I work around this area and was referred to this pizzeria by another person. I got pizza here the last 3 weeks about a dozen times at least. Today I sat down and ate there so I got the refillable drinking cup rather than the soda in a bottle. They tried to charge me an extra dollar for a refill of my soft drink. Like I said I been giving good business to this place for almost a month now I will not be going back at all. After all that you wanna be a cheapo.... That one dollar just lost you my lunch I get every other day now. The worker was good it's really the owners son that is being cheap.(not surprised if ykyk) read more

Picked up an order through Slice app. Ordered a large pizza half extra cheese half eggplant. Also calamari. When I picked up the pie it was already cold, although the app indicated it was just ready for pickup. The eggplant were little cardboard chip like substance. The calimari was rubber mushy bands on top of French fries, just as cold as the pizza. I think it's funny how businesses can treat customers like this and wonder why business is bad?? Hmm read more

Excellent pizza and chicken wings! Crispy delicious pizza and wings. Delivery was quick and so great. We've tried other pizza places in the Suffern/Mahwah area and this is the best so far! Thank you. read more

Wanted to thank Pizza master for taking a group of 15 walk ins. We came from a memorial and they accommodated us in every way. Pizza was really good too. read more

Great pizza! Friendly staff. Clean. If I order out or in it is always good. Perfect place to grab a slice or pick up a pie

Definitely one of the better pizzerias around this neck. I like the vibes in here very much, and the service is overall outstanding. Place has an old school ambiance but has new school slice options. read more

Mahwah Pizza Master - two slices of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Mahwah, New Jersey

Stopped by here today for lunch , pretty bad pizza for NJ. the sauce tastes like cheap ragu and they are overpriced also. Would never go back or recommened to anyone. read more

Mahwah Pizza Master - This pizza isnt very good. if i had to rate it 1 to 10.... it would be a 3.... the crust was the only good thing about it - Pizza Near Me - Mahwah, New Jersey

Terrible service $4 for one regular slice And grabbed my pizza with his hands Get gloves Spatula Something read more

This has been my all-time fav pizza place and I have suggested it to literally every single person I know in the area. I'm not sure what's going on but the last three times I've ordered from them the pies have been so overdone. The cheese is crispy the crust is crispy everything is really crispy. What I always enjoyed about this pie was that it was a little less done on top with a crispy bottom and you were really able to taste the tang of whatever special cheese they use. That has gotten lost for me. Owners please go back to making your pizza the way you always did it. It's hard to find legit pizza. I have not given up on you but next time I order will ask for it to be less done. read more

Mahwah Pizza Master - Cheese pie - Pizza Near Me - Mahwah, New Jersey

Called them last minute right before closing and the customer service was top notch. They didn't rush me or make me feel like a burden ordering so last minute. The food did not disappoint one bit! Very tasty pizza and salad was insanely tasty! Truly hit the spot! read more

Mahwah Pizza Master - Half Master Special Pizza & half plain pie - Pizza Near Me - Mahwah, New Jersey

See all

Absolutely would revisit!! Mozzarella Sticks, On Point!! Garlic Knots On Point!! Service Was Spectacular!! read more

Mahwah Pizza Master - a plate of food - Pizza Near Me - Mahwah, New Jersey

See all

Excellent pizza!!! Excellent staff. Do t be confused by Mahwah pizza and pasta. Stole the name by adding "and pasta". This is your home town pizzeria. Fantastic!! read more

Mahwah Pizza Master - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mahwah, New Jersey

Great burgers I was sleeping in the hotel next door so before they closed I stop by for a burger and beer food was delicious beer was ice cold and employees weee awesome read more

I work locally and we ordered dinner ... I have to say it was absolutely DISGUSTING ... I'm Italian and this was insulting... the sauce tasted like a tin can, pastas overcooked , was charged extra for cheese that was never put on an order.. the man .. boy who took the order was RUDE... 10 coworkers ordered our dinner tonight ... 6 of us threw our food away !!!! Will never order from here again and all of my coworkers will be writing reviews too ! read more

