Always a great meal here. My family loves the garlic knots and pizza. The owner is so personal.

I ordered via DoorDash. I know prices are inflated on there with extra fees. A large pepperoni pizza was $18.49 and 10 lemon pepper wings were $14.75 plus tax, fees and tip. The pizza arrived as shown in the picture I posted. I wouldn't think an establishment with such high reviews would send me pizza with burned parts on it. The bottom of it was so burned it was like eating cardboard. The taste of the cheese, pepperoni and sauce was good so I'm sure an unburned pizza would be superb. The lemon pepper wings lacked seasoning. The blue cheese helped with this. Other than that they tasted like plain unseasoned wings. This place has come highly rated by many of our friends. Although I am completely disappointed with my first experience with them, I am willing to give them a second chance. read more

Justin’s Pizza - Lemon Pepper Wings - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

See all

Terrible management and customer service. The owner gave me one wait time, immediately went back on his word by adding more time, and responded with pure attitude when asked about it. They treat DoorDash and Uber Eats drivers like trash here. If you can't respect the people helping your business run, you shouldn't be in business. read more

It's the only place I can get close to NY pizza without being go there. If it wasn't a ride I'd get my pizza from them all the time. There's nothing more like a slice of pizza with a glass of wine. 10 out of 10. Service is alway pleasant and. It feels like a nice homey pizza shop. read more

Pizza was really good and the staff were very friendly and helpful. It was quick and I had an overall very pleasant experience!

Great food made by great people! Always a pleasure when ordering from here. I've been going almost weekly for several years now

We love Justin's pizza and we would love more if there were more well-garnished on the toppings.

They have the best pizza. And their lemon pepper wings extra crispy are some of the best in town. Highly recommend

Great tasting pizza! I ordered a pizza with ricotta cheese, black olives, and garlic. Soooo good! The guys were really friendly and communicated well to keep me posted on when my pizza would be ready. You can dine in. They have booths. Everything looks clean. read more

See all

I anticipated a mind blowing meal, based on reviews, however, I was very disappointed. Ordering: very easy to order over the phone. Ready to pick up within 25 minutes. Food: lackluster, flavorless and soggy. We ordered wings and subs, but maybe that's where we went wrong. Perhaps we should have ordered a pizza instead. The wings were soggy and lacked flavor. The subs were dry and definitely not cheesy enough. May try a pizza next time, but this meal was definitely a below average experience. read more

Justin’s Pizza - Chicken Cheese Steak Sub - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

See all

My wife and I wanted some pizza and didn't really want the large chain delivery options. We typically go to Mellow Mushroom but didn't feel like sitting down at a restaurant. My wife found Justin's Pizza and we were pleasantly surprised. We placed an order for pickup. A large meat lovers and the garlic bread. We drove on over and were initially confused. The online directions brought us to a food truck on 301. After figuring out the place was definitely not there, we mapped it again. This time it showed up on the other side of 301 in the Winn Dixie plaza. The guys at Justin's confirmed they have had issues with the Google maps directions. Our food was ready when we arrived. The place is small. A few tables to sit at. A couple fridges with soda and other cold items. The staff was friendly and invited us to let them know how we like the food. We got home and dug in. The pizza looked pretty good! A thinner pizza with plenty of meat and cheese on it. A little on the greasy side but flavorful. The grease dripped down the crust but it wasn't overwhelming. We each had a few slices and we were happy with it. Hot, fresh and worth the price. The crust had a good bread flavor to it as well. Not too much char or anything. Brown and crispy. The garlic bread with cheese was a different story. We ordered it thinking it would be garlic bread, as in the long thin sticks of baked white bread. Instead we got what looked like a whole wheat sub sandwich roll that was cut open, filled with butter, some parley and little bit of garlic and then popped in the toaster oven. The cheese wasn't really there either. There was some but it was hit or miss. It was not very flavorful and we didn't finish it. And that was $4. All in all, we would go back. We would definitely try their pizza again but we will not order the garlic bread. The staff was friendly and the service was quick. If you're looking for a local pizza place, check Justin's Pizza out! read more

Justin’s Pizza - Meat Lovers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

See all

One of the best New York style pizzas out in the Riverview area. I'd say a little pricey but very good tasting. Unfortunately me and the kids love pepperoni and bacon. But on our first try here they forgot the bacon. But I will say still it was a good experience. read more

