Best Restaurant! Food is Amazing! Drinks are Delicious! Awesome Service! Love This Place!

Third time visiting. First time, ok. Second time, nah. Third time, never again. Service, very slow. Food, very bland. Nope. Done. read more

Most of our meals were good. The second time my husband ordered the pork chops and the were overcooked. They use to be so delicious!

We have been here a lot at least once a year when we do our annual Mystic trip for the last 5 years. Sadly this has gone downhill each of the last couple of visits. I don't like leaving bad reviews but this one is deserved. First of all the food is amazing but their "summer" menu seems far more limited than the non-summer menu. After being in Italy a few weeks ago this place is on par with many of the meals over there. It definitely has become drinks are fast to come out but food is slow. This has been true the last 2 times both in August. We had to ask our waitress for several things multiple times. It was a running joke that we asked for more bread 3x, butter 2x, another glass of wine 1x, and a side of sauce for the kids meal 1x. None of these ever showed up except for the wine. Then she disappeared for 20 minutes and never asked about our meals. Also, the kicker is one of the previous pics from 5 years ago is from the penne vodka with added chicken. We asked to add chicken again and for $9 we got one tiny thin cutlet which doesn't even compare. We love coming to this area but it might be our last time since there are so many good places. One other thought is when we first came in 2021 there was an older gentleman offering ice cream to all the kids. My kids loved it and always wanted to come back. It was great since they didn't charge us. Fast forward to 2026 and there was no ice cream in the building. We also heard the same guy arguing with another table that it took an hour for their food to come out and asked was it at least good lol. read more

See all

Very nice date night restaurant! We've sat inside and outside here and both were very nice. Service and the food have both been great. Drinks were also very good. read more

Hoofs Restaurant - Chicken Parmesan - Italian Near Me - Pawcatuck, Connecticut

See all

The bruschetta I had last night was the best I've ever had. How were those tomatoes sooooo good? Maybe it's because it's peak tomato season? Idk but they were like candy. And I'm very picky about tomatoes. The jammy balsamic was to die for, and the bread. THAT bread speaks to you. So fresh. Really couldn't believe how good that bruschetta was.. mmm mmm MMMM! read more

Great food coupled with attentive service. I highly recommend Hoofs. The Attis also charming.

I was in the area for the day and searching for dinner options brought me to Hoof's in Pawcatuck. The ambiance is elevated above casual but not stuffy or exclusionary. I was in there a short time after opening and my waitress was fantastic. I will say the bar staff were a little sweary amongst themselves which could be heard when I wasn't even seated at the bar. They serve warm bread and hummus to start the meal which was great. Im not a hummus person so I used the table olive oil with some fresh grated parmesan instead. The meatballs were amazing. The veal cutlet was ok. The sauce is good. Pasta is served tossed in the sauce rather than just placed on top. I eat a lot of red sauce italian and the food leans roughly middle of the road for me BUT the total experience brought it to 4 stars. I would definitely return and will check out some other dishes. The pictures of the bolognese look amazing. read more

Hoofs Restaurant - Veal parm, ordered with no cheese and adding only a light amount of parm when served. - Italian Near Me - Pawcatuck, Connecticut

See all

Went to visit our son who lives in Pawcatuck and he recommended that the 3 of us dine at Hoofs. He was spot on! Food was excellent and our server Steve was great. Attentive and friendly. Everyone enjoyed their meals. Highly recommend dining at Hoofs. read more

Had a lovely meal here while visiting friends in town. Our friends, who eat here frequently, recommended seafood. I had the scallops and risotto special. It was delicious and the scallops were so tender! We shared a sticky toffee cake for dessert which was yummy. read more

See all

Love it here food is amazing atmosphere is dark and cozy. Ordered spicy rigatoni in vodka sauce and added sausage chefs kiss

There are so many things I love about this place. It's clean, upbeat, and the service is prompt. Our servers name was Sam. Clean cut young man, very proper which is so appreciated these days. We sat outside on the patio because it was booked solid and I was really craving the food here. It's pretty noisy with the traffic and the trains, but it's a small price to pay for perfection. We had the lobster nachos for an appeteaser, YUMMMM! I had the surf and turf pasta. It was great. My son had grilled chicken and mashed potots, the wifey had a white truffle pasta with grilled chicken. The food was great. I hate to reiterate this but, the traffic noise is obnoxious. It really took focus away from the experience. Other than that, it was a pleasure. read more

Hoofs Restaurant - Strawberry basil margarita - Italian Near Me - Pawcatuck, Connecticut

Great food. great service. 100% great vibes. Real Italian vibes. Will definitely be back

