Wow, what a hidden gem!! This spot is a bit off the tourist path, but we'll worth it. Our server Collin was terrific, he took the time to explain some menu items and recommended some delicious items for us to sample... the big winner was the Snickerdoodle Crème Brûlée dessert (what an amazing combination) it was perfectly creamy and the caramelized to perfection. Don't let that take away from the delicious entrees my wife and I thoroughly enjoyed. I ordered the smoked sliced brisket, wow that was was super delicious. My wife ordered The seared chicken. She was raving about how well the chicken was cooked, literally to perfection, juicy and tender with very robust flavor. The brown gravy and mashed potatoes were also to her liking. In all the entrees were outstanding, with big portions that are cooked to perfection. Seriously don't miss out on this place, everything about it is amazing. read more

See all

While every dining experience I've had at the Mill has been outstanding, planning and hosting events here is what inspired me to write this review. I have hosted two events at the Mill including a wedding luncheon and both have been amazing experiences. Nicole, the events coordinator, is exceptional! I never had a doubt that everything would go perfectly. Nicole was so accommodating and worked with us to make sure every detail was perfect! The event staff is always attentive and very competent. The food is always delicious and will have your guests raving! The Mill is always my first recommendation when someone needs to host an event. read more

Ambiance was great! I told our waiter that his demeanor just matched the whole vibe- he was so good at his job and went beyond with his service. The food was good. Some of it was a little salty, I will say that was my own criticism- too much salt on the chips and the fries. But everything else was good. And my drink- oh my goodness! I got Lime in the Coconut ... I would drive the 2 hour drive back to this restaurant just for that drink again! When I'm Hershey again - I'll definitely go back. read more

One of the best meals I have ever had. The lamb special appetizer was delightful. Both my husband and grandson loved the food.

Excellent choice for supper! MAKE A RESERVATION, if not than you have to eat at the bar (which wasn't bad). The bar was very large and had plenty of space for our plates and drinks. The menu is limited in my opinion, but they are willing to amend a dish which was amazing. Service was great, LOVE the drink menu. All drinks had fresh ingredients, no additives to give the flavor (blueberry, rosemary, mint, etc.). Food came out fairly quick and was fresh. We ate downstairs and it was really neat seeing the structure of the old mill. Renovations to turn it into a restaurant were amazingly done. This was the perfect stop before going to a Hershey Bears game. The reason for 4 stars is because a little pricy and the limited menu - it would be difficult to bring a family or to meet up with friends. read more

See all

Such a quaint place . my husband and I went and had a great dinner. Service was awesome and we can't wait to go back.

The Mill is always one of my favorite restaurants in the area and therefore was excited to show it off while a friend was visiting. They didn't have their usual menu which was slightly upsetting (LOVE their salmon wrap) but was able to find something else... The chicken taco was tasty and flavorful however it was a bit soggy and crumbled in my hands. That said the covid menu is a fixed $10 so definitely cheaper than their usual entree prices! They have a cute enclosed patio in the front with heat lamps above every table. Will return like I always do! read more

The Mill - Hershey - Chicken tacos - New American Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

The vibe here is everything. I love visiting the Mill for drinks and dinner. Between the ambiance and fantastic food & drink selection, it's a no brainer to stop here for a good meal. Recently, I visited The Mill for drinks. I saw on their Facebook page the new Toasted Old Fashioned. It's was the perfect fall cocktail to cozy up with on a cold Friday night. This delicious drink is made with Basil Hayden toast bourbon, vanilla simple syrup, chocolate bitters, and creme de cacao, with a graham cracker rim & toasted marshmallow. It tasted just as good as it looks! read more

The Mill - Hershey - Toasted Old Fashioned - New American Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

Amazing ambiance, delicious food and great service. Everything was fantastic! Great portion sizes and an elaborate menu. Plenty of great non-alcoholic cocktails (mocktails) for anyone AF. Beautiful space, both cozy and trendy. The snickerdoodle crime brûlée was to die for! Crab cakes were fantastic, quality crab meat with barely any filler. Steak was cooked perfectly. read more

See all

Good food and ambience. I found the service to be good as well. The outdoor area they added is comfortable until late in the fall.

