9.5/10 for the vibe, ambiance, and service -- and a full 10/10 for the food. I'm not a picky eater, but I've had some really disappointing oxtail lately, so I was hoping for the best here. I'm Dominican so I know oxtail pretty well and have made it myself. Thankfully, this place absolutely delivered. The oxtail was perfectly slow-braised, tender, and falling right off the bone -- exactly how it should be. Absolutely amazing. Of course I had the rice and peas, plus some veggies. A few of the veggies were slightly overcooked, but still flavorful and enjoyable. The drinks looked incredible, but I went with the rum punch and loved it. It was a little sweet, but super flavorful, strong, and definitely worth ordering again. For dessert, I had the Hennessy cheesecake, which was rich, decadent, and unbelievably delicious. There were three of us dining, and we all left completely satisfied -- with take-home containers because the portions are VERY generous. The only thing that bothered me a bit was that our server seemed to focus most of her attention on my friend. She is Jamaican, and because I look like a white American woman, I felt a little overlooked at times, even when I had several requests myself. We also had to look for her a couple of times while she was sitting with a group nearby. That said, everyone overall was very nice and welcoming. The bussers especially stood out -- they checked on us often, kept everything clean, and even greeted me in Spanish, which I appreciated. Overall, I really enjoyed my experience and will definitely be back with more people next time. read more

See all

The moment we walked in, I knew we were in for an amazing culinary experience. It was my birthday weekend, and we were in New York for an extended stay. For my hubby, Brooklyn is home - and we always love exploring the new places the city has to offer when we visit. We had reservations, and were seated within 10 minutes, which was reasonable. The place was packed - everyone was in high spirits, and I was ready to taste some of the best Caribbean cuisine in the region. My hubby's best friend - a Brooklyn resident, joined us. He had been to the restaurant a few times - and had good things to say. We were not disappointed. I had the Brown Stew Red Snapper - *chef's kiss*. Hubby had the iconic Jerk Oxtail over Macaroni & Cheese Pie! The English language cannot convey the beauty of that combination! Tender, tender oxtail, falling off the bone with the creamy, cheesy mac & cheese! He wanted to savor that dish another day, so he got a to-go bag and took it back to the hotel! (I couldn't help but clean my plate - I was obsessed with the fish!) Our friend enjoyed the Hennessy Fried Shrimp (not pictured) - one of his favorite dishes at the restaurant. It looked delicious as well. For drinks, I had the Bob Marley cocktail. A colorful drink - flavorful - and effective! There were people celebrating their birthdays throughout the night - and the wait staff goes IN! I was enjoying watching at least 10 people receive the Stevie Wonder "Happy Birthday" song while we were there. Imagine my surprise when it was my turn! My birthday was the day before, and we had already celebrated in Manhattan. Having two special recognition events made the evening that much more special! Shout out to the Simpson crew who came with the song, the rhythm, the sparkling cake, and the good vibes! My 70th birthday was exceptional - without a doubt. The Simpson added the touch I needed. We'll definitely go back next time we're in Brooklyn! read more

See all

Initial walk in, the greeting was prompt and warm. We were seated quickly and received water after a short wait. I asked for bottled still water, but the staff member didn't know what they offered, so I decided to wait. Our server came over for drink orders and she was very warm and kind. She took our full order at once. I asked again about bottled water and she confirmed they had Voss, which was perfect. I requested ice on the side. When the water still did not come, I asked a third time. At that point, she told me they only had sparkling water. Ma'am... were you ever going to tell me? Or was I supposed to just sit there guessing and waiting? I was two seconds from going to grab a bottle out of my car. Food: * Cod fish fritters (appetizer): very good, and the aioli really elevated the flavor * Brown stew snapper with veggies, rice and beans, and mac and cheese: the snapper itself was flavorful but not hot, which was disappointing. The veggies lacked seasoning, and the mac and cheese tasted like plain noodles with cheese * Oxtails (my mom): she loved them, but they were just okay to me * Chicken and waffles (my husband): he enjoyed it * Fresh fruit punch: absolutely delicious Service: This is where things went downhill. After the initial interaction, I had to constantly look for our server or any staff member whenever I needed something. Not once did anyone check in to ask if we needed anything or how everything was. That level of inattentiveness is unacceptable. I was extremely annoyed. This is not the experience I expected based on reviews, but then I realized something important. Google and Yelp reviews are very different. Yelp reviewers tend to be more honest and consistent, and I should have listened. Final Thoughts: Traveling all the way from Boston for this experience was a letdown. Between having to chase service and inconsistent food quality, it simply was not worth it. If it were not for how I was raised, the tip would have been 10 percent, and even that would have been forced. Simpson's needs to either hire more staff or seriously retrain their team on customer service. Bostonians: it is not worth the trip. read more