The perfect date night dinner, every time! Reasonably priced, masterfully prepared food, and meticulous service (without feeling overwhelming!). Their bread and roasted red pepper hummus is drool-worthy. I'm a big fan of anything served with their house pomodoro. read more

Hoofs Restaurant - Joe with menu - Italian Near Me - Pawcatuck, Connecticut

Some of the best pasta I've ever had. Place is super nice, seating is spacious and comfy, and service was good! Our waiter was nice and kept bringing us some of their delicious bread. I had the rigatoni and meatballs and they were *chef's kiss.* read more

Hoofs Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Pawcatuck, Connecticut

See all

Being a creature of habit last night I had Hoofs Pork Chop which is always delicious . unfortunately management have decided to reduce the 1 1/2"-2" chop to 3/4" . Why ? Very disappointing ! read more

Why did I detect some arrogance in the staff? I am an ordinary person just trying to have an ordinary nonalcoholic drink at the bar. I am not a demanding customer and I don't drink alcohol, so my perception of events and attitudes was not askew. I tried to speak to the manager, but management apparently had no interest in speaking to me. Very noisy environment, but it was a night to be with family and friends and celebrate. I'll give them this one. Menu items seemed overpriced, but again I decided not to eat. I cannot comment on food quality, but I can comment on service. And I am doing so right now. FYI...tipping is never automatic. I decide what I want to tip, and you have no right to round up to the next whole dollar because you don't have the change on hand. Is this a special occasion restaurant only? If so, I'll go elsewhere. read more

Amazing dinner tonight at Hoof's!!! We had the Bone-in Veal Chop, it was HUGE, tender and simply scrumptious. The Caprese salad with tomatoes that were red, ripe and delicious. The cheesecake was the BEST we've ever had!!! Our was waitress was Maddie and she was a breath of fresh air. The atmosphere, food, drinks and service were all top-notch...can't wait to go again!!! read more

Okay, we've been looking for a new high quality Mediterranean place that has other things as well. Hoofs Restaurant on the Pawcatuck/Westerly line (I prefer to think of it as Westerly) nailed it. With outstanding service, a great, lively vibe (without being obnoxious) and incredible food, we had an amazing 39th birthday dinner for my wife. (We had a 39th birthday for her over a decade ago as well...., hmmm). Our server Beth was generous with her time, gave outstanding dining suggestions, was intimately familiar with the menu and ingredients, and was very nice and hospitable! Thanks Beth!!! We started off with an appetizer to share, it was a filet mignon carpaccio, which is a thinly sliced, almost tartare consistency on a delicious bed of fresh arugula (In February, nice touch), topped with romano crumble and bits of crispy prosciutto. I could've eaten just that for dinner but I wanted the pork chop that my buddy told me I HAD to go to Hoofs for. So clearly I had the pork chop calabrese plate, which blew everything you've ever thought about a pork chop away. Moist, tender, flavorful and definitely filling. Served with spinach, peppers, sun-dried tomatoes and thick, super flavorful slices of tender, fried potato, it filled me up, and that's hard to do. My wife had the salmon piccata which was one of the nightly specials, and she, who NEVER finishes her whole dinner, loved it so much she "ate through the pain" as I recommended and killed it! Her dish came with some light/fluffy mashed potatoes that were lightly seasoned and delicious. She also had the arugula salad which includes pears, red onion, shaved fennel and goat cheese (gross...sorry, my opinion, she and many others love it, haha) Closing out the night we had a delicious piece of authentic Key Lime pie with an Oreo crumble crust. Beth even jazzed it up for my wife's birthday and added a candle and even got me to sing Happy Birthday to my beautiful wife. Perfect night, perfect meal, our new go-to, special event place. As a comparison, we went to a highly advertised/recently opened place in one of the casinos recently, paid DOUBLE what it cost us for a better, more delicious and enjoyable meal at Hoofs. read more

Hoofs Restaurant - Pork Chop Calabrese from Hoofs - Italian Near Me - Pawcatuck, Connecticut

What a fantastic restaurant! Perfection! Menu is amazing and the food is even better! Drinks are mixed flawlessly. Fun atmosphere, great bar area with large screen TVs. And, parking! Just across the Pawcatuck River from downtown westerly. We love Longo's, Guytannos, and Ella's, but Hoofs hits on all cylinders. read more

Always a pleasure. The service is great. They really know how to treat their customers. The food is delicious. You can tell that it is fresh and not over done. Been there a few times and have enjoyed the experience each time. read more

Never had a worst experience at a restaurant before. Waited 1.5 hours if not longer for food and the owner couldn't even give us an answer as to when our food would be coming out. We ended up leaving, not even getting served our food. Waitress was forgiving and equally as pissed off due to shitty management. read more

