Ordered a to go Cheese Pizza...arrived and it was very busy inside. Cute little place! Walked in and was greeted and Pizza had just come out..ordered it crispy and it was perfect and lots of Cheese too..it was a very good pie...will be back! read more

See all

Pretty good especially considering I am not a big Chicago pizza kind of fella. But oh my LANTA delicious. Sauce is delicious, cheese is great, dough is delicious. Cooked to utter perfection. I was impressed. Also the service as great, our waitress was so kind and so hilarious, definitely loved it! And the decor in this place was amazing. Loved it. read more

Best pizza ever. Great staff always friendly. We go about every two weeks! It never disappoints. Highly recommend read more

Cappy's Pizza - Dining room always clean - Italian Near Me - Riverview, Florida

See all

Delicious pizza at Cappy's!! The place is small about 5 tables outside and maybe 7 more inside or so. Service was great! Friendly and attentive. They offer traditional NY style crust and a deep dish. We got the pepperoni deep dish and split the Large Cappy which had all the toppings. Also got a salad to start and a small one was enough to split it between 2 people! Super good overall, I loved the pizza and salad alike. Will come back!! read more

See all

Best pizza around! Wonderful salads and service Friendly staff make an all around great time read more

The food is always good and the staff are friendly. We struggled to find good pizza in the area. This is our go to place for New York style pizza. read more

We were looking for a quick bite & decided to give this place a try. We are so glad we did. The calzone was amazing. Both of us were super impressed. Prompt, friendly service. Next time we'll have to try the pizza. read more

Cappy's Pizza - Calzone - Italian Near Me - Riverview, Florida

We went here after going to the movies nearby, as I was living off popcorn as my only source of nutrition for the past seven hours. The first thing I noticed was the cozy, warm interior. On top of that, the music choice that night was great--playing Neil Young, The Beatles, ABBA, and many other great '60s and '70s artists. Remi was our server and was great. You could tell it was a pretty busy night, and she was attentive to every table--we were no exception. We ordered a small (12") New York-style pizza: half cheese (I'm boring, I know) and half with pepperoni, olives, and other various vegetables. I also ordered a draught beer with my pizza--the name is escaping me now, but it was good! We were able to watch our pizza being made fresh from the open kitchen 10-15 feet away from our table. The smell of the pizzas wafting from the kitchen made the whole place smell amazing! Our pizza was out within 10-15 minutes and looked amazing (sadly, the camera did not eat first, and I have no evidence to prove this pizza ever existed other than by word of mouth). My side was the perfect temperature--just below "burn the roof of your mouth" hot--and it was delicious. Remi offered to bring Parmesan, to which I, of course, obliged. There was also oregano at the table, which only added to the great flavors of the pizza. There were two of us, and the pizza was more than enough food for us. Overall, the experience was great--from the atmosphere to the service and, of course, the food. I would definitely recommend Cappy's in Riverview! read more

We order pizza here a lot and I am always hopeful. The sauce and crust are good and the salads are fresh, however the pizza leaves me feeling ripped off. It's $50 to $80 dollars everytime we eat here. Today it was $55 for 1 large peperoni , 1 small peperoni, sausage, mushroom and onion and a salad. I did not know the second pizza had mushrooms until the second slice. I would really like $20 dollars worth of pizza for my money. The toppings are so sparce I have to add to the pizza everytime. read more

Cappy's Pizza - The bottom small slices should be peperoni , sausage and onion, and mushroom. - Italian Near Me - Riverview, Florida

I went twice within the week I found out about this place it was so good, and just happened to be just for Pizza. I'm in the midst of moving with my sister and after a long day of work from building and organizing everything, I just wanted a nice big pizza. This spot was local and had good reviews so I didn't even think twice. I found it cool that not only did that have 2 listed 'options' even though you can really get anything, but they also do Chicago OR New York style!! You don't see that everywhere..The service was amazing and truly helpful both times- we were recognized during my second return. Both times I got the Cappy, Chicago style and both times it was perfectt. Like so yummy, they know how to cook a dang pizza, and consistently. Now I have a new local favorite. Prices are a little high, but I'm okay with it. read more

