Has always been our go to local pizzeria. Nothing special but never disappointed. We had a last minute catering need this past weekend and Natale's far exceeded our expectations! Food was fabulous and they came through with barely 24 hours notice. Chicken Marsala and eggplant parm were even better catered than on their regular menu. I don't think Mac and cheese is even on their regular menu but it was a huge hit. We will definitely use them for our next catering need. read more

Noticed a new staff around the kitchen. Tried their staple buffalo chicken wrap, subpar. Came back to try pizza, waaay too greasy and waayyyyy too much cheese. Feels like im just chewing a bunch of cheese. Changes being made but not for the better im afraid. read more

Natale's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

Our go to when I don't feel like cooking. The salads are always fresh and crisp. The chicken tenders and cheesesteak egg rolls are fantastic, and the pizza is always perfection. read more

What is going on here? It's like there's no quality control anymore. The last 2 times we got the Sicilian pie were pure letdowns. Added mushrooms were not spread out. Seemed like the person just dumped a half handful onto the center of the pizza which. All the water from the mushrooms created a super wet (NOT AT ALL crusty) crust. Another time, a good 2 inches from the entire border was cheeseless. WTH? will probably give Natale's one more chance. read more

The pizza is fantasitc - perfect for a night when you're just not up for cooking or going to a sit down place. This will be our go to spot for pizza. My partner really liked the penne vodka chicken but it seemed just ok to me. I added some spice at home and it was perfect. read more

Natale's Pizzeria - Margarita Specialty Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

See all

This is the second Christmas that we ordered catering from Natales. It was so good and we received so many compliments from our guests. The meatballs were delicious as was the eggplant rolantini. We also ordered the cavatelli with broccoli and the number one hit was the tray of assorted Stromboli! Everything was delicious. They help me carry the trays to my car and were so helpful on the phone. They also included instructions on how to heat the Stromboli. We order from Natales at least once a week off the regular menu as well. We are already talking about what to order for the best event. read more

See all

When I order pizza for myself, I like extra cheese. And I usually order it well done. Because with all that cheese, it tends to get a little floppy. So I ordered a regular large pizza with extra cheese well done. It was delivered sooner than they said and it was perfect. It was not floppy at all. It may have been the best pizza I have ever had. read more

See all

Still my go-to pizza spot but I'm a little disappointed the last couple of times I ordered a Sicilian pie they were incredibly lazy with the sauce and cheese and missed a pretty significant amount of real estate on the pie. In fact tonight's had three slices that were 2/3 or worse without any sauce or cheese. It's a little hard to tell from the photos here but look at where the cuts are so you can get an idea of size of the slice and just how little sauce and cheese there is. I like their pizza, I just wish I got what I was paying for. read more

Natale's Pizzeria - A slice of crust with two pieces of pepperoni and almost no sauce or cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

See all

Again, had the pizza, as good as ever. My wife , again, had the eggplant rolitini......which she says is the best she has had. As you can see, this place is consistent read more

We've been ordering from Natale's for the past ten months and we couldn't be more pleased. The food arrives hot and is always fresh and delicious. our particular favorites are the pizza (thin crust), chicken parm dinner and sandwich and just about anything with their delicious marinara sauce. Delivery is fast and their prices are most reasonable. read more

One of the best thin crust Pizzas in Waldwick. The service is good and price is reasonable.

I decided to go to Natales to pick up an eggplant, Parm hero, when I got home and went to eat the sandwich , it was horrible!!!The sauce had no flavor . Tasted like a can of tomato paste with no seasoning. The eggplant was oily With no flavor and there was hardly any mozzarella cheese on it at all. I was starving I didn't have lunch and I was waiting to eat my dinner right after work when I got home. I will never go back there again. I am surprised they are still in business with the way that sandwich was. I used to purchase from them many years ago. Their sandwiches used to be good. They've changed the tomato sauce and the way they make sandwiches need to change. I'm surprised they're still in business. read more

I would have to say best pizza I have had in a long time. We had a party at the super dome in Waldwick we liked the pizza so much we stopped on the way home to Dumont and got 2 large pies to take home. Made well done like we asked good spices and sauce, crust was very good. Establishment was very clean and everyone was very nice we will be back soon. read more

