Great pizza. I will say the Detroit style vodka tasted so fresh, the bite was so soft but crunchy crust and non overpowering vodka sauce. Same goes for the grandma pie. It's bigger than it looks, but delicious. Definitely a place to come on a Friday night. But it does get crowded quick so plan accordingly. You seat yourself and when you are ready you go to the counter and the ladies will take care of you. Side note : this isn't just a pizzeria. Coniglois is a great place for lunch or a coffee and a sweet treat. They have so many options of baked goods and a case of bread made in house that you could take home. Overall it was fantastic. I didn't get to try everything but I'll be back for more. read more

Coniglio’s Old Fashioned - Detroit Vodka - Pizza Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

See all

PROS: Staff is friendly, spacious inside with loads of seating, food is good, menu variety is plentiful, and located in center of town CONS: Overpriced, even for the area, and there's only street parking OVERALL: I recommend coming here as long as you don't mind spending $12 for a coffee and if you don't mind searching for parking read more

Coniglio’s Old Fashioned - Pizza Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

BYOB The pizza was good the service was ok. But it was nice to just sit down eat a pie or most of, and enjoy the night. Next time I have to grab a sandwich they looked tremendous. Better make reservations always packed read more

A go to spot for lunch (although on the pricier side). Some of my favorites include, vodka stracciatella pie, meatball & ricotta pie, squash and farro salad, and the crispy chicken caesar hero. Excited for when their extended dining room finally opens up! read more

See all

Called in a simple order Sandwich and a Salad Cesar salad was 50 % ALL CHEESE Person that took my phone order was basically rude Pick Up counter person handed me a bag No napkins or utensils No Receipt Sandwich was all bread Bread was delicious but Very skinny on the chicken Overall Very Very Disappointing read more

This was my second time having aid here, but this time I got it delivered. The first time I got a grandma pie, which is not my favorite. Pie in general to get any establishment it was pretty good for sure but a little bit more on their expensive side but most of the time those types of pies are at any place this time I got a regular cheese pie, which was delicious and very tasty. I ordered the chicken Parm meal and it tasted pretty good. There's a lot of other stuff. I would definitely try here and it's very quality food. read more

Coniglio’s Old Fashioned - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

See all

Stopped by here while I was in the area and so glad I did! Cute casual but lovely interior with seating indoor and outdoor. You order at the front and can seat anywhere in the restaurant. If you're doing take out you pick it up in the back. They have sandwiches, pizzas and pastas available. You can't purchase pizzas by the slice you have to order the full pie, prices are around $30 for the full pie. I ordered pasta to go which came with a slice of sourdough bread. They also had a grab and go area for drinks and an array of pastries, I got a Nutella donut which was also delicious. I got the vodka rigatoni pasta which was so good! Great flavor and can't wait to come back for more food and pastries. read more

See all

I visited Coniglio's Old Fashioned for a casual family meal while visiting downtown Morristown. We ordered the Brooklyn Round pie, and the pizza was excellent. The crust and dough had a really tasty, unique flavor that stood out from other pizzas I've had. We also got salads, which were fresh and a good size. Prices are a bit on the higher side, but that's expected given the area. Service was good -- you order at the counter. The vibe is trendy with nice garage doors that open up onto the sidewalk, giving it a nice, open feel. It wasn't busy when we went in the middle of the day, but from what I've seen at night, it gets super packed. They're planning to expand next door. The baked goods looked tempting, though I didn't try any this time. Overall, I'd recommend Coniglio's if you're looking for a more upscale pizza spot in Morristown. read more