This place as many other reviewers point out, is the best you can get around here. From the classy, big-wooden beamed multi-level interiors to warm and inviting servers, this place pulled out all the stops for a perfect dinner night. My pictures speak for themselves - they were all good so I'm not gonna say much, other than to say pear salad and the beef dish were extraordinary. The Mill is a solid spot for all kinds of gatherings and meals - great vibe, music, and extensive selection of beverages. I doubt I'll be passing by Hershey anytime soon, but will always be back if I am. read more

See all

Stopped here while visiting hersey in November for dinner with the family and had a great experience; even in 2020 lol. For dinner i got the peppercorn steak which was delicious. Steak was cooked perfectly and the sauce was great. For dessert I got the pumpkin bread pudding which was pretty good. Not to pumpkin tasting and came with a good ice cream. Service was good and the venue itself had a very nice rustic look. Overall a great spot to try for dinner. read more

The best experience and meal probably the entire trip. We called for a reservation and on arrival the table was set and ready for us. Great Service and food was excellent. Burger was great ! Nice atmosphere read more

We did not have a reservation, but were quickly seated on the ground floor. A bit chilly down there this time of year. Our waitperson was prompt, attentive, and very helpful as we considered the menu. We shared the Seared Scallops appetizer (3 scallops), and it was tasty. My entree was the Udon Noodle Bowl with chicken. A very zippy dish. My husband had House Smoked Sliced Brisket. He liked his meal, and I enjoyed the Brussel sprouts I snitched from his plate. We stopped short of finishing our meals to have dessert. Snickerdoodle Creme Brulee - holy moly was it amazing. Hubby had the peanut butter and was over the moon. Fresh coffee was a good complement to the sweetness. Another shout out to our fantastic server. read more

We were visiting in town and wanted an upscale place to go before seeing a show. This fit the bill, it has $25-$40 entrees. Someplace I would only go for a very special occasion. Ten dollar cocktails, ten more dollars for dessert. The food was good, definitely good, but nothing out of this world. read more

The Mill - Hershey - Udon noodle bowl - New American Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

See all

After a day at Hershey we were looking for a nice meal. Love the rustic decor of this place. They are strict with the 90 minute seating limit which we understood especially during Covid and how much restaurants are hurting. Our service was prompt so the 90 minutes were not an issue even though we were a group of 7. They have a nice drink menu and I would have liked to tried a few of the options but went with the seasonal mule. it was delicious! steaks were all cooked to perfection and the monk fish literally tasted like lobster. The salads were fresh and tasty. The only thing we were not fans of were the duck wings. They were rubbery and greasy. They didn't look or taste good. when in the area again I would love to stop in again and try some of the other options on the menu read more

The Mill - Hershey - New American Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

The brunch menu is great. The food was even better! The beef tips cooked perfectly and the breakfast bowl full of great food. Service by PJ helped round out the day. Nice place off the beaten path. Worth the money! read more

The Mill is definitely over priced and over hyped. I was excited to give it a second chance because it didn't live up to the expectations the reviews set a year ago. It is sadly still the same. The building and area itself was wonderful. I loved the beautiful outdoor seating. However the food is overpriced for the flavor and portions. A nice place like this should offer a complementary appetizer such as bread. I'm happy the service was fairly quick, but many other restaurants with lower prices could have had better portions and flavors. Our waitress also had no personality and when we decided to pay, she gave back my husbands card and told us to wait. She came back with a dessert menu, sat it at our table, and left. She did not tend to us other than asking if we wanted a drink. It was pretty dead for a Saturday night and she was standing talking at the bar to her coworkers most of the time we were there. Our food came out cold and a different waiter brought it to us while our waitress mingled with her coworkers. Half of my plate was unfinished and the waitress tried to take my plate without asking if I wanted a box. I was not pleased with the unprofessionalism from the waitress. I appreciated the other staff members who complimented my dress but they were much younger with more enthusiasm and personality. I understand some days are harder than others but I am easy to please and this waitress was very unprofessional. read more