See all

This was my second time here and it's more of a 3.5 star review. Stopped in with a girlfriend of mine around noon after a 5k in prospect park on Saturday. The place wasn't busy when we arrived, but it was by the time we left around 2. Place is a decent size, but it can get super crowded. Service this time was much better than my last visit. Our server Diamond was really cool and open to giving menu recommendations. There was a mix of soca and dancehall playing and I appreciate that it was at an appropriate volume where you could hold a conversation. For drinks, I had "The Pash" which was fine (nothing amazing) and my friend had a mango slush with rum. For the appetizer, we shared the ackee and saltfish bammy bites. Those were really good and I remember liking them. For entrees, my friend got the jerk chicken which she (as a Jamaican) said was super spicy, but manageable once you get past the jerk sauce. I had the Belgian waffles and shrimp. The flavor of both were good, but here's where I had the problem. My waffles came out damn near cold. I sent them back. They were apologetic and I was promised fresh waffles. When they came out the second time, they STILL weren't hot but I dealt with it. This means that it's sitting under a warmer and not "fresh off the press" so to speak. The place is a little expensive for my liking and there are better restaurants for the price point. read more

See all

This is my second time eating at this restaurant and they did not disappoint. The oxtail was succulent and seasoned to perfection and the Mac and cheese had an awesome cheese pull. Everyone was so friendly and respectful from the host to the servers. Although it was kind of loud, it was expected since it's also a sports bar and it drowned out the noise my toddler was making. Overall I'd visit this place again and again because the menu is so extensive and appealing! read more

The Simpson Restaurant & Bar - BK - Jerk Oxtail Over Macaroni & Cheese Pie - Caribbean Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Excellent service! Walked in during a busy dinner hour and only had to wait about 15-20 min. The oxtail dish was so good. Salad I could've skipped. Mac and cheese was flavorful as well. read more

The Simpson Restaurant & Bar - BK - Slow Braised Oxtail and Butter Beans, Classic Caesar Salad, Sweet Plantains, Macaroni & Cheese - Caribbean Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I came in on a Friday around 12:30. The bar was empty so we just sat there. The service was good. The waitresses were nice and gave us good suggestions on what drinks to order. The tacos were delicious! I will say their jerk chicken is spicyyy! I still ate it all but just make sure you have water lol. The mini bites of ackee & salt fish was also good. So we were off to a great start. That rum punch with punch you btw so be careful of that too lol. We split the platter and loved everything on it. Only thing I will say is that the oxtail was a bit salty. I will definitely be back probably for lunch again because I know it gets packed for dinner ! read more

See all

Walked in with no reservations but we were able to grab a seat at the bar. I ordered the jerk salmon and it came with veggies and rice. I initially asked to substitute the rice for mash but they said I was unable to. The rice was dry but had flavor. Maybe next time I'll ask for some gravy on the side. The jerk salmon was ok. Prob will try the snapper next time. The rum punch was rummy just the way I like it. I had 2 and it put me in a good place. This place is always crowded. It can take forever to get the bartenders attention but she was polite. read more

The Simpson Restaurant & Bar - BK - Caribbean Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I recently visited Simpson Restaurant in Brooklyn, New York, we have tried to come here twice before and we couldn't be seated because it's always soooo crowded but we tried again for a third time and we finally made it in, and I'm still thinking about how amazing everything was. From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere felt warm, welcoming, and full of good vibes. For my meal, I ordered the brown stew snapper with rice and beans and veggies, and it was absolutely perfect. The fish was seasoned so well, tender, and packed with flavor--every bite was a 10/10. My partner ordered the stew pork with veggies, jerk shrimp, coconut shrimp, and mac and cheese, and honestly, everything on that plate was just as incredible. The variety of flavors and how well everything was cooked really stood out. And let's talk about the drinks--the rum punches were AMAZING. We each had two, and they were the perfect balance of sweet and strong... definitely a must-try! Between the delicious food, great drinks, and overall vibe, this place exceeded expectations. If you're looking for flavorful Caribbean food in Brooklyn, this is definitely the spot. 10/10 - I will absolutely be back! read more

