Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Watch Hill Inn

    5.0 (1 review)

    Watch Hill Inn Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Watch Hill Inn

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Italian 1,727 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Casa Della Luce

    Casa Della Luce

    4.0
    (201 reviews)
    4.2 mi
    $$

    This pizza spot has been my family's go-to since I was in high school, and coming back home for a…read morevisit meant we had to order from here. The nostalgia was real, and I was hoping the food would still taste like it used to -- and it totally delivered. We got a large Meat Mania pizza, a small buffalo chicken pizza, and 6 garlic knots. The Meat Mania was packed with all the classic meats and had a great ratio of toppings to cheese. The buffalo chicken pizza had a nice balance of spice and tang -- not overwhelming, just right. The garlic knots were more on the well-done side this time, so they were a bit chewy and harder to tear apart than usual, but they still had a rich buttery garlic flavor that paired really well with the pizza. I wouldn't say they were perfect this time, but I still enjoyed them. Everything tasted just like I remembered -- the kind of comfort food that hits different when you haven't had it in years. If they keep up this level of quality, I'll keep coming back every time I visit home.

    Out for a "Sunday ride" and decided we wanted to give Casa Della Luce another try. We had garlic…read moreknots, hubby had a side Caesar salad, and we had a spinach and artichoke pizza, with ricotta and mozzarella cheese. Last time we were here, we left disappointed. This time, we left happy, and full! Garlic knots with marinara, on point! My husband enjoyed his Caesar salad with house made dressing. And the pizza was delicious! The spinach and artichokes had just enough flavor not to be bland. The ricotta was a nice layer - not thick- and flavorful. The crust was light and airy, just enough crunch. Maybe it could have used a drizzle of olive oil after cooking, but it was still very good. Our server, Cassie, has been there for a long time, and was right on top of everything. It was slow... Mid Sunday afternoon, but we know they can get busy. There is a large parking lot, as well as outdoor seating. If new to the area, you could miss it... The plaza sign is covered with overgrowth, so watch closely!!

    Photos
    Front
    Front
    House made Cavattelli, Sausage, Broccoli Rabe, Aglio e Olio. Excellent dish.
    House made Cavattelli, Sausage, Broccoli Rabe, Aglio e Olio. Excellent dish.
    Banfi Cabernet Sauvignon,  Sangiovese blend

    See all

    Banfi Cabernet Sauvignon, Sangiovese blend
    Longo Ristorante & Pizzeria

    Longo Ristorante & Pizzeria

    3.7
    (108 reviews)
    5.0 mi
    $$

    Really cute place with outdoor seating, small parking lot, and on street parking. Definitely…read moreshould have a reservation, which we did, but there were empty tables all around us, even though we were told they were booked solid when we tried to change the reservation time. Service was great. Our server was really attentive, with 4 - 5 tables pretty much seated within minutes of of us getting seated. I tried a Longo Cosmo. Not really my thing, but it was good. The espresso martini was better! We had drinks, an app, dinner and dessert! Rolling out of there is an understatement! And it was all super delicious. I had chicken francais, aone friend had the carbonara and the other had chicken caprese. We did start with calamari , which were delicious, super light and crunchy. Gelato and a chocolate mousse cake were delicious dessert choices. Sorry, forgot the dessert pics! Quality is what we had here, for the prices, I would have expected nothing less. I would come back here again to try the pizza so many have raved about. But the dinners looked so good, we went with our own meals.

    The meatballs are absolutely wonderful, and the service is great…read more However, you get more meatballs in the appetizer than you do when the spaghetti and meatball dish-ugh. The chicken francaise was meh. The ambience was fantastic, and, it was packed and the place is very clean.

    Photos
    Longo Ristorante & Pizzeria
    Gnocchi Sorrentina
    Gnocchi Sorrentina
    Strawberry swing with muddled strawberries and basil

    See all

    Strawberry swing with muddled strawberries and basil
    Andiamo

    Andiamo

    4.3
    (181 reviews)
    6.9 mi

    I got a Veal Piccata ($34) and it came out in about 15 mins. The sauce was creamy and lemony!…read morePasta was good and so was the veal. Great portion size, enough to fill you up and then some. The service was good, staff were nice and ambiance was chill. I enjoyed the meal here and would come back. Food(50%): 7.7 Staff/service(25%): 7.5 Value(25%): 7.0 Overall: 7.5/10

