Great food. The pizza crust is burnt. Just the way I like it! The whole belly clams are phenomenal!

Cool Spot - Great Food As a so called dive bar we stopped in here for great pizza and soup as well. I am a soup lover and they do it very well. a nice lobster roll for the wife and a small pizza for me with soup. I rarely drink beer but I made an exception here and it was good and cold from the tap. This is one of those hidden gem types that has seating with service and it is clean.Some days it is hard to find a close place to park on the street but on a nice day or night it is no big deal. It is a small town. There is a large lot across the street. I like the way the pizza crust is crunchy and they do not skimp on the toppings. A real nice place to stop and it is worth a trip, clean with good service. Tip: They always have great list of menu meal specials, but their Bahhhh pizza is very good. Just an overall great place to stop in and have good meal and cold drink at a reasonable price. Thanks read more

Hilltop Cafe - A pizza on a stand is positioned on a restaurant counter, with plates, utensils, and drinks visible, and diners seated in the background. - Pizza Near Me - Westerly, Rhode Island

Amazing pizza! Expect to wait at this popular local spot. Service is great-Justine and Nicole are great.

Maggie was a great server and the Pizza is the best bar pies by far maybe in the whole state .Fum local and a Hugh menu of very good plates.

An overpriced dive. $14 drinks, $19 bar pizza in a filthy setting...skip it. We only went because David Portnoy gave the pizza a high rating. Not worth it. read more

We needed to find a venue for a funeral reception which means we had no idea how many people might be coming and very little time to prepare. From our first contact with Dave, we were impressed by Hilltop and what they offered for an event like this. They have a separate room for events and setup a buffet which was convenient. Because it was on a week day, they allowed overflow to sit in the main restaurant area which was a relief to us when you don't know the size of the crowd. Dave and his staff were extremely friendly and helpful making it very easy on us. The food was delicious and very reasonably priced. Our crowd raved about the food, buffet selection and the service. And parking in the big (free) parking lot across the street. I would definitely recommend Hilltop Cafe for other events. read more

When we stepped in, we weren't sure what kind of place we'd found but we're thoroughly impressed with the place. Pizza was excellent and the waitress was very personable. Over all, excellent for a casual meal. read more

I am newer to the area. I was told that the Hilltop was a goto place for pizza. I tried it twice. The first time was ok. Thick crust, not my preference. Generous portion of toppings. Nothing to rave about but I thought that I would try it again. The second time was not very good at all. Too much on the toppings. Pizza was supposed to be three toppings each half. Very doughy and greasy. An obscene amount of grease. Sauce? I saw something red but didn't taste any. I will keep looking.... read more

Hilltop Cafe - a half eaten pizza in a pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Westerly, Rhode Island

This long time, local establishment, where everybody knows your name is quite a throwback. Good food, imaginative food, and you are guaranteed to be taking away a portion for your lunch tomorrow. Very nice staff and curious surroundings. read more

Perfect pizza every time. I live in Griswold CT and travel to get this perfect pizza!!

A great local place with lots of character! Nice tap selection, cheesy pepperoni pizza, yummy soupy sandwich, & the server (who also handled the bar) was very friendly. Definitely not a tourist trap & well worth a visit! read more

No matter what we order it's delicious! Live the fish and chips and veal and peppers with Italian bread to dunk! Great servuce also

Tried coming in today a Sunday at 1pm and the hours online say they're open 12-3 but the doors were locked. If you're not going to be open for business you need to post it on the site otherwise follow your site and actually open the doors smh pretty disappointing for my visit here as I've heard nothing but great things about this place read more

The Hilltop is your basic blue collar neighborhood watering hole that serves good food. Nothing fancy. Stopped in for a quick bite with the wife. Started with a plate of wings. We split the sauces and had both the gin and classic buffalo. Both were spicy and hit the spot. Two thumbs up. For an entree, I had the whole belly clams from the specials board. They were cooked to perfection. For $18.95 they gave me a plate full that I could barely finish. My wife had the baked scallop casserole dish that was loaded with local sea scallops. The were also baked just right and not over done. The Hilltop is a great place for a no frills but great food meal. We will be back. This is one of Westerly's hidden gems that have yet to be raided by tourists. read more

Omg! If you remember and loved Roxy's, Hilltop is for you...order the pizza crispy though to get that little bit of burned edges; otherwise, it's sometimes too cheesy (like that's a bad thing?) resulting in a bit droopy pizza. Had two pizzas cooked a little crispy and BOTH were soooo flavorful! Worth the calories I consumed as I think I ate like 5 pieces...and craved it again the entire next day. read more

Extremely poor service! Downright rude! Don't bother even ordering the food. We didn't.

