This is one of our favorite Bee Cave restaurants. We LOVE the italian chopped salad. It's soooooo good. And huge, so it's a good item to share with a pizza. The Mulberry Meatball pizza is one of of our favorites, yum yum and yum! There is a veggie one, and I am forgetting the name right now... but it has arugula on it and it's great! The chicken parmesean, spaghetti and meatballs are also good items. Know before you go: they have some really good lunch specials, and tuesdays they do by one get one pizzas! read more

Tony C's is one of the best restaurants for pizza in Austin if you like REAL pizza! I love the thin crispy crusts and generous toppings. We ordered the Sausage & Pepperoni which was a little greasy, but what do you expect with sausage and pepperoni? I can't wait to go back and try the Goat Cheese & Prosciutto! Reasonable prices & a great staff... Tony C's is a keeper! read more

Emily, the bartender, is fantastic! Drinks don't go empty without her already having asked if you want another. Food orders are put in immediately and accurately. She can talk sports and engages with all customers. Wish she worked more nights! Pizza is wonderful. read more

I think this is the best pizza you can get in Bee Cave/Lakeway area and it is a great place to catch a drink before a movie at the Galleria. They have a little patio but I wish it were larger. They cook their pizza's at a super high temp and the result is pretty impressive. Sometimes the crust can burn, but the pros outweigh the cons. Service has always been good and price is normal. read more

I'm not in love with Tony C's, but it was better than average... I think a 3.5 would be appropriate. We had the sausage and pepperoni pizza, which was good, but not amazing. We also shared the antipasta plate. The cheeses on the plate were yummy, as were the olives, they had these oven roasted tomatoes stuffed with goat cheese! TO DIE FOR... but I'm a fan of all things goat cheese. My friend drank beer and a drank a glass of red. The bottle had clearly been open a while, but it was drinkable. The service was ok, although we weren't given napkins or silverware until we asked. Overall, my friend who picked it really enjoyed it, I'm not sure I would go back. Nothing terrible, but nothing overly wowing (except those goat cheese tomatoes) Not the cheapest pizza around, we had a 12" pie, the antipasta plate, I had two glasses of wine and he had two beers and our tab was $70. read more

As far as Austin-based pizza goes, Tony C's is the best of the best. Great NY-style pies, with a good variety for both veggie and meat lovers. I haven't gone far off of the pizza path here, but my daughter has always been happy with the pasta/meatballs. They have great weekday specials with buy 1, get 1 free pizza deals on Tuesdays, and half priced bottles of wine on Wednesday. A good layout, and very friendly service has always made it a nice dining experience at Tony C's! read more

We've been dining at Tony's for years with a high level of satisfaction. In fact I wrote a 5 star review several years ago and I'm a Tony's C's regular on Yelp. Unfortunately, the pasta dishes I've had the last couple of visits are average at best and last night the ziti was nothing shy of absolute crap. My bad for not immediately sending it back but we were already late for the movie and hadn't eaten all day. I regret not taking a picture of the orange colored sauce.......that's right ORANGE. I worked in an Italian restaurant as a kid in Miami and what I was served last night was disgraceful and should have never come out of the kitchen. Tony's isn't off my dining list but after last night it's position just got much lower. I'll definitely restrict my selections to the pizza from here on out. read more

Wonderful NY style pizza! We loved this place. The service was fast and friendly and food is tasty. The food came to the table in the speed of light, without compromising taste or quality. not too fancy - just a good Pizza place. read more

Our server Parker was amazing - seriously. Buy one pizza get one free Tuesdays - we will be back!

Delicious, consistent pizza. I've had their prosciutto and goat cheese pizza before, with arugula and roasted garlic. It is to-die-for. Today I went back for my standard pepperoni and roasted garlic to give Tony C's a real review. Wow. I'm still in heaven... the crust is perfect. Thin and crispy without being cracker-like. The pepperoni is great and the garlic comes generously in whole cloves. Service is always fast and nice. The only thing that takes 1 star away is that the pizza is greasier than necessary. It was dripping with grease and as each slice was picked up it left a pool of grease on your plate. I always get crap for saying that a pizza is too greasy because people say it's SUPPOSED to be greasy. Yes, of course, when you're dealing with melted cheese and hot pepperoni, grease is a given; however, so much grease that there's pools of grease on top of the pizza as it arrives to your table... a little too much. That's all I'm sayin'. WITH THAT SAID, I'll be back in a heartbeat. I don't mind asking for extra napkins to blot my slices here and there... Yumm... read more

Who doesn't like well done, New York style, Italian Food? The Ziti and the Lasagna Rolls are great, and the Pizza is the best out here in the Lakeway/BeeCave area. Love the Tiramisu and the Gelato is petty awesome. The Caesar is only so so. The service isn't always stellar, but I know how hard it is to find, train and maintained a decent waitstaff. They used to keep more management on the floor. Now I only see one guy in an untucked dress shirt. Not sure what's up w/that... We'll be back, again. ....and again. read more

