The pizza is always consistent and very good. The wings are the surprising hit! My husband & daughter love to order the buffalo/ bbq mix not sure if it's on the menu but they make it amazing. It's their favorite. My favorite is the cheesesteak with a little bit of marinara. Another unexpected hit for this place is the curly fries. Creative specialty pizzas and always reliable garlic knots. Friendly staff with great service! Relaxed ambiance with NY / Philly vibe. Worth the drive! read more

See all

The BEST New York style pizza in the area. Best place for a quick lunch or delivery is also quick and easy.. Gary read more

Tried this place with a couple of my coworkers and was delicious. The pizza was great and fresh, definitely a good place to eat and enjoy with friends. Now, the location was dirty. The common areas in general were not too organize and there were food and dirt everywhere on the floor and some tables. This would be a really good spot if the location improves on that. read more

See all

This place is my favorite lunch spot. I love getting slices of pizza for a great price. Try the sandwiches too. I have enjoyed everything I've ever ordered here. I love supporting local businesses, glad I found them. read more

I used to order just 2 slices with Marinara on the side but it just wasn't enough pizza!! So now my husband and I split a large pizza and a BOWL of marinara sauce HAHA!! This is finger licking GOOD pizza. The staff is friendly always smiling. We loving going here. We use all the seasonings on the table; oregano, cheese, red pepper flakes, garlic. Our pizza comes ALIVE with flavor. Can't wait to go back... probably today now that I'm talking about it, I'm hungry for this pizza again!! Good ambiance too! read more

See all

We ordered a lot of food and it was fast and fresh and great service. Wings and pizza were good and overall a great place for good food!!

The pizza was sitting on the counter for a good 8 minutes before it was brought over to us. Asked for mushrooms they just put them on top didn't cook it with the mushrooms. The other slice was half a slice. Didn't eat the mushrooms and got half a slice. Not what I paid for. Said something they told me that is a regular slice size , but did offer to replace both I refused because honestly it shouldn't have came to that. read more

Times Square Pizza Company - Pizza Near Me - Brandon, Florida

We typically get a pizza from here because my NYer husband loves their pizza. Today I was in the mood for some wings and let me tell you I am a hard critic for wings and typically dont eat all of them but today I consumed all of them they were so awesome and crispy and no slime texture to them. The service was awesome as well Abby did a great job helping us and making sure we had everything we needed and her sunny disposition made the visit even better. We will be ordering again. read more

Times Square Pizza Company - Large cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brandon, Florida

The food was fairly decent. Pizza crust was halfway decent after we reheated it in the oven both of them they made the crust a little bit crispier as that's what we like. Flavors were fairly bland, however and they forgot to add black olives, mushrooms, meatballs, and onions to the pizza as requested and paid for. Delivery was good not sure if we would use them again but whenever you order pizza for delivery is a crapshoot. Paying a $50 for a pizza and not having all the ingredients is always a disappointment especially when it's a mid afternoon when it's not that busy at the location. I'll give them another chance but who is anyone gets. read more

Been trying a bunch of pizza spots in the area and so far I think this is the best place. Pizza is pretty decent. Coming from Little Italy in the Bronx where there's a pizza shop on every corner, I don't expect to find NY pizza in this area but this place is pretty damn close. I still need to try their white pizza but so far their cheese and special pizza are really good. I wasn't crazy about their Stromboli. It's not authentic Stromboli so I would skip that. The best thing overall that I enjoyed from this place was the garlic knots. If you have to order anything on the side with your order, go with the garlic knots. They are (dare I say) just as good at NY garlic knots. They're soft (not dry and hard like other places) and are drowned in Parmesan and garlic (which is how it should be). You take a bite and then swirl your knot in the garlic sauce. Amazing. read more

The food is always fresh and delicious. The customer service is the best! Just a great place to hang out.

I paid for a whole pizza it took to long plus the pie came out burnt I just left the whole pie there didn't even bother to ask for a refund read more

This was the best pizza I've ever had. We never get our pizza anywhere but here. I bring friends and family here. Every chance I get because it's absolutely amazing. Excellent service, everything.!!!! read more

Still not open for dine in but they do have outside seating, we ordered the loaded fries and a pie, it came out pretty quickly the girl up front brought us waters while we wait, the fries are AMAZING they were loaded with cheese bacon and more cheese the pizza was okay for me a little underdone on one side but overall it was good food better than the last time for sure read more

See all

I ordered my custom pizza and they offered me a special to get a second cheese pizza for a great deal. I paid about $21 for two large pizzas. I'm glad I got the special because the plain cheese pizza was the best. My kids approved and gave it two thumbs up. I would say the adults would say the pizza is good. I wouldn't get spinach again. It wasn't a great texture. read more

Times Square Pizza Company - Half pepperoni, half meatball and spinach large pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brandon, Florida

