another great dinner. had to come to try the new pasta dishes that they have weekly. i had gnocchi with lamb ragu. it was simply amazing little puffs of clouds with a awesome ragu. pizza great as usual. Brussels sprouts so crunchy and tasty. love this place you have to come here. read more

See all

I finally got to try Mili Lucci Pizza in New City, and overall, I liked it! I ordered the Snow White pizza and thought it was really good. I'm glad I went with that one because I definitely enjoyed it! My only complaint would have to be the pricing. I felt like it was a little expensive for pizza, especially since it doesn't come with anything on the side. Don't get me wrong, I don't mind paying more for good food, but I do feel like the price should match what you're getting. Other than that, I had a good experience! I wouldn't mind coming back and trying something different on the menu. I just wish the prices were a little more reasonable. If you're in the area, I'd say it's worth giving a try! read more

Not your traditional pizza place - High end iItalian imported ingredients w/ a special dough that takes 3 days to get just right that I've never had - quite good - bring your appetite - you get a big dinner - no slices here. Server very friendly and informative as well! read more

Mille Luci was highly recommended to us by my coworkers and we were not disappointed with the food, staff, service and atmosphere. I recently took my family there to celebrate a birthday and from the minute we walked in until the time we left, our party was services promptly and professionally by Lucas our waiter and fellow staff. The owner took time to stop by and ask how everything was and also to share about how the restaurant came to be and how his passion has shaped his restaurant. Needless to say you're missing out if you haven't been to Mille Luci yet!!! The food is great and the staff are excellent. Make sure you visit Mille Luci and have a great dinner with family and friends. read more

Mille Luci Pizzeria - Enjoying a great night with family at Mille Luci; the best restaurant in New City. - Pizza Near Me - New City, New York

A friend recommended this place they sell their pizza by foot and not by slice. Beware the only accept cash. Pizza dough is well cooked, Nice crunch, good flavor. Lots to choose from. I made the mistake of ordering a 2 foot pizza when I could've tasted two 1 foot versions. And even more ghastly, I took home the left overs I wanted for my wife and had them sideways in the saddlebag of the bike. Well, some of them spilled . Definitely not your average corner pizza place. A must try. read more

See all

Aesthetic ambiance. Kind attending servers. Went with a friend and we had the meat lover pizza, just wish the pizza was big enough for the both of us, great fresh flavor just felt slightly short of being satisfactory for 2 people- again in terms of size only. Would recommend read more

I recommend this place highly! Great food and service! really great experience! We will be going back again for sure! Try the meatballs!

I live in San Francisco and make sure to visit this restaurant every time we're in town. The pizza is incredible! The baking process comes from Italy and it's very specific. The crust is light, crunchy and chewy. If this restaurant were in Manhattan you would see a line out the door. I tried the dessert today and it was also amazing!! This place is definitely worth a visit! read more

Had a couples dinner at Mille Luci last night. Our friends had been there a couple of times already and wanted us to try it. We walked in and the first thing I noted is the intimacy of the setting. Truly a cozy and beautiful restaurant. All of the staff were friendly and professional throughout the meal. Our waitress was especially good, she had a strong knowledge of their menu and had developed favorites to recommend. We had the burrata appetizer and the cheese and meat antipasto for appetizers. We also had Caesar salad and the arugula salad. The burrata is a highlight, it's definitely high quality. Everything was solid quality. My friend and I shared two feet of pizza. The Snow White was excellent ricotta and hot honey and the Pesto Scamorza had great smoked provolone flavor. The crust itself is quite good. We also had one gluten free pizza. We were pretty full but the desserts were too tempting to pass up. The waitress let us know that the owner gets the cannolis from a Brooklyn bakery, they were outstanding. The pistachio ricotta cake was also a hit! If I had to recommend anything, it would be finding a way to add grilled chicken, shrimp, and steak options to the salads. Some people don't eat pizza for dietary reasons and the options would be nice. read more