See all

Updated review a couple of years and many visits later: this was five stars on our first try, but unfortunately I have to take a star away for lack of consistency from this place. The round pies are always solid, but the Sicilian is completely hit or miss; when it's good, it's GREAT, but when it's not, it's just okay, and at this price point, it needs to be great every time time. (Sidenote, the Tavolino guy I mentioned in my first review left after a few months and opened his own place in Rutherford called Casano's.) They started serving breakfast a while ago, sandwiches and different pastries, which I really like, but again, the consistency is lacking. The bomboloni were soft, fluffy, doughy perfection when Coniglio's first started making them, but lately they've been way overcooked/too dark on top. The eggs on the breakfast sandwiches are super fluffy and plentiful, but again, if I'm paying $10 for a sausage/egg/cheese on a bagel, I would expect that. Still a great place, but we admittedly go less frequently than we thought we would because the price is too high for not knowing what you're going to get. I couldn't call myself a pizza connoisseur without updating my review to say that. read more

See all

I think I have my new favorite spot for pizza in NJ. To be frank,it all started with my uneducated statement amongst friends that I'm yet to find tasty pizza in the state...this is definitely hit! And what's more,they have a great selection of sourdough pastries,Italian frozen delicacies and coffee under the same roof. Very cozy interior,musical background was on-point (think of 50's jazzy vibes). Once in,you need to order at the front but then the food is brought to your table. Our group of 5 ordered 2 pizzas and had just about enough room in our bellies for some desert (croissants & bambolinos!). Pizza choices were Vodka Straccatella and Nonna's Spinach-both had a lovely crust,but we all voted for the Vodka as our favorite because of its flavors and creamyness; Nonna's was a tad dry! Will definitely be back here to try some other items from their menu. read more

See all

Come for the pastries or the pizza, you can't go wrong! This is my first time dining at Coniglios and I'll definitely be back! If you're coming for pizza, it's best to come with 2+ people since the pies are round. They do have a Detroit style pizza which is smaller and what I ended up getting. It was very delicious! The staff here are great too and super friendly! I'll be back with more friends to try the larger pies! read more

See all

The pizzas are delicious and fresh and the staff is friendly and quick to get the food out to us even on a very busy night. The ambiance is nice and the location is convenient to the town center. Recommend. read more

See all

The pizza is excellent. Unfortunately that's all I have to say because that's all we tried. Everything else looked great but it's about the pizza. It's actually so good that it's worth a trip to Morristown and it's associated parking debacle just to have it. I took off a single star because they don't offer slices which is annoying if eating alone or with just one other person. Since I stopped in, I've returned a few times and it's consistently good, delicious actually. So if you're ever in Morristown with at least one other person, you should pay them a visit. I\'m sure you'll be glad that you did. Kudos. read more

Coniglio’s Old Fashioned - Pizza Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

See all

Catered from here, the pasta was ok, but better penne vodka and pizza at the Nonna's in Florham Park (as compared to the rigatoni a la vodka and margherita pizza). I do like the fresh loaves of bread, though, very tasty on that. Salad was so-so, and they didn't give enough dressing to use for folks. Desserts were good, though, I like the bombalonis and the cookies. read more

See all

Last week my family tried Coniglio's Morristown location. We tried the pizza, the roast pork sandwich and their pasta with bolognese sauce. The food is good. They also sold breads, pastries, and Italian filled donuts that you can buy. The interior of the restaurant is nice and it's decorated with pictures of rabbits. This place is a good place for pizza in Morristown. read more