    I had high hopes for Andiamo, but sadly was extremely disappointed. I am new to the Mystic area and…read moreseeing that this restaurant rated so highly I was excited to order some takeout with my daughter after moving some things into our new apartment. Ordering was very easy online, even though the prices seemed a bit high. We ordered $109 worth of food...Arancini ($16), garlic bread with cheese($16), Penne al Vodka with sautéed chicken($32), and the Alfredo with chicken cutlet($38). I was expecting a lot for prices like these. The Arancini were 5 pieces the size of golf balls and the flavor was ok, not worth $16, out garlic bread with cheese ($16) was left out of our order, the penne vodka with sautéed chicken ($32) was dry and there were 5 small pieces of chicken, and the baked penne chicken Alfredo had broken sauce, full of grease and almost inedible...I threw out most of it. I expected so much more from this establishment. The parking lot was packed and parking just to get takeout was challenging, but the food and prices were amazingly disappointing. We may try their pizza to see if that is any better, but I would not recommend the pasta dishes. I can see charging g prices like that if the pasta was homemade, but even that is a stretch. 3 stars is generous

    Photos
    Andiamo
    Baked Penne Chicken Alfredo
FRIED CHICKEN CUTLET,
MUSHROOMS, MOZZARELLA
    Baked Penne Chicken Alfredo FRIED CHICKEN CUTLET, MUSHROOMS, MOZZARELLA
    "Belly up to the bar" never looked so good

    See all

    "Belly up to the bar" never looked so good
    Trattoria Amalfi

    Trattoria Amalfi

    4.1
    (160 reviews)
    6.7 mi

    This was one of the stops on a bus trip that I recently took. It's right off Coogan Blvd in the…read moreMystic Knotwork area. I Absolutely loved the aesthetic of this restaurant! The decor is gorgeous, blending Mediterranean-inspired blue tiling with warm mustard seating and rustic wood accents. The lighting is soft and inviting, and the layout feels spacious yet intimate. It's a beautifully designed space that sets the perfect mood for a great meal. The bar area is beautiful and full of character! I love the mix of the rustic whitewashed wood front and the intricate tile work. The tiered ice display filled with Limoncello and fresh lemons adds such a fun, refreshing touch, and the giant floral centerpiece is stunning. It's a bright, lively spot that's perfect for grabbing a drink. If you prefer dining al fresco, there's a patio and the porch space has a fantastic atmosphere. It feels bright and cheerful thanks to the lively pink flower baskets and the bold blue outdoor furniture. Because the deck is fully covered, you get plenty of shade while still being right next to the walkway. It's a very cute, well-maintained exterior that adds to the overall appeal of the place. The service here is awesome! Our waitress was incredibly sweet and hospitable, and she completely understood that we were on a tight schedule with a bus tour. She did an amazing job of being attentive and accommodating without ever making us feel rushed. The food rolled out in perfectly timed layers, and she even offered to refresh our drinks before we could even ask. I initially thought the garlic bread was a bit pricey but was totally worth $12. The focaccia bread was nicely toasted and seasoned with herb butter and four cheese fonduta. Next was the fried calamari with cherry and banana peppers. The calamari was delicious, seasoned perfectly and was a combination of rings and tentacles. Those who enjoy banana peppers might enjoy that they are lightly fried too resemble the calamari, however I'm not the biggest fan and probably should have asked them to hold them. With them being breaded the same as the calamari is difficult to tell them a part so when your taste buds are gearing up for a bite of calamari and instead you bite into a pepper or can be slightly disappointing. For $19 I would prefer more calamari and less peppers. The salads are very good here too. The Roasted Garlic Caesar features a classic Caesar dressing enhanced with a bright hint of lemon and topped with crunchy breadcrumbs. I added salmon as my protein choice, which was cooked beautifully and paired perfectly with the savory, garlicky flavor profile of the salad. This made for a filling and flavorful meal. Tagliatelle - Outstanding homemade pasta and sauce. The tender, shredded short rib ragu is perfectly tossed with fresh noodles. It has an ideal noodle-to-sauce ratio and avoids being overly rich or heavy. A deeply comforting, cohesive dish topped beautifully with parmigiana. Also enjoyed the lobster roll which was served warm with butter on a perfectly toasted brioche bun, accompanied by a side of fries. The rich, melted butter beautifully complemented the sweet lobster meat, and the brioche added a wonderful touch of sweetness and crunch. Really glad that my bus tour stopped here. I'll definitely return and highly recommend!

    This was my second time visiting this restaurant, and unfortunately, I'm still not impressed with…read morethe food. It could have been seasoned much better, and I'd give it a 4 out of 10. While the atmosphere was great, the food simply didn't meet my expectations either time I've visited. The service from Trinity tonight was amazing! She was very knowledgeable, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed throughout our meal. She truly made the experience enjoyable. The outstanding service and welcoming atmosphere are the reasons I would consider coming back, but the kitchen definitely has room for improvement.

    Photos
    Sicilian Mule
    Sicilian Mule
    Octopus
    Octopus
    Outside front of restaurant

    See all

    Outside front of restaurant

    Watch Hill Inn - italian - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...