Mahwah Pizza Master - The sauce that tasted like it was from a can was watery - Pizza Near Me - Mahwah, New Jersey

See all

Very convenient location from my hotel. Walked in and was greeted by the person behind the register. They are open for indoor dining, no masks required from the looks of it. The pizza looked delicious, and the kids enjoyed it. The only criticism they had was that there was a lot of sauce near the crust uncovered by cheese. read more

I ordered through their website (via Chownow) and their delivery estimate was approximately 45 minutes; it showed up 15 minutes early. I ordered knots since I needed to meet the $15 minimum (pizza was $13.75) and they were delicious; not overly oily and they were soft on the inside with just the right amount of crunch on the outside. Their pizza was good; the ratio of cheese, sauce and dough was perfect for my liking. The only downside to the pizza was it 'flopped' when you fold the piece in half. I wish it was cooked a tad longer so the crust was crunchier through out, but all and all the ingredients were yummy and I will for sure order from Mahwah Pizza Master again for their pizza - i'll just ask for the piece a little more well done and then it'll be 5 stars. read more

Mahwah Pizza Master - Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Mahwah, New Jersey

See all

Our boys love this pizza place! Always consistently good, fresh, hot and pleasant when you pickup.

Pizza Master in Mahwah, NJ, is a top-notch pizzeria that offers delicious food, a welcoming atmosphere, and exceptional customer service, all thanks to the owner, Larry. It's no surprise that customers keep returning for the fantastic food and friendly service. The service was exemplary!!! Like, unbelievably amazing. I am serious. And I will be ordering today as soon as they open lol. read more

Called in an order at 8:08 tonight first was told half hour then was told 45 minutes the guy showed up over an hour later. I called twice personally answer the phone said guy is on his way should be two minutes 20 minutes later shows up pizza very thin and cold worst Customer Service worst pizza for $17 and change Plus tax 22 bucks read more

Ordered a couple pizza's, garlic knots, calzone and antipasto salad the other night. Pizza was pretty good, garlic knots were alright could have been cooked a little more and had more flavor, salad was your average antipasto, ham &cheese calzone was very good. Overall happy with what we ordered, just thought everything was pretty pricey for what it was. read more

We've lived less than 5 minutes away for 8 years, but never came here, for unknown reasons. My son had pizza from here with friends and told us how good it was, so we ordered pickup. We've been keeping it in our rotation because the food is yummy, the employees and delivery driver are great, and it's reasonably priced. Glad we finally ordered from here so we know what we were missing! We love having a family-owned business locally to support and they do lots for the community! read more

Very good food, ordered a large cheese pizza. Delicious with the right amount of cheese and nice sauce. Cesar salad had fresh croutons and nice crispy lettuce. Fries were brought to the table hot and crispy. Mozzarella sticks rounded out a good meal. Ordered at the register, not really sure if they have table service. The girls working there were friendly and brought food out as it was ready. Very good value. We will be back soon read more

Don't order from here if you want your food AND don't want to be lied to! I TRIED to place an order and their "driver" claimed they couldn't find my 100 year old home and that he 'knocked' on the door. LIES!! I was BY THE DOOR and NO ONE KNOCKED or even came in the driveway. I was told they would get back to me in 3 minutes with my order. It's now 3 HOURS LATER and I'm STILL WAITING!! When They were contacted, I was informed my order was cancelled. They PURPOSELY waited until EVERY OTHER Pizza place was closed BEFORE They informed me they cancelled my order. FIRST they LIE! Then they wait to cancel the order until it's too late for you to get food elsewhere. WORST RESTARAUNT EVER unless you want to BE LIED TO and NOT get food!!! read more

Sooooooo gooooooood!!!! We ordered a pepperoni and garlic, cheese pizza! So good! Better than homemade!!! The crust is perfect! Made my husband almost cry the first bite! It's been a couple years since we got pizza here. read more

Mahwah Pizza Master - Medium Cheese Pizza Deal with pepperoni and garlic. - Pizza Near Me - Mahwah, New Jersey

I have been a regular customer for many years. Love the pizza, but I really enjoy their parmigian sandwiches. Their bread is authentic Italian. If you like salad, get a large one. read more

We recently moved into the area and we were searching for our pizza place. We found it in Mahwah Pizza Master. Their pizza is delicious! We love the thin crust and the sauce is outstanding. We will be here often. read more

Great experience and really great tasting food. Great delivery. Ordered pizza and wings dinner- my kids love it!!!! Prices are good too!!

