This place sucks. Ordered online about a year ago, paid, and go to pickup...door locked and nobody there. Had to fight tooth and nail to get my money back. Just went tonight, ordered online, pizza not even made. The fuck is wrong with this place? Been here for years. read more

If you like New York / New Jerswy pizza this is the place. Just order it well done and it will come out perfect. Also for the Jersey transplants he serves breakfast. Come and get your pork roll egg and cheese sandwich. read more

Formaggio's at Riverhills - This is the Works Pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Lithia, Florida

See all

Awesome food and great customer service. I had a "small" Stromboli that was enormous and very tasty. We ate it there and got to watch as he prepared other orders and put them in the pizza oven. Quality pizza and as fresh as it gets. read more

Pizza was great, great tasting, great size and cooked perfect. Owner is a great guy. If you read this, give them a shot. Local small business, show your support! read more

It Been a while since i been Here But I Rember How Good The Pizza was Here it Was Great, I Get Pepperoni Pineapples and Mushrooms on my Pizza there and Is Great nerver Disappoints read more

I cant give a good review since my delivered pizza took twice as long, by the time it arrived it was warm at best and semi soggy. Sorry guys! Im sure it is delicious when fresh. No repeats for me. read more

I live very close to this restaurant and have never ever tried it, but I was craving a cheesesteak and this came up in my Yelp search so I thought I would give it a go. Oh mylanta!!! This was exactly what I wanted. I keep trying cheesesteaks from places, getting lame cheesesteaks, being disappointed, and never curing my craving. This placed cured it! It's a tiny little spot, and we did not dine in. It has typical pizza shop vibes. The staff was absolutely friendly and pleasant. My boyfriend and I both got cheesesteaks with fries. Their fries are ok. Their cheesesteak was out of this work. The meat was flavorful, tender, and seasoned perfectly. It was perfectly cheesy. The veggies added so much flavor, and the bread was fantastic. I will be back over and over again! read more

Pizza is good and the staff if super nice. Food comes out quick. These guys truly care about their customers.

Best pizza in Valrico I've had by far. Specifically love the margherita pizza. Great owner/atmosphere

Great pizza! I stopped in for the 2 slice special. I ended up getting a full cheese pie! You Definitely won't be disappointed as a pizza lover! read more

10/10 service 10/10 pizza the best tasting pizza that I've had even better than Eddie and Sam's in Tampa. Closest NY pizzza that you will get here. Love this place. read more

The pizza is amazing. I love really good New York style pizza. Some of the other pizza joints need to take notice because Formaggio's is very consistent. read more

Ordered an 18" pepperoni and pineapple, my family loved it! Owner was in the back making everything fresh, and truly cared about his food. He was eager to either leave your pizza in the oven longer, or take it out to leave it undercooked and floppy if that's your preference. Great experience and total breath of fresh air compared to his competitors read more

Amazing pizza and extremely good service they made us a fresh pie in not even 10 mins. Owner is very wholesome and kind. They have all sorts of italian food not just pizza. Highly recommend for a pizza place that's not a chain. read more

Great little restaurant in three outskirts of town. Food was great. Prices are little high. Quality of food is ok. Nothing to write home about. Probably try again in the future. Nothing I could say I long for. Service was great. Meals were delivered. All be it, it took over an hour which I feel is a lot. read more

We just moved to the neighborhood and Formaggios had solid pizza reviews. I ordered in store so it was hot and fresh, a cheese pizza with sliced sausage topping. I'm admittedly a pizza snob, lived in New Haven CT area for 25 years. The pizza was just ok, no better than the Papa John' s I got in metro Atlanta. The biggest disappointment was that the sausage was large crumbles, not sliced like advertised on the menu. The sliced sausage works better for me - you get some crispy edges that way. The crust was chewy, but there was not a crispy bottom. Sauce and cheese fine, nothing remarkable. Overall, call me disappointed. If this pizza showed up in a Papa John's box, it would have met my expectations. I expected more from an independent guy. read more

Formaggio's at Riverhills - Sausage pizza with nuggets, not slices as on menu. - Pizza Near Me - Lithia, Florida

Best pizza around I make the drive from plant city and pass over a dozen pizza places on the way just to get Formaggio's it's the perfect amount of fluffy yet still crispy in every bite ! read more

We order 1 large cheese pizza and being from New York I like my pizza extra crispy. When I went to pick it up and heard them cut into my pizza. Oh man, the only thing u can hear is crunch! It was the best pizza!! read more

Great pizza and garlic knots!!! They can get busy in the evening, so get your order in early!!! :-)

We love their pizza and get their lunch special (2 slices and a soda) often. The best part is Eli is always so nice and accommodating to all our needs. read more

The owner Frank is an absolute jerk. Customer service sucks so bad that even if the food is pretty decent, I'm not interested. West shore, Marcos, and a few other local spots are far better overall. Not to mention cheaper and not made by burn outs. read more

I just picked up my first pie here tonight. My local friends had told me this is the best pizza locally. I've gotten pizza at two local places. One was just ok, the other very good. This place has been the very best, so far, if you like NYC style pizza. The crust is very thin. All of the ingredients are good quality and delicious. The only thing I would say, but way of recommendation, not criticism, is that the mushrooms didn't seem fresh. I think that fresh mushrooms would contribute to both texture and flavor. Of course, we know what they say about opinions! read more

