I have always heard a lot of individuals talk about this place but I have never actually try it. Well I think I could had avoided this place at all cost. I did not care for the pizza at all. When I first have seen it in the casing I was like well I want to walk out of here because it looked so old but I deicded to purchase a couple of slices. I had the chicken parm slice as I was driving home and I was not a fan of it . The other pizza was pretty average too with barley any chicken on it. I am not sure what the hype is all about ? read more

See all

First time having their pizza and it was pretty good. We had the pepperoni to feed a bunch of guys for lunch and it was good. I have not had their other pizza so can't really do a full review. Staff was very friendly and helpful. read more

See all

It's on the way home and I wanted to try it. I had been there a while back. I ordered a pizza and a salad. Salad was good Pizza was not good. Edible, but thick hard crust with burnt bottom. Verry little cheese and toppings. Very small pizza. I will not be going back. Salad was surprisingly good, while the Pizza was surprisingly below average read more

Huge, delicious specialty slices - that's what you'll remember most. You'll also remember the extreme pop-culture laden decor. Great service, clean space, and always great musics read more

The Pizza Pit - a slice of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Sloatsburg, New York

Very lackluster pizza and at 4 bucks a slice it was small, too. Very similar to NYC 99 cent pizza. I was hoping for better.

This place is pretty sweet. Ended up coming here as I was working close by doing some construction, and I went on a lunch run. Some other people said this place had really good slices, and they delivered. The place itself is chill, standard pizza shop, places to sit when normal times come back, and I dig the vibe of decorations, all movie related. First, the movie posters on the wall are awesome, I gave props to the owner who was working and we talked about Tarantino, Pulp Fiction and Grindhouse, always cool to have a good vibe with who's working. The Merch Shirt is awesome for all you Rob Zombie and Captain Spaulding fans, another really cool movie lover touch. Also, the selection of pies is decent. BBQ Chicken Slice, Pepperoni Slice, Regular, Sicilian etc. Lots to choose from. The slices are huge, I would say they are the size of 2 slices in most other places which is great. Ended up getting 1 BBQ Chx, 2 Regular, 1 Pepperoni, 2 Ice Teas and an Orange Drink for 18 bucks, pretty damn good. The pizza itself was great. Foldability was solid, not too much sauce, cheese had some flavor, Lil Doughy which I like, and filling. So a big win for me. 5 stars. Great vibes. Good people. Tasty slices. Prime service. Would deff return read more

See all

The pizza Is delicious and the staff is super friendly. They serve large slices so go when you're hungry! 10/10 recommend and would go back.

Meh - nothing special. Expensive $$ for what you get and small. Always give a place a second chance but many other pizza options around. read more

The Pizza Pit - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Sloatsburg, New York

See all

The sauce may have been great on these wings but it was like banquet frozen wings with sauce on it I would not get these again restaurants you guys have to buy fresh wings and at least have them marinated so and waiting to be cooked for eight dollars I feel like I got ripped off. I also ordered the mushroom hoagie steak whatever I guess for the price it was OK but it just didn't seem like it had much flavor and they didn't put any peppers on it maybe I should've stuck with the pizza read more

The Pizza Pit - chicken wings in a foil pan - Pizza Near Me - Sloatsburg, New York

See all

This was my first visit to Pizza Pit. It was a Saturday at 3:30pm after a hike. I ordered the Sausage, Peppers & Onions Hero. I enjoyed my meal while both watching and listening to the rock band Rush on the televisions. I had skipped breakfast so I went back and added a large and thick slice of Pepperoni pan pizza to my order. Mind you, the hero sandwich was not small. It was great service, great attitude and great food. read more

For the prices they charge it should at least have some flavor. We wouldn't mind paying the price if it's worth eating but in this case they're cutting corners reflecting on quality. It's a shame. read more

Amazing pizza and fast and friendly service! Would definitely recommend for after a hike

Food wasn't tasty at all. Wings were dry. Pizza was chewy, tasteless. Pickup was ready as expected.

Best pizza I had in a long time. Prices are great!! Large variety of options including Italian ice

Called to order their 28 inch pizza and was denied. The person who answered rudely suggested that was on the menu it dates to preorder this pizza.. I explained that it didn't say that on the menu I have nor does it say it on their website.. they should promote something and refuse to make it read more

Very good pizza! Have been stopping here on the way home from hiking. Pleasant staff. Very much recommended.

Holy schmidt, eat at Pizza Pit. The pizza is stellar, and if it's not - just tell them and they will ensure it's stellar. We haven't been there in a year, but before we moved we under estimated the greatness that is Pizza Pit. The dough is made fresh daily, and the pizza pies are super fresh. The mozzarella sticks are KILLER and you might even be lucky enough to catch a JAWS flick while you dine. The only thing to that would make this a 6 star review is draft beer on tap (hint hint). read more

Love hitting this place after hiking in Harriman. Great grandma pie and strombolis.Then off to Auntie Els for dessert!

This is truly my FAVORITE place to get pizza, and I have gone to MANY different pizza places both in orange and Rockland County (with pizza being my favorite food). The owner, Rich, is SUPER kind and they serve huge, DELICIOUS slices. Can't say enough good things about this place, how exactly they make their pizza I don't know, but it's phenomenal. My new favorite lunch spot. Thank you Pizza Pit!! -Reese :) read more

Definitely not "the best slice in Rockland County". Don't waste your time and gas to get here.