The service was great. The food was okay. Since it was my first time eating at Tony's I asked the waitress for a recommendation. She advised against the dish I was going to order... I appreciate when servers don't hold back. I ordered the spinach salad with goat cheese. No complaints. My daughter ordered the pizza, which looked like one of those old Sbarro slices warmed up. The garlic knots were bland. Nice ambiance. They have an upstairs, a downstairs, and outdoor eating area. The bar looked decent. I'm not rushing to go back, but I would give it another shot. read more

Chick parm for the win!! Tony C's has the best Chicken Parmesan entree that I have had outside of my kitchen or my Italian mother-in-law's kitchen. This local spot has a cozy environment that makes me feel like I am back in NYC or Chicago and the food is just as good as a homemade experience. I am adicted! read more

One of my favorite places! We go at least once a week for Pizza and we usually go on the weekend so we can enjoy the company of our favorite bartender Emily! We are always greeted with a smile and she has our wine glasses and a bottle of our favorite wine by the time we are in our seats at the bar. We have found many of the entrees and the chopped Italian salad to be delicious. read more

Look! A great place hands down! Managers and staff are great! Emily and Matt are the best hosts I've met. Ever!

Overall its a great place to stop and sit at the bar. The pizza has gotten better (crust is less soggy), but the restaurant is a bar type environment. Noise pollution, and lack of privacy come to mind. However, it may not be bad thing if your in the mood for that type of environment. The service is decent as well. I like to grab a beer, and slice of pizza at the bar just before the movie- read more

I took a trip to visit my mother in law and she picked this place. I'm so glad she did. I'll make thus short and sweet: the service was great, the pitcher of sangria we shared was divine and oh, the margherita pizza. Oh Lord. Such simple ingredients were used and that is the sign of a well made pizza. Their pizzas don't get the respect they deserve with the "fake" parm. Can you imagine if there were freshly grated parm on such a great pizza? Seriously, go there. Try the pizza. Wash it down with sangria and sit outside if the weather is nice enough-the dining room was a tad on the loud side and it was easier to chat with my dinner guest on the patio. Hands down the BEST pizza I have ever had. read more

Mediocre at best. Our actual waiter turned out to be decent, but that was it. The rest of the staff were a total letdown. Grumpy bartender. Food really a waste of money. Bland salad. Pasta bland too. Pizza verrrryy average. Whatever this 'great coal fired 1000 degree oven' was supposed to be, we couldn't taste. read more

I ordered two pizzas and some meatballs online for pick-up. Ordered two hours ahead because they offer that option on their website. They confirmed the order and promised a follow-up e-mail to let me know when my order would be ready for pick-up. They e-mailed 45 minutes before the pick-up time that it would be ready. I arrived exactly, to the minute, at the appointed time. The pizza was cold and soggy, clearly not piping hot from the 1000 degree coal-fired oven they tout. The order was also wrong. A pizza with a clear request for an ingredient to be on only half of the pizza was on the whole pizza. I live roughly 10 minutes from their location, had a hot oven waiting for them. Pizza was still mediocre even after warming it at home. The experience was a disappointment and we won't return. The meatballs were ok, but intensely seasoned with garlic and salt. It might be better if you eat there, but can't personally recommend it for take-out. read more

The pizza here is hands down delicious. Only thing is their service can be extremely slow, even when it's in the middle of the Afternoon. The pizza is worth the wait though. Bonus points for being right next to the movie theater too! read more

Ordered the 'prosciutto with goat's cheese' and it was AWESOME! Haven't had a pizza that good in a long time. Our ticket was missed in the kitchen, but our server Jason was on top of it without us even knowing. Came to our table and offered a free appetizer while we waited a bit longer. The calamari was dee-lish! Pretty impressed with the service, the staff on the patio were all attentive without hovering or being too annoying. read more

Waiting for a long time for the food here, as others are. Wrong food brought.......not good getting things out from the kitchen. Others are like us, in jeopardy or masking a movie. I will review the food later, but for now the wait continues. At least it is not as bad as the ladies next to us who have been here over an hour. BTW....meatballs and a cheesecake ?? Should not take this long. read more

Love this place! Food is really good. Brian is great and the bar feels like " cheers"

Me and my family go here a lot with our new puppy and the food is always great as well as the service but this time we had a server we haven't had yet named michael and he was amazing. He was very attentive and friendly. He was very helpful offering suggestions on food and deals. Definitely a great hire and we are looking forward to coming back to visit him again soon! read more

Stephen Perez, Averi and the entire staff made this the best experience! The atmosphere and food was exceptional and will definitely be back! Highly recommend this restaurant. read more

Raviolis are great, pizza has a smell like old socks. Toss pizza a way better option.

So, what's the big deal with coal-firing? Well, courtesy of Tony C's, I can finally add my name to the list of those who have experienced this particular variety of food porn. Yes, it sounds weird, but coal-firing produces a delicious pizza. We had the Prosciutto and Goat Cheese pizza, which also included fresh mozzarella, arugula, and roasted garlic. WIN. The crust was super thin, yet perfectly crispy thanks to the high-temperature oven. This pie was just bursting with flavor, and went perfectly with the glass of Chianti I also had. I finished it off with a delicious Tiramisu that came in a big latte mug. Nice. The service was good, too. Not lax yet not overbearing, and the guy was pretty cool. The place looks great, too. Price? It's about twice as expensive as Papa John's. It's about 20 times more delicious. Do the math. So, there have to be some cons to this place, right? Not a whole lot, and entirely subjective. It's located in the Bee Caves Galleria, so your level of convenience depends entirely on your proximity to Bee Caves and/or your ability to tolerate upscale whitewashed suburbia (this place is by far the coolest thing I saw here.) It's also quite small, which to me is awesome, but if you've been running one of these soccer-mom breeder colonies with eight rugrats and a hideous minivan, maybe not so much. However, if you just love pizza, I highly recommend that you give this place a try. If it were closer to town, Home Slice would have a battle on its hands. read more

This place is great. It's my favourite restaurant to eat in the Galleria. The atmosphere is chic and quaint. The New York style pizza is perfection. The only gripe I have is the mozarella they serve at this place. This is the reason for 4 stars instead of 5 - DO NOT order the 'fresh' mozarella salad or any pizza with fresh mozarella. The 'fresh' mozarella is comparable to a thick cream cheese that has a strange taste. I did not finish my meal either time when I had ordered menu items with this type of cheese. Other than that, Tony C's rules. Oh, and half price wines on Wednesday!!! YES, PLEASE read more

Went here today for lunch for Mother's Day. Most places had a long wait, but not here! We got a table as soon as we walked in. Our server, Bryan was great! Very personable and no mistakes on our order without writing anything down. Very impressive. Really enjoyed the salad and garlic knots. The bacon wrapped figs were interesting, but not great. Pizza was a little thin, but pretty good. My son thought the Italian beef sandwich was awesome! I'm looking forward to going back. read more

They have done a fantastic job adapting to both covid and the winter storm. The employees continue to (somehow) smile through the struggles going on in the world and keep this place upbeat as well as high quality. Giovanna is an incredible waitress! Thank you!!!! read more

Awful! And terrible service. Tried to get the game on and got attitude because she was busy. I first went to the GM who said give me one minute. 5 minutes later my wife went over and asked again. Ordered a bottle of wine and they changed the channel begrudgingly. Funny, they turned it to the wrong game. I left my cc and paid for wine I didn't drink and went to cafe blue where they know how to use a remote and give service. Great Job Tony! Btw, it was the LSU and Bama game. Doesn't matter who you cheer for it's he biggest game of the year when 2 and 3 play each other and you have every game on but that one. read more

We went to Tony C's on Tuesday evening. It was busy because of the two for one pizza night and we were in time for happy hour. Our waiter Michael W was fabulous! The food was super yummy and we can't wait to return. read more

Had high hopes for this place since it's a cool looking restaurant... but the food is a huge let down. We ordered the Antipasto (which I found out is not a salad... big let down), the chicken parm, and the coal fired Ziti. The food is mediocre at best, it looks nice and is presented well but has as much flavor as a microwave dinner from the frozen isle of H-E-B. The antipasto was alright kind of expensive for what it is, basically some cold cuts and canned veggies on a cutting board. On the bright side, the bread was decent and the water is very wet! read more

We had a great experience at Tony C's. the staff were friendly. The Bianca pizza was delish. Our favorite dish was the buffalo mozzarella. The calamari was fine, but not fantastic. The sangria was just right. Lots of fruit. We'd recently made the mistake of going to the downtown Austin Uncle Julio's, where the hostesses were surly and the food was mediocre, so Tony C's was a pleasant discovery. Definitely going back to Tony C's! read more

The pizza is on point and their Ceasar salad with the homemade dressing rocked! Highly recommend. Great price point too. read more

Tony C's - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bee Cave, Texas

See all

Tried them for the first time recently and had an amazing experience! Great waitress, pizza good -- antipasto app could use bread or garlic knots served with it...but it was brought once we mentioned it. Zeppoli are light and delicious! We'll be back!! read more

I used to like this restaurant but tonight was the final straw. I will never go back. We ordered online two pizzas which seems simple. I was told when I arrived that they made a mistake on one of my pizzas. Twenty minutes later they said my other pizza was given to someone else. I ordered on line at 5:30, I received my order at 7:00. The manager offered me a $25 gift card for their incompetence which I refused. If I was in his shoes I would have worked with the customer to satisfy them, he basically told me to F... off. I assume this post won't see the light of day. Today's world. read more

Delightful place to get great food. Wait staff is friendly. Manager made sure we had everything we needed and seemed genuine. She was great to talk to. read more

Service was super slow even though it wasn't crowded. We had to wait 15 mins for just water!! The pizza was dry & cheese was used sparingly & the server messed up our dessert order & packed it to go & then when I asked for dessert plates, he disappeared again read more

My family and I have been to Tony C's many times over the years. When you walk into the restaurant, the yummy smell of wood Fired pizza hits you! The pizza lives up to its wonderful smell. The staff is always nice and accommodating too! We recently had a party of 10 and they worked to get us in. The fried mozzarella, calamari, pizza, spaghetti and of course the wine selection is highly recommended. read more