I recently had my friend's bridal shower here. It was a great event but there were definitely some concerns along the way. I will start out with the good things. They were very accommodating and let me bring in decorations the evening before. The atmosphere is fantastic! The building is beautiful, the food is very good, and I have no complaints about the servers. The banquet team however needs serious improvement. Getting information out of them was VERY difficult. I had reached out numerous times by email, phone, text and even stopped in without someone getting back to me. I was told that is not uncommon. The person assigned to my event didn't even show up on the day of the event, she did not let me know she would not be there and she has not responded to my message thanking her for her help anyway. My advice to the owner of this business would be to consider hiring a new events team or work with the one you have now on greatly improving their response time. Teach them how to give your guests a proper tour of the facility and suggestions on the layout for their event. You are in the service industry and getting back to your customers is crucial. Don't take your customers business for granted. You should want your level of service to match or exceed your cuisine. read more

The Mill - Hershey - New American Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

Amazing food, amazing drinks, and amazing atmosphere!!! If you're looking for a fancier dinner spot, stop in!

Rated as the best restaurant in the tiny town of Hershey, situated in an old mill factory that consists of three levels for dining and an outdoor patio space. Reservation is recommended as they do close early as most of the restaurants in this area. We went as a company dinner with 7 colleagues each ordering a main dish and shared a bottle of moscato from Italy. JJ our server was friendly. They have a full bar and wine selection from around the world. If you like farm to table fresh ingredients, then dine here. The menu consists of casual American cuisine including burgers, salad and chicken amongst the seafood entrees we ordered. Reminds me of Napa in California. read more

See all

Decided to try The Mill after a long time and was pleasantly surprised with the excellent quality of the food, service and overall experience. Had the Mahi-Mahi dish that was superb along with a wedge salad that was as good as it gets. A superb experience that will bring me back. read more

Really yummy low & slow brisket. The drinks and beer selection were very good. Our waitress Nicole was super sweet and efficient.There is a time limit on tables due to covid. But, I didn't even know. 90 mins at dinner is plenty for us. We like prompt service! We sat outside on the new patio they just built. Awesome for us because we don't dine inside yet. Inside was super pretty though. read more

See all

I wish I could rate The Mill- Hershey 10/10 stars because I was so impressed with the food, service, and ambiance. After a full day exploring and indulging in chocolate at Hershey's Chocolate World, we headed over for an intimate dinner at The Mill. We had made reservations for outdoor seating given the pandemic, however, did not dress warm enough and requested to be moved indoors. Thankfully, the staff were very accommodating and honored our request. We felt comfortable dining indoors as staff were wearing masks and tables were socially distanced. We were seated at a high top table in the lower level. The lower level was impeccably and simply decorated with boasting large wood beams and stone walls. From our table, we were able to watch as the bartenders poured specialty cocktails with fresh fruit and herbs. I ordered the St. Germain Cocktail with Elderberry Liqueur, Ketel One Vodka, Pear Nectar, Fresh Lime, and Champagne. It was delicious! Brian ordered the Cinnamon Spice Mule with Apple Liqueur, Apple Cider, Ginger Beer, and a Cinnamon Stick. He said he could drink his cocktail all day. For dinner, the Low & Slow Brisket stood out to both of us. After the first bite, you could tell the ingredients were locally sourced and of high quality. The brisket was served with mac & cheese and green beans. The portions were so generous that it allowed for two meals worth of leftovers. I can seriously not wait to go back to try more cocktails and more food! read more

The Mill - Hershey - New American Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

The service and food is great and will be back soon with friends to visit with us who are interested in trying out the menu