Buffalo chicken pizza was a hit with the family also tried the peppers. The kid working there was very nice. No complaints nice take out pizza. Oh and it was thin crust. read more

Formaggio's at Riverhills - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lithia, Florida

See all

Ordered the buffalo chicken pizza , crust was okay clearly had frozen chicken strips on top. Would expect fresh chicken breast not the frozen kind you can buy in your local grocery store! read more

Their pizza is fantastic; we always take out and it is one of our favorite places in the area.

wanted to give this place a try and as close to our new home. Called in a calzone order for pick up. arrived early and they were not busy. They were nice enough, but the calzone was burnt (black) on the bottom. read more

Food was excellent. Pizza and Greek Salad. Ordered as carry out due to kitchen rehab. Enough food for two people for two days. Pizza nice and hot and Greek Salad was fresh with plenty of potato salad and dressing. 2nd time ordering there and will continue. Service on phone very professional. I did not pickup so guess that was good. Value was great for the amount of food. read more

I've eaten and enjoyed their pizza for many years. However, they told me tonight they're not delivering. I guess our relationship has come to an end. October 8, 2022. read more

Josh makes the best pizza in the area. New York style and I get it well done. Funny story he has worked there for 15 or more years and then ended up owning the place. Such a great guy and a great pie read more

Update: 6/6/16 Oh my, what in the world happened to Formaggio's in the span of 2 months? Ordered delivery from here a couple days ago & was VERY disappointed to say the least. I've placed delivery orders numerous times with the owner in the last 6 months, but never with such hostility & snark. The last 2 times I ordered, he said, "Sorry, I'm closing early". Okaaaay. Tried again. This time, he made it perfectly clear that, in order for him to bring my food to me, I'd need a "minimum order of $20", which has never been required before. I guess times must be tough? Ordered large sausage & bacon pizza & garlic-cheese breadsticks. Both arrive late, when the business closes. Owner obviously planned this delivery for when he was going home for the night so we ate very late, well after the dinner hour. I pay $30, not including tip. I hate that :/ Pizza looks like a big grease ball & tastes like it, too (tried to blot the grease, it just lifted the messy cheese!). I ate 1 piece & it sat in my stomach all night like a heavy rock. The rest went in the garbage the next day. The garlic breadsticks were reheated the next day, cheese didn't reheat right, went in the garbage. Garbage food. Never again. I'm done. Bye bye now :D read more

See all

We love the pizza, calzone & meatball subs, but I had a disappointing steak & cheese sandwich tonight. I know I should not be getting a steak & cheese at a pizza place, but I'm trying to make a slightly healthy food choice & this was it. Anyway. It looked like 3 steak-Ums that weren't even pulled apart and just cooked stuck together. So...don't ever get the steak & cheese. Stick with anything else. Their delivery & other fees were not as excessive as most places & it was easy to order online. read more

One of the best Pizzas I've had. The crust was perfect and the toppings were flavorful and fresh. I ate one more slice than I should have. Had too. read more

We ordered a calzone to go. It was ready when promised and was very tasty. It was filled with lots of delicious veggies and cheese. It came with a generous portion of pizza sauce for dipping. I would definitely try Formaggio's again. read more

I ordered a very simple large cheese pizza two hours later after two calls I was told it would not be coming. I was told that the driver was there which was baloney cause I left the front door open with the screen door closed I was sitting in the living room and I have a dog so if anyone came to the door I would've known about it very easily. A major disappointment, I was home sick I couldn't leave to go out and get anything it was a nightmare and all I got was excuses and lies I won't use them again. read more

Wanted to try a different pizza place - read a lot of reviews on Yelp - regretting my choice. The pizza was to greasy and everyone dissatisfied. Will not be going back - now we all have upset stomachs. read more

I understand that a lot of businesses were ruined by the 'pandemic'. This place used to be fantastic. We ordered pizza for pickup from here a week ago and it was just about the worst pizza we'd ever had. Had very little flavor, except for the very sweet tomato sauce. read more

Service stinks. The male workers are rude. Go to a different pizza place. I was going to order but after I saw the dirtiness of this place and the worker's attitudes I changed my mind. Go some where else. read more

Enjoyed this pizza for the first time recently. It was pretty good... nice flavor, right amount of sauce, good balance on the ingredients, tasted nice but not 'gourmet', crust was ok (I expected better, deducting 1 star for the "ok" crust). Place is mainly for takeout, too small to eat in-house. It's a bit of a drive out for us, but if I'm in the area... sure, I'd takeout again. read more

Always a place to go...Have to wait though...but worth it. Proud to support a retired marines family business. Will add that the cooks must add beard and hair nets...come on guys. Basic stuff for food safety and food safety managers. And putting the pizza spatula on top of the pizza oven..ew! Cool people though. Four stars because of the cleanliness. read more

Formaggio's at Riverhills - Always good for us. - Pizza Near Me - Lithia, Florida

This place is THEE place to stop and grab a pie, you won't be disappointed! Their cheese bread, knots and pasta dishes are also delicious. read more