Terrible ... Will never go back...They should take the steak off the menu. We were a party of eight seated at a table that should have been for six max. read more

I found this gem earlier this year, and I honestly can't stop going back. I love going out to eat, but Hoofs has quickly become my absolute favorite spot in the area. The food is incredible every single time--the Linguine alla Vongole and Rigatoni alla Vodka are hands-down the best I've ever had. The drinks are amazing too, especially the sangria! The atmosphere is fantastic and welcoming, and the service is always exceptional. Every visit feels like a great experience from start to finish. If you're looking for amazing food, great drinks, and a place you'll want to return to over and over again, Hoofs is it! read more

What an amazing meal we just had at Hoofs! the pan-seared scallop special was delicious, with a lobster and asparagus risotto which was to die for! Another in our party had the very hearty Bolognese which he raved about. The mussels, clams, and fried calamari were also devoured by our party. Our server Colleen was top-notch, and we never wanted for anything. What an amazing restaurant! We will definitely be back! read more

Hoofs Restaurant - Pan seared scallops with a hearty serving of lobster and asparagus risotto. - Italian Near Me - Pawcatuck, Connecticut

It was the second time I gave them a chance. The first time, I found it impersonal and the food bland. I've never tasted Rabe, which had no character. The last time I had the franchise, the chicken was tough and dry. I could have said something, but I shouldn't have to for $25 Entree. The server was pleasant, and the bartender made a fine, dirty martini. read more

As locals we've been to Hoofs many times and had good meals and service. Our dinner yesterday was not very good. Hard, dry rigatoni and chicken picatta that was tough as nails. Not sure if there's a new chef or just one of those off nights in the kitchen. read more

A busy noisy Italian restaurant on a Friday night. While someone screwed up the reservation, we we lucky to get a seat. The clams oreganato were good as an appetizer and the salmon and the pork chop was big and moist. Hoofs is a good place to go for veal and pork, so that was no surprise. Service was a bit slow but I attributed that to how busy they were. Reasonable wine list. Not a bad place to go if your in the mood for Italian. read more

Very nice restaurant located in the downtown area. What I liked: Very attentive service. We had a reservation and were seated promptly. The team service was great as they had dedicated staff serving bread, water, and serving your food as it came up. The server was able to focus on us. The food: The prime rib was excellent and my wife ordered shrimp over risotto (exchanged shrimp for scallops with no issue). She also ordered a shrimp cocktail and raved about the cocktail sauce. The cocktails and wine list. Cocktails were very creative and the wine list was extensive by th glass and bottle. My only disappointment was the oysters I ordered. They were so small I worried I might be breaking the law eating them rather that letting them grow for a year . Parking is available around the building and on the street if the lot is full. read more

My friend and I scored a table outside on a busy Saturday night.. thankfully because the inside was so smokey. Their cocktails are strong (as they should be for $14) and decent. They cooked my filet mignon perfectly, just as I asked (medium rare). The food was terrific. Would love to dine here again. read more

Hoofs Restaurant - French martini (front), chocolate raspberry cocktail (background) - Italian Near Me - Pawcatuck, Connecticut

See all

Very elegant and amazing atmosphere. Service was impeccable and everyone was very nice. Owner came over and talked to me & asked how's things going. The lobster bruschetta was amazing with a crunchy bite. & succulent bites of tender lobster. Jumbo cocktail shrimp with some homemade cocktail sauce with horseradish. & talk about entrees omg the scallops were so tender plump & the creamy polenta. So spot on and the rib eye juicy and cooked just right with fresh green vegetables. read more

See all

We were a bunch of hungry musicians looking for a late dinner after a concert nearby. I had made a reservation for the group for outside on Open Table, but the remnants of Hurricane Ida had other plans. We called to see if we could get a table separate from the main dining room. When we arrived everything was all set up and to the side as requested. Even though they had officially closed, they continued to take our orders without seeming to rush our very chatty bunch. The COVID protocols on their website state that they try to limit parties to 90 minutes, and previous reviews have mentioned feeling rushed, but the only sign of them keeping us in a time limit was how eerily fast the food came out and how quickly dirty plates disappeared and how quickly drink refills came out. Completely welcome when it's late and you are hungry!! Service- 5+ stars. The food: why the place is called "Hoofs" I have no idea. The cuisine is Italian and perfectly executed (though when the server announced the "hoof salad" I did half expect to see a equine foot on top of the greens). Lobster risotto with scallops was right up there with another one of my all time favorite risottos (one in Italy and one in Iceland). The fresh pappardelle was perfection. Our bass player who is a huge foodie, went old school and got the chicken parm and we didn't hear a peep out of him the whole time but for the nom nom sounds coming from his end. Top that off with dollar Bluepoint oysters ("dollah oystahs" as they say across the river in Rhode Island) and it was a magical evening despite the raging storm outside. We will come back to Pawcatuck for our Italian fix from on. 5 million stars. read more

