At the end of the day --the food was hot ---the food was tasty and good --the service was pleasant and relatively fast --so why not a five ? Because we could not give a 4.5. The decor was dated ---gray panel walls and old ceilings. If that stuff doesn't bother you -we would give it a five. Sometimes atmosphere does matter. A quick rip down of the panels and a coat of white paint would freshen the place up and since this is by the beach it would fit right in. The service we experienced was excellent Charlie the waiter was terrific read more

Twin Harbors Restaurant - Seafood bisque - Seafood Near Me - Bayville, New York

See all

Food is horrible I can't even believe I took my family to this place. The inside is so dark the food was so dry I ordered the pork chop my husband order the chicken parm. I have to say the worst food i have ate in my life!!!! The worse part I got a house salad found a bug in it I asked to speak to the owner some short bald guy came up to me drunk and very rude told me if I didn't like this food I can leave. I couldn't believe the disrespect I got from this man. I will never again come to this place so I'm warning all you now. I'm gonna try the restaurant down the road hopefully that place will be better. 0 STARS FROM ME IF I COULD!!! read more

Went for a date night 7:30 on a Sunday knowing restaurants are now eligible to stay open til 11pm, having called ahead just to be sure they were open. Walked in, saw few patrons at the bar but no one in dining area. We thought to eat at the bar, but while we waited to be seated we were repeatedly yelled at by what we thought was a tipsy patron yelling, "we're closed!". We waited until the bartender appeared since nothing else was said and he informed us that it was the OWNER yelling they were closed! Zero conversation. Zero explanation. Zero apologies. RUDEST THING EVER! And we'd eaten there plenty of times for over 30 years!!! Not any more read more

Best burger on Long Island hands down. Great family vibe and never a bad meal. If you are in bayville you must eat here

For appetizers, we got two baked clams which were good, but the international salad was legitimately a house salad with peppers and asparagus.. no added flavor. We waited almost an hour for the main course (2 lobsters and a penne all's vodka with chicken). One of the chicken pieces from the penne alla vodka actually had a piece of metal in it so we weren't charged for the pasta, but the pasta wasn't flavorful either. Service wasn't too good and they could only accommodate 5 tables and even with 8 empty tables (they turned other guests away). It was honestly a pretty ridiculous night. Wouldn't recommend going when it usually would be busy as everyone was very flustered and wasn't done with good quality. read more

The food is no frills, bit it is absolutely amazing. Drinks are perfect, service is plenty and there is never a long wait. It's the perfect local spot. read more

Got takeout from this place, seafood platter broiled and stuffed flounder. Two entrees that were total amateur night 2 shrimp, clams, and scallops , one flounder fillet absolute joke food had little taste and portions were shit. Only buy appetizers stuff that can be fried. Seafood restaurant served by ex Mexican bull fighters. Fried is fried . Many other restaurants too choose from. read more

The food there is AMAZING, but the cheesecake is the best I've ever had...EVER HAD. It's even better than Juniors! Yes, you read that right. I suggest getting steamers too, those were delicious. You really can't go wrong w/ anything they have, but don't miss out on the cheesecake. Oh yeah btw get the cheesecake, its great. In case I was too subtle, TRY THE CHEESECAKE. read more

The seafood here is topnotch! Everything is freshly prepared. Lobster, shrimp, scallops, clams, flounder , steamers, & crabs are always excellent. All entrees come with a nice garden salad & bread basket. Even the vegetables are fresh! The soups & chowders are great too. All the desserts are homemade, so save some room for one. The waitresses are friendly & eager to please. My favorites are any of the fried seafoods. Lightly breaded & fresh. OK, so it all sounds pretty great right? What could be wrong? In one word: DECOR! The place is dark, dreary, dingy, & dated. I think the last time they fixed the place up was 1970. The walls & bar area are dark wood. The dining room has heavy blue drapes covering nonexistant windows. Old dusty nautical decorations. This place needs Robert Irvine from Restaurant Impossible to give them a face lift! I live in Bayville & really like the food. I would go there more often, but there is no atmosphere! So If you want a great meal in an old dreary decor go to Twin Harbors. read more

This is a quaint restaurant off the beaten path in Bayville. The fare is traditional seafood, with a few steak and pasta options. As this is mainly a seafood house, I have always stuck to the fish offerings. However, other people in my party have ordered non-fish items and enjoyed their meals, so go out on a limb if you like. It is worth noting that there is no water view at Twin Harbors. I know a lot of people come to Bayville for waterside dining, so if that's what you're looking for, have drinks with a water view and food here. The dining room is dated, but not in a terrible, or horrible way. The prices do seem expensive at first for the space, but once you receive your meal you will understand why. The portions here are easily enough for 2 meals. Both times I visited, I left with some food to take home. The first time, I had stuffed shrimp, which is pretty standard, but they were memorable. The crab stuffing on top was very good. The second time, I ordered some flounder prepared francaise style over a bed of spinach. Typically, I would not order such a boring fish, but I am a sucker for anything francaise style. The fish filet was nearly the size of the plate, amazing. The quality was fresh and delicious, can't wait until I come back again. read more

Best local restaurant in Bayville! Been coming for years and even though I've moved away, I make sure I can get a bite when I'm in town!

