This place deserves ten stars! What a find! It's on the smaller side so you really need a reservation we went on a Saturday at 4 and it was starting to fill up halfway through our meal and what a meal it was! We started with the case salad , Argula, romaine olives and zucchini. It was so light and the dressing was delicious. We also had the shrimp app which went perfect with the salad because it had a little bit of spice to it so it was a great combo. We then moved on to the main course which was a margarita pizza and a side of broccoli Rabe. We are really picky when it comes to the broccoli and this place nailed it it was just like eating my grandma's recipe and the pizza was absolutely amazing. It was late and the taste was out out of this world. You can taste that they use all high-quality ingredients. I also need to add that the place is immaculate. Even the bathroom was spotless. Please make sure you stop in and give them a try read more

See all

Fabulous Neapolitan style pizza. Super light and authentic. We got it to go. one pizza 1/2 margherita 1/2 Jabroni. Simple yet very nice. Due to its thin it gets cold easily so it's best to dine in eat while it's warm from the oven read more

Quick late lunch but omg it was amazing. Half margarita half cheese was so so good. Crispy crust no flop Spicy rigatoni with sausage amazing. This is starting to be a fav read more

See all

Cozy area with a family setting and welcoming, plenty of parking outside with other small shops to stroll around after dinner and walk off all the carbs. Waitress and workers were all friendly with a smile, you don't feel like a bother asking questions about things on the menu. Ordered a bunch of things to try for a party of 6, made reservations but it was a weekday and def didn't need one but better safe than sorry. I read it was homemade pasta? Which is awesome you rarely see that these days. Sauce on each pasta was nice and cheesy. I just say the pizza was a tad floppy for me though. Perhaps too thin? Or maybe not burnt enough? It had great flavor but I rather it have a good when I grabbed it. Overall I would def come back and try other things. Pizza pie and beer? Can't go wrong with that! read more

See all

Delicious pizza- had the margarita and the pallon. Both were excellent. Crust is very light on the stomach and not floppy. Stomach felt great after too (not greasy)! Also very nice ambiance! read more

Pizzetiello - Margarita & Pallon - Italian Near Me - Pearl River, New York

The service was great but the pizza was average. I had the white pie and it wasn't anything super special. Crust was more chewy than I'd like. I doubt i'll be back just because there is a different spot close by that I like a lot more. read more

I finally got to try this relatively new place and brought my family of four on a Friday night. I called in advance and made a reservation. The person on the phone spoke clearly and was pleasant to talk to. There are a decent amount of tables inside considering it's a small place. They do get crowded at peak hour so we were fortunate to have the reservation. They sell beer and wine here. Prices for a bottle of wine aren't terrible, so I bought a bottle of Montepulciano. It wasn't wonderful, but was drinkable enough. We started with their Casa Salad (house salad). The portion size matched the price and I enjoyed it. Loaded with shallots and olives, it's my kind of salad. My daughter took one bite of the picked zucchini on top and was turned off due to the acidity. My wife ate the salad with my, but if anyone doesn't like salads that are too acidic, maybe try a different one. Our server was very pleasant, friendly and I noticed all servers worked well together and communicated well. I think the staff here do a fine job. None of our entrees had us generally satisfied. My son's gnocchi in Sunday sauce was bland and watery. It wasn't a rich flavorful sauce at all. The peak cheek also lacked flavor. No seasoning, salt, pepper, anything could've helped this dish a bit. It just tasted like we were eating boiled pork and potatoes. I was very excited to try the pizzas here as I make my own neopolitan pizzas at home and have had wonderful, amazing ones in Rome. Both pizzas we received were quite watery in the middle. We couldn't lift a slice of margherita without the entire middle half sopping over and contents oozing. We did our best to squish master together and bite, but that's not how it should be. Even my daughter's polpette Pizza want much better for structure and she also said it got a little sickening to eat. I do think the pizza dough here was delicious and there's potential. Whoever was making these pizzas was likely putting too much on them for the thickness of the crust. Unfortunately, nobody enjoyed anything enough for us to warrant a return. I am very pleased to say they do not charge a credit card fee! Bravo to the owner. read more