See all

This would be the first review I have ever done without eating the food. My son likes this place, and he really wanted their Pizza for his Dinner. I did not want pizza, so I stopped to see if I could get him a Slice & Drink or a Kids Meal. We walked in at 5:03pm. When a female employee walked by and said, "Hello, I will be right with you." So we took the moment to look at the Menu and discovered their Lunch Special of a Slice & Drink was from 11am-5pm and they didn't have any Kids Meals. When she came back at 5:05pm, I inquired about my son wanting to get a Slice & Drink. She informed me that they can't do slices after 5 pm. I find it super odd that if I would have walked in 3 minutes earlier, he could have been served a Slice, but immediately at 5pm, no more slices are allowed. Do they have a machine that immediately discards the pizza being used for slices at 5 pm? This would be the first local pizza restaurant I have seen that does not have some sort of Kids Meal, whether it be a pasta meal, personal pizza, or even slices. I am highly disappointed in this establishment on both accounts. That type of take it or leave it rules will equate to a short life for a strip-mall independent pizza restaurant read more

I've been getting pizza from this place for a long time now and they have the best pizza in the area, everyone is always nice and friendly as well. The menu is all fairly priced too and they regularly do deals throughout the week, just one downside tho is the pizza is usually a little greasy as per every pizza place so there is no avoiding that but a napkin always solves that problem. This place is definitely worth a try read more

Fantastic food and service, and excited to hear one of the owners and workers in this restaurant was one of the kids in The Sandlot movie - Tommy, "The Repeater" kid. Totally respect him leaving Hollywood and now making the pizzas here!! read more

Times Square Pizza Company - Pizza Near Me - Brandon, Florida

Ordered a cheese pizza and Stromboli. The delivery arrived slightly ahead of the estimated delivery time and was cooked perfectly. The Stromboli was one of the best I've ever had and the pizza was a great combination of a thin and crispy crust with an incredible sauce. Nice job! read more

Went here with my family to eat in. It was definitely a hidden gem. I'm from Philadelphia and lived in nyc for 5 years dads from Brooklyn we owned many pizzerias in the north and hands down the best pizza I have had around this area. I am definitely going to be ordering my pizza from here from now on, 30 minutes away it is worth it for me. Keep up the great work! :-) read more

This used to be my favorite pizza for years. It was fantastic. Something changed over past 6-8 months. Pizza is tasteless and thick bland crust. I would guess they skimped on product quality instead of raising prices for the good stuff. Such a shame. Their wings are still good though. read more

I came across this place on a hungry night and I was not disappointed. I ordered the Philly bomb pizza and it was delicious I could've done without the cheddar sauce and maybe add jalapeños but I still enjoyed it . I had a second order this time getting a Philly steak and cheese with jalapeños with a side of curly fries and small pep pizza. I had the sandwich and I can confirm that I will be returning without a doubt . Small pep was enjoyed as well by fiancé . If you get a chance give them a try. read more

Tried this place today for a quick cheap bite, they had 2 slices and a soda for $5.99 which my boyfriend and I shared. It was fine but nothing special, not bad but wouldn't go out of my way to return. If I was shopping in that plaza I would stop in though. I got the meat lovers slice and boyfriend got the times square special, slice size was inconsistent......mine was nice and large but his was much smaller. Boyfriend also wanted 12 wings but they only had 10 so that was odd, said they could charge us for the 12 but we would only get 10 since that was all they had.....Nah, no thank you. read more

Times Square Pizza Company - Meat lovers slice. - Pizza Near Me - Brandon, Florida

Thank you for this delicious pizza and calzone! Glad we got to try you! Will be back for more soon!!! read more

Times Square Pizza Company - Sorry forgot to take the photo first.. too yummy! - Pizza Near Me - Brandon, Florida

This place is hit or miss. The first time we ordered from here (about a month ago) the pizza and wings were amazing. Today, not so much. The pizza barely had any sauce and cheese and our wings were dry and hard. My Family and I are calling it chicken jerky. I called and complained, and they offered me 20% off of my next bill. I got off of the phone and tried to keep eating, but we just couldn't do it. So I called back and asked if we could have our wings replaced. The girl placed me on a brief hold, came back to the phone and told me that they acknowledged that the wings are overcooked, but that they cannot make us some more because they would most likely end up the same way. She offered to credit my account for the wings. I don't know if I'll be ordering from this place again. It's a shame because the food that we got the first visit was so good! read more

Times Square Pizza Company - Chicken Jerky - Pizza Near Me - Brandon, Florida

We would have preferred to dine in, but totally understand during this Covid crap! Pizza was certainly worth it, nice, fresh & hot! Missed that NY style pizza. I would normally drive out to Plant City to get my pizza, not any more! Thank you Times Square Pizza! On another note - Kenzie was awesome! read more

Ordered a small pizza with cheese, sausage, mushrooms and green peppers. Garlic cheese bread. Zeppoli. This was $32.00 worth of food. The pizza barely had cheese on it and the peppers were raw, mushrooms canned and I didn't even notice the sausage. The garlic cheese bread was a small sandwich roll with maybe 2 oz of cheese on the whole thing. The zeppoli was probably the best thing and they were okay at best, pretty sure they were baked. Frozen pizza would have been betters a Totinos frozen pizza that you can get at Walmart for $1.25. read more

So I have had authentic NYC pizza several times. This is by far the closest to the real deal anywhere around Tampa! I highly recommend. We have had pizza from here four times now and every single time it has been on point. I don't usually judge places on one visit- so I can definitively say it's great! read more

I love the pizza here! I'm from this area, and it's just like home . My family has made it our new favorite pizza place!