Top notch seafood in a laid back, unpretentious setting, Twin Harbors completely fits in with the Bayville vibe. My shrimp francaise was great, but what blew me away were the oysters. Literally, the best I've had in my life. Huge, plump and juicy, I could have died and gone to heaven right then. I can't wait to go back and sip martinis and have a dozen oysters, then walk back home along the beach. Perhaps, if there was one complaint I could have made, it would be that the decor hasn't been updated in several decades, but frankly, the food's too good to fret about such trivial things. read more

The restaurant is a jewel . Food is fresh and delicious , prices are on point . I highly recommend it, the food here is much better than any other restaurants in the area . Best fish and chips I ever had read more

Love twin Harbors Restaurant. Only been here once but it was amazing. Looking forward to going back again the seafood in this place is so fresh. Took a star off due to the decor being a little old and stale. Still a great place though without a doubt. read more

Ate here for the first time last night. The food was quite good: I had a monk fish special with spinach, my husband had a Fisherman's Platter. Everything had a nice texture and flavor, crisp and lemony. Service was friendly and prompt and the waitress was patient and kind with our wiggly young daughter. Almost all the menu options are seafood, though they do have steak and pasta. The decor and salad dressings are definitely from a bygone-era, but that's not a criticism, just an observation. The one criticism is that the iced tea was awful, tasted dusty like they used cheap tea bags. We will certainly try it again this summer. read more

Stopped here after a day outside because of Yelp reviews. When I pulled into the lot I went to the back of my SUV to change out of my hiking shoes and a waitress came out to tell me I couldn't leave my car there to go riding. We laughed about it when I said I was coming in to eat. Anyway, the food was excellent. The oysters were amazing and I had soft shell crabs, sauteed which were also great. I was envious of the lobster that others were having which is what I had meant to get but SS crabs aren't always available and lobster is.If today wasn't Father's Day I would go back for one of those. I took home a slice of cheesecake which was very good. The dining room could use some brightening up, very dark inside. I was in front of the only windows. Definitely will come again. read more

Wow the best stuffed mushrooms I have ever had they were delicious.... Cesar salad was also on point!!! I highly recommend the chicken lobster Marsala.... read more

This place is great! It has a cozy setting with dimmed lighting & nautical decor. The service is phenomenal. A blonde waitress and young busboy provided us with exceptional service leaving our water glasses full at all times. The food is phenomenal. I especially enjoyed the mussels appetizer. The fisherman's platter (broiled) was also delightful --especially the scallops, which were cooked to perfection. read more

I've been here a bunch of times. Food and service is always excellent. They make a good drink.. read more

Twin Harbors Restaurant - Whisky sour. . Old school. My father's favorite cocktail. - Seafood Near Me - Bayville, New York

Super good food, old school wait staff. For that matter everything here is old school, right down to the knotty pine paneling, but I wouldn't change it this family-owned-for-years place one bit. Very casual, best soft shell crabs ever, all fish dishes are the best. Specials each night are the best choice. Don't forget the home-made banana cream pie-ask for it at the beginning of your meal-made by Dad! read more

I see mixed reviews about this place on this site. But let me tell you, this restaurant is something else. There are a lot of great restaurants on Long Island but at the same time I feel like most of them don't touch the level that this place does. Two words: home cooked. Its not an Italian restaurant but if I could make up the best comparison it'd be that Italian grandmother's amazing meal that you wish you could make yourself. Warming comfort food. I've eaten here quite a few times and I've had anything from a Cheeseburger and Fries to a Swordfish and Lobster Tail special and I have never not been blown away as to how good the food really is. Totally unique and stands out among other restaurants around. Need I say the owner of the restaurant is also the head chef? Twin Harbors has been around a long time and does not need this review to prove itself but I do not play games when it comes to my food and I felt the need to leave this right here. Enjoy. read more

