Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Cakehole

    4.7 (19 reviews)
    Open 9:30 am - 3:00 pm

    The Cakehole Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - The Cakehole

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Wednesday Addams themed birthday cake
    Audrey K.

    Absolutely amazing experience with The Cakehole. I had been searching all around for a bakery in the Indianapolis area to make my son's Wednesday Addams themed birthday cake. It's become a family tradition to have over-the-top birthday cakes, but I was striking out everywhere for weeks as it's May and therefore wedding season has begun. I wanted black buttercream frosting with minimal food coloring icing a red velvet cake, which means using black cocoa in it. Desperate, I posted to a Facebook group for suggestions, and the owner was tagged in the comments. I sent her a message and she worked some kind of magic to get me squeezed in last minute. The price was reasonable for what I was asking for, and I was happy to drive out to New Pal to pick it up. Not only was the order completed on time, but it is GORGEOUS, and it is exactly what my 8 year old had envisioned as he was describing what he wanted. I swear to you, I will make the drive every year for another one of her masterpieces and for her amazing and timely service. I'll just call her FIRST from now on. Thank you for making a little boy's cake dreams come true.

    Fishing-themed Birthday Cake
    Miriam S.

    I put my order in less than a week ahead and though it was not preferred, she was able to work it in. The cake was beautiful, exactly what I needed to fit our theme and even more, it was delicious! I ordered the turtle flavor and it is up there with the best I've ever had. You can tell she is a true artist and enjoys her work! Thank you so so much! I already have another order scheduled for August!

    This is the place to go for adorable and tasty cakes!
    Ericka D.

    If you've ever wanted a unique cake in Indiana, this is the place to go. She designs all sorts of things and the more over the top the more I think she likes to create it! I recently had the S'mores cupcake and the Berry Lemonade Cupcake and couldn't stop there! The Oreo is awesome and a favorite seems to be the Black Bottom cupcake. Now a store front in New Palestine! Check out the website: http://thecakehole.net/ Mmm, good.

    a three tiered cake on a table

    See all

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Jan N.
    11
    76
    665

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    We ordered cupcakes for my sons birthday party and it was delicious! Super nice and easy to work with. Highly recommend!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Great cakes and cupcakes tastes as good as they look. Made with personal touch in New Pal

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Emma P.
    22
    15
    0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - The Cakehole

    Review Highlights - The Cakehole

    If I have future events that need bakery services Jovanna will definitely be my first choice!

    Mentioned in 5 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Frosty Boy Drive-In

    Frosty Boy Drive-In

    4.4
    (111 reviews)
    0.2 mi
    $

    Awesome onion chips (vs onion rings) good coney dogs, and perfect milk shakes. Loved how the onion…read morechips were exactly the right size and easy to eat. It's been around for years, and is a favorite among NewPal residents but others come from far away places to enjoy a true mom'n pop drive-in. For the food and ice cream they serve, they do it well. This visit today was pleasant. Beautiful day for an outdoor experience.

    America , Americana lives most strongly in the heartland , Frosty Boy Drive -In is a strong example…read moreof the America that STILL EXISTS!! From the eye catching blue and white paint scheme to the iconic awning Frosty Boy invites you to experience what had been lost in so many cities and towns across the USA. this a true "Attraction eatery " in Indiana . Worth the drive wherever you come from . It is featured on Roadside Architecture.com 1) the FOOD menu harkens the lucky patrons to another time when life and liberty were different , excellent selections , every item on the menu is smile restoring good ! I've yet to see a frown on any person enjoying their expertly presented food choice ! 2) the Ice Creams !!! oh wow does this take me back ! kids in middle America used to get lucky enough to go to our local Dairy Queen , or Dairy Dream,Dairy Sweet or Polly Freeze in Georgetown In! While a few of these great locations still exist, FROSTY BOY is a classic example of great soft serve Americana dessert , feel good treats!! 3) plenty of parking access easy on and off the street nice level parking and plenty of under the awning classic seating . 4) Customer service is paramount , they greet you with eye contact and smiles and are genuinely nice and polite (very refreshing in today's world) the quickly and efficiently answer your questions and process your selections . 5) Cleanliness, not trash or debris falling from overfilled receptacles , no trash or messy spills noticeable anywhere . The over all ambience is truly American , truly Family friendly .. We absolutely love Frosty Boy and I personally love the anchor it gives me to another time when this sort of excellence was the norm . Well done Frosty Boy we will be back for years to come !!!