Came here with some coworker friends for a weekend lunch at the recommendation of one of my coworkers. I was very excited to try more Caribbean food. Located across the street from the Barclay Center, it was very convenient to get to. The restaurant was much larger than I expected too but wasn't too crowded for a Saturday lunch so you can definitely just walk in. I was very excited about the sampler bowl. We were told it was a good portion for a group of three and adding a side would make it the perfect meal. The sampler came with curry goat, chicken, oxtail, plantains, and rice and veggies. The meats were all well seasoned. I guess my palate isn't too familiar and used to the Caribbean spices so i thought it was just a bit too spicy for my liking. The mac and cheese on the other hand was amazing. We also ordered festival, a Jamaican slightly sweet deep-fried bread that I tried for the first time. read more

See all

The restaurant is very cute. It definitely has a vibe. I arrived early for a group dinner so I sat at the bar. I ordered a drink from a male bartender who never brought my drink. After twenty minutes I asked a young lady to take care of my drink order. She quickly brought my drink. I gave her a $20 and told her not to share it with the other bartenders, especially the incompetent man standing next to her. The wings were finger licking good. However, the macaroni and cheese was dry and had no cheese pull. read more

The Simpson Restaurant & Bar - BK - Macaroni & Cheese - Caribbean Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

One of my favs!! The Simpson is without a doubt never a miss. The food is always good and the rum punch is like you are in Jamaica. Honeyyy. I would most certainly recommend sitting at the bar. It's fun and fast service. The Simpson is a vibe for sure. read more

Correctness/Taste (1-5): I got the jerk chicken, rice and peas, and macaroni and cheese. The rice and peas was really good. If you're looking for traditional jerk chicken, this may not be to your liking, it was more spicy than smoky and flavorful. - 4/5 Value (1-5): So there are many mom and pop Caribbean food spots that will give you jerk chicken, rice and peas and mac for half the price and arguably better tasting. This is where you go for a party and gathering with friends to eat and vibe out to music. - 3/5 Customer Service/Ambiance (1-5): My server was really nice and attentive, though take that with a grain of salt, I arrived about 15 minutes after they opened (empty at the time). I'd imagine with the layout of the restaurant, it could be harder to get attention during busier times. The ambiance to this place is really lovely too, a lot of old school music, definitely a place for parties/dates/group gathering. - 4/5 read more

The Simpson Restaurant & Bar - BK - Walkerswood Pan Jerk Chicken - Caribbean Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Came here on a Friday afternoon. Highly recommend you make reservations. This place gets packed pretty quick. Staff here are friendly and super attentive. Our server George was great. This place is serving up great drinks and vibes. The food was delicious. Every dish we tried was packed with flavor. I highly recommend to try The Simpson (biggie) sample platter if you would like to sample a few dishes all at once. The oxtails and goat are delicious. The reggae pasta was creamy and flavorful with just the right amount of spice. The Simpson Rum Punch was my favorite out of all the drinks that we ordered. Do not sleep on the dessert menu. The red velvet, lava cake and chocolate tuxedo bombe were delicious. This is a nice Caribbean restaurant serving up some great dishes. I will definitely be coming back. read more

See all

We love the food here! The Atlantic City location is cool but the BK location is my favorite. Thankfully we didn't need reservations when we arrived just as they opened on a Friday afternoon. Biggie Platter- A splendid and a full glorious spread of Jamaican goodness: Rice and peas, White Rice, Oxtail, Curry Goat, Sweet Plaintians, Jerk Chicken, and mixed veggies. And if I did not have enough to choose from, I ordered a side of Mac and Cheese. It was perfect for sharing and had enough left over to take home. Everything was delicious. I had a refreshing mocktail that I believe was a mix of guava and some other tropical fruit. Very good! The service was good but very Slow. It was like the waiter wanted us to stay for the whole afternoon. read more

