Would give 0 stars. Placed an online order through their website, showed up at the time selected (noon).. google says they open at 11, door says 12... NOBODY WAS THERE. Waited 20 minutes!!!! Spent $40 on food I never received.. disputing with bank. Tried to call business multiple times and you can't even leave a voicemail. read more

Justin’s Pizza - Review - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

Being from NY, I've had my share of GREAT slices of pizza from some pizza legends! Tougher to find in Florida. An unassuming pizza joint in the Winn Dixie plaza...to be honest, it's been there a year and I never noticed. Once I saw it, it was time to give it a ride! I stopped in, owner was a personable guy from up north and the pizza was good! I got a regular cheese slice so I could make a sound opinion and it was solid! Better than I expected, nice little surprise. Been there a few times since then! read more

Justin’s Pizza - Cheese slice; meatball and garlic slice - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

This little place has some awesome pizza one of the best around. They also have great sandwiches and wings. This is a small place in a win dixie plaza if you want some great pizza then you should try this one. read more

The food is always great here and the employees make you feel like family!! The are very accommodating if you don't want something which I appreciate!! read more

Some really solid pizza here! It's definitely on the thin crust side but very flavorful. Their sauce has a really robust flavor and is becoming one of our go to spots for pizza! I would definitely recommend you give them a try if you're in the area! read more

Overall pretty good! I liked the small onions added to the cheese of the garlic bread, a nice touch. The lemon pepper wings were crispy and a light but noticeable lemon flavor, not to overpowering. Considering it was delivery I'm impressed how crispy and hot they were once we got them. The pizza, a simple cheese, pep & bacon, had a nice blend and was cooked just right read more

We live close by, so new restaurants are always exciting. On a lazy Saturday, we decided to pop in for a slice. I had the lunch special which was 2 slices of pizza and a drink for $5. The crust was thin and crispy, and just the right amount of sauce and cheese. I also added ham and pineapple- which is my favorite! My bf has the chicken philly and they made it exactly how he likes it. I have a feeling he will be "disappearing" every now and then to sneak in a visit for a chicken philly! I hope Justin's is here to stay! read more

Justin’s Pizza - Pineapple and ham pizza-lunch special. Delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

Having been raised in NJ, near Philadelphia, I found many taste disappointments failures to live up to my expectations. Justin's Pizza has returned the flavors I grew up with. While their cheese pizza is delicious their Grandma Gourmet Pizza is a killer. It's the best I've ever had. It's loaded with the flavors I grew up with. read more

Awesome pizza -- has become our favorite place. We have gotten pizza from many establishments in this area and this my is 1st review ever. So see they rank high - fresh, so tasty and great service. read more

Justin’s Pizza - Pizza from Justin's!! Sooooo good!!! - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

I am in love! This pizza is delicious and the people that work there are awesome! Perfectly seasoned, perfect thin crispy crust, and a single gal like me can get a slice or two when I dont need a whole pie! I found my new go to spot in Riverview...and its so close to my house!!!!!:) read more

Justin’s Pizza - Pizza perfection! Yum! - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

Delicious pizza (especially the crust) and gracious owners! Definitely will be a repeat customer.

Customer service was great! Dude reminded me of Joe Pesci, aside from that the food is amaze balls! Definitely gonna be the new go to spot for pizza AND salad! read more

Justin’s Pizza - Antipasto salad - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

Pizza was phenomenal! Hand rolled garlic knots and a large fresh salad... yum plus the pepperoni on the pizza was just how I like it- crispy on the edges This will be our new neighborhood go to, highly recommend! read more

You should take my rating pretty seriously because I'm a native New Yorker and also I never write reviews on yelp. But this pizza is dank. And cheaper than everything around. This place is my go-to now. read more

Justin’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

Ordered a pizza via Doordash last night. It was absolute fire. Grew up in the tri state area, and this pizza is on point. Took awhile to find it, but pretty positive I won't be going anywhere else for pizza. read more

Fantastic pizza!!! Been trying to find a local pizza spot to be our go to and this place is it! The customer service was truly amazing and very professional. They were extremely friendly and genuinely made me feel welcome which is always a plus. Highly Recommend the 4 cheese pizza! Can't wait to go back! read more

Pizza was great!! We had a pepperoni pizza (carry out) that was cooked to perfection!! Pizza was hot and ready upon arrival. No doughy crust or burnt edges . Staff was very personable! #supportyourlocalbusinesses read more

Justin’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

Love this place. The pizza is great and the owner is better. The pizza is awesome and perfect for lunch or family dinner.

Have ordered for 4 other places since moving here and all were crap. Justin's is the first good place we've experienced. Pizza was great. Chicken wings had good flavor just wish they were a little crispier. Will order again. read more

Good pizza and friendly staff. Had the supreme and it was delicious! The pizza came out fast too!