See all

Amazing food. Great vibe to just chill with your family. Best service. Great variety. read more

Mille Luci Pizzeria - Mix of different pizza. Almost 4 feet long. All different toppings. - Pizza Near Me - New City, New York

CASH Only! ATM inside or bank ATM in shopping center. The ambience was much trendier and classy than I expected. Simple menu with phenomenal food! Some of the best pizza I've had! Everything made to order. Cut everything up so it is easy to share. Started with a glass of rosé and a beer with a salad. Salads are also designed for sharing as well as the pizza. Will be back for sure! read more

See all

Probably the best Pizza I have ever had. Once u get used to the original shape and ordering one or two foot sizes, you are in for a unique treat . The salads and garlic focaccia are also excellent. read more

We visited for the first time today. We had the Nona meatballs and the burrata and let's just say they did not disappoint. For our main dinner we had the Snow White and the Diavolo pizza. They are both very different and very delightful to eat. We will definitely will be returning. The staff was very friendly and on point. read more

Where i live there are at least 8 Pizzzaria ' Mille Luci is Roman pizza. Excellent if you Never had it you must try it is my favorite read more

Went on a Wednesday Night. They had a singer who was great. It really made the pizzeria a lot of fun. The restaurant was clean and well appointed. The staff were attentive and on top of everything. The food? WOW! The pizza comes in personal 1 foot or 2 foot. We had the meat lovers pizza and the vegetable pizza. Fresh ingredients and delicious! We ordered the meatballs as an appetizer and they were off the hook. The salads were fresh and delicious! We also had the Brussel Sprouts and they were done to perfection. The cannolis were fresh and tasted heavenly. The espresso was wonderful. We were not rushed and the atmosphere was friendly and relaxed. Credit cards are not accepted but there is an ATM on premises. The restrooms were spotless! Mille Luci is an experience. You really need to make the trip! It was worth every penny! read more

Best Pizza in Rockland! The pizza by the footb is a great concept, saw a few large groups getting 4 ft pies. We got the Nonna's Meatballs to start, they were great. We then got the San Daniele, which was delicious. For desert, we split a peice of ricotta cake and a couple of cappucinos, delicious and perfectly made. Great Service. Seems a bit cramped, but was grateful that I didn't need to wait on a busy Saturday evening. Can't wait to go back. They only take cash, but they have an ATM that doesn't charge a fee. read more

Wasn't sure they would be open, but decided to give it a try on Sunday 5/24/26. Have gone several times for lunch and found them to closed with hours removed from their door. Pizza was good, but expensive. $100 for a party of 4 - glass of wine, a beer and 2' of pizza. Plenty of choices out there ,,,,, I don't think we will be back. Also, NO CREDIT CARDS! Only accepts cash. Most customers know a pizza costs about $5 in ingredients - no reason to market it up 10+ times. read more

To start, we had the Caesar salad and garlic zeppoles. The salad had a generous amount of shaved Parmesan on it, as well as a few anchovies, which I like. The zeppoles had nice little mounds of minced garlic parsley mix on top, and some great marinara. For pizza, we got a 1 foot margarita, and a 2 foot vodka margarita with sausage and onions. Both were superb, with great cheese, and a nice crispy undercarriage. The onions were finely diced and sprinkled evenly, and the sausage was quite tasty. We finished with some mini cannolis that appeared to be freshly filled for us. Great service, appetizers and drinks arrived promptly, with the pizza coming like 15 mins following that. We will be back here again! read more

Outstanding Food & service! Fried calzone the BEST. The pizza is AMAZING. We had meat lovers & the prosciutto arugula pie. Each foot is about a small pie. We ended with a complimentary dessert. Will absolutely be back!!! read more

See all

The pizza was excellent!! The Cesar salad dressing was super yummy and the dessert special read more

Mille Luci Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - New City, New York