Located in the heart of Morristown, Coniglio's had been on my pizza hit list for a few years ever since a friend clued me in on them. Sure enough, an online search reveals they've won several awards, with some considering them as the best pizza in New Jersey, so I had to try them out even though Morristown is a bit outside of my normal dining radius. We had heard they served up old fashioned soda that was hand mixed, so had to try that out since I'm not aware of any other place that offers it. Honestly, we felt that it tasted like a slightly flatter version of your typical Coke, so although we're glad to have tried it, felt it was more of a novelty thing rather than something we'd try again. We wanted to try out several items, so ordered the mozzarella sticks, meatballs, vodka chicken parmesan sandwich, and the upside down Sicilian pizza. You could tell everything was high quality. The mozzarella sticks, while not the best I've had, were solid, and the hand breaded variety with just the right amount of flavor in the breading. The vodka chicken parmesan sandwich was very flavorful with a decent cut of chicken and the right taste of vodka sauce working in harmony with the cheese, but wasn't a fan of the sesame seed roll it was served on. Knowing how it's normally served, if I were to reorder it, I'd pass on the vodka sauce in favor of tomato sauce and ask for regular Italian bread without the sesame seeds. The upside down Sicilian pizza was a bit of a disappointment given the hype. We agreed that the dough/crust was the best part, but the cheese and sauce didn't have the flavor profile we prefer in pizza. The sauce relied too heavily on the herbs and the tomato really didn't pack much of a punch. It wasn't bad as all the ingredients were high quality, but it just wasn't in our wheelhouse for preferred pizza flavor; however, I can see how some who like more artisanal pizzas may really like it. If I were to return, I'd stick to one of their more traditional round pizzas to see how that fares rather than go with a Sicilian pie again. Their display of baked goods looked incredible, so we went with both the almond and Nutella filled croissants. They were both decent and above average in flavor, but also came with a hefty price tag in the $6-7 range, so probably wouldn't order them again unless I was really in the mood for a pastry. There wasn't much seating indoors, but staff did a great job of turning over tables quickly on a busy Saturday night. While they didn't have a formal wait staff and food was dropped off at tables, there was a super friendly elderly staff member bringing water to the tables and asking how everything was. Overall, the 4/5 Yelp rating seems just about right as all the food was fresh & high quality, but several of the recipes just didn't quite hit the mark with us. I recommend others give Coniglio's a chance to see for themselves, and look forward to returning to try out some of their other menu items. read more

See all

Coniglio's is one of my favorite pizza restaurants in NJ. What I think separates itself from others is the flavorful options, such white tomato garlic, and the extra crunch in every bite. So good. I also eat some of the vodka stracchiatella pie and it was equally as good. Coniglio's offers outdoor seating in Morristown's busiest street and it is a great place for lunch with co-workers and/or friends. Highly recommend. read more

Coniglio’s Old Fashioned - White Tomato Garlic - Pizza Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

See all

Wildly expensive for average quality. Not impressed and the owner thinks they are the king of pizza

This was on my to eat list for a while, and it was definitely my bad for delaying! I ordered through Grubhub for delivery: The Detroit Red and Josephina's Grandma Pie. UGH chef's kiss... the crust THE CRUST the tomato sauce... it was great. The crispy cheese. I am actually close to this place, so I have no excuses now. You and me Coniglios forever or at least as long as I live around here. All I can say is, you should try it! Also, side note, the logo and marketing is really great. read more

Coniglio’s Old Fashioned - Detroit Red - Pizza Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

See all

if you haven't tried the Chicken Caesar sandwich, its a must. that and the Josephina. mic drop.

With all the hype from Best of Lists and Barstool, we checked this spot out for an early dinner. You order and pay at the counter and then you grab a seat and they bring the food out to you. The place isn't too big so it quickly became chaotic and really loud as the more and more people come in. We only got the pizza but they have a ton of salads, pastas, baked goods, and even gelato! Now the pizza. We tried the Brooklyn round ($26) and the Nonna's Spinach Pie ($28). The Nonna's was absolutely perfect- good flavor, crunch, and absolutely huge. The Brooklyn Round had a good crunch and was just good pizza. We had tons of leftovers and the pizza did heat up really well the next day which is a plus. The dine in experience sort of left a bit to be desired but the pizza here is delicious and quality so my recommendation is for takeout. read more

Coniglio’s Old Fashioned - Nonna's Spinach Pie - Pizza Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

See all

This review is specific to some pastries I ate the other day. The croissant was quite good. It's a little on the denser side, but it had a nice sweet flavor and was fresh-tasting even in the middle of the afternoon. I also had the strawberry-filled bombolone. Wow - quite the combination of sweet (but not overly sweet) strawberry filling inside a doughnut-like outer shell. I cut it in half and the strawberry cream spilled out. I took a bite, and strawberry cream spilled out. And yet the inside was still full of strawberry cream! Can't ask for more than that - I will be back just to get this. read more