The chicken speciality sandwich has no peppers, sauce or anything else they advertised. Pizza was also bland and so oily that it made the pizza soggy read more

Justin’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Riverview, Florida

The guys that own this pizza joint are the nicest guys, and they know how to make a good pizza too. Always pretty quick even when they are super busy, and always consistently good. Thanks! read more

Pretty good pizza and wings, I enjoy the calzone and it happens to be located right in front of one of the best carwashes I have ever been to. read more

We did delivery. Now I know traffic is bad. I wasn't even surprised when it popped up that it was going to be a half hour late. However it should have stilled arrived hot. Especially considering the $6.00 service charge. It was barely warm and I use your preffered delivery service. As for the food. Every Parm sandwich I tried to order was out of stock. I don't even know what to say to that when your restaurant is a couple of doors away from Winn Dixie. The food itself, when reheated was just okay. read more

Omg they make their pizza just the way I like it!!!! crunchy and cheeesyyyy! It didn't taste like plain of mozzarella either, I'm curious to what cheeses and herbs they use to make their pizza. The kids loved it too !! read more

Hot damn that's some good a$$ pizza. Sauce is amazing, perfect crust. Simply awesome don't know what else to say

Really good! If your looking for that "up north" taste, this is the place!! They are also VERY generous with the toppings! Glad i found this place!! read more

Great pizza, ordered for Delivery and it was piping hot when it showed up! Definitely my new pizza place!

I have heard many people raving about how good Justin's Pizza is so I went to try it out with my family. We ordered Antipasto Salad, Pizza Slices, Garlic Knots, Wings, Italian Sub, and Chicken Parmesan Sub. We found the food to be OKAY but probably wouldn't return or recomend for others. Upon arriving I found it odd to have a Pizza place directly next to an Italian Kitchen but that was just my observation. The location is small and quaint which is the norm for NY style pizzerias in the area. The man at the counter which I am assuming is Justin was nice but not overly helpful when ordering and seemed to be stretched thin between taking counter orders, phone orders, and cooking. We ordered a variety of food to get a good perspective. The Antipasto Salad was okay but was very odd that it didn't have Banana Peppers on it and they didnt have Italian dressing at all. The Pizza was good but probably the 4th Best NY Pizza in the Tampa area. The Wings were overly fried so they were tough to eat. The Italian sub was also very strange that it didnt have Banana Peppers and tons of Mayo on it. The Chicken Parmesan sub tasted like the breaded chicken breasts were frozen as the ends were hard. Also, the placement of the meat/sauce/cheese for the Chicken Parmesan Sub looks great for pictures but makes folding your Sandwich to eat very difficult and the bread used crumbled/fell apart. The garlic knots were okay but the outside was really done and the inside was almost raw. The food looks great in pictures but not the best for eating. I couldnt recommend this place with a clear conscience unless your other option was McDonalds or Burger King than it's a great option but much pricier. read more

See all

From PA so I'm picky about pizza just like everybody from up north....these guy hit the mail on the head definitely the closet I found to authentic pizza since moving to FL read more

Found my new local pizza place! Food was absolutely delicious and I will definitely be back again! We ordered a sausage and banana pepper pizza and the quarto formaggio and they did not disappoint. Perfect ratio of sauce, cheese, and toppings. read more

Awesome pizza! The eggplant pizza is the best. Hard to find but they have it down to perfection. Cutting the eggplant up into squares makes sure every bite is delicious. read more

Some really good NY style pizza. Great crust, good amount of toppings. Right amount of cheese and sauce. Also had the right amount of grease on top. Fold ability was also great. Would recommend to anyone. read more

Grandmas Pizza and Hot Garlic Wings are my go to any night I need some convenient tasty comfort food.

First time...... pizza was very good ordered wings I prefer baked not fried but tasted good. Will come back read more

What an amazing addition to the neighborhood!! My family hasn't tried one thing yet we haven't liked. The pizzas are cooked to perfection with plenty of toppings and cheese. The owner is very friendly and I love supporting mom & pops. I recommend Justin's Pizza to everyone!!! read more

Best pizza on in Tampa Bay. The service has always been on point. Keep up the great job.

The calzone is fantastic. Pizza is tasty/above average; might not rival downtown Tampa/Seminole Height spots but quality for Riverview-Brandon-Fishhawk... Owner(s) are good people. My family is currently enjoying wings while watching Sunday Football. read more

BEST PIZZA IN THE AREA, HANDS DOWN! I have been ordering from them at least twice a week, it's a problem!! Lol but they are sooo good. BEST cheese, perfect amount of sauce and the Stromboli/Calzones are huge and amazing as well. Do yourself a solid and just order...right now. Owner seems really sweet too! read more

Wow... I never write reviews for food establishments but I felt the need here I ordered 3 items via Grubhub from Justins pizza. I ordered justins specialty pizza, wings, and a caesar salad. They managed to mess up all 3 items. For the "Justins Specialty" pizza it clearly states "anchovies" as one of the toppings. On Grubhub and their direct website. When you order on Grubhub you can deselect the toppings you do not want. When I called Justins pizza to ask why no anchovies their response was they only include the anchovies when people specifically ask for them. So why list it as a topping for the pizza then!?!?!?! totally bs response and they offered nothing to make it right. For the caesar sald I put in the notes "extra dressing please" they gave me ZERO dressing. Imagine a ceasar sald with no dressing. The rude kid that works there must have been trolling because his response to ZERO dressing on the caesar salad was that they didn't know what kind of dressing I wanted..... on a caesar salad.... For the wings I put in the notes "ranch and blue" which it states additional requests may have additional charges. Ok thats fine. still only got blue cheese. Their customer service was terrible, the kid on the phone was rude and told me "next time leave it in the notes that you want anchovies" lol next time? next time??? yeah right. As if they read the notes I did leave!!! I prematurely went on grubhub and requested a refund of the pizza which they provided but it was not until after I realized my salad had no dressing. No I don't have the option to refund it. Don't waste your time with this place. The pizza is pretty bland and the wings suck read more