See all

The Simpson Restaurant is a nice Caribbean spot with really good food. Food: the brownstew fish, fried chicken, lobster tail, oxtail, chicken wings, saltfish flitters, spring rolls, fried rice, and the mac&cheese Service: the service was good as our waiter was very attentive. Everything came out fast and accurate with smiles. Ambiance: the ambiance is very open styled seating, with a full bar, and catering hall for big parties. The tables, lightening, and overall views give island vibe. The overall rating is 4.7/5.0 read more

See all

From the moment we walked in, the ambiance stood out--beautiful lighting, thoughtfully curated décor, and an overall inviting atmosphere. We visited on a Thursday night, which turned out to be perfect, as the restaurant fills up quickly. The staff was wonderful: courteous, attentive, and genuinely welcoming throughout our visit. The food was absolutely delicious, and the drinks were even better, making for a truly enjoyable dining experience. read more

See all

Good food, great service, ambiance okay. I recommend this restaurant $$ Zzzzzzzzzzzzzz read more

The other day I checked out the The Simpson in Bk and had an enjoyable evening. We went to celebrate my friend's birthday. We had the honey curry wings, escovitche fish with festival, breadfruit, and the steamed fish with bammy. The wings were okay. More sweet than curry. Both fish dishes were made with red snapper. The escovitche was good but the steamed fish was phenomenal. I especially liked pumpkin and bammy in the sauce. The breadfruit was fried to perfection and the festival was soft and delicious. The server was nice and attentive and gave us great suggestions for dinner options. We enjoyed our meal and I will definitely dine here again in the future. read more

See all

Located right across from the Barclays Center, this spot is the ideal place to grab a bite and set the vibe before a Nets game or to keep the energy going afterward if the team pulls off a win. The food was outstanding and incredibly filling. The portions were no joke. I ordered the Jerk Oxtail over Macaroni & Cheese Pie, and both the flavor and the serving size had me completely satisfied. Our server was friendly, quick, and attentive, and I was even able to use my military discount for 10% off my meal. If you're in Brooklyn near the Barclays Center and craving some Jamaican cuisine, definitely check out The Simpson Restaurant & Bar-BK. You won't regret it. read more

My husband and I been waiting to try this place for a month now and we finally got to try it and it was so delicious. We didn't make a reservation which is rare for us but we were still able to walk in a get a table and we didn't have to wait long. The ambiance of the restaurant is so cozy the lighting was dim and perfect for an intimate date night or a big party gathering. I had the crab legs and hubby had oxtails and Mac and cheese we just shared each other's food. The food was so good and we had dessert. The oxtail was my favorite. We will definitely be back. read more

See all

The Simpson's, located in Brooklyn, is a Jamaican restaurant, and walking in, I was immediately struck by how spacious and thoughtfully laid out the space felt. On the left side, there's an open, creative area with a bar where you can seat yourself. On the right, there are more traditional dining-style tables. The space feels open in multiple directions, with festive decorations adding warmth. There's also a waiting area off to the right, which works well if you're waiting for the rest of your party or to be seated. One detail that really stood out to me was seeing someone actively managing the floor -- greeting guests, seating them, and offering water while people waited. That's not something you often see in Jamaican restaurants, which are usually structured differently, so it felt like a really intentional and elevated touch. As someone who grew up in Jamaica, I was especially curious to see how this restaurant balanced traditional Jamaican flavors while also appealing to a wider range of palates within a more modern dining setup. I ordered the macaroni and cheese, the brown stew snapper with mixed vegetables, and rice and peas. I had never had macaroni and cheese made by a Jamaican person before -- it wasn't a Sunday staple growing up -- so I was genuinely curious. The rice and peas ended up being a standout for me; you could tell the coconut milk was used really well, and that depth of flavor came through. I also had the carrot juice, which was really good. I actually told the people sitting next to me about it, and even though they already had drinks, they ordered it too -- and they said it was bomb. That felt like a strong, real-time endorsement. My server, Jared, had great energy and was very kind. From a logistical standpoint, though, he appeared to be the only person covering the dining area, including a large party. Because of that, there were delays when it came time to check out and ask for to-go containers. The guests next to me were also placing additional orders, which added to the load. From a management perspective, I think additional support or better delegation during busy times would make a big difference. One person shouldn't have to carry the entire dining room, especially when timing matters for guests. On the facilities side, the bathroom was clean, had multiple stalls, and featured a nice flowing water or filtration setup. I also appreciated the ramp leading into the dining area -- I noticed someone using a wheelchair, and it was good to see accessibility already built into the space. Overall, the experience was solid. The food, atmosphere, and intention are clearly there. With more front-of-house support during peak moments, this could be an even stronger experience. read more

See all

We came here on a Sunday night to celebrate my sisters graduation from medical school! We have a doctor in the house ya'll! The restaurant was packed and the bouncer at the door only let us in after we stated that we had a reservation. My sister, brother, and I ended up booking three separate reservations to get all 16 people a reservation for this celebration. They ended up being able to seat 10 people together and the other 6 (my table) sat at a different table. Be ready to open your wallet really wide when you come here because it is not cheap! I think they take advantage of the Barclays center being right across the street but the food is delicious. If you do shareable plates and split the check amongst one another you can save a lot of money though. The table of 10 complained that their service had been slow; however, my table of 6 had a great time with great service because our waiter, Bianca, was on it all night long! We started with the cheeseburger sliders which were tasty and cute. We probably shouldn't have ordered them considering how much food we took home after but we'll know for next time. You really don't need an appetizer because the portions are so big. The jerk oxtail over the Mac n cheese pie was fire. The flavor and seasoning of the food was perfect and left nothing to be desired. The oxtail was good and a little spicy while the Mac n cheese was creamy. The rice and peas was tasty and a little spicy as well which was a nice surprise. The jerk chicken was cooked perfect and still moist, not dry at all. The mixed vegetables were good. I think they were just on the plate to make us feel like we had some type of green food lol. I will definitely be back to this restaurant next time I'm in the city though. read more

See all

The ambiance was a cool vibe and lively. The service was a bit dodgy because we waited more time to receive our food and we were the first to order amongst the other parties, but received our food nearly last. Our waiter barely checked on us and we waited long for our bill. My party stated their food was good, and I tried the curry lobster which was good. I think the curry salmon I ordered was not satisfying possibly because the salmon temperature was cool, the flavor lacked, and the texture was overcooked. Overall, it was okay and would try something else if I ever were to revisit while in the area. read more

See all

I went for the first time on Thursday after work. I had an amazing time and experience. Danisha was my server. I sat at the bar. I hope I spelled her name right. She kept the most pleasant smile on her face. She was so friendly. And attentive. Her drinks are on point. I had 2 Notorius. The food was also good. However, The cod fish fritter appetizer had too much breading mixed in it. Barely any cod fish. They need to work on that but my brown stew snapper was to die for. So damn good. The atmosphere was a chill vibe. The music was the right genre for the crowd. I was drinking and jamming. LOL. I am definitely going back and with more friends and for service from Danisha. read more

The Simpson Restaurant & Bar - BK - Brown Stew Red Snapper - Caribbean Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Pretty cool West Indian Restaurant & bar , I had the Mac and Cheese and Oxtail and the Barclays drink (its blueberries and Hennessy cognac , its very delicious ) I wanted to try the bob Marley drink but our waiter said it very slushy so stick with the Barclays drink instead , it was delicious and fingerpicking my oxtail and mac and cheese , My friends had a great time so did i . the drinks was tasty & delicious , its located right near Barclays center & not far from Brooklyn paramount on Flatbush Avenue & Atlantic avenue areas (those concert halls similar to Kings Theatre ) ,Any how this location right literally across from Atlantic Terminal mall :Marshalls, Target , Burlington, Nike store , Stop & shop supermarket , Guitar center , Victoria secret, Uniqlo , and oh yeah and old navy store , and etc. stores and Apple store on Flatbush Avenue and walking distance from Fulton street mall (Fort Greene /Downtown Brooklyn area . Any how back to restaurant . I advise you to make reservations there tables get booked very quick escipally if the Brooklyn nets are home and there playing a game or concert near by at Barclays center or Brooklyn paramount , big shout out to our waiter "Kevoy" very kind hearted dude , he was kind to tell us our food would take bit longer than supposed to , hope I see him again if i ever come back to this restaurant , and big shout out to the waiter who quickly refill my glass of water when i was coughing , i order spicy oxtail and had me coughing lol , next time i would just order the mild oxtail . Thanks guys appreciate you're hospitality !!!!! P.S. There played every Genre there here had : Soca, R&B, Dancehall , Rap (Hip & Hop), Afro -Beats, ........I'm surprise there wasnt playing Kompa or Dennery segment , Bouyon music , any how two thumbs up to this place !!!! , oh yeah parking can be a hassle escipally its in a busy area Very convenient by the mta transporation: Subway: 2,3,4,5, B,D,Q,N,R-Train-Atlantic Avenue -Barclays Center ( L.I.R.R- Atlantic Terminal -Flatbush Avenue & Atlantic Avenue's ) or C-Train. Lafayette Avenue ,Train station. or G-Train.Fulton Street ,Train station. Bus: B41,B103,B45,B25,B38,,ETC BUS read more

I literally love it at this restaurant. It's truly a must try. The food is great, I've tried many things on the menu but my favorite food items that I'd recommend are the honey curry wings , if you are a sweet savory person, the jerk shrimp taco are good but you must have a tolerance for spice and heat. I'd also recommend the biggie sample platter. It's gives you a little of everything and it's shareable. I haven't had a dish that I didn't enjoy. The waiters are also very attentive , although they are busy they always try their best to ensure you are having a great experience. read more

Fast friendly service i sit at the bar, inside is pretty big and spacy for large parties , pricing is good for the serving sizes ,my full ratings out of 5 on all the dishes i try. - 5/5-Steam fish- nice and moist! I wish it had a little more spice to it bit overall Good! 3.9/5- Curry losbter- i didnt taste much or little to no coconut curry flavor the flavor wasnt all there to me but it was ok. 4.9/-5 - A great plate for anyone who want to try different meats . 5/5 - Frozen drink . Also-They added a 20% service fee at the bar, idk how that works or how u determine what percent to add, but okkk...(i tip anyways , alwaysss..but i dont like to be told what to tip.) Other then that, Will i be back yes! .. should u check them out yes! Whenever i visit new york again i will be stoping by or recommending to others! read more

I just love the vibe of the restaurant. Food is really tasty. I have been there twice. Will definitely be going back. read more

The Simpson Restaurant & Bar - BK - Coconut Shrimp - Caribbean Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

My mother and I stopped by Simpsons for lunch after handling some business at the DMV. She wanted to try the restaurant and Simpsons is definitely a cool spot to check out. The host and staff were great, attentive and friendly. Give up to our server who was on double duty while bartending as well. My mother enjoyed her oxtails and had some to take home as well. I loved my jerk salmon, rice and peas with veggies, finished the whole plate. The rum punch was a little syrupy for my taste, but okay. Always a good time hanging out with moms and trying out new restaurants. read more

See all

Junior.B the waiter was very knowledgeable about the cusine and very hospitalbe. Also, I ate the brown stew vegetarian chicken with peas and rice. read more

The Simpson Restaurant & Bar - BK - Rum cake - Caribbean Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I went here with my best friend awhile back and I've seen this spot and always wanted to go here. I drag her with me to most food places I visit. I do like the vibe there. It's comfortable and you don't feel out of place. The staff were friendly. They helped us pick something out and we got the sampler meal. Now... the girl told us it would be a lot of food. I didn't believe her. She didn't lie. It was a lot of food and we struggled to eat this between the two of us. They were not playing. The food was good. No stops. It was good food and the price was worth it for the sheer amount of food you got. There was no rush to make us leave immediately after we were done and we just chatted for an extra 30mins before we left. I'd come back here just to try other dishes. The price is nice, good area, near the TRAINS so my itis could kick in and I can go home and sleep it off on the couch. I don't think I have anything to complain about. So... yea! read more