Our group of four, plus baby had unsuccessfully tried to find parking in Oyster Bay for the oyster festival and we were hungry and tired of being in the car. Yelp brought us to the nearby Twin Harbors, and while it wasn't a terrible experience by any means, I think Yelp missed the mark here. First, I take issue with the 2-dollar sign rating. Maybe it's comparative for Bayville, but $19.95 for fish and chips is a little steep for me. The food was okay, but I thought it would be better at that price point. I ordered the special baked clams with red pepper and mozzarella cheese, along with seafood bisque and Cesar salad. The bisque was the highlight: a lot of chunks of seafood including lobster, but the clams would have been better without the extras. My husband's fish was mediocre, but the fries were pretty tasty. Unfortunately, the service was lacking. We were one of two tables at 4:00 on a Sunday afternoon, and the bus girl only came to refill our water glasses once during our whole meal. Not cool. The waitress wasn't much better. After offering us drinks, my husband asked what they had on tap. She responded, "Nothing," and gave him a blank stare. Perhaps she could have suggested a cocktail, or let him know if they had any bottled beers, but she missed the opportunity for a larger check, as we all just stuck with our scant amounts of water. Finally, as others have mentioned, the decor is just dismal, making the price of the food seem like even more of a slap on the face. I didn't hate it, but I don't think I'll be back. read more

My wife got stuffed shrimp, I got the breaded pork chops. Both of use really liked our food. Seasoning could have been used a little more; the food, while very satisfying and comforting, needed a little "pizazz". I'm thinking the mostly older patrons we saw here liked their food on the bland side. Also, the place had a 70's look about it and needs a facelift. Again, overall the food was very good but needs a little "oomph". read more

First time here. Service was good and very pleasant staff. Very old school atmosphere which made it feel cozy. Food was average, and prices were very reasonable. I would come back for drinks and lunch next time. read more

I'm actually appalled to read the ratings from other folks (presumably locals) who claim that the food here is fresh. Frankly, I don't even know where to start. First, the place is dark, dreary, and is in dire need of renovations. Some better interior lighting would really liven up the mood of this otherwise mediocre restaurant. I came here with my family, and frankly, I was so embarrassed to have brought my family here because the quality of the food is atrocious. My biggest disappointment came with the stuffed mushrooms and stuffed shrimp that I had. Both had the same exact crab meat stuffing, which was nothing more than store-bought, cheap, inferior quality crab salad that has been over-saturated with mayonnaise and carrots. For crying out loud, the restaurant is a stone's throw away from the ocean. Bayville is a seafood haven. How could you NOT have fresh crab meat on your menu? Pulling a wool over customers' eyes and telling them that their crab meat concoction is good is as sacrilegious as saying that serving Domino's pizza in an authentic Italian pizzeria in Italy is good. Aside from the atrocious crab meat stuffing, my baked potato was dry as sand and the veggies were nothing more than Green Giant straight out the package. I was hoping for a great meal, but was severely disappointed. Looks like this will be my first and last time at Twin Harbors. read more

The food tasted like an out of work middle school cafeteria worker made it. Enough said....

If you can get past the expectation that comes with a very unassuming and dated establishment and thick utilitarian cafeteria-style china, you will be pleasantly surprised to find very good quality food along with charming service. We had delicious sautéed scallops and melted cheese-topped stuffed shrimp, where the stuffing was crab (or faux crab, couldn't tell) and veggies, which wasn't dominated by breading. If we find ourselves in Bayville again, we'll be back for dinner for sure. read more

Have eatin several times nothung but good food. Great service always busy n the wait isnt bad at all. There atmosphere is very homey. Love this place read more

The food is good and prices reasonable at this unassuming seafood restaurant in Bayville. The decor, however, is somewhat dated, and the ambience is that of a rural country inn or diner. Not the place to go if you're looking for pizzaz. Although all the dishes were good and the portions plentiful, the scallops my wife ordered were most memorable. read more

Love this restaurant! Freshest seafood in Bayville and the burgers are terrific as well. Best homemade seafood bisque and the salads are always fresh. Many times we go with friends who are not seafood lovers but they always enjoy their chicken and steak dinners as well. The waitresses are terrific and make the whole meal wonderful. Solid dependable restaurant that we know is a go to for a great meal! read more

This is a cute little local place in the heart of Bayville. The restaurant is dimly lit with a large busy bar area. The atmosphere is what you would expect from a seaside homey restaurant. Don't expect a fine dining experience here in regards to atmosphere. The waitresses were plentiful but it seems they were in a big rush even though the restaurant was not packed. The food took too long to get to us- large gaps of time between courses. . I would say that the food was on the par of a very good diner. The portions were large and the food was very tasty I will say that some of the seafood dishes were excellent such as the steamers some of the best I had ever had and the salad which is included was very good. If your expectations are realistic you will enjoy this place but don't expect to come here and have a fine Oceanside dining experience you will leave disappointe. The prices somewhat reasonable depending on what you order. read more

Went for lunch on Saturday at 12:15 and it was closed. No hours posted, no times on door, no message on phone. Website shows lunch menu. What gives? read more

Love the food and atmosphere whether you eat at the bar or dining room the service is terrific amazing

Amazing service and amazing food. I've been to tons of seafood restaurants and this is simply the absolute best I've eaten at. Also, the price is right and the staff is great all the way down to the valet. Go here for amazing food and service. You won't be disappointed, especially since the prices are great too! read more

The reviews about this restaurant here on Yelp, must be that the owners paid for them, or that the owners themselves and their friends are posting! This has to be one of the WORST places I've ever eaten! Come on, guys! This is in Bayville, right by the water, you can't get fresh fish? The calamari looked like onion rings! you knew they were frozen when you saw the big rings, no head no tails! Really? The so called stuffed mushrooms and stuffed shrimp were stuffed with FAKE crab! SEA LEGS WITH MAYONNAISE! The place was dark and divey, it's really a bar that sobers up the drunks with their food. Their vegetables were bad and the baked potato dry. The two steaks were OK and the soft shelled crabs fried and breaded. I think I got the best dish which were the Fish n Chips. Not bad. The waitress was attentive and friendly and we felt bad so we left her a $40 tip. Not her fault that the food was so bad! The bus girls would just pick up plates without asking if you were done.For 5 people the bill came to $220 w/o tip with NO ALCOHOL!!! Just that food!! Big mistake we made but were desperate because our intention was to go to Walls Wharf where the wait for a table was two hours! I know why! excellent food there. Do not go to Twin Harbors! RUN!! read more

great little place.seems like just a bar but the resturant is excellent .kind of dark inside and not that big but you will enjoy the food and the service.get there early if you can because it gets very crowded read more

My husband and I went here for dinner last month - I just never got around to coming on YELP until now. The food was very good, and the prices were extremely fair. We had such a wonderful experience because of the staff. The owner actually greeted us in the parking lot. What a wonderful guy!!! We love giving our business to deserving family owned restaurants!!! We will absolutely be returning to this restaurant in the future. The owner is humble but the food really is fantastic! The atmosphere is one of family and comfort and happiness! Definitely worth checking out and you will fall in love :) read more

A great little restaurant. The food was good, large portions. Warm bread basket brought to the table once you order. Our party ordered the mussels and baked clams specials for appetizers. Both were delicious. My husband had the fish and chips and I had the stuffed shrimp. Both came with a salad and veggies of the day. We both really enjoyed our entrees. The stuffed shrimp had large pieces of crab, almost a crab salad rather then the typical bread crumb stuffing. Too full for dessert. Prices are reasonable for the amount and quality of food you get. Staff was super friendly and attentive. As for décor, I would say more nautical then dated. We definitely will be going back. read more

A close friend took us there Friday as he remembered it being great. That was not our experience. Although the food was fresh, the two shrimp dishes were overlooked. That in itself is forgivable but he service was another experience. Although we arrived late, about 9:30 on a Friday, we asked before we sat if it was too late. We were told absolutely not and to please come in. Upon seating we noticed we were missing two place settings, we politely asked for them and the waitress came over and handed us a bunch of silverware. She could not be bothered placing them at each persons spot at the table. Upon being served she hovered and came over twice asking us if we were "still working.." Upon completion of our meal the waitress made a statement ,Ike oh you don't want desert do you? We declined. During our meal the valet brought us the car keys and said I've moved your car out front. I'm tired and I'm going home. My friend felt terrible and the closing statement of the evening was Some memories are best left as such. Never again. read more

This is a very clean place with attentive service. Prices are OK. Menu selection is fine, especially for seafood, which is what I was seeking. The pictures on Yelp are accurate. It strikes me as though it's stuck in time though. Not a knock, just a bit dated. Salads are typical, nothing creative though. Fried clams appeared to be from hard shell clams, not the usual steamer variety, so be forewarned. As a lover of fried clams, this is a big red flag but may not be a problem for others. Clams oregano were a bit over cooked so a bit chewy, they may have been previously made and frozen as they lacked that all important juicy brininess seafood lovers crave. Main dish was served with a nice baked potato, but the steamed (although very fresh) carrots and broccoli were again, unimaginative and kind of institutional. I had sautéed soft crabs. Served two, they were delicious but quite small ($25). My son's cheeseburger was pleasantly large and cooked perfectly, served with fries. read more