See all

We have been talking about wanting to go to Pizzizalo for a while. We went on a Thursday night and when we arrived at 5:30, with no reservation and it was empty. However, when we left, the place was slammed and almost every table was taken. For drinks I had the red sangria, which was just average, I wouldn't order it again. My husband had an Italian beer. We ordered one of the specials as an appetizer, little dipper. The description had baby spinach, italian artichoke, house ricotta and more. When it arrived, it was not what was expected. It was all mixed together like a spinach dip. The flavor wasn't good, it tasted like frozen spinach. I did not like it at all. It was served with sourdough.The sourdough was by far the highlight of the meal. It was warm, crispy, and soft. We almost ate all of it. For an entree, we split the sausage and broccoli rabe pizza. It said it was spicy on the menu, but there was no spice at all. All I tasted was the broccoli rabe, which was delicious. The dough was too tasty, but it was too thin and would fall apart at the bottom. We are happy we tried it, but we won't be returning anytime soon. read more

See all

Amazing food and great service. Love this place. The white pizza was the best I've ever had.

Owned by a true Italian, this small and cozy restaurant invites you to experience a true taste of Italy. I was incredibly impressed with everything I devoured. I recommend the mouth watering fresh autumn buratta accompanied by a bed of arugula with prosciutto, almonds, apples, and drizzled balsamic glaze. The cacio e pepe ($19) was delicious and perfectly cooked. The owner creates his own phenomenal pizzas in a brick oven of around 700 degrees. I highly recommend all pizzas, but the Benny blanco pizza ($20) was out of this world. We sat at the wine bar where the ambiance was intimate and all staff (most from Italy!) were friendly and attentive. The wine list offers many options, but we had the crisp Sauvignon blanc. I will definitely be returning to Pizzetiello! read more

See all

Run, don't walk to this authentic Italian "pizzetielo." Great menu. The pizza is very special. The arugula salad was the best I've ever had in my life. Gracious staff with lots of smiling faces. Large portions, two could share a salad n pizza. As ambiance goes, I felt transported back to Napoli. I can't wait to come back. read more

See all

This restaurant is a gem, offering delicious food made with seasonally sourced ingredients. Tonight's soup, salad, and pomodoro sauce had ingredients from an Amish farm in Pennsylvania. I was tempted to try nearly everything on both the regular and specials menus, but I knew I wouldn't be able to finish it all. The soup was freshly made, the Casa salad was fantastic, and I absolutely loved the Spaghetti Pomodoro! The servers were wonderful--kind and attentive, enhancing the overall experience. The atmosphere was relaxed and cozy, making it a perfect spot for a meal. I'm already looking forward to my next visit! read more

Love this place ! The service slays too and always a great crowd in it ,, prob my fav Caesar salad but all the food is good read more

See all

Do not sleep on this local Italian gem. Since my wife and I found this place we come once a week. Everything on the menu is yummy. The pasta is made in house and the portions are fantastic. It's a cute spot with great ambiance and easy on the wallet. Not a full bar but the drinks offered are perfect along with Italian wine and beer. Giada, the lead hostess, is amazing. Highly recommend. read more

See all

Service was wonderful, the food was mediocre. despite the welcoming & attentive wait staff and the delicious fresh salad as one of our appetizers, the overall experience didn't quite live up to the price point (ex: le pizze). read more

We had lunch at Pizzetiello this weekend. We kept it pretty simple and straight forward with a house salad, Spicy Vodka Rigatoni, Pesto Napoletano and the Tiramisu neo-classico for dessert. We started with the salad and as an italian american with grand parents from naples, the salad took me back to sitting shoulder to shoulder crammed into my grandparents back yard, perfectly dressed, fresh ingredients, perfectly pickled veggies and delightful olives was the perfect start and a really nice palate cleanser that we kept on the table through the our pasta course. The pasta dishes were wonderfully balanced and perfectly cooked. My rigatoni was very al dente, just spicy enough and the right amount of besciamella to counter the heat. My wife had the Pesto Napoletano which had plenty of of zuchinni and lovely mix of basil and cheese. We finished with the tiramisù neo-classico which featured mascarpone whipped cream that was a really nice touch. Simple and delicious. The restaurant is very clean and well appointed, the staff clearly takes pride in keeping the establish looking it's best. It's open, fresh and very welcoming. We are fortunate to live in the nyc area with a plethora of amazing food options and experiences but this is honestly the first restaurant i've been to that is as good as the food i've eaten while in Italy. We always yearn for Italy 'style' italian food which for whatever reason seems very difficult to replicate in the states but Pizzetiéllo has done it! This is my new favorite restaurant i literally can not wait to go back! read more

