pizza was amazing here the wings weren't the best I've had but they were good def coming back for the pizza

Haven't been to Baldwin pizza in many years, since I moved to AZ from NJ. Literally nothing has changed, in the absolute best way. The staff is friendly and efficient, and the pizza is amazing. Literally can't improve on a thing. We ordered 4 slices: cheese, sausage, chicken parm, and margherita. We shared, and they were all as delicious as the next one. Definitely worth a stop here for amazing food. read more

Baldwin Pizzeria - Margherita, cheese, chicken parm, and sausage slices. - Pizza Near Me - Parsippany, New Jersey

See all

Excellent selection of slices and the dinners are very good as well. Give them a try if you're in Lake Parsippany near Saint Peter's church.

Baldwin Pizzeria in Parsippany, NJ delivers classic Jersey-style pizza with a perfectly crispy crust and flavorful toppings. The menu goes beyond just pizza - offering everything from sandwiches and wraps to pasta, empanadas, and more. We tried the buffalo chicken slice, which was delicious, and the chicken francese, which was rich and savory. The staff is friendly, and while there's limited seating inside, it's a popular spot for takeout and dining depending on the timing. read more

Baldwin Pizzeria - Buffalo Chicken Slice and Chicken Francese - Pizza Near Me - Parsippany, New Jersey

Been getting our calzones from here. They seem to make them the best we have found. Will continue to buy them from here

This pizza was an absolute delight from the first bite. The crust struck the perfect balance--crispy on the outside, soft and chewy inside. read more

Baldwin Pizzeria - This pizza was an absolute delight from the first bite. The crust struck the perfect balance crispy on the outside, soft and chewy inside. - Pizza Near Me - Parsippany, New Jersey

We order here 2x a week the wraps and salad are so fresh , chicken penne vodka is my go to and servings are great

First order should be white pie and an order of their vodka sauce pasta your next visit you can try your usual choice of pizza you won't be disappointed . read more

They say that man cannot live on bread alone and that may be so, but you put Sauce, Cheese, and Pepperoni on it and I'm Your Man, Lol. Parsippany is FULL of great Pizza places and Baldwin's is definitely a really solid example of that. This place gets it's name from the shopping center where it calls home. It's a Family owned and operated Mom and Pop type Business that's been around since 1969. Justin and his hard working staff are always busy serving up some incredibly tasty Italian inspired comfort food for all of their customer's dine-in, takeout, or delivery conveniences.    You Win, I Win, Everybody Wins at BaldWin Pizzeria!! Lol, but seriously the real winners are anybody lucky enough to enjoy some of this delicious drool worthy Jersey Style Pizza. Come And Get Your Munch On!! read more

See all

Always on the lookout for pizzerias, I found Baldwin Pizzeria in my bookmarked list. Today, I had the chance to stop there for lunch. I really liked this place. It reminded me of old time pizza places I grew up on in Queens. The restaurant is in a strip mall on Baldwin Rd, right off Rt 46 in Parsippany. Easy to get to, plenty of parking. Usually when I try a new place, I just go with a plain slice. Here though, the chicken rollatini slice was calling out to me. Really tasty with a nice crust. Delicious! I'm not sure if the guy behind the counter was the owner, but he was very friendly. $5.50 for a specialty slice and can of soda is very reasonable too. Stop in and give this place a shot! read more

See all

Came in for for lunch. I had sicilian slices with Pepperoni. They were delicious! i've come here before and the pizza is always delicious and service is friendly and great! read more

Yaaaaaaaaaaaas! I recently moved to the area and I was hoping I would find an amazing pizza spot with gluten-free crust. Baldwin Pizzeria is in a perfect location right off of Rt. 46 in a shopping center with plenty of parking. They offer delicious and fairly thick (for gluten-free) crusts and of course, regular pizza. I treated my parents to lunch and they loved it, which is shocking because my mother is super picky about 'za. Good for my mental being and not for my waistline, I'll surely be ordering from them again and again. The staff are awesome and make you feel like you're an old familiar, even if it's your first time visiting. read more

Baldwin Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Parsippany, New Jersey

Delivery was very fast , food quality and price was excellent . Driver was very professional. Chicken salad was extremely fresh . Pizza was cooked perfect crust chewy nice blend of sauce and cheese . Garlic bread with cheese was perfect also ( fresh Italian roll). First time order from here definitely will be ordering again read more

I used to come here all the time when I was in high school. The staff is super friendly and outgoing. They are very welcoming to all their customers and quick on their feet. I used to order their cheese pizza all the time because it was only $2 a slice. I came back a week ago to visit because it's been a while since I had their pizza. I decided to try out their margarita pizza and thought it was amazing. I really like how their crust is crispy and not too soft. Even though their pizza is reheated pizza, most pizza places are like that anyways. So, I don't find an issue with that. The only thing is that I wish they would label what flavor(?) pizzas are on display. I found it bit difficult to identify what pizza flavor I was looking at -- like margarita or veggie, etc. I think by labeling which pizza is on display will definitely help their customers when they are ordering instead of having to point for the one they want. Overall, I've been to a lot of pizza places since I grew up in Parsippany, and I believe that this is honestly one of the best pizza places around here. read more