Hoofs Restaurant - Blurry Rabe - Italian Near Me - Pawcatuck, Connecticut

See all

Nice upscale Italian restaurant environment. Although we didn't have reservations, we were able to get a spot at the bar. The bar tender was very attentive, even though super busy and everything we had was delicious. We started with a burrata salad - tomatoes, pickled onion, balsamic vinegar and burrata. So delicious. I had the white truffle mushroom Alfredo fettuccine, the Alfredo was not too rich and the pasta was Al Dente, both to my preference. It was fantastic. My partner had chicken Marsala. The sauce was rich and Betty and intense with perfectly mashed potatoes. We topped it off with Key Lime Pie and Ice Cream. The Key Lime Pie had an Oreo crust, which isn't quite as good as Graham cracker crust. The Ice Cream was creamy and homemade. The menu was wide and varied, everything around us seemed equally as delicious. For a treat head here. read more

A go-to if you're visiting the area or live there. this space has been a few different restaurants and this is by far the best! The restaurant was packed with people. 100% recommend making a reservation. We started with the mussels. Plenty for 3 people and the broth was flavorful. I had the shrimp scampi. There was plenty of large, fresh shrimp and the Pasta was delicious. Another person at the table had the scallops with lobster risotto. The picture speaks for itself- so good! Highly recommend. Such a great restaurant in the pawcatuck/ westerly area! read more

See all

We ate there for the first time and our meals were fantastic. We had the Hoofs pasta, Chicken Parm , and the pork chop. We would order turn again and again. The service was good and the bib is great. read more

Food excellent, service attentive and prompt, ambiance pleasant if not a bit loud. Prices a bit high but commensurate with quality of food. read more

Although I've been to a lot of Italian restaurants, I can say by far that Hoofs really knows how to provide great food and service. Just from the environment when you walk In seeing wait staff pouring water to the clean glasses and folded napkins. If you're looking for a great pasta dish both the rigatoni and white truffle are delicious. Overall will be back to try more options! read more

See all

Had another phenominal evening a hoofs. Best italian restaurant in town! Bottle of persecco Calamari appetizer Scallops over crab risotto Chicken parmesan read more

See all

I don't know how many times I've driven past hoofs and thought absolutely nothing of it. I'm pretty sure that the location threw me off, as it has seemed to change hands quite a few times over the years. On a whim we opted to stop in for a drink and an appetizer....Upon arriving I was taken at back by how busy it was, so busy there was not a single bar seat. By a stroke of luck there was 1 two top table in the bar area. At this point we had to see what the heck was going on in there. Was it happy hour specials, Sunday dinner specials??? Much to our surprise we were greeted by the absolute friendliest most personable host I think in the entire town (Patrick), and we just new we had to stay for more then an app. I have to say the entire dining experience was top notch and if I could give more than a 5 star rating I would. The pricing was more than we anticipated, but that's par for the course in 2022. The steaks are cooked to perfect, and can be paired with a great cocktail or wine as well!! Very nice desert options like an amaretto cake if your into desert(whose not) All in all if your looking for a really nice local dining experience and ok with spending some money to do it, then HOOFs it is!!! Cheers read more

Hoofs was one of our go-to restaurants in the Westerly/Stonington area. Our last visit was not so good. First of all, our server did a very good job and our cocktails (martini's) from the bar were also very good. Its what came out of the kitchen that was not-so-good. We started with the tomato salad. The tomato(s)were nothing better than one can find during the off season (greenhouse) vs local and the cheese was plain old mozzarella slices that one could buy in the local grocery store. Nothing special. I think they could've done better. Both my wife and I had chicken dishes for entrées. I had the chicken marsala. The 3 small scallopini were dried out and hard. Usually when I get chicken marsala, it is covered in sautéed fresh mushrooms with the wine sauce. There were no mushrooms in this dish. It was sub-par in my opinion. (I've had better at local pizza joints) My wife had a chicken piccata dish, which was also overcooked and dried out. I am not sure what is going on at Hoofs but appears like many other successful restaurants in the area, complacency has taken hold after a steady clientele has been established. The food coming out of the kitchen simply is not up to their reputation. Maybe this was a one off or maybe this is a pattern that is starting to set in. Time will tell. read more