Decent pizza, but.... 7 bucks for two plain slices?? Is it just me or is that a little expensive..

Aw man this place is fantastic. Not only do they have traditional pizza style with an amazing crunchy crust, they keep the place jamming with 80's/90's alternative punk rock. Punk Rock Pizza FTW!!! Thanks guys for having a unique and passionate vision definitely my go to spot! read more

Don't let the name fool you! The pizza is top shelf, some of the most creative toppings you can find. I highly recommend the jalapeño tai slice easily worth the drive 25-30 min drive! Amazing read more

Came here after a hike. I loved this place immediately. When we walked in we were greeted by the friendliest guy ever, and he made sure to let us know what specialty slices were available. I got a Sicilian slice and it was literally the best I've ever had. Crunchy crust (cause you have to get a corner piece obviously) but the middle was soft. LOVE the 80s music videos on the TV too. read more

Pizza is good when fresh. Wish the music was a little less aggressive (not a fan of Green Day or similar acts) and the classic movie should be on the big screen with closed captioning instead of Green Day karaoke. Simple improvements in ambiance go a long way to making people want to return. read more

Chicken was a little greasy... The salad was really good and so was the buffalo wings! Staff is really really friendly! My sister loves the French fries there too! read more

This is the best pizza on the god damn planet awesome atmosphere, but the pizza is amazing!

The pizza pit was okay taste of the pizza was so so. The crust of the pizza was definitely missing something. If you are just looking to have something to eat it's okay. read more

If your driving through this city you have to stop and grab a slice......Or two !! Sauce,cheese and the crust all blend and compliment each other perfectly. Grandma pie is tasty !!! Top it off they play actual music videos like back in the day of real music !! Owner is a nice and friendly guy who's doing it right !! read more

The pizza here is consistently awful- tasteless, undercooked, just gross. We wish they would do something to make their pizza more palatable. The nickname the PIT has stuck for us locals for a reason. Go to Ramsey or Tuxedo if you want good pizza nearby. read more

Great pizza place, had plain, was very thin and crispy. Had a great sicilian with sausage and pepperoni, the dough was great! And the arugula with wasabi sauce and roasted peppers was very unique and delicious! Thanks for a great lunch read more

I can stop this review after 3 words "BBQ Fry Pizza" ! But I just have to say this place was more then that. Not only was their pizza delicious and out of this world, they were super friendly! Wish I could have tried more of the variety of pizza they had there. Chicken bacon ranch for example. I recommend this place especially to the friends on their way or coming back from Warwick tours with an appetite for pizza :) Keep up the great work Pizza Pit! read more

Terrible. The Chicken wings were Cold and one of the Meatballs had something chewy in the Center, we think a chunk of Fat. The only positive thing about this place is the easy access from Rt. 17. read more

Best pizza joint in Rockland and Orange County. Great pizza selection, due to pizza's selections changing daily. Must try!

Great pizza , great customer service. We ordered the deep dish pepperoni pizza and were highly satisfied.

Called in for a pie and the gentlemen who took my order was extremely hard to hear. I needed to change the order and he was rushing me off the phone before I could finish giving him my order. He told me the pie would be done in 15 minutes, upon my arrival as told the pie was ready. As I looked around I noticed the place was a graveyard. No one in there and only one employee working. The restaurant was very dirty not to mention the gentlemen who rang up my order didn't know how much to charge me for a half plain half pepperoni pizza. To me $16 for a basic pie is a little pricy. Needless to say I won't be going back. read more

Best slice of pizza I had in along time and I am from Philly where there are pizza spots all over! When we walked in we were greeted with smiles and friendliness! He told us about all the different types of pizzas available and delivered all our slices to the table himself again with smiles. I would highly recommended Pizza Pit! read more

Sadly, our experience stunk! I don't think either of the two staff members that were there had experience in the customer service business. We got there at 6:45 on a fri night. It was empty. I ordered an antipasto salad. My friend ordered 6 wings and a slice. The slice got burned, so they apologized and asked us to pick a different kind of slice. The salad came out in a take-out tin, which was odd, but fine. Well, all of the lettuce was Frozen! Ice, and everything! The second slice came out and it was cold! I think they were afraid of burning it! The wings came out... there were four whole wings, and two nubs of bone with a little bit of meat and sauce. When I went up to pay, I nicely mentioned that my lettuce was frozen and that I didn't eat it. I didn't even bother to complain about the wings. The girl did not apologize or offer to take money off. She just said, "I'll mention it to the cook."! Wow! No wonder they were empty on a Friday evening! read more

These guys make a crisp flaky crust that is a little bit sweet . I love New York Style thin crust, but the chef here has improved it. It's the best crust ever. I liked the Buffalo Ranch Chicken pizza, cannot wait to try some others. They close early, as pizza places go. When I was there, there was nobody else there, and no problems with service. I don't care about ambiance, it was nothing special. I am surprised that some reviewers didn't like the pizza, mine was awesome. read more

Food isn't great. Ordering is hard. Food takes forever to cook. Hours are terrible. The pizza is never cooked well always slightly burnt and sucks. The wings are mini. read more