Baldwin Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Parsippany, New Jersey

See all

My husband and I were driving back from the beach and decided to try this pizzeria out (we had been planning to do so anyways). We placed our order for the "Baldwin Chicken Cheese Steak Pizza" ($18.50 w/out tax or tip) when we were 40 minutes out. We were told that the order would be ready in 30-40 min so it worked out fine. When we got there, we walked in and told them my name. Although I didn't get an email confirmation that my order was ready, they brought it out pretty quickly. The pizza is pretty big, we were surprised! We got to tasting once we got home and let me tell you - this pizza was DELICIOUS! I wasn't sure how I'd feel about having "potatoes" as one of the toppings but it tasted good. My husband said it was unlike any pizza he has tasted before. You could tell that it was freshly made. This review is strictly reviewing the pizza because our interactions with the staff were very limited. They have great pizza, and if that's what you are looking for - check this place out! read more

See all

And the owner Mike allows problems to occur between his employees. The food at this pizzeria isn't even that good

Love the slices here!! At such a great price too. The staff was very helpful. We had a plain, sausage, and mushroom slice, all of which were heated up perfectly and had the right sauce to cheese ratio. read more

We did door dash almost the last order of the night. Omg if you skip this place you just made a mistake. Place your order now. Don't hesitate! Antipasto salad, large pizza, dessert, Yum!!! read more

Your average pizza place. Service was pleasant and efficient. I got a plain and a pepperoni slice to go. Crust was nice and fluffy on the edges yet perfectly thin in the middle. Something about the cheese was a little off, flavor reminded me of the kind on frozen pizza. Nothing notable about the sauce. I also wish they had a larger drink selection. Pepperoni didn't seem overly greasy. Overall, not bad if you live nearby, but, given it's not located in my immediate area, I wouldn't go out of my way to eat there. read more

Ordered thru Uber Eats and the food was excellent. The tortellini soup was delicious as was the grilled chicken.

We order from Baldwin almost weekly. Food always tastes great. Service is also a great. Definitely recommend Baldwins

I have tried just about all the grandma pizza from parsippany Pizzaria. BALDWIN HAS THE BEST! it's thin and covered with fresh mozzarella, basil and grated cheese at the best price! Vic read more

Went here for my birthday. Sat down and no one greeted us. So I went inside and asked if there was table service. They said yes. So I sat back down. Nothing. 5 minutes later, I go in again. The staff of 3 looks at me. One person acts as though she was "just" coming out. So I go back and sit down. Nothing! We had to leave to find another place because I didn't want my birthday to get worse across the course of the meal. This place is horrible. read more

The food used to be great, we got a shrimp scampi pizza a few weeks ago and it was SO fishy it was barely edible. Tonight, we tried to give them another chance since it is close to our house and convenient for us. We ordered an eggplant vodka sandwich, when I get there they ring up the eggplant parm sandwich and had a $5 "custom item" - so I said this must be incorrect, and they said "no that is to have vodka sauce instead of marinara".... I said so it's FIVE DOLLARS to have a different sauce?! they confirmed that since it isn't listed that way on the menu that they charge another $5. First of all this was NOT told to us on the phone or we would have said forget it, and honestly, part of customer service is catering to your customers, at least a little bit. I don't think requesting a different sauce is ridiculous, and I honestly refused to pay $18 for a sandwich. I would NEVER go back here, and we used to go all the time. I highly suggest trying some of the other great pizza places in the area. read more

I come here a lot for dinner to-go and no complaints so far! I feel like things are a bit on the pricey side when it all adds up but I guess it's pretty on par with surrounding pizza locations. The chicken wings deal on Wednesday is awesome though! Whenever I visit on a Wednesday, nearly every customer orders it. When I order custom pizzas or pastas (like adding chicken into baked ziti), they are quite generous with the toppings with is great since some places kind of skimp out on it. Also, the dishes that come with a side of bread - they REALLY give you bread, much more than you'd expect which is great because I love bread. Overall their dishes are pretty good but I do personally prefer the taste of Anthony Franco's pizza over theirs. But don't get me wrong, their pizza is very good too! In the numerous times I've ordered, my order has always been correct; however once they forgot the mini side salad that was supposed to come with my pasta dish. It wasn't a big deal and they were pretty busy that day but oh well I was really looking forward to getting some greens in with my high carb meal. The staff are very nice and friendly as htey greet you as soon as you walk in. They also bring the food out to your table when you plan to dine in which is a plus. The wait time is also pretty standard and I do plan ahead and call in for a pick-up order ahead of time and they've been pretty good ad giving estimates and having everything ready upon my arrival. read more

Ordered a pizza on a Monday night, got a cold pizza pie. Joke! Will never order from Baldwin again

It's been years since I ordered a pie from Baldwin Pizza-not because there was anything wrong with Baldwin, we moved across town and found another 'go-to' pizza place. I happened to be out with the kids and we decided to give it a shot. We ordered a half sausage pie and garlic knots and hoped for the best. I was very surprised-I thought the pizza was even better than I remembered. The sausage on the pizza was phenomenal. The crust was a little crispier than I usually like and the sauce was good, but a little sweet. I loved that they didnt cheap out on the amount of cheese they used. My kids loved the pie and the knots-even asking if we could go there again...while that's great, it's pizza, my kids love pizza no matter where we get it (well almost, they would eat anything from Pizza Hut if it were free). I'd give Baldwin 3.5 stars, but I need to give them another shot before they get a fourth star. Maybe next time we'll eat in. read more

The place has really good pizza, Margarita & Grandma style pizza are delicious. Also serves really nice sandwiches. Recommended for pizza lovers !!! read more

Baldwin Pizzeria - Grandma Sicilian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Parsippany, New Jersey

Ordered a Cobb salad for dinner and received a salad with leafy greens and avocado beginning to rot. This is not what you should be serving your customers. Needless to say, I won't be a repeat customer. read more

Baldwin Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Parsippany, New Jersey

See all

Rude and disrespectful women who is very unprofessional get rid of her! I went in to ask about pizza availability and the women who was there was very rude! Told my husband go to the Godfather pizzeria down the street they are much nicer there!!! read more

I absolutely love this place! The staff is always super friendly and welcoming, and the food is amazing. The prices are very reasonable and the portions are great. The pizza is delicious, but my favorite dish is the Baldwin Platter. The platter is rice, sautéed broccoli, and grilled chicken that is topped with avocado, diced tomatoes, and carrot shreds. It also comes with a side of homemade chipotle sauce... which is so good they should probably sell it by the bottle! They alhave a bunch of other unique menu items that you can't get at a typical pizzeria. I would highly recommend this restaurant if you are in the area! read more

I go there all the time! Pizza is good, especially if you order a whole pie. The tomatoe or extra cheese is very good. I really like the staff there , very friendly and nice. read more

I love this pizza place. Whether it's for a quick slice or to order a few pies for a party. The pizza is perfect thin pizzeria pizza. The garlic knots are very good as well. The staff is friendly and always caring. It's a great local pizza spot. read more

Horrible pizza, chicken is disgusting and they charge almost a dollar for honey mustard that comes in a packet! So cheap and disgusting the dessert pizza also was chewy and just not enjoyable looks like a toddler had to go potty on it. I've been here many times and always tried to give them a chance but just terrible. The pizza looks nothing like photo! read more

Baldwin Pizzeria - Dessert Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Parsippany, New Jersey

Decent pizza for the area. I went out last night and got two slices, an order of garlic knots and two empanadas. The garlic knots were awesome and definitely helped my decision on bumping up the star rating for this review. If anything I recommend you trying an order! However I'd avoid the empanadas, which I should have known considering it's a pizza shop. The empanadas were chicken, the inside was dry and after my first bite I couldn't finish it, it tasted old, most likely because it sat in the case too long. The pizza was ok, but definitely not the best, I personally wasn't a fan of their sauce. Needs more flavor, maybe garlic, a little salt.. idk maybe an entire new formula. But again it's a personal preference. Restaurant interior is okay, basic Italian pizzeria vibe. Perhaps look else where if you're craving good pizza! But if your looking for a quick bite try for yourself! read more

We frequently order pizza from here, always very good. Today we ordered something different and were very displeased. We ordered lasagna, which was basically a cheese platter. There was barely any meat and had the consistency of mush. We also ordered a meat lovers calzone and that too had more ricotta than meat. Not tasty at all. Lastly, we ordered butter pasta for our daughter. Upon picking up the order the butter had spilled inside of the package bags. The counter girl was kind enough to re bag the order but once we got home the butter pasta was dry, no butter in the container and our daughter did not like it at all because of this. Wanted to order take out to relieve a long day of work but ended up having to cook dinner. Disappointed and a waste of money this evening. Never again read more

Baldwin Pizzeria - Meat lovers calzone that has more ricotta than anything and they slapped some meat in there - Pizza Near Me - Parsippany, New Jersey

This was my favorite pizza place ever and they seem to have just changed ownership recently. They changed the recipes to everything and now it's mediocre at best. I'm literally heartbroken this place was a tradition for us read more

Just ordered 2 chicken lunch specials, 1 with vodka sauce, one franchaise. Each were too salty. I mean dead sea salty. The vodka sauce special was so salty it was inedible.....additionally, the penne was undercooked....and yes, I know pasta should be al dente....but this pasta barely touched boiling water. I wish I had read the reviews before walking in. read more

Real authentic Italian food. Totally affordable and portion size is huge. I would def recommend to anyone.

Reheated pizza is always a good thing sometimes better than fresh. The Eggplant Rollatini slice I had looked and tasted great. The bathroom facility was terrible: broken toilet seat, watered down soap in dispenser, and no mirror. read more