Cappy's Pizza - The Cappy , No Ham - Italian Near Me - Riverview, Florida

Wow! This is the best tasty Chicago deep dish pizza I'm tasted down south that reminds me of my Home style favorite deep dish pizza from Chicago. As soon as I walked in the pleasant aroma of homemade pizza hit you in the face and immediately my mouth began watering so I knew I was in the right place. On my recent visit to Tampa my friend that lives there recommended this pizza joint and we ordered the Cappy's deep dish. Boy was it good and flavorful!! The Marzano Italian tomato sauce and sausage were as close as you can get to tasting like Chicago style deep dish, also the crust in itself has amazing texture and delicious. I'm back home in Houston and I'm still craving this pizza...LOL. If they shipped I would definitely order it. The ambience was very cool. reminds me of an old-school pizza restaurant from the Midwest with the cool Chicago Bears marquee on the wall so I'm sure the owner that owns this place maybe from the Midwest area. I have not tried the thin flat crust so I cannot comment on New York style, but the Chicago style pizza met my expectations because I was very skeptical at first as a pizza snob. If you're from up north, you would like and appreciate this style of pizza. If not, I understand some of the negative comments as this pizza is made with heavy tomatoes and sauce, more like a pie style pizza, which we call "stuffed" from up north. Anyway, the service was great. The staff were very friendly as we waited about 30 minutes for our pizza to be made, which is completely normal as everything is made from scratch. So if you're familiar with the deep dish style of pizza or if not give it a try as the flavors are result of fresh ingredients which one would like if you're a foodie like me! read more

See all

This was my first time trying this restaurant. Cappy's is located in a nice area with plenty of parking spaces. I went with a group o friends. Once we arrived, we notice that the decorations inside were really cool. I ordered the Chicago style dip dish Cappy. It was very cheese, huge amount of sauce and very tasty. Unfortunately, it took a long time to get the order (almost 50 minutes). It was understandable since they have a lot of people, but that was too much. I'll go again, but probably I'll call and pick it up. read more

Cappy's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Riverview, Florida

See all

I have been wanting to come here for a long time but always seemed to be in the area during their closed hours. On a Sunday at 4:30, we found a pleasant table outside for the 4 of us. Our server was super friendly and quickly brought drinks and took Lori orders. My husband and I settled on a small Chicago style made Cappy's way and a large NY style with pepperoni and onion (we like leftovers). Pizzas arrived and I forgot to take pictures so the pictures I have are what we took home. I started with the deep dish and enjoyed the crunchy crust and the sauce. I didn't really taste all the ingredients but the sauce had a nice kick to it. Next was the NY style, which I wouldn't call NY style as it was very thin at all. It wasn't all that much thinner than our deep dish. I think the sauce is more overpowering and again, couldn't really taste the pepperoni and just maybe a slight taste of onion. I only ate 3 pieces as it was very filling. I walked away thinking of 4 stars as it wasn't my favorite pizza, but service was good and I liked the crust and sauce. It moved down to 3 stars when I was up all night with a bad stomach. read more

Cappy's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Riverview, Florida

See all

Cappys for family dinner night and they did not disappoint. Ordered over the phone had a bit of a wait time but when I got there my order was ready to go. I asked politely for a side of basil and the gentleman at the front got me not one but two which I appreciate very much! The pizza was delicious everyone loved it and the cheese bread is always a hit. read more

See all

Ordered Large Cappy Pizza and Large Greek Salad. Very smooth process to complete the pick up order. Provided an estimated time of 20 minutes, but it was available in about 15 minutes. Unfortunately, the pizza crust was very tough and difficult to cut with a knife. My mother gave up, and just ate the toppings. My husband, who almost never complains, voiced his concerns with the quality of the crust. He said "I think they cooked this too long by the looks of this crust," and pointing at the backside of the crust. The greek salad was the worst! The tomatoes and lettuce were not fresh, in addition to very large portions of green peppers. We were looking forward to our usual good pizza and salad, but it wasn't in the cards tonight. read more

Summary in a sentence: Cappy's's is a must go. Would someone enjoy traditional old hat, Chicago style pizza? Could you possibly even have asked a Chicagoan? Because the answer would almost always be a yes. That being said, expectations of Chicago-style pizza also apply - thus, we know the difference between "pizza with extra cheese" and pizza pie. So I'm giving this a five, but absolutely not for the quality of the food (which is still a solid 4.5, imo) - but because of the ideal outdoor seating options and vegan options, something few and far between for Chicago. They are happy to make all things vegan - from the bread stics, to the salads, to even the deep dish pizza. But, I digress, it is "deep dish" despite them calling it Chicago Deep Dish. It's about half the height you'd get out of a serious vegan deep dish from somewhere like My Pi (3.141592634, haha!) back home. Sorry folks. Maybe they need to offer a "double deep dish" or something to differentiate between "nice thick pizza" and true deep dish. Which, again, is not something I'd say would detract from the generally positive experience that makes Cappy's worth a visit. The vegan bread sticks are great and worth scooping one or two orders worth, and the chopped salad made vegan is classic with a nice Italian dressing. I did notice a tiny bitterness to the vegan cheese - not sure if a quality issue or by design, but otherwise the pizzas were also great and worth getting. You do pay for a premium topping to get a vegan pizza. For a party of 5 we opted for a large chopped salad, a medium deep dish vegan pizza, two orders of bread sticks and the non-vegans got their own pizza. Everyone ended up taking at least a couple slices home. read more

See all

Cappy's Pizza is the best pizza in riverview. The New York-style thin crust option; it's crispy, chewy, and just the right amount of char. The sauce is spot-on tangy-sweet, and the portions are generous. Friendly service, clean spot, and it always hits the spot for pizza night. Highly recommend. read more

Cappy's is located in the Winthrop Town Center in Riverview. We discovered this delicious restaurant after many years. Not sure why it took so long but it has now become a favorite spot! The first time visiting we had a regular traditional thin crust round pizza. It was delicious but the star in this restaurant is the Chicago Deep Dish Pizza! After trying the deep dish it's the only pizza we order here. The sauce and the crust are delicious and we are fans! Along with our pizza we always order a Greek salad. They offer a few kinds of salads but we always order the Greek salad. It's so good and the salad is topped with feta cheese. If you're not a fan of all that cheese, do as I and ask for it on the side. The dressing on the salad is amazing. I recently learned they actually sell the dressing! This pizzeria is not huge and it's always crowded for good reason! They have a few tables outside as well. The restaurant is only open for dinner and I believe the hours are: Mon-Thurs 5-9pm Fri & Sat 3:30-10Pm Sun 3:30-9Pm The staff and all the young servers are all excellent and extremely sweet. read more

See all

Excellent NY pizza! Very fresh. Was totally surprised to walk in and find this gem. We left Acropolis as the wait time wasn't conducive to our plans. read more

Cappy's Pizza - Large NY Cappy style - Italian Near Me - Riverview, Florida

4.6* (out of 5) Food: 5* Atmosphere: 4* Value: 4* Service: 5* Would I go back / Recommend?: 5* (Definitely) Total check/person: $20 05/20/2024 My Dad was up for pizza for dinner, so we looked around the Riverview area and chose Cappy's Pizza. The exterior of the building was a clean, modern brick facade with decking on the upper levels giving it a bit of a European / New Orleans feel. The interior was full of classic agricultural and automotive signs from yesteryear and was well-lit. To start our meal, we ordered a large Greek Salad (see picture) to share and we were not disappointed - it was delicious! We ordered 3 pizzas to share (see pictures) - 2 NY Customs and a NY Cappy. We enjoy thinner crusts and found all of these options to be very good - wood-fired edges with plenty of sauce and toppings. A rock-solid pizza shop that I would recommend and look forward to a return. If you found this review helpful, please show your appreciation with a Like or a Follow. read more

See all

Always amazing! Good location convenient to many neighborhoods and a walkable plaza. Their veggie selection is extensive. The deep dish is so filling, a single slice will do you good! read more

The best Chicago pizza in the area. Always a hit, and the salads are very good as well. They desperately need to offer delivery though. read more

Cappy's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Riverview, Florida

I have eaten in the restaurant and also take out from the New Tampa location. Both were excellent quality and good value for the money.

Dined in on a Tuesday afternoon and got a large Chicago deep dish with meatballs and caramelized onions. A little disappointed that they didn't have ricotta because I think that would have elevated the pizza 10-fold. It was a very solid pizza and the crust was buttery and flaky! The crust is what made it delicious and unique. The sauce was flavorful and it was very cheesy! Even reheated the next day, it tasted pretty good. Not the best deep dish I've ever had but you'll leave satisfied. 3.8/5 read more

Cappy's Pizza - Chicago deep dish with meatballs and caramelized onions - Italian Near Me - Riverview, Florida

We had takeout pizza. It was very good. Close to NY style, and I'm a New Yorker so I have experienced really good pizza in my days on this earth. read more

The best NY pizza in town! The atmosphere is vibey and perfect. They are very quick, especially with takeout orders!

Finally tried this pizzeria after living in Riverview for 6 years. They are only open for dinner. Cappy's specializes in Chicago Deep Dish pizza. They also make traditional round pizza. You can order either type with all kinds of toppings and in several different sizes. The menu also contains three types of salads, bread sticks, and calzones. We tried the Cappy which is like a supreme. We also tried the Chicago deep dish without any toppings. Both were excellent. I think the deep dish is my favorite. They serve tap and bottle beer as well as soft drinks. There is both indoor and outside seating. The pizzeria is not very large and can get crowded. read more

See all

*To go order* Service was divine, everyone I spoke to was kind and patient. I ordered a Chicago deep dish pizza and cheese sticks! I was able to taste the cheese sticks while they were still hot, they were so good! I wasn't able to taste the pizza while it was still hot because they didn't cut it *sad face* but once I got home and I was able to reheat it and cut it, it was pretty good. It wasn't a true deep dish pizza as they do in Chicago but I still enjoyed every bit of the pizza and cheese sticks and the crust of the pizza was so good. I will most definitely be going back FOR SURE! Can't wait to try the thin crust pizza! Can't speak much on the ambiance because I just went to pick up my order but it looked like your typical pizza restaurant. Definitely check them out! read more