    Photos
    Frosty Boy Drive-In
    One of the 3 chili dogs remaining.
    One of the 3 chili dogs remaining.
    Frosty Boy Drive-In

    See all

    Crave

    Crave

    4.3
    (44 reviews)
    17.6 mi

    I accidentally came to this location thinking it was the one for my Yelp experience…read more The lady working here was so friendly that I decided to purchase something since I was here. She told me about the cookies and drinks they have. The drinks sounded interesting so I thought I'd try one out. I asked the worker for her recommendation and she told me her favorite drink was the Full Blitz. The base was sprite mixed with some fruity flavors. It sounded good, so I purchased that. It didn't take her long to make it, and the color of the drink was pretty. I was happy with the selection because it was delicious, I thanked the worker for her recommendation. They offer different sizes, I went with the smallest which was a 16oz and it cost a little under $4. I noticed the inside isn't too big, and it looked more like you grab and go here. I didn't see any inside seating for dining in, although outside had a table so could be an option for when the weather is nice. Parking for this location is street parking, they have spots right out front, and it is free. They change cookie flavors every Friday morning.

    I ordered from the app and read the descriptions and followed through. The app is very easy to use…read moreand you can set the time that you want to pick it up for. The service when I got to the shop was awesome. My order was ready to go. However, this is where things changed. I ordered the lemon poppyseed. Now, if I was just ordering a poppyseed cookie, this would've been nine out of 10 there was crispness to the edges, soft middle, but not too soft and also not too sweet's a really solid cookie. However, since I went into it thinking this was gonna be lemon including lemon icing drizzle on the top I did not smell lemon when I first smelled the cookie and I did not taste any lemon in the cookie itself so I have to say that my review went from 9 to 5 out of 10 because I love lemon flavor and almost never does anyone have enough lemon flavor. in this case there wasn't any. Highly disappointed crave. Onto the next cookie, I ordered the mango sticky rice because the ingredients looked awesome and the concept sounded good There are big chunks of mango in every bite. I believe these are dried mango pieces. I think fresh mango would've tasted better, but probably would've led to a much more wet cookie. This cookie was pretty dense. It was not as soft as the first cookie however, it was also not very sweet which was good. I would probably order this again.

    Photos
    Raspberry Cheesecake, PB Cup S'more, Snickerdoodle Toast Crunch, The Bisc-Oreo
    Raspberry Cheesecake, PB Cup S'more, Snickerdoodle Toast Crunch, The Bisc-Oreo
    Crave
    Chocolate chip cookie

    See all

    Chocolate chip cookie
    Beurre Sec Pastry

    Beurre Sec Pastry

    4.8
    (9 reviews)
    14.6 mi

    I was able to get in line and get some pastries from Beurre Sec Pastry. These are French pastries…read morethat are even more beautiful in person than the pictures I've seen. Yes, these are quite a bit pricer that's for sure. People were buying one of everything in line. I was like wow! Some Items the combinations of flavors didn't appeal to me. I love tiramisu and pecan pie so I got them both. One suggestion I would have is to have utensils and napkins at the table for people to use. The pastries I bought are really temperature sensitive and need to be kept cold. Both had a cream - mousse inside. They wouldn't last long only a day or to the next. I loved the pecan item I ordered. It was great! The tiramisu one I wouldn't order again. The bottom flakey part was so bitter. I love coffee and expresso and tiramisu. But, the whole thing just wasn't what I thought it would taste like. Now I know. :-( Creamy, sweet, smooth, with a kick of coffee all come together to make a great tiramisu. This is what most people love about it. I don't know if they are planning on opening a store or not. The pop ups are doing well it seems. I will try other items whenever I can get to one of the pop ups.

    Had the pleasure of trying Beurre Sec at a recent pop-up event! I took a few friends so we could…read moretry more of the pastries and I'm so thankful I did -- the line was wrapped around the corner 30 minutes before the event had started, and when it did, people were spilling out with BOXES of pastries. What went from ordering 1 pastry each turned into 8 total.. and we regret nothing. The Tiramisu Danish was exactly as I had hoped for! The bitter taste of espresso paired with the sweet mascarpone cream filling reminded me of the holidays when I would watch my mom make tiramisu for our family. While a lot of people prefer a sweeter espresso, I thought this was perfect and very true to a traditional tiramisu taste The Pear Kouglof reminded me of a fresh yeast donut that's been tossed in sugar This was a very kid-friendly pastry in taste and while I wasn't too blown away by it, it did make me wonder if I would have preferred it with a stronger, more potent, fruit. The Cherry Basque Cheesecake -- this pastry was the house favorite. The texture of this cheesecake was creamy, but somehow still spongey.. cakey, but more like pudding. Mix that with the juiciest sour cherries and the crunch of a biscoff crust.. mind blown was an understatement. We're looking forward to what Beurre Sec has planned for their next pop-up

    Photos
    Beurre Sec Pastry
    Tiramisu Danish it's pretty but this was so bitter.
    Tiramisu Danish it's pretty but this was so bitter.
    Beurre Sec Pastry

    See all

    Hitherto Coffee and Gaming Parlour

    Hitherto Coffee and Gaming Parlour

    4.8
    (107 reviews)
    8.7 mi
    $$

    Game store and coffee shop. Just a place to chill, hang out and play games with friends. There are…read more2-person tables on one side, good for co-working, chatting with a friend, reading a book with some coffee, etc. On the other side are large tables that can be reserved for game playing. The table reservations are $40, but once you arrive, that money becomes credit to be used in the store for food, drinks, games, etc. They have a coffee shop in the back with elixers, coffee and tea, and a small assortment of baked goods. They also have a large selection of brand new games and game novelties for purchase. In the very back, behind the coffee counter is a selection of games that can be played while in the store. There is no charge for those. You cannot bring your own food or drink in. The table reservations are for 2 hrs I believe. They also do events in the store like D&D.

    The name on everybody's lips is Hitherto Coffee and Gaming Parlor, man. I keep hearing about this…read morecoffee shop / gaming space. One good friend wrote about it, then a Yelp friend mentioned it the same day when I saw her in person. I guess those two things were a sign that I needed to visit? Journalism school taught me that three instances of something equals a trend, but I was satisfied with two things, this time. Hitherto is more than half an hour from where I live, but I made time on a Friday morning to visit. To heck with work and the PTO meeting, right? Your girl needs a chai latte! I usually exclusively drink black coffee, but I heard that the chai latte here is dope so that's what I got. I'm glad I did! It was smooth and creamy, with just the right amount of spice. I also got a chocolate chip cookie, because it had fleur de sel on it. I love sweet things with salt on them! I like to think I'm a chocolate chip cookie connoisseur, and I can spot a great CCC just by glancing at it. I wasn't even in the mood for a cookie, but after looking at the cookies in the display case, I had to get a chocolate chip cookie because I knew it would be amazing. I told myself that I would take it home and eat it later, but I ended up eating it in my car. You guys. The chocolate chip cookies at Hitherto are perfect. I don't know if they make them in-house or source them from elsewhere, but if you want a little sweet treat and you're not sure what to get (they have lots of delicious-looking baked goods), get the chocolate chip cookie with fleur de sel. It's a good thing. The space inside the coffee shop is so cozy and inviting. It's a small space, but when I visited, there were plenty of tables available. Some people were tucked into a corner playing board games, some people were behind laptops working, and some were chatting with friends. It was a nice vibe, and I'm so glad a place like this exists in Indy. I just wish it were located closer to me! Part of the shop is a space dedicated to new board games that you can purchase. They had lots of games for all ages and interests, and even my oldest kid's favorite board game, Splendor. They also have board games that you can borrow and play at your table. Bonus: They play good music here! Hitherto was exactly where I should have been at that very moment on Friday morning, and do you know why? Because when I walked in, a song that I've been rinsing and repeating was playing over the speakers (a Jose Gonzales cover of a The Knife song). What! It's not even a popular cover. I plotzed. It's so fun when things like that happen in life.

    Photos
    Raspberry cream soda, berry galette, and ham & Gruyère pocket pie. De-lish!!
    Raspberry cream soda, berry galette, and ham & Gruyère pocket pie. De-lish!!
    New games for purchase
    New games for purchase
    Hitherto's Sachertorte Gourmet Dessert

    See all

    Hitherto's Sachertorte Gourmet Dessert
    Amelia’s

    Amelia’s

    4.8
    (335 reviews)
    13.8 mi
    $$

    I love bread! This place has great bread selection and other goodies too. This spot is located in…read morefountain square, but Amelia's has grown over the years and they have a couple other locations too around the city. This one is good for grab and go, unless it's nice out and then you can enjoy seating located out front. Service is friendly here. The workers are always up to answering any of my questions. They told me the olive bread is only sold on Wednesdays. I've never had it, but it sounds good. The bread I love is the focaccia. They sell it in a square loaf for $5. I like to eat this bread plain, with cheese, or make a sandwich with it. I also purchased a chocolate croissant (I love me a good chocolate croissant) and it was so flaky, buttery, and filling, very delicious. I warmed it up a bit at home and enjoyed every bite of it. Ive had a coffee from here and it was good, coffee and bread is a great combination. To get here, you have to find street parking as they don't have a parking lot. I usually find a side street to park at that doesn't charge.

    I love grabbing any and all things at Amelias! Their bread, pastries and items for purchase on the…read moreshelves and in the coolers are always fun finds too! Im always greeted upon entering with a smile too, so I cant help feel like its visiting an old friend! I love the vibe of the store, the esthetics of the in and outdoor are lovely too! I admire old architecture!

    Photos
    The name on everyone's lips is kouign amann.
    The name on everyone's lips is kouign amann.
    Fresh apples
    Fresh apples
    Cookies!!

    See all

    Cookies!!

    The Cakehole - cupcakes - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...