I feel like this place gets a good rating just for the prices. Go to go orders twice here. First time got a supreme pizza- it was ok. Nothing to write home about... I've had better Second time got a chicken Marsala, chicken parm dinner w vodka sauce, chicken parm sandwich, and linguine w clam sauce. The best dish was definitely the chicken Marsala. The vodka sauce was flavorless! Just tasted like cream. The worst was the linguine w clam sauce. Tastes straight out of a can (no joke; when I'm lazy and need to eat I use canned clam sauce and it tasted EXACTLY like that). All the pastas were over cooked but not mushy... Would I recommend? Ehh... I don't think so read more

Pizza is very basic and pricey. Will not be going back and It's too bad because they were very nice. read more

Natale's Pizzeria - The saddest slice of margherita pizza one has ever seen. - Pizza Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

I've been a customer for many years! Always good quality, delish, hot pizza delivered by friendly drivers! We love the veggie pie that inclides yummy eggplant! Nice salads and garlic knots and linguine dinners. Making me hungry just writing this!!! read more

Always a great meal! Natales is quick delivery, great customer, service, and delicious food

Always my go to pizza place ! Tonight I went and not one person in the kitchen or counter were wearing a mask ! As far as I know we are still dealing with Covid... I thought in the food service they were required to wear they ! Definitely I will not be returning ! read more

Staple in town. Pizza is pretty good and their barbecue chicken wrap is sooooo good! Pretty much always guaranteed you see someone you know from town inside. It's a great spot! read more

Natale's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

I was excited to try Natale's after seeing a picture of their grandma's pizza. Maybe I caught them on a bad day, but my family and I were quite disappointed. The sauce was good but the pie was so overcooked the crust was burned in many places and had a tough texture. The fact that they didn't' make a new one after seeing the first one wasn't' right shows a lack of care. read more

Natale's Pizzeria - Burned crust, seems obvious they left it in too long - Pizza Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

See all

I ordered a pizza to be picked up this past Saturday night at 6:30. I placed the order for a full pie, well done with black olives on half at 5:30 for the 6:30 pick up. Went to pick up the pie at 6:30 and they said that they were backed up and will have it out in 10 minutes. The pizza came out 20 minutes later, and was not well done as requested and a grand total of 5 olives on it. There are multiple other options in the Waldwick area that I will be going to I think. read more

Starving in between appts in Waldwick area wanting an inexpensive quick bite so I yelped $ cheap eats and Nats came up. Small pizzeria with 3 small circular tables that sit 3 and a small counter that sits 3. Definitely a take out joint because there is obviously very limited stool seating with no atmosphere. Almost everything including entrees is under $11 with subs around $6. Big selection of can/bottle soda. $7.10 for 10in Veal parm sub and can of soda is a good bang for the $ unfortunately the veal quality lacked, seems like premade frozen breaded pattie. The sauce was good. They don't use fresh mozzarella boo. The staff is friendly, no bathroom. OK for a quick cheap bite, but I'd say check out one of the other dozen or so restaurants within walking distance and pass on Nat's. read more

Natale's Pizzeria - Inside, limited seating. - Pizza Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

They're skimping on all the ingredients. It is not pizza when a cup of sauce and some mozzarella cheese is thinly spread over a soft thin oversized cracker. The pizza had no crust and barely any dough it was that thin. The slices were weightless. But I guess props to them for managing to roll out a breadsticks worth of dough into 16 inch circle. $15 bucks for some bland sauce, cheese and no dough pizza. Nope. read more

Bunch of people from work go here so I figured give it a shot. This places is great, it's small, but it's great. What I really like are the prices...they aren't bad. They have lunch specials that throw in a soda for a couple of bucks, and anything in this day and age helps. I have to say though that it's not what's expected in our area, they knock it out of the park...and a few places can do that! read more