Coniglio’s Old Fashioned - Croissant and strawberry bombolone - Pizza Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

See all

My friend took me to try out Coniglio's, stating it's "Morristown's best pizza." We ordered the vodka stracciatella and salsiccia pepper onion round pizzas. The vodka stracciatella was my favorite of the two, with a perfect creamy, cheesy base that I loved. Though, I would have preferred for the basil to be cut up rather than us having to roughly bite through it. As for the salsiccia pepper onion pizza, I liked the sliced sausages but wish there was more of this topping. For our order, the pizza was also dripping in oil, which drenched the crust and was a bit off-putting. It seems this place can be hit or miss depending on your order. The pizzas are pricey (~$30 each), but the huge slices make it worthwhile. Overall, I'd return for the vodka pizza, but it might depend on what you're in the mood for. read more

Coniglio’s Old Fashioned - Salsiccia pepper onion round pizza & Vodka stracciatella round pizza - Pizza Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

See all

Tipsy Santa is my FAV but they only have it around the holidays. It has pesto and vodka sauce in it. read more

Coniglio’s Old Fashioned - Pizza Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

See all

So I have now gone back to Coniglio's to give it another try and I'm happy to report I am now impressed. The first time trying it, I went against my norm by going with the grandma's based on other reviews I had read. I almost never stray from a plain pie (although they really don't have anything "plain" on the menu). I didn't much care for it. This time I got the round Brooklyn, which is the closest thing to a standard cheese pizza. It was very well baked with a nice crunchy crust. The crust around the rim was quite a bit wider than I usually like but it was very nice so I wasn't too mad about it. The sauce was probably the highlight. It was just a tiny bit chunky/thick and had a very nice flavor to it. I'm sure the cheese was absolutely top shelf but it wasn't my favorite (again, given my non-discriminating palate). Huge basil leaves are also not on my list of favorites but, being huge, they are easy enough to pick off. All in all, it was a very good pizza. Climbed several dozen spots higher on my NJ pizza ranking. read more

The entire family went here after Sunday's Mets game. The nice thing about Mo-Town on Sundays is that parking is free. There was a good size crowd, but the restaurant was not overly loud. Nevertheless, we rolled up here to get a pizza. Of course, our daughter wanted the chicken parmesan and not pizza. We ordered at the register and were then told where to sit so the servers would know where to bring our food. We got the Brooklyn Round, which is a Margherita Pizza. $25 is pretty steep for that particular pie, in my opinion. We got it well done as we do with most pizzas, otherwise there is too much tip sag with the slices. The crust was the best part of that particular pizza, so I'll leave it at that. Our daughter housed the chicken parm, so I will go out on a limb and say that she enjoyed it thoroughly. We took a couple desserts to go and they were delicious. I think Mama Coniglio stopped by the table to check on us, and that was a nice family touch. read more

Coniglio’s Old Fashioned - Pizza Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

See all

Not sure what the hype is about this place. Pizza was average. Too much crust. Over priced and limited options.

I heard a lot about this place so I decided to bring the whole family down here for dinner. We ordered 2 pies and 2 pasta dishes. As we were having our dinner, a kind lady was going around the floor checking on the guests. I assume she was either the owner or the matriarch of the family. When she got to our table, I mentioned to her it was our first time and we loved the food. The restaurant lived up to its reputation. She told us that she'll bring us some treats. I was thinking some cookies. She came back and brought a whole box of pastries. We were all stunned by her kindness and generosity. She definitely made our night. We will definitely come back here. read more

Coniglio’s Old Fashioned - Box of assorted pastries. Oh My God! We were in heaven! So Good!!! - Pizza Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

See all

This place is a little gem. I ordered a plain pizza with onions and fresh tomatoes. My friend inhaled 4 slices! The sauce did tasted fresh, and so were the ingredients. My only tiny gripe was that it should have been baked a little longer, but that can easily be rectified. Did I also mention they have freshly-baked sourdough bread?? This place is a keeper!! read more