See all

Get a slice every time I get a cut at Cindy's barber shop next door. One of the few places that sells slices and it reminds me of back in NY. Good solid cheese slice. Nothing fancy but always hits the spot. read more

There was little to no sauce on my pizza which was very disappointing. A good pizza must have a good amount of thick sauce to really be delicious. I did ask for extra marinara so they gave me that and these little cups but it was a very watery sauce. If they can fix their sauce issue this could be a very good place to eat. read more

Well, it is a bit of a drive for us but we decided to take a ride down and check out this establishment. Justin's pizza makes a fantastic pepperoni pizza. Hot, fresh, delicious crust, sauce is good, cheese is on point and the Pepperoni is not spicy which I personally prefer. They also make a very good chef salad and their cheese fries are very good. The staff is friendly and when you're there they're happy to see you. While there is certainly nothing fancy about this establishment in anyway that just doesn't matter because the pizza is THAT GOOD.. They did everything they could to make us feel welcome. Frankly this place reminds me of some of the pizza places near where I grew up in New Jersey. If you want a good pie stop in here! read more

Justin’s Pizza - The counter - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

Ordered basic pepperoni pizza and regular cheese slice to go. ( first time ordering here ) Would order again thanks ! read more

Justin’s Pizza - Justin's pizza outside store - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

See all

When I'm the area this is the place I go when I want some good pizza and not to mention their wings very friendly the guys and funny lol and dad doesn't stay behind as for as the atmosphere it's good nice place to sit and eat I always do anyways now I'm hoping I can get my picture of my favorite pizza was there last week and I sure did forget to write my review like I like doing...I thought I was able to eat both but I wasn't lol Took for the next day to eat...taste better anyways the next day lol guess it's a New York thing...by the way they are from Jersey so it's real pizza see ya soon... read more

Justin’s Pizza - Good a$& Pizza lol - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

Always great. Pizza is good. Better to pick up than wait for delivery. Look forward to our next order. read more

I'm all for 2nd chances... and that's it. They forgot to put pepperoni on the slice ($3.50) we waited for and this is the smallest most pathetic cheesesteak I think I've ever seen. All the potential, so much wasted. read more

Justin’s Pizza - Cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

New to the area. Found this place on Yelp. Pizza we had was good, will try again with another flavor. Hot wings were good, but not very hot (spicy). They could improve the blue cheese dressing- not very good. No veggies with the wings (usually celery is served with it. read more

I'm allergic to tomatoes, but I would risk everything for a slice of Justin's pizza! Hot, cheesy, great tasting sauce -- did not disappoint! My boyfriend is born and raised in NY and I'm pretty sure that he ate more than half this box by himself! I know food pricing has gone up due to availability, but the quality is so absolutely worth it! read more

We have always craved a good NY style pizza for a reasonable price in this area, and then we ran into Justin's! I can't say enough good things about this place. We love the Pizza, the calzone, the wings, the salad. They are consistent and quick every single time, and always so friendly! I recommended all of our friends/family and now they are hooked too. read more

Justin’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

We ordered Justins pizza tonight as I have seen lots of great reviews on this place. The menu is extensive....so much to choose from. We went with a medium build your own pizza with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers and anchovies. We also ordered 10 wings with a medium garlic sauce and a side of ranch. The pizza was great. Lots of flavor, good crust, really good sauce and fresh veggies. The wings were awesome. They were covered in sauce and full of flavor. My lips are still tingling from the flavor! When we picked up the order the guy at the counter told us how to order the same items next time and save some money just by ordering a little differently. We will definitely be back! read more

Justin’s Pizza - Medium Build Your Own Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

See all

I wanted pizza so I looked online and saw that Justin's was close to me. The menu and pictures looked promising. The establishment is pretty clean all around. But the pizza was not a hit at all. I ordered a pepperoni pizza, and hot garlic wings. The wings are really big wings that are unseasoned with mushy skin. And the pizza was extremely greasy. I really expected more from this place. Definitely won't eat here again. read more

Justin’s Pizza - Pepperoni Quarto Formaggio Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

this place is sooooooo good would definitely choose this over pizza hut any day. I got bacon as a topping!