How I haven't reviewed this place already is mind blowing. This is the pizza place I grew up with and every other pizza judgment revolves around this and Nellie's, depending on style. The cheese when eaten fresh and crust when still hot are virtually impossible to beat. The key to whether you like Natale's Pizza or not is whether you like the sauce or not because people do have preferences in this area. For me when hot, the sauce is perfect, although it does not reheat as well as some people would like and may be thicker than most people would like. Though not nearly as much quantity, the physical consistency of the sauce is more along the lines of a Chicago deep dish. The speed is the same as it has been for the last 25+ years even though the prices like every pizza joint have risen. The service turns over quite a bit, though my experience last week was of the highest quality. The quality of sandwiches and other items can vary year over year as well, even though the pizza is about as consistent as you can possibly be over multiple decades. This is a borderline 5 for me, even though I could see why people who go for other sandwiches could disagree. There are many other Italian options in the area, some of which have better stombolis and calzones and for that reason I give four stars. read more

This place is a typical local pizzeria. Pizza is good, nothing really special about. Price is reasonable. More expensive than Domino's, but the quality and taste is better. What my wife and I usually order from the place are wings. The wings are good size and sauces are decent. But the amount of sauce you get depends on who makes the wings. Sometimes the wings will be drenched in sauce and sometimes the sauces will be inconsistently spread on the wings. They need a way to coat the wings properly with the sauce. There is a wings and sub shop close by called Ike's that's more expensive but the taste is the same. Other food here such as wraps, subs, and pastas are decent. It is what you would expect from a place like this. Overall, ok food, reasonable price, nothing special. read more

Natale's Pizzeria - Half eaten orders of bbq and buffalo wings. - Pizza Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

Fresh mozzarella and basil pizza with vodka sauce is a must have if you're ordering here. Actually anything with vodka sauce here is amazing! Always fast service and a staple for take out nights and football weekends. Service is always friendly and delivery is quick too! If they jarred their vodka sauce and sold it I'd buy a lifetime supply! read more

Natale's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

Great local pizzeria. Price and specials (check the entrance - not on website) is what drew us to this place. The entire family loves it and it is part of our rotation. Nothing fancy - but everything is what you would expect from a local pizzeria. read more

Natale's Pizzeria - Specials - Pizza Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

Overall the food was pretty good. Just got something simple, a grilled chicken salad. Stars taken away though because one of the reasons I chose natales was the prices seemed good for standard items. But when I got there what I was charged didn't match the menu. They went out of their way to point out their digital menu. But the price ended up two dollars higher somehow. The regular board in store had no prices on it which I think might actually be illegal. So ok food but not the value that it looked like. read more

We ordered 8 pizzas for delivery for an outdoor birthday party. Not only were they delivered exactly at the specified time, but they were very hot-we had a very hungry and very happy group of party-goers! Great experience! read more

This place has good pizza. Their Hawaiian is great. It had a ton of pineapple and ham on it . . . More than most places put on it. The grilled chicken wrap with sun dried tomatoes and mozzarella was a little bland. I would get their pizza over anything else. read more

We had not ordered from them for a while and it was WONDERFUL. We got a large sausage pizza and a salad. Super fresh, right on time-really great value. read more

If you like thin crust ny style slices, this is a great place. Clean and fast. Crust is on sweet side and sauce isnt too spiced

I ate here 2 days in a row this last time I was in NJ because their pizza is truly delicious and I plan on eating there again every time I'm in NJ. Natale's was THE place that finally got me to admit that Pizza is just better on the east coast because I haven't been able to find anything close to Natale's pizza in CA. read more

My default pizza joint whenever I get to New Jersey. Great NY style pizza. Love the veal parm hero, and the meatball hero too. Mostly carryout. A few high top tables. Fast friendly service. read more

Being a Manhattan-ite it's near impossible to find real pizza. Natale's is true NYC pizza with the perfect balance of ingredients, the exact thickness crust should be, and cooked down to the right second. The staff is polite, efficient, plus it's delivered fresh and fast. read more

Place has very good pizza. We often get pizza from here when we have people over. People here are very quick and accommodating!

We love the pizza!!! We usually order a plain pie and a pepperoni pie. Always excellent, hot and crispy! Good delivery, arrives when they say it will. we also order the garlic knots, love these. read more

Delicious Pizza! Just like you would expect to get when you travel to NY. The cheese and pepperoni was the bomb! The sauce was simply divine. We will definitely order again. We had delivery and it did not take too long, and it was the first time they had delivered to this building. We all can't wait to order from here again. YUM! read more

Natale's catered my daughters B-day party. Everyone loved the food! Great pasta, chicken, sausage... yup, all good!