Average pizza place in the area. I like to pop in here at lunch for a slice or two. It's not overly crowded and the staff is very friendly. I have only tried the plain slice and pepperoni which are were both good. Still wanting to try their sandwiches to see how they stack up. Will be back again! read more

Mahwah Pizza Master - Pizza Near Me - Mahwah, New Jersey

This is my favorite pizza place in the area. I love the sicilians here and the garlic knots. I think their food is delicious

I am a big fan of Mahwah Pizza Master. The food is outstanding. The customer service is even better. Whenever I walk into the restaurant they give me a big smile. They are genuinely happy that I am there and they are happy to serve me. I wish that all businesses could treat me the way that Larry and his staff treat. It is a great way to do business! read more

We stumbled upon this place after being hungry and exhausted from skiing at Campgaw. We didn't know what to expect but we were very pleasantly surprised. We ordered a pizza, a serving of penne ala vodka and garlic knots. Everything was fresh and delicious (and I'm writing this as a NYC pizza snob). The prices were very reasonable and the staff was friendly. The next time we're in the area we will definitely stop by. read more

Incredible service when delivering. Great manners and the food arrived ten min before designated time.

This was our first and only delivery since self quarantining and it went great. Ordered on seamless who offered a great deal with a $10 off 30 coupon. Brought to the house sooner than expected, left at front door for contactless delivery. Pizza and pasta fagioli soup were delicious. Having chicken franchise tonight. Left the take out containers outside and threw out immediately, transferred to our own plates on the porch! Would order Update: have since ordered many times. Our go to pizza delivery. Delicious and always arriving on time and hot read more

The best pizza I've had upstate. The sauce is tasty, and the cheese to sauce ratio does not make the pizza bland. The crust is not chewy, but nice and crisp. read more

Doesn't look like much but the pizza is great! Anything I had was always good. Just the right ingredients not overloaded amazingly delicious

While stranded in the Newark area last week, I was feeling pretty stressed out and decided to take advantage of the Yelp/GrubHub service. Ordered a medium Margharita Pizza along with some Garlic Cheese Bread. Order came quickly enough, about 35 minutes. The pizza was fairly good, typical New York style pizza. They messed up my garlic bread order though, I got two slices of chicken alfredo pizza instead. The whole thing set me back about $27. I'd order again though, this place still beats Domino's. Plus they're fast, that counts for something. read more

We always order from here since we are local and food comes fast. The pizza is excellent as well as the dinners. We are such long time customers, and I just want to say that our delivery man tonight was the greatest! So friendly and courteous. I hope he is there for a long time! read more

Ordered a meat lovers pizza delivered. The pizza showed up early and the pizza was delicious.

Hello People, So i stopped by Pizza Master and I had a slice of pizza and buffalo wings. Wings were excellent and I really enjoyed eating there with my friends. One thing I would say about it is the seating is a little too tight. For example, I sat right by the door and every time someone walked in, my friend had to move. Also as i was drinking my water, i looked in it and there was some black stuff on the button of my cup so I stopped drinking it. I was a little disappointed but the food was top notch. The buffalo wings were very crispy and I enjoyed every single second eating them. One thing I would say is when they buffalo wings come out, make sure you wait a little because it was a little too hot. I suggest you guys clean up the bathrooms a little too because it was a little disgusting. The employees there were very generous. That was very good first impression i had there. Overall the place was pretty good and I had a great time read more

Not only is their food great ( Chicken bacon Ranch pizza, specifically) but Larry is also a real stand out guy who does a lot for the community around him. He's always willing to help out when time allows and has been a big supporter of our heroes in the health industry. Thank you Larry for making great food and being a tremendous part of our community. read more