See all

The best pizza in the area, hands-down. We had the prosciutto and burrata pizza, It was so delicious. We met the owner Joe who is a pleasure to deal with he was able to get us a table during a busy time of the evening. For dessert we had the Best cannolis ever. Also to wash it down we had the espresso ice cream, It was so delicious. Such a hidden gem. The go to place for amazing pizza, beer, and wine. We will be back again soon. read more

Mille Luci Pizzeria - Burrata & prosciutto pie. - Pizza Near Me - New City, New York

If you like Roman style pizza without marinara sauce then this is the place for you. Fresh ingredients and a crusty, thick pie means it's also very tasty. If you also like a noisy, cold & drafty room that only takes cash then this is still the place for you. Good service, clean & bright room with reasonable prices and wines & beers, this is a good restaurant but not great. read more

Eat here all the time! It's not your typical round pie... food is amazing meatballs best I've ever had. I Will be coming back.

A wonderful dining experience!!!! The food is that of Italy! Whether we dine as a family or order 12 foot pies for a party, the service and food along with the atmosphere are all exceptional! read more

Best pizza in America hands down, closest thing to authentic Italian food I've ever had in the United States. Incredible service, friendly and great atmosphere. Must try the snow white pizza, the brussel sprouts, meatballs and the zeppoles. Everything was delicious and the list goes on. Can't wait to come back! read more

Mille Luci Pizzeria - burata and snow white pizza, AMAZING! - Pizza Near Me - New City, New York

Went for the first time today with my friend. Between the 2 of us, we had 4 kids and a baby! I'm always nervous to go anywhere with the kids but the staff and owners were so welcoming and happy to have us! They even complemented by 7 year old's behavior, which meant a lot to her. We ordered meatballs which my picky 4 year old devoured! We also ordered the margherita pizza, margherita with vodka sauce, and sausage and peppers. Very good! Thin and light crust, sauce is delicious, perfect ratios. The establishment is really pretty and very clean. We will definitely be back! Just a tip-cash only. read more

From food to service 5 stars!! we are definitely picky about our pizza and calzone and this is probably one of the best! Joe the owner is wonderful! and Nick our waiter/bartender top notch! definitely will be back for a third time ++ read more

First time at Mille Luci!!! Everything was Amazing from start to finish. I consider myself to be a food snob!Let me start by saying that the service was excellent !! The pizza was like no other. Great crust and flavor!! OMG never tasted pizza like this. Highly Highly recommend!!! The calzone was so so fresh and tasty!! Caesar salad delicious. We went on a Saturday night. Met Joe the owner!! So so nice. He has an amazing recipe that no one else has. Quality Quality:))) can't wait to bring my family back. 5 stars for sure. Thank you for a great dining experience:)) read more

We arrived close to closing, we had just been at my dad's wake for 4 hours, and were starving! They made us feel welcome and happily seated us without a word about how close it was to closing. The garlic zeppolis were amazing, so buttery and garlicky but also very light and airy. My husband also had Nonna's meatballs and he said they were delish. For pizza we got 2 ft of meatball, 2 ft with eggplant (think it was The Parmesana) and a ft of sausage and peppers; everyone loved what they tried! The crust was thin, but not too thin and a perfect crispness and the toppings were plentiful but not too much for the crust. Sooo good!! read more

Mille Luci Pizzeria - 4 feet of pizza - Pizza Near Me - New City, New York

The food is definitely good, especially the brick oven pizza. However, I'm not a fan of their prices.