I really wanted to love this place, but ... ya no. Could have been just a bad choice but the vodka sauce round pizza made my stomach turn, the Ceasar salad was bland, no saltiness you expect from a legit Ceasar dressing with anchovies. Figured I would salvage the night with a dessert, it was decent, pistachio doughnut, or whatever their version is called. The dough was good, the filling I suppose I was expecting a deeper pistachio flavor akin to pistachio butter, this was much lighter. Will give them another shot with their Brooklyn style read more

Coniglio’s Old Fashioned - Pistachio Bombolone - Pizza Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

See all

I ordered an upside down sicilian to go while we were at the Morristown Jazz and Blues Festival. The kitchen was fast, service was great and the pie was fantastic. The crust was crunchy on the outside, soft and light inside. Goos sauce, perfect cheese and fresh basil. My granddaughter liked it so much she wants to make the 45 minute drive again. read more

Coniglio’s Old Fashioned - Upside Down Sicilian - Pizza Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

Service was wonderful and staff are so nice. I will be back. The pizza is the best I've ever had and I've eaten a lot of pizza.

A new old school pizza restaurant run by a noted pizza master and rated 8.3 by Dave Portnoy We shared: - 18" meatball and ricotta pie ($30) The pizza was enormous and very good quality. The two of us are big eaters who polished it off easily. The ingredients were top tier but could've had more flavor. There was a perfect balance of ingredients in terms of sauce, cheese, oil, crust, and basil. The outer crust was dry and tough. I'd choose this spot for pizza in Morristown in the future. 8/10 pizza read more

Coniglio’s Old Fashioned - Meatball Ricotta Round - Pizza Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

Delicious artisanal pizza pie (no slices to go), very friendly service, and large portions for the Caesar salad - went for the pizza and fell for the desserts. Don't sleep on the coffee/latte menu, this was also a pleasant surprise! It was very popular for lunch time so make sure to come early, will be back to try some other goodies on the menu! read more

See all

Holy cow! Coniglio's is insane. It's a bit tight inside, but so worth it. You order up at the register and find a table (they'll help you find one too!) and your food comes to you. There's also a nice set of baked goods so you can choose a dessert (if you'll even have room at the end).... The Squash and Farro salad was amazing - so unique, fresh - and a great way to start off a meal before downing all the good cheesy pizza (it's all about balance!) The Brooklyn Round is THE BEST and the one you should always get by default (you can vary the second). We added some pepperoni for some protein, but you can't go wrong with this one. read more

Great pizza and a beautiful spot. The service is kinda meh though. You order at the counter and then they sit you at a table and bring your food to you. Don't expect anything beyond that, no water, and further checking up on you, nada. Despite that the pizza makes it worth it. I had the Brooklyn round with meatballs and it was fantastic. Not only did it have an excellent taste, it looked beautiful as well. read more

See all

Pizza was good, not great, with very good crust but too much parmesam cheese. Ambience was busy and crowded. Too bad they don't serve beer.

I get a Coniglio'a craving once a month because their pizza is that good. I've had several of their pizzas before and hands down my favorite is the Brooklyn round. The fresh mozzarella and basil combined with the lovely sauce, is -mwah- chef's kiss. The crust is also amazing too. It's a mix of crunchy but also has a nice chew to it. You can't go wrong doing takeout or eating at the restaurant because their food is always good :) read more

Coniglio’s Old Fashioned - Brooklyn Round - Pizza Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

Our very first visit at the recommendation from our 'Foodie Guru' Tony Mangia. A great Upside down Sicilian Pizza that was awesome. The service was also great and environment a pleasant dining experience. read more

Coniglio’s Old Fashioned - Pizza Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

See all

Despite the surprise, Coniglios has been one of our go-to spots for breakfast or brunch. Their sandwiches are amazing, and they haven't disappointed us. We have ordered their pizza through delivery, but the experience of going there to get their breakfast sandwiches is better than having their pizza delivered. We have tried their pastries and, unfortunately, were not impressed. Friendly staff and nice environment. Highly recommend! read more

See all