Order a small ( or large) pizza with everything but fish. Fantastic pie. They put it all on and it is always the most satisfying pizza available. Bacon, sausage, soupy, peppers of all kinds, onions, olives, the whole nine yards and all of it fresh and baked to perfection. I love Pods. read more

My wife and I ordered at the bar. We do visit every couple of months and do takeout. Tonight, we waited for close to an hour for a small pizza and a salad. We still were not served. The bartender checked 3 times after 30 minutes not getting our food. You would think the kitchen would have prioritized our order. No. Multiple people after were served. It may be a while we consider going there. The issue was after the first time the bartender checked, there was no action to ensure we got our food. The bartender handled it as best she could. read more

Absolutely tremendous. We had 6 people at our table, one compliment after another. Whole Belly Clams, possibly the best I ever had!! Bolognese like being in the North end of Boston. Dave, I believe the owner, was very hospitable and welcoming. read more

Best pizza in westerly. Even better when you dine in. Pro tip: Get the small pizza and ask for it well done.

Yummie Sausage & Potatoes, sausage & peppers, and pizza! You will not be disappointed

Sadly - the Bartender decided to add $4.50 to each drink. They are normally $7.50. - She couldn't get a receipt out of the machine so she printed up a separate one - drinks at 12.00 each..... Wow.... Just desperate -........why would anyone eat here??? read more

A classy dive bar in Westerly. Tons of specials every night and ice cold beers on tap. The food is always delicious. Recently had the pods gin wings, which were pretty good and a small soupy pizza, which didn't disappoint! They have started to get local beers and ciders on tap. They have a beer from Beerd and a cider from right down the street tapped apple. read more

Food is typically good at this restaurant. Last few times we went the portion sizes seemed pretty small and the last time I ordered a mixed drink it was $12. Charging venue prices at local bar. I can understand charging a little more for food and drinks due to prices increasing on everything but this seems excessive. read more

I ordered fish and chips 15.00 a plate looked like a child size plate one piece of fish and literally 8 French fries food was cold and very greasy never again.. read more

Pizza is on my top 10 list of foods I could never give up. If I had magic powers I would make it calorie free and gorge on it daily. That being said, I firmly believe there are two types of pizza. You have your healthy, brick oven, veggie filled gourmet pizza and then you have your greasy sloppy cholesterol raising pizza. Hilltop definitely falls into the latter category. I love it! It is so bad for you, but for the days when you just don't care it is pretty good pizza. My parents go there once a month or so for Fish-n-Chips and my father rates them highly. The beer is pretty cheap too. Since you've already thrown your diet to hell by eating their pizza, might as well have a bev. read more

Normally I love this place. That's the only reason it's getting 3 stars. The last 2 times I came here the bartender was horrible. She was more interested in the tv and her cell phone than getting anyone drinks. Today the pizza (which I normally LOVE) came out burnt to a crisp. I couldn't even cut it with a knife. The bartender didn't even ask how it was. As a cook, how could you even send that out? As a bartender, how could you serve that to us? Lesson learned. I won't be back. read more

Hilltop Cafe - Burnt. Yuck - Pizza Near Me - Westerly, Rhode Island

We ate there on the recommendation of our realtor and loved it. Their food was authentic and homemade. The meatballs were excellent. The panini sandwich was delicious and the pizza was great. Also our server was knowledgeable and very personable. We had a really fun time. read more

I typically enjoy ordering pizza from here when I'm in town and being from New York where there's a pizzeria on every corner, I enjoy eating this pizza. But the last couple of times I've been here we have ordered chicken on our pizzas and there has been little to no chicken every time. This isn't something I would typically be complaining about but if I'm spending $50 on two pizzas, I would like to enjoy chicken on it. I don't even spend that much on pizza in NY and it's supposedly more expensive over there than over here. Highly disappointed with these past orders. read more

Food took over an hour to get the waitress was overwhelmed but nice and the food was terrible the gin wings were ok but a small portion for 11$ won't be going back read more

The pizza is the best in town! Great bartenders. Family crowd. My favorite place to grab a bite to eat.

My entire family loves this place! The pizza is dangerously good and the only thing I order (try the vinegar peppers!). But my family swears by the specials, and have eaten everything on the menu. It's a good local spot if you aren't looking for anything fancy. read more

Haven't lived in westerly for a few years but miss this place. All pizzas have tons of cheese and are nicely well done and crispy. Same kitchen as hilltop and no matter what is ordered from there it's usually great. read more

This is the best pizza in R.I. ! A fun place to get great food and a few brewskies ! It's RI's answer to the TV show cheers and small town hospitality !. read more