I am a pizza enthusiast and it's all about wood fire or brick oven and I'm looking for a place in New City, saw the pics on this place and you can tell when a pizza is good just by the way the crust looks. I'm the first here greeted by a young kid who knows his beers and the food they make and my first bite into the 'Snow White" you can literally taste the quality of all the ingredients , an explosion of flavors in your mouth. The owner comes over to say hi and says all his ingredients come direct from Italy, I mean, the richness in the ricotta cheese was enough for me to take my cheat meal to another level and kill the whole thing. Everything is made from scratch, low in sodium, without the other crap you can taste in some pizza. He said his cannoli comes direct from Palermo Italy frozen and DAMN! I had a face like a man who was dreaming. I cannot wait to come and try something else and something else. CASH ONLY!!! They got it like that read more

Mille Luci Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - New City, New York

Pizza choices are amazing. I love the Snow White and the Prosciutto and Burrata is especially good. Service is warm and friendly and the atmosphere is casual but well above fast food. A fave of mine. read more

Believe the good reviews Our son lives in NJ, about 45 minutes away and he took us there while we were traveling from Florida. We thought he was crazy to travel that far for pizza but we are so glad he insisted we try this place. Delicious, delicious delicious!!! Eating there is like being at a party because there were many large groups enjoying the evening. The pizza is sold by the foot not by the pan and you can get one as long as six feet long. Everything else we sampled was also good and the owners and staff were warm and friendly. If you are in or around Rockland County, do give this place a try. read more

Yum! We went to Mille Luci to celebrate a few family birthdays and it did not disappoint. We ordered 6 feet of pizza for 7 of us, which was a slight miscalculation, but happy to bring home leftovers! The Snow White and Margherita pizzas were favorites - we will be back! read more

Mille Luci Pizzeria - Snow White - Pizza Near Me - New City, New York

See all

The fun, cozy and rustic ambiance, extremely warm and friendly service and delicious pizza combine to make Mille Luci a family favorite. This is NOT your average take out pizzeria, but, rather, a more elevated, unique and GREAT restaurant that serves yummy pizza. The incredibly affable host and servers make you feel like you're dining in your Italian grandmother's kitchen. Mille Luci checks ALL the right boxes for a family favorite, neighborhood gem restaurant. read more

Pinsa was excellent! Sausage , sauce, cheese and dough were right on the money. Bring cash. Nuff said.

I would give Mille Luci ten starts if I could! I'm a foodie, cookbook author, and was born into a family of restauranteurs. Mille Luci exceeded my expectations, serving me and my friends beautifully crafted pizzas, generously proportioned fresh-green salads, and desserts like tiramisu and cream filled cannolis that tasted better than any I've ever had before. The owners are passionate about food and take great pride in sourcing and importing from little towns all over Italy the finest ingredients for their pizzas and desserts. It shows! Plus, I recognize quality and finesse when a restauranteur uses Stanislaus tomatoes -- recognized by chefs as the tastiest (and most expensive!) on the market. Kudos to Joe and his family for creating a place I will return to again, even though I live on the other side of the Hudson River! read more

We had a girls get together and really enjoyed the food and wine! It's a small place so make sure you make a reservation if you have a bigger party. read more

See all

I just heard about this place today, and it is the BEST pizza in Rockland! The ingredients are all fresh from Italy. The dough is very light, and the cheese and sauce and everything else on the crust is indescribably delicious! Joe the owner explained everything to us with great detail, and I can tell he loves his restaurant and runs it very well. The place seems to be very popular, which makes sense because the food is just that good! I ordered the Margherita pizza (1 foot), and my girlfriend ordered the Prosciutto e Burrata pizza. We both loved it and will be back soon! They accept cash only, but they have a free ATM to use so you don't have to worry about any charges to withdraw cash. Hurry and try it out and be amazed! read more

See all

Searched on line for a restaurant in the vicinity of our hotel and came across this hidden gem. We are originally from.Brooklyn and have eaten our share of pizzas. This was by far one of the best we've had. The dough is delicious - light and crispy- and the toppings are to die for. Everything is so fresh and all high quality ingredients. Service is great and the owner and his son are super friendly and walk around and talk to the patrons to make sure all is well. The on the house dessert was out of this world - a variety of Italian specialties..The cannolis were so delicious. If you are in the area you have to stop in - your wont be disappointed . This is definitely our go to place from now on when we are in the area. read more