Pizzetiello - Spicy Vodka Rigatoni - Italian Near Me - Pearl River, New York

I LOVE Pizzetiello - it's absolutely become a Pearl River favorite! The food is DELICIOUS and I love sitting at the bar space with the open kitchen - seeing the pizzas made is really incredible, you can see how fresh everything is and how much care goes into making them. Want to make a note that it was explicitly explained to us that when ordering pasta, it's more of an appetizer size (though for me, it was more than enough when paired with an app!). The cacio e pepe I had was some of the best I've had outside of Italy - absolutely perfect, SO fresh, and filling! I actually couldn't finish all of mine. The pizza is also DELICIOUS, with so many different varieties and the perfect size to split (or just have for yourself if you're really hungry!) - love pairing and splitting a pizza and pasta dish. There are always great specials too, we've taken advantage of the burrata apps each time we've gone. The drinks are also solid - beer and wine/wine cocktails, but incredibly unique and some great Spritz variations! The service is also beyond amazing - the whole team is friendly, they remembered us when we came back, and were just delightful to interact with. Can't speak more highly of the team working at Pizzetiello! This is one of those spots we walked by one day and bookmarked to go into and I am SO happy that we did - it's the perfect spot for time with friends, to have a date night, or grab a pizza/food to go! Very different (in a good way) from other Pearl River spots (and I'm actually now craving another cacio e pepe, so will have to make a stop there soon!). read more

See all

Fresh ingredients, large servings! Great night to share plates with friends/family. The Cesar salad was a favorite

Love this place! Pizza is great. Pasta is incredible. Very home cooked feeling. The staff is always very kind and helpful

The best restaurant around! The owner and chef Danny is a remarkable cook and human being, with years of training and experience cooking for some of the top restaurants in the country under his belt before opening up Pizzetiello. The pizza is immaculate and authentic- the only real Neapolitan pizza in the area! They are now using fresh mozzarella too! The pasta is fresh pasta and is just as authentic and exquisite. The staff are friendly, attentive and professional. The entire place was well constructed and meticulously designed, creating a soothing ambiance that celebrates the Napoli FC Football club from Naples, Italy- where the chef's family is from. I can not say enough good things about Pizzetiello. It's worth coming to no matter where you are! You won't find too many places like it anywhere. read more

See all

I've had pizza in Naples and every pizza I've had here more then holds its own against them. Seriously worth your time to stop in read more

Pizzetiello - One of the best pizzas I've ever had - Italian Near Me - Pearl River, New York

We were craving for a good thin crust pizza and our fave spot in New City had closed. Finally, found a great replacement and we will be back for more. We tried the margarita and eggplant parm pie. Delicious and quality ingredients and cannot wait to come back for more and to try the rest of the menu. read more

Pizzetiello - a pizza on a table - Italian Near Me - Pearl River, New York

See all

The food was great, and the pizza was even better. The staff was very attentive and really showed how hard they tried to do a great job. Matt, our waiter really showed he cared about giving us great service. read more

Pizzetiello - Italian Near Me - Pearl River, New York

Hands down the best Neapolitan pizza in NY! This is a real TRUE pizza experience where the owners are true pizziaolo's and make every pie with true artisan love and freshness. Hands down amazing dough and ingredients. The service is amazing and a real fantastic place for a date night or family pizza. You won't find more authentic anywhere close. I also tried the prosciutto panini which was fantastic! Can't wait to try the rest of the menu. If you haven't yet tried it. Get there! Highly recommended read more

Everything was delicious. The wait staff were so nice and attentive. Perfect place for lunch or dinner with good vibes. They did a very nice job on the interior. read more

Pizzetiello - Italian Near Me - Pearl River, New York

See all

Chef Dan is a pizza master! I highly recommend Pizzetiello, delicious pizza and pasta.

Great Southern Italian cuisine.Original dishes. Comfortable ambitious and stellar service. Owner is also the head chef. Best casual restaurant in the county. read more

The food was very good. The service was excellent and we had a wonderful time, relaxing and enjoy enjoying ourselves.

Excellent Freshly Made Individual Pizzas - Finest Ingredients. Ice Cold Beer. Nice Wine Selection. Absolutely Fantastic Pasta Dishes. Top Notch Neighborhood Gem. read more

Cold cuts was old and skimpy for the appetizer. The pizza was blahhh...As an Italian I give him 1 star .

Review only for the pizza - ordered here twice. The cheese and toppings fell off on both pies while trying to eat it. I understand that the pizza is thin but it's difficult to eat when the entire slice is falling off. I think it needs more dough. read more

Great little pizza place both to eat in and take out. Service is friendly and knowledgeable. atmosphere is great and food is great. We especially love the appetizers, but the pizza is great as well. Highly recommen. read more

This is the absolute worst pizza & food I've ever had. My 3 year old grandson who loves pizza cried because he did not like it. He said, "I don't like" & cried. The eggplant pizza looked NOTHING like the picture & barely had any eggplant. The ragu pasta was not ragu and was so bad, it went into the garbage. Shame on you. Horrible & horrible. read more

Went in here for the first time, had to be some of the best pizza I've ever had. The people were nice, and the whole place was very nice. 100% recommend read more

The owner's response to my review speaks volumes. In addition to spewing nonsense, he has the gall to lecture a customer about the style of pizza. I did not know that 500 years of tradition resulted in giving a customer raw dough. Seems they would have figured it out by now. As for his assertion that my order was ready 5 minutes late is absurd. I find it interesting that a guy running around on a busy Friday night knew exactly what time I arrived and left. I arrived at 6:44 or so and left at 7:10. The young ladies working there told me there would be a delay when I got there and suggested I hang out at the bar. They were apologetic and very pleasant and professional. I gave them a tip when I left. I would never curse at hard working teenagers who had nothing to do with the stupidity of the owner. As for a new concept, I would suggest you try the other "Roman" pizza places popping up in the area. Went to one last night. My pizza was actually cooked properly. Imagine that. read more

First time trying since it opened. We were immediately transported to the fantastic Neapolitan pizza we had in Italy. The ingredients were fresh and the pizza and risotto were delicious. Service was attentive and friendly. Highly recommended. read more

See all

Have been here a few times now...our favorite spot in pearl river! Everything on the menu is amazing, love how simple yet flavorful the ingredients are, true quality. Keep it up, pizzatiello! Already looking forward to coming back. read more

It's just not worth it. My daughter wanted to go here for dinner after seeing it on Instagram Service was awkward and seemed forced. The pizza had very little flavor. Had a Broccoli rabe dish that tasted like bleach. I really wanted to like this place but it seems like they're still in the very beginning stages of figuring it out. The menu itself is very crunchy. every other word is organic. I wouldn't spend money here again. read more

I love this place! Great atmosphere, very cozy. The staff is very attentive & kind. My fiancé and I love to come here, split two pizzas, some wine, and we try something new every time, have never been disappointed. My favorite thing about this place is that all of the ingredients taste super fresh and high quality. Hoping all good things for Pizzetiello! read more

Pizzetiello - MUST TRY! Hot honey & Pepperoni - Italian Near Me - Pearl River, New York

I first heard about this restaurant on Lohud. When I saw they had Neapolitan style pizza I knew I just had to try it! My husband and I are picky when it comes to Italian food. This place truly blew us out of the water! Not only is the atmosphere perfect for the cutest date night, the food is seriously amazing. I've been here several times and always have a great experience. The pizza, apps, and cocktails are all so tasty. They have unique options as well such as citrus tiramisu. The service is always great and they truly make sure you are taken care of. You can tell the owner very much cares about quality and your experience as a customer. Shout out to Matt and Rafael! Our favorite spot! read more

See all