See all

Our first time here, my dad and I got a deep dish pizza. The crust is incredibly delicious. The sauce is delicious too. The problem was, the other ingredients didn't have enough flavor (or quantity?) to overcome the taste of the sauce. It was basically like eating a chunky tomato sauce pie. I actually thought they forgot to put the cheese, pepperoni, sausage, and peppers on it. Not a problem, we will get a thin crust next time. Unfortunately, they don't use the awesome crust for the thin crust pizzas. They use a crust that is worse than anything I've ever had from a chain like Dominos or Pizza Hut. And the delicious sauce wasn't overpowering this time because it seems like a teaspoon per slice was all we got. It sucked! We will usually have fried eggs on top of our leftover pizza the next day (try it! It's delicious) but this time there were no leftovers because we threw away 5 slices. read more

Staff are top notch and the food is delicious. Never been disappointed. We love to get a large tossed salad with our pizzas. Chef's kiss read more

Cappy's Pizza - Half cheese half pepperoni - Italian Near Me - Riverview, Florida

I was looking for a local pizza shop around me and Cappys came highly rated. Ive heard great things about their deep dish so we decided to try it! First things first, the service was absolutely amazing. We sat outside and it was a bit chilly. The servers came around and reheated the warming lamps for us and asked if there was anything else they could do. We truly appreciated that. Our order: Cheesy bread sticks Caesar Salad Cheese deep dish pizza Veggie deep dish pizza The appetizers were a perfect intro to everything else! I love a good caesar salad and theirs made me want seconds. Ive never had deep dish before so i was nervous but also curious. Our pizzas were bigger than expected but the flavor was immaculate! The fresh tomatoes, cheese, and the crust were amazing! Unfortunately i only ate two bites and was stuffed. We ended up taking it to go and it tasted even better the next day ! read more

Cappy's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Riverview, Florida

Another great dinner here. This time instead of pizza we decided to get a Cesar salad and a calzone. Salad was awesome. Dressing was flavorful and the croutons were to die for. A great salad. The calzone was prob the best calzone I ever had. Dough was nice and thin and had a great crust to it. Was filled with a ton of cheese and had chopped ham which I think is nicer than sliced ham. For the price it's huge. read more

Cappy's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Riverview, Florida

Food: The pizza here is really good! We try to stop in when we are over in Bloomingdale around lunch time. Atmosphere: The inside is smaller but if there's no seating they have some outdoor tables. The outside area is nice and if the weather is good it makes the experience really enjoyable. Our server was awesome. Crystal is her name. She was informative, thoughtful, and remembered us from last time! Asked about kids drinks and really paid attention to the table. Kids or Date: Cappys does not have a kids menu. But the cheese bread is really good and my kids will devour it. If you're in the mood for a pizza date I'd say sit outside and enjoy the weather and service. read more

Cappy's Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Italian Near Me - Riverview, Florida

See all

Came back last night to buy dinner, and my experience was far better than the last time I went! Service was still great, food only took about 20 minutes, pizza was excellent and the greek salad was fresh! Glad to see them open earlier in the day, meaning I can grab myself great pizza right after work from now on. read more

See all

The food is always great. I've been there about once a month for over three years. Never disappoints. Service is careful and caring. I enjoy the ambiance of a small pizza joint. read more

This has become our go-to pizza spot! We've never dined in, so my review is based on takeout only. Overall, my experience at Cappy's Pizza is always what quick, friendly and tasty. I've ordered the NY style pepperoni pizza a few times now and a NY style pineapple pizza. Each time the pizza tastes fresh and yummy. Never too much sauce and just enough cheese and toppings. Rating: 4 stars for take-out. Once I dine-in I'll write up a new review. read more

Huge fan. So far have only ordered carry out, but being from Chicago area this is the best deep dish we have found down here and it never disappoints. The crust is delish. Service over the phone and always friendly and my orders have always been exactly right. Kind order takers! I crave this place at least once a month lol! The cheese sticks are also delicious. read more

Great deep dish pizza! Friendly staff! I loved this pizza. Crispy crust and super filling! read more

Cappy's Pizza - Deep dish pizza - Italian Near Me - Riverview, Florida

Secret is in their sauce - excellent and so goes the rest of their pizza - need it every week

Want a Chicago style pizza in Florida? You got it at Cappy's. They also have thin NY style but I can't get past the deep dish. Just as good, maybe better than some in Chicago, Cappy's delivers big taste. Craving windy city pie? Head over to Cappy's to scratch that itch. read more