a gorgeous evening. Waitress was very attentive. read more

The food is absolutely amazing. Service is great. They have great seasonal menu & drinks. read more

See all

12/30/25: Thought we'd try a local restaurant we haven't eaten at yet and found Olivia's in Gettysburg. We were glad to see that it's open until 10pm! Walking in the front door you see the bar, but to the right is the restaurant area. They had everything decorated for Christmas - very pretty. We were welcomed warmly and seated immediately. Our waitress was friendly and professional. She knew the menu well. It's a Mediterranean restaurant and they have quite a variety of food choices. My husband chose the lasagna which came with soup or salad and garlic cheese bread. I chose the salmon which came with sautéed spinach, asparagus, and steamed broccoli. I couldn't eat the smashed potatoes that came with it, so I asked for it on the side so my hubby could eat it. I also ordered a bowl of their Maryland Crab vegetable soup. They were very accommodating. Our food was delicious. I didn't leave any on my plate! My husband was full halfway through his lasagna & so he had to say no to having dessert this time. Definitely a great evening out and we recommend it highly! I look forward to returning in the future! read more

See all

Just ate there a few hours ago, my husband got the pork marsala and I got the steak smothered in onions, mushrooms and cheese...we also had the stuffed mushrooms...always wanted to stop there cause the parking lot is always full...We were not disappointed, that was the best steak I had in a long time, it was perfect! The food was great! Service was good also... read more

The staff were friendly and helpful. Food was outstanding. Between 2 appetizers, 2 bar drinks, 3 dinners and dessert, everything hit. The crab and sirloin tips especially stole the show. Olivia's is only a 15 minute ride from Gettysburg college and well worth the trip if you're in the area. Better than most of the local Gettysburg restaurants. read more

On a trip to the Gettysburg outlets, we decided to stay in the area and look for lunch. We agreed on Olivia's which is close to the outlets and the other choices for lunch were less appealing. Olivia's has charm that is only matched by the quality and appeal of the food. Our choices were exceptional, and, the service was attentive. The desserts are homemade. The Greek selections are a standout. My selection for lunch was the Hot Roast Beef. It was perfect in every way. Olivia's is a find for fine food, excellently prepared and presented. Don't forget the Baklava! read more

Olivia's - Hot Roast Beef to savor. - Greek Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

This restaurant is ALWAYS amazing! The food is great, the staff is awesome, and the ambiance is relaxing. This place has been one of my family's favorite haunts for years. No matter what the occasion, my picky-eating daughter requests to go here for the dinner (even though it is an hour drive for us.) Well worth the trip every time. Gettysburg's best. read more

See all

Authentic Greek/Italian food in a homey yet elegant atmosphere. Perfect for a family gathering or special occasion dinner. Everything was delicious and portion sizes were just right. read more

See all

I like the Friday prime rib, and the salads are like no other restaurant. Great place, try them!

Appetizers and entrees are huge portions and delicious. Service great as well; very attentive, pleasant and helpful in describing the dishes. A very comfortable, casual environment with a touch of sophistication. read more

Enjoyed dinner here on a Saturday night, though they were busy, the servers were all working hard and very attentive (especially ours). When we arrived we were greeted immediately and while that host was working on a table for us, another also greeted us and ensured we were being taken care of. The food was fantastic as was the martini I ordered. Honestly can't say enough good things about this restaurant. I've visited before, this was the first time in a long while and my husband's first visit to Olivia's. It won't be our last! read more

Food is always great. Staff is friendly. The variety of great dishes keeps us coming back. One of my favorites is the French onion soup. Everything I've had keeps me coming back for more. One day I might get to the desserts, the portions always fill me up before I get there. Another reason we keep returning. Gettysburg treasure. read more

Been here many time... it's one of the reasons I call Gettysburg my happy place! The food is unbelievable and the service and atmosphere is absolutely the best! read more

Olivia's - Greek Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

See all

We went with friends who have strong Greek ties, so we weren't flying blind. The restaurant is dimly lit - but not overly so - and the overall ambience was very welcoming. We had a great waitress who was responsive throughout our meal. We all shared a couple of plates of dolmades to start - delicious. I decided on lobster and seafood Mac and cheese for dinner and my wife had an order of Yia-Yia's Italian meatballs. Both were scrumptious. We'll definitely be back!! read more

Excellent food & even better service in a home cooked atmosphere. And don't miss the cheesecake!

Great burger very filling. Greek flavors mixed in to a traditional burger. It was very good and fresh. read more

Olivia's - Texas bootlegger Burger - Greek Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Do not pass this up. Where do I begin. We had lunch there it was so good we returned for dinner. I have lived in Europe, and I had some the best Mediterranean food here. The hummus, tzatziki, Greek salad, Gyro and then the Mediterranean Surf and Turf. Chef Yanni uses the freshest ingredients to create amazing dishes. The locals are fortunate to have such a place. This family owned and operated restaurant shows how much pride they have in their menu and service. Their staff is professional, knowledgeable and welcoming. This will be an annual stop when we visit family. read more

We had high hopes for Olivia's, we were disappointed. The appetizer was very good lasagna fritte, so our expectations were high! Entree's, we had the Caesar salad with grilled chicken, this is where they failed. We had to ask for it NOT to be in a bread bowl. The description states grilled chicken and lettuce with a homemade Caesar dressing and croutons. What came was mixed green that has wilted, chicken tenders baked with way too much balsamic vinegar, croutons not seasoned and the homemade dressing was tasteless. Dessert was baklava, ok, nothing to speak of. The atmosphere was loud, we were in a booth but could hear the conversations of both booths behind us. High hopes, but were sadly let down. read more

This is by far one of our favorite restaurants! We are from Maryland and come to Fayetteville several times a year passing through Gettysburg and we always eat at Olivia's, at least once. We've often said we wish it was closer to home. We've even made day trips just so we could eat at Olivia's. Best meatballs we've ever had!! The French onion soup is amazing!! We love the staff and always sit in the bar to see our favorite bartender! The newly added blueberry mojito was delicious. We've been coming for a few years and never been disappointed. Don't get me started on the desserts.. to die for. Planning on going again tonight read more

Wonderful place to eat and relax, outdoor area for sitting, outdoor bar area as well. Food and service is always on point

Everything was excellent. Lamb meatballs, pistachio and lamb kabobs. We were traveling and this was a lucky find! read more

Wow ... what a tremendous place! Seafood in pastry and Granddad's ribeye were perfect. Best steak in years. Nailed medium rare. I generally don't order smothered steaks, but this one was exceptional. Service was attentive and solid. Drink menu looked great, but we were driving and did not partake. Easy scenic drive from DC metro -- whether up 270 to 15 or straight up 97 (Georgia Ave.) read more

Huge menu with great food. Don't sleep on the crab nachos! Great dessert and service is always been good. Portions are large! read more

Olivia's - Crab Nachos - Greek Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Service was fantastic. Food was terrific. I would eat here anytime. We had the lobster macaroni and cheese. And it's not like Kraft macaroni and cheese out of the box. Have to order this to see it it's hard to describe. The Thai lamb kebabs were great for a Greek restaurant. We had the Ratatouille as a side. The dolmades and Greek sausage for an appetizer. Both of which were very good, but whoever made the dolmades really knows what they're doing. Nice atmosphere, pretty easy parking. It's a bit pricey, so probably not a once a week thing. The only minor complaint that I would have is the bench seating is hard but that's it. We have been trying to get to this place for years but it just never worked out. Finally made it for a 35th anniversary. Will definitely be back. read more

Excellent food Excellent home made desserts Nice staff Have been there six times and Service and food is consistently Excellent. read more

This gem is the best food we had in Gettysburg. Caution ...the portions are very large. The service and food are excellent. I would eat here on a regular basis if I lived in the area. Give Olivia's a try you will not be disappointed. read more

Very good food and an interesting menu. Seems to have a Greek Italian influence and the service is good. The night I was there this kitchen was a little slow but I'm sure that changes from time to time. read more

This was the best meal by far that we've had during our visit to Gettysburg. This dish was loaded with seafood and was deliciously cheesey. I have had lobster Mac n Cheese at quite a few restaurants and this was my favorite. If I lived here this would be a regular stop for me because of this dish. If we return to the area, we will definitely return to Olivia's! read more

Olivia's - Watermelon Paloma - Greek Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Ok so I like you lol saw Oliva's on Fox43 and drove an hour and was NOT disappointed! It was sooooo good! For an appetizer we had Rockefeller Oyster! She's had the Caesar salad and I had the Greek salad.We demolished them! This sauce that the oysters were in was absolutely amazing. I kept swapping it up with the delicious homemade bread. For supper my friend had the Baja Chicken and Shrimp and I had the Shrimp, Lobster, Crab (trio) scampi. For desserts we had margaritas, dirty martinis, Reese cheesecake, and a Stella. Our server Chelsea was the best. Mama stopped passed our table every so often to see how we were. WE WILL DEFINITELY BE BACK! We love Oliva's! Excellent Mother's Day! read more

See all

This place great. They offer large portions of really good food. My wife and I enjoyed the food, the friendly service, & the atmosphere. The smashed potatoes are extremely garlicky but still good. read more

Friendly staff, great entertainment, salad thumbs down (garden salad) junk lettuce. Food ok, small potions for price. Small glass of wine 10.50 ouch! Of course desserts look and are amazing. I know times are tough, Covid etc. not our favorite choice. read more

Amazing dinner! Olivias was recommended by our hotel front desk guy (John at the Courtyard) and it was amazing! The bread is amazing!! Hubby loved the hummus, but I am not a fan of cumin, and it definitely had cumin. That is OK, though. The bread is fine alone! Their cocktail game is strong (try the lavender French 75). I had the lamb keftes and a Greek village salad. Fair warning, the salad is HUGE. Hubby had the crab cakes (subbed a salad for the broccoli). Our server (Lily) was amazing. Soooo friendly with great info on the menu. Service was on point. read more

We were told by several how good the food was. So this being our 1st time, our expectations were a little high. However, the only thing we thought went well was the very friendly staff. We original were sat in the inside however the jazz music was very loud and was not our taste. We were moved to the deck which was a much nicer atmosphere. It took about 15-20 minutes to get our drinks. After that, our Food didn't take too long which was nice. Although we were left with food and no drinks at one point for about 10-15 minutes. The steak was very bland with a lot of fat on. It was cooked medium and had very little juice. Would not recommend this item. The crab imperial was decent and the potatoes with melted cheese were good. Overall we won't be returning as our bill was expensive as we were trying something new. Not worth the money in the end. Would rather go ti a place for half the price and much better quality. read more

We are repeat customers and dined on the outdoor patio for the first time. It had a great beach vibe and was great to enjoy the perfect weather today. Service was very good, attentive as always. The Summer Lemonade and Sangrito were great cocktails on the specials list. I had the Turkish Shish Kebabs which was delicious and very generous portion (I took half home) my husband had the butter basted rib eye which he really enjoyed. read more

There is nothing impressive about this place. Food is mediocre and high priced. There is nothing special about the service and it's dark. I will not go back! read more

We have been coming to Gettysburg for over 30 years and yet this was our first visit to Olivia's and it was not disappointing. The food and helpings were great. Don't miss the stuffed grape leaves . A nice relaxed atmosphere and wonderful service, we will definitely be back! read more

Our server lily was very friendly. We were seated immediately and our order was taken immediately. We had very little wait time for drinks and soup. They provided bread and hummus as well. The food came out quickly and hot. Everything was so very delicious. When I am in the area again, I will definitely come back. read more

Olivia's - Greek Moussaka - Greek Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

We stopped in here on a whim on Father's Day and sat at the bar. Thought the food was excellent and service amazing. Felt like we were at a neighborhood joint and we were regulars. If I could offer a suggestion to the owner, it would be to add more variety in the appetizers. Neither one of us are fans of grape leaves and we wanted more than dips. Our original intent was to get two apps and maybe dessert. Instead we split one entree. I agree with other reviewers about the price. We had two cocktails and one pasta entree and the bill was $54.00. I'm hoping we were charged a "Father's Day" up charge because that seems about 20% higher than comparable establishments. I would highly recommend Olivia's provided you understand the pricing before you walk in. For us, we will absolutely go back and simply adjust our ordering because of the price. (We eat at local restaurants one to two times per week all over the central pa region as a frame of reference for our price comment) Lastly, Olivia (THE Olivia) makes a mean cocktail. She has an art. read more