I've been coming to casa Mia for years and this place used to be really good one of my favorite…read morepizza places but the quality has definitely declined, one day you can order and the pizzas great the next day it's soggy, overcooked, taste like yesterdays pizza or just slapped in a box like no one cares, hate to hear of the ownership change not seeing a great future with the place especially with the new place on the boardwalk also not a fan of the huge candy section at the counter

This is everything a small, casual family restaurant should be. Incredibly friendly and attentive…read morestaff that is eager to please and make you feel at home in their boisterous Italian kitchen and dining room. To start, we were brought a generous amount of warm, toasty bread that was like the love child of pizza dough and focaccia. There is a lot of variety on the menu, but I opted for seafood - fried calamari appetizer is a nice portion to share, with mild, fresh tasting marinara. And the Seafood Combo is a good mix of jumbo shrimp, mussels, calamari, and a few clams. It is not typically spicy, but I requested fra diavolo style and they gladly obliged. To be honest, the linguine was soft and overcooked for my liking, but the flavor was great, price was reasonable, and portion was big enough to have some leftovers the next day. The sauce combined with the seafood juices may have been even better the next day! Gnocchi w/ pesto was delicious, though a bit too much of the same thing - would be great shared for a family style meal. Most entrees are also served with soup or salad. Didn't try the soup, but salads were a nice option. And they brought us an unexpected order of zeppole to share, which was so kind and nice way to end the meal. With a little restaurant like this in your neighborhood, you may question why you would ever step foot in an Olive Garden, Bertucci's, or similar chain restaurant ever again. Note, there are a few quirks. Water offered in paper disposable cups, and don't expect an itemized receipt. While they do accept credit cards, they offer discounts for cash payment.

They are really nice here and treat their customers well. I have catered food here for parties…read moreseveral times and it is always great and i always get compliments from my guest

I really can't believe the rating of this place is anything less than a four. The pizza is…read moreterrific. There is a great variety and the quality is very good. The restaurant layout is well structured for easy pick up delivery and seating. If you prefer the service is always pleasant. This week I ordered pizzas , a Stromboli and a half tray of hot wings. Generally, I feel like trays of wings always end up soggy and not so great. These were perfect. Everyone loved them. well done!

I've lived in the area for a while and always heard good things about this spot, so I finally gave…read moreit a try. Honestly, the pizza didn't really hit the mark for me, but the fries were decent. The staff was really friendly though, which I appreciated

Excellent pizza and dinner entrees. We love their pizza, anything with their vodka sauce and…read moreeggplant rollatini. Whenever we get delivery it arrives hot and made correctly.

I had loved Il Porto in this spot so when I saw a new place opening on Lake Mohawk I had to give it…read morea try! Still a nice cozy interior with gorgeous views (big win if you're there when the water ski team is practicing - great entertainment!). Service was great, polite and timely! The star of the menu is the pizza - the "thinny thin" had a great Barstool Pizza rating and I see why! SUPER thin and crispy pizza with great cheese all the way to the edge. Also had the risotto and penne vodka and while good, the pizza is for sure what you should go for. Will definitely return!

Was attracted by a clever video of Angeloni's on social. Then noticed average yelp reviews of both…read morelocations and did not have much expectations. Disappointing to see because I was hoping the place would be as good or better than the video. Last Wednesday after my wife Sabina's final students left her arts school, I took her to try the restaurant anyways. Reached there late, the final half hour before closing and they accepted us. Honestly, we were pleasantly surprised. Sat at a table outdoors on the boardwalk overlooking Lake Mohawk on a beautiful evening. Restaurant was still busy as all tables were full. Sabina captured and shared videos of the lake views like we were at a destination in Italy 1. The waitress was not bubbly just kind, helpful, and honest about the food ingredients since we are vegetarian. Checked with chef on one item in particular to clarify/confirm whether it was made with meat before giving us a wrong answer. She was pleasant 2. First time here and first time taking a chance on an eggplant pie, the "Gina Marie." It was great in our opinions, worth the trip, wait, and money. Could not find anything off with it really. Enjoyable 3. They have an affogato which was not the best in the game but done right the traditional Italian way I think. I once went to an Italian restaurant in Florham Park where, wildly, no one in the staff knew what an affogato was and said "We are not Starbucks" like I was an idiot. Couldn't stop laughing inside at those morons. Great affogato I have tried is at Eataly store which has diff flavors like pistachio gelato and pistachio crumbs 3. Leftover slices in the air fryer the next day tasted similar to the day we ordered it. Definitely a plus as pizza from some restaurants taste terrible next day. Prices are elevated which is fine as long as the experience, depth of flavors (as an Indian), and quantity of food reflect. Did not try other pies so cannot share review/judge of them. Not sure why the reviews and rating are opposite our experience because we were fully 5 star satisfied.

My wife and I stopped here at about 7:30 on a Thursday evening. We were both fairly hungry and had…read morenever tried this place so... boom,. We were seated quickly and Anthony, our server, stopped by right away with menus, a bottle of water and glasses, and a tray of bread, olive oil, olives, and cheese. We hoovered up everything that he'd brought to us- the bread was fantastic. I mean- wow.... seriously good bread! We both ordered a pasta dish, I got linguine with bolognese sauce, my wife ordered a seafood penne dish. She had originally opted for the lobster mac and cheese- but they were sold out... :-( Being from Queens and transplanted to NJ as a kid, I'm very pasta savvy. The linguine was perfectly cooked- just a little bite. The Bolognese sauce was also on-point. So many NJ pizzerias think that mashing up a meatball and adding it to a ladle of sauce is ok.... This was the real deal. Both plates had huge portions, as well. We were both slightly disappointed- no bread, no spoon, no cheese. Anthony made his way back to the table and rectified those issues. More of that fabulous bread, ha ha! Look- I can absolutely say that i'll be back. Food was good... Place was nice...

my chicken cutlet was completely rubber. there was a droplet of mayo. and let's not discuss the…read morehard as a rock bread. I didn't return it because I decided that I will just never return to this establishment.

Food is usually cold and unappetizing. Their fries are particularly bad and always ice cold and…read morestale. Chicken tenders are usually insanely small and they don't make up for it by giving extra.

I got penne pasta with pesto and chicken and my chicken was undercooked. My bfs chicken alfredo was…read morewatery.

We stopped for coffee earlier in the day and had a craving for wings and beer. Since we were in…read moreSparta, we stopped in to Krogh's. Our server Day gave me 3 different beers to try before I settled on their Three Sisters Golden Ale while hubby opted for Sullivan's Irish Stout. We ordered the traditional wings and split a delicious brisket burger with American cheese and fries. All the classics with the brews. The bar was full of happy people and the vibes were joyous. They have a great menu, be sure to stop in and grab some food and awesome cocktails. When the weather is nice, you can sit outside or on the rooftop bar. The town is super cute!

Nice exterior and interior, some booths have wood carvings…read more Sat immediately and waiter came over quick. Ordered pretzel appetizer, but had to remind waiter after 20 min of waiting. Seems was mixup and app came out with lunch. In fairness manager came over and comped the appetizer due to their mistake. Fish and chips were ok. Spicy rigatoni with home made sausage, we were told spice level of sausage varies since home made.... however...the whole dish was too spicy for us, blew out our palette on each bites finish, could not even dent the meal. However, if you do like alot of heat this may be your dish!