The food is awesome. We just moved into the area an we wanted a local pizza spot that had good pizza. I saw on the menu online that they had Stromboli and since a good Stromboli is my weakness I gave them a try. The pizza was made perfect and was hot and fresh. The Stromboli was to die for. It was hot and fresh and just like I get it when I am up north. The service was great. They are where all working and knocking out orders quickly and they were so nice. The place really made me feel like I was back home up north at some of my fav pizza joints. My kids loved the pizza and decided that Justin's goes on our list of places to get real fresh and great pizza. We demolished the pizza and Stromboli before I remembered to take a pic. read more

THIS IS SINGLE HANDEDLY THE BEST FREAKING PIZZA OF MY DAMN LIFE!!!!! We ordered the xl cheese and pepperoni and the Quatro Formagio(different cheeses) the flavor was phenomenal from the delicious cheeses to the tasty meat and riding the wave of grease right into heavens gate. Gotta go eat way more now bye. read more

Justin’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

See all

First time ordering from here. Got a Buffalo chicken pizza. It was more like a Buffalo cheese pizza. There was 5 or 6 tiny pieces of chicken, but like the kind of chicken that goes in a chicken cheesesteak. Sad excuse for Buffalo chicken pizza. Make it right or take it off the menu. read more

Justin’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

Great wings, pizza, meatballs, sausage and so much more! Service is amazing. Deliveries always hot and timely. read more

This place is becoming my regular pizza joint. The pizza is really good and larger than other places (think their large is the other guys extra large). This is a family business with great service and great food. read more

Honest and trustworthy review Went for the first time Saturday on the way back into Riverview and decided to give it a try. Ordered garlic bread with cheese and a cheese (this was conveyed very clearly)calzone. Results: Made it home and found that the Garlic bread was hard and overcooked with no cheese. And the calzone had cheese (yay) and ham (what?) on it. I called them back to ask about the calzone and they said they put ham on all calzones! My son doesn't like meat!!!! Hence the reason I said CHEESE ONLY. So I had to drive ALL the way back to get a CHEESE only calzone. And to boot they didn't seem very remorseful that they screwed up my order. This will unfortunately be a one and done for our family. read more

My new favorite pizza spot. It's really good and it's not a chain pizza place so I love that.

Food is always good. Pizza and Chicken Parmesan sub is delicious every time! I also love their crispy onion rings.

From Jersey & I must say, I'm impressed! Very good, was not expecting it to be & the chicken wings were on point. read more

Justin’s Pizza - So good only 1 left out of 2 orders. - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

We decided to try Justin's because it was close to our home and the menu offered so much. We are New York transplants and were definitely pleased with the pizza. They didn't skimp on the toppings and it was cooked perfectly! We also ordered wings that were also cooked perfectly. They have our business along with 5 stars read more

Justin’s Pizza - Large pie with pepperoni, sausage and bacon. Other pie is half green peppers and mushrooms. - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

My family ordered dinner here for the first time today. After reading the reviews, I was expecting delicious food, but what we got was a burned Cuban sandwich and underdone cheeseburger. I was planning to try their pizza in the future, but probably won't do that anymore. So disappointed! read more

Justin’s Pizza - Underdone Cheeseburger - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

See all

We ate here, due to they had dine in available. They were really nice, the place is clean and so are the restrooms. We had pizza and meatballs. We were charged $13 and change for 2 slices of pizza, 2 meatballs and 2 drinks. Not bad, but the food was ok. I appreciate and support small businesses, but we won't be back. We recommend you try it for yourself and make your own decision. read more

Justin’s Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

See all

The only thing wrong with this place is it's not closer to me. The pizza is the best I've had since moving from New York. It's tucked away by a Winn-Dixie. Great prices, too! read more

Ordered pizza and cheesesteak sub. Pizza tasted good but was warm, not hot. I don't live very far away so not sure why it wasn't hot since delivery was 10 minutes early. Cheesesteak was not as requested. Specifically requested "no mushrooms" and even said 'Please'. Don't give mushrooms to someone who hates them, it can make them not ever return. It's really hard to pick them out of cheesesteak. On the fence about returning. read more

Would give 0 stars. Placed an online order through their website, showed up at the time selected (noon).. google says they open at 11, door says 12... NOBODY WAS THERE. Waited 20 minutes!!!! Spent $40 on food I never received.. disputing with bank. Tried to call business multiple times and you can't even leave a voicemail. read more

Justin’s Pizza - Review - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida