When I tell you the service absolutely fantastic.... I mean it really is! We were late like 5-10 minutes before they closed, we were greeted with a smile, a good chat, and outstanding cheesecake! Place is always got a great vibe about it and well outstanding variety of cheesecakes! I ordered this time strawberry wedding cake, the strawberry on top was fresh and cold! The cheesecake was creamy and thick! Couldn't ask for a better cheesecake! read more

When Cheese Met Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Greenwood, Indiana

See all

Omg! Heaven! I love, love, love their cheesecake!! My favorite is hands down the confetti cake on top of plain cheesecake. The cake is dense but moist and oh so yummy! The buttercream frosting is just the right balance of cream and sweetness. It's not sickeningly sweet like some buttercream frosting is. The cheesecake on the bottom is the best cheesecake I've had in Indiana. The texture is absolutely perfect. The slices are huge and definitely shareable. I ate this all myself but I was able to make it three portions. Highly recommend When Cheese Met Cake! Btw, the owner is super sweet and is always happy to see her customers. read more

When Cheese Met Cake - When Cake Met Cheese - Confetti cake on top of Plain NY-Style Cheesecake (delicious!!!) - Bakeries Near Me - Greenwood, Indiana

I've had this place on my list for a while and I wish I had stopped in sooner. Most important thing - follow them on Facebook, the menu changes pretty significantly day to day and they post the menu the day before/morning of, and do a really great job of updating on what's in stock through the day. (When a flavor sells out, that's it!) The cheesecake is heavenly, the cookies are great, and I'm sure everything else here is really top notch. With 200+ flavors in rotation, there is bound to be something you'll love! read more

Cake and cheesecake mixed together is such a yummy combination!!! The cheesecake is NY style and perfect amount of sweetness to it. The cake portion is a good amount and mixed together it's delicious. I've gotten the pineapple upside down (twice), carrot cake (crème cheese frosting is not too sweet) and the cookies and cream and all three have been fresh, consistent and perfect! read more

See all

SO GOOD! When Cheese Met Cake just opened not too long ago. I have been following her on Facebook for a while now and she just opened a brick and mortar store. Follow her page on Facebook because she posts the flavors for the next day on her page. She told me there is usually a line when she opens so make sure you get there early if you have your eye on a certain flavor! She is a one woman show and is doing great! I can't wait to see how her business grows! I definitely would recommend trying it out. There are other options if you're not into cheesecake. They change daily so check out her Facebook page. I can't wait to come back and try more flavors! read more

See all

I have nothing but good things to say about When Cheese Met Cake. I ordered a large Valentine's Day basket/box. It came with 6 mini cheesecakes, 6 chocolate chip cookies, 6 chocolate dipped strawberries and a box of brownie bites. While there picking up my basket I also ordered a slice of plain cheesecake with strawberry topping on the side and a cookies and cream cookie sandwich. EVERYTHING WAS EXCELLENT! I took a bite of the plain cheesecake and it was one of the creamiest cheesecakes I've ever had. It's was amazing. Everything in the basket was delicious was exactly what I was told ESPECIALLY those strawberries. I will say the price is just a little high BUT the quality of the product COMPLETELY justifies the price. I will MOST DEFINITELY buy from there again. Great people, great service and absolutely fabulous treats! read more

This was our first experience here, and it will definitely be our last. We spent $60 on two slices of cheesecake, one cookie, and a bar. The cheesecake slices were unbelievably tiny, an absolute joke for the price. If I could give zero stars, I would. Absolutely do not recommend this place. read more

When Cheese Met Cake - Absolute joke and not worth the money! - Bakeries Near Me - Greenwood, Indiana

Ordered the Brookie New York cheesecake for my husband's birthday. The suspense of waiting long enough after dinner to eat it was killing me! It looked amazing! Layers of thick brownie crust, New York style cheesecake, with cookie and brownie pieces on top, and rimmed with fresh whipped cream. It is not possible to cut a small piece haha It was absolutely delicious and oh so rich! I loved the plain cheesecake flavor, so creamy and flavorful. The whole process was simple. I ordered and paid online and selected the pick up day. I received a text day of letting me know it was ready and to come before the shop closed. Upon arrival I told them who I was and out it came. Would definitely recommend. Gone are the days of my cheesecakes cracking and wondering if it is too done. I will definitely order again! read more

Wonderful service with knowledgeable staff. I've purchased slices for a few different kinds of cheesecakes and the ones my friends, family, and I have had are excellent! read more

This is a must go to! You are initially welcomed in by the cutest decor and vibes. I want to come hang out here all the time. There were two women actively baking more goodies and they were so nice and welcoming. It was fun to see them working in action. You can get slices of their cheesecakes or the day, brownies, cookies, dipped strawberries and cupcakes! I got their cinnamon swirl cheesecake and it is delicious! You can also reach out to them and order a custom made item! I will be back and ordering all my future goodies! read more

See all

Simply amazing! Everything is delish and to die for! Her bakery is adorable!!! Congrats on the opening. She posts flavors nightly for the next day. Check her out. read more

When Cheese Met Cake - Butterfinger, cookie sandwich, cotton candy - Bakeries Near Me - Greenwood, Indiana

AMAZING! Drove from Plainfield hoping this would live up to the hype! Got the Oh My Ganache it's Strawberries and the Caramel Pecan for my husband and I to sample! BOTH were the BEST cheesecake I have EVER tasted!!!!! I only ate a few bites of each so I will probably return today to try the Lemon and Christmas Tree. Staff is very friendly and excited about their product! 20 out 10 for taste!!!!! Also purchased chocolate dipped strawberries but I have not tried and peanut butter and ganache drizzled brownies for my husband which he says are DELICIOUS!!!!! I've watched FB post about this establishment for weeks but made myself go today out of curiosity after reading a bad review. Everyone has a different experience but mine was the total opposite. VERY satisfied with the price I paid for the goods I received as well as the service from the staff. read more

Best cheesecake ever!! Been sooo many times and never disappoints! I love checking her Facebook as that is where she posts the menu for the day and it's so easy to see what flavors will be selling! read more

See all

Yum! We happened upon this cute establishment and are so glad! Delicious! Friendly staff! read more

When Cheese Met Cake - Strawberry cheesecake and Caramel Macchiato cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Greenwood, Indiana

Finally our first time in after following on Facebook. We got the turtle cheesecake and a cookie sandwich... so yummy! The service was fast and friendly and everything was attractively displayed. We will return! read more

Best cheesecake I've ever had but her other treats are delicious too! The cookies are so soft. Brownies are rich. Whether you like the word or not, her cakes are so moist. Everything is made fresh. Ingredients are top notch. Dannielle is just a peach and always provides a great experience when you walk through her door! Love that she offers a place to sit and eat inside too. All around a wholesome little bakery with great staff! read more

You know how sometimes you hear of a place that looks intriguing but the prices give you pause? This little shop is like that, but these cakes are worth every penny! I ordered a single slice of a delectable Butterfinger and caramel-drizzled delight, and now I want to try every flavor they have! Each week the offerings are different, and you can tell the owner is a true artist in her craft. The parking situation gets a little crazy, but I would gladly park a little ways away and walk to get myself a slice of this perfection! read more

I've had a lot of cheesecake in my life but this cheesecake is by far the best and freshest you'll ever have. Everything is made daily with the best premium ingredients. There are no shortcuts here. Cookies, cookies sandwiches and brownies are also to die for. Do yourself a favor and head over and see what I'm talking about. She sells out most days and list everything will have each day on her FB page. You will not regret it! Oh and it's super cute shop!! read more

See all

So delicious!!! Can't wait to try more. Love the daily menu posted on Facebook, easy to see what is offered each day and she posts when sold out each day. read more