The Simpson Restaurant & Bar - BK - Sampler - Caribbean Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

love the BK location but the way you really need to make a reservation is serious , don't think you can com here on a walkin and get a good seat you may just end up at the bar eating AND who likes that ... but I DID anyhoo the Shrimp cocktail was so good and fresh .. I went all in and ordered the **Biggie Platter**--and when I say it was a glorious spread of Jamaican goodness, I mean it! Rice & peas, white rice, oxtail, curry goat, jerk chicken, sweet plantains, and mixed veggies... it had everything. And because I clearly didn't have enough food already, I added a side of mac & cheese. Perfect for sharing and still had leftovers to take home. Everything was delicious, full of flavor, and that mocktail (pretty sure it was guava mixed with another tropical fruit) was super refreshing. The only downside was the service--it was good, just slooow. Like the waiter wanted us to stay and hang out all afternoon. Overall, amazing food and vibes. Definitely worth it if you're craving real Jamaican comfort food! read more

The Simpson Restaurant & Bar - BK - Caribbean Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

4 Stars for Yadira and the drinks. Yadira recommended Pash Island and it did not disappoint. Unfortunately, the food did disappoint. I ordered the Jerk shrimp which was overly salty and my friend had the Hennessy shrimp which lacked any type of Hennessy flavor. Overall we had a good time due to Yadira. read more

I came to this restaurant before a Brooklyn Nets game and now that will be my pre-game ritual. The service was fast, friendly, and accurate. Our waitress (I think her name was Jessica) was so helpful and gave us the best recommendations. All of the food was fresh and delicious. Everything we ordered was delicious. The oxtails, rice and peas, shrimp tacos, and rum punch were my favorites. The coconut shrimp and ackee were good too. I got a tequila drink that I loved but I forgot the name. This is a great restaurant and I will absolutely be back. read more

See all

I've been to this location once and the one in Atlantic City and those times were amazing. But this last trip was disappointing and had I not been here before I would've gave a 3 star. However the staff are very friendly and professional, they check in on you often. The restaurant also still looks really nice and definitely really clean. This time around I got bourbon ribs and the half baked potato. The ribs weren't anything to wow about and my potato had no flavor and felt like the cheese was just burnt on top of it. The portion size was great for the cost but after a while of eating the ribs, it didn't taste good anymore and I disregarded the potato after a few bites. I'm assuming it would've been better if I got it on a weekend. I'd recommend trying them out on the weekend or knowing exactly what to order through reviews, like the oxtail with Rasta pasta. read more

The Simpson Restaurant & Bar - BK - Caribbean Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I went here one night before a Nets game and they had the nerve to come to our table to tell us they needed the table before I could finish my sub par Bob Marley drink. The jerk wings were not good and my husband's entree was okay. We won't be returning. read more

We came without a reservation and were told the wait would be about 20-30 minutes. Since the waiting area was full, one of the host (man)suggested we head to the bar. My cousin asked if we could grab one of the many empty tables near the bar and someone told her yes, but as we were about sit down a female host came through with another party and very rudely told us we couldn't sit there. Her tone and facial expression were unprofessional and off-putting. We went back to the bar, there was only one stool for the three of us. Security came over and politely explained that standing wasn't allowed--he was professional and kind about it, but at that point I honestly considered leaving. Luckily, when we returned to the podium area a large group had just left, so I was finally able to sit (important since I have back issues). Once seated, it took a while for our server to get to us, but she was apologetic and explained she was handling a large birthday table. From then on, things turned around. The atmosphere was nice, the music was great, and the food really stood out. We ordered cod fritters, honey curry wings, and jerk wings to start. I didn't try the fritters, but a couple were left. The jerk wings were excellent--spicy and full of flavor. For entrees, I had the reggae pasta with oxtail (so good, though I wish the oxtail pieces were bigger). My husband had the steamed redfish and loved it. My cousin ordered the ribeye, which was tender, seasoned perfectly, and cut like butter. For dessert, they had the red velvet cake and chocolate lava cake, which disappeared before I could even snap a photo. Overall, the night started rocky with the seating confusion and a slow start to service, but the food and atmosphere won us over. If I'm ever in New York, I'd return--but definitely with a reservation next time. read more

See all

The wings here were my favorite specifically the jerk chicken wing! We tried the buffalo and bbq which were pretty good as well! The Rasta pasta was also pretty good, the sauce was slightly heavy but overall pretty good. read more

The Simpson Restaurant & Bar - BK - Rasta pasta with shrimp - Caribbean Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Food, service, drinks, ambiance... The Simpson has all 4!!.. Portions are great, food is seasoned and flavorful. Please go, you will not be disappointed. We already have a reservation set to revisit. read more