Love this place! Great Philly Cheese Steaks, made with real Amoroso's bread and "whiz"! They even have a Philly Cheese Steak pizza, which is as good as the sandwich. The meatlovers pizza is also awesome. They have two pin ball machines tucked into a corner to keep the kids busy, so bring quarters. They have Daily Specials making the price better than the chain takeout pizza places. read more

Times Square Pizza Company - Meatlovers - Pizza Near Me - Brandon, Florida

See all

This is my second time eating here the first time it was AMAZING! not busy and very fast. However, I returned this time and im extremely disappointed. I got the Philly Cheese steak no bell peppers extra mushrooms. When I got home I started to pick at the meat that fell off the sandwich. The meat tasted like dirt as I chewed it had a crunch. The more I looked at the sandwich it seems the grill was not cleaned and all the black bits ended up in my sandwich. read more

See all

Price advertised should be your actual Price charged . There's a lot to be said for honesty ! Shame read more

We stopped in after reading some of the reviews. I love NYC style pizza, and this was supposed to be good. We stopped in for a couple slices, and we were the only ones in the place. When we got our slices, although nowhere near the size of a slice that you'd get in NYC, the taste was pretty close! We thought that it was good enough to take a pie home. We ordered some wings, and an antipasto salad. My wife likes the wrongs, but the salad, I wouldn't order again. I felt they skimped on the meats and cheese, compared to all the others that I've had elsewhere. The pizza however... Didn't look like the pizza we had in the shop, let alone taste the same. Reminded me of school pizza. Bottom line, eat in the restaurant. read more

Only takeout during covid, daily specials, delicious pizza! Closest I can find to a NY slice down here. The Times Square pizza is delicious. Call to order it's best. read more

All the other pizzas were good but the wings don't have much sauce and they are dry today the pizza Was overcooked and the crust was hard but don't come at night the pizza isn't as good as the daytime pizza read more

It's not often that I am surprised by a restaurant, especially one I've passed a million times thinking that for some reason I had eaten there before and didn't like it, or by just the location itself that it couldn't be good. Well, my visit to Times Square Pizza the other day would define those thoughts, as I could've sworn I'd been there before, but wow was I wrong. Reliving the weekly debate with the kids of "what do you want to eat?", led me to this establishment as I was tired of going to our usual pizza jaunts and wanted to try something new. The 3.5 Star review on Yelp immediately left me skeptical, but because there were so few reviews I decided to roll the dice. Well, surprise surprise!!! Not sure what other people have encountered, but from the time I walked in, till the time I finished my food, the overall experience was top notch. The girl at the front was super friendly and accommodating, and the food itself has now made this place my number one in the Brandon/Valrico/Bloomingdale area. Incredible crust on the pizza to go along with the fresh ingredients and perfectly cooked pie. Just so happens that they were also running a special the night I was there for a large pizza with the works for $12, BEST DEAL IN THE AREA. Also got an X-Large cheese pie, and for giggles, a Philly Cheesesteak. Can't begin to reiterate how great everything was (okay, only complaint was that the Cheesesteak was a little small, but it was only around $5, so I couldn't be that upset). I implore you to try this place and let me know what you think. Do yourself another solid and check out the daily specials they have, as they too are rock solid. Ohh yes, like Arnold says..."I'll be back!" read more

See all

Online ordering says they offer BOGO and also gave the option to order all flats for wings and charged extra but of course neither was received. Pizza is not NY style at all and the crust is not tasteful. Very disappointed after paying $43.00 for one pizza and 12 wings. read more

Got a pizza here the other day and ended up throwing it out. I am a pizza lover and for me to throw it away says alot. It had a burnt bottom and tasted horrible. read more

I'm not sure why this place has low ratings. I have been there twice and I have enjoyed my pizza each time. I love the Monday through Wednesday specials. The pizza taste better than A LOT of surrounding pizza shops. It even heats up great. You have to try their pepperoni stick, it's so darn good and for only $2. Give this place a try it is really good. read more

Times Square Pizza Company - Pepperoni sticks - Pizza Near Me - Brandon, Florida

Hallelujah! I finally found a pizza joint in eastern Hillsborough County worth a flip! This place was recommended by several over the past few months and we finally got around to visiting. If you're looking for authentic, New York style pizza, this is the place! On the inside, the place doesn't look like much. It's a little dated/run down, but there are pinball machines and some 80's Atari's arcade games. The wait staff and other employees were very friendly. We go a large meat lovers pizza. Huge portions and lots of toppings. We also ordered two drinks. The drinks are unlimited, but the refills are behind the counter, so an employee has to get them for you. The place looked clean, and when we were done, the staff came out and cleaned up the table (there aren't any trash cans out on the dining room floor). The pizza itself was great! Not too greasy, it wasn't burnt on the bottom, and the meat toppings were delicious. I will say that it was about a 15 minute wait, which isn't too bad, but when you're hungry it seems like forever! All in all, we've finally found our "forever" pizza joint. Great place! read more