Have been here several times now. Love the atmosphere here. Great addition to the Hershey restaurant scene. The salmon is perfectly prepared and delicious! My wife always enjoys their brisket, so tender and flavorful. The service is always excellent here. Plan to make reservations on the weekend or take your chances at the bar. read more

See all

Kim and I first met in September of 2021. In 2022, to celebrate our 1st-meeting anniversary, we had a meal at the Mill in Hershey. We ate on the patio and loved it, so we did the same thing in 2023. When we decided to marry, it was an obvious choice to have our wedding there. We contacted the folks at The Mill and arranged to have our small ceremony on the patio in early May of this year. The event manager, Nicole Schlesman, was amazing to deal with from start to finish. Nicole's enthusiasm and interest in the success of our wedding were obvious from the beginning. It was apparent that she was personally invested in helping us to make the day a memorable one. She was receptive to our plans, added some great ideas, and made sure that everything would go smoothly. The food we chose was beautifully presented and was delicious. The service of the staff was flawless. Marcus and Amanda were our primary servers and Nicole was there as well. They made the event a complete success. They made sure that all we had to think about was the ceremony. Because of their attentiveness, it was perfect! The Mill is an excellent restaurant/venue. The ambiance is warm and inviting, the food is spectacular, and the staff are fabulous. We would like to thank Nicole, Amanda, Marcus, the chefs, and the rest of the staff for helping to make our wedding one of the best days of our lives! read more

The structure is amazing inside with that urban, industrial vibe: two floors, spacious with high ceilings, wood, concrete and even an outside patio. The host, Adam, who I thought reminded me of Tiger Woods, was interested in where we wanted to dine and congenial with great smile. Third star for the server, Colin, who ROCKED with his simple service on this Sunday brunch hour. We started with the deviled eggs. Standard. Hubs ordered the sausage gravy, too much flour/gravy, needs more meat. And seasoning, which it would have had if cooked with more sausage. The crab cake was barely warm, side of ditalini Mac and cheese, it was clumped together and not even warm, like dished from last nights left overs. Oh and those looong garden carrots. Bland. Add a bit of brown sugar, maple syrup, something. $25 for that entree. A clementine salad with rotten edged greens And assorted toppings And citrus dressing. Lastly, the quiche was tasty. The highlight of brunch was the two desserts of Snickerdoodle crème brûlée and that peanut butter pie enrobed in chocolate. Cheers to the baker! Overall, the food does not parallel the cost. It wouldn't have bothered me at all if the food was hot and fresh as indicated by the SCRATCH KITCHEN marketing statement. And I'm sure the head cook was relegated to that nights' kitchen duty. I feel this extraordinary venue is not all that it advertises regarding the food quality and there's something amiss in the kitchen regarding food temps and storage. read more

See all

This place has the friendliest staff! Amazing food! Great cocktails! This place is so unique! Loved it will definitely be back read more

See all

Came in for the first time the other day to try it out. The atmosphere is very nice. Our server Brady was amazing and extremely professional. The fresh pretzels were a wonderful appetizer and the steak was delicious! Everything down the the Mac and cheese was on point, couldn't have asked for a better night! read more

The Mill - Hershey - Angus Ribeye, Mashed Potatoes, Mac and cheese - New American Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

The outdoor seating, which I am told is relatively new, is comfortable. There are fans and sun shades and the tables are nicely spaced out. We were gathered for a birthday. Part of our party was a couple that lives together and the other part a couple with a toddler. The Mill has both booster seat and high chairs available. We all sat at a table but with a seat separating each family because social distancing is important with part of the family having a compromised immune system. All of the staff wore masks at all times and we only removed ours to eat & drink. The Mill has hard copies of the menu if you need one, but the tables have a QR code to access the menu with smart phones. We went to the Mill because I wanted a crab cake and I got an excellent crab cake meal. The remoulade was flavorful and the fingerling potatoes were creamy and soft. The crab cakes had very little filler and large sweet prices of crab seasoned just enough that I could enjoy the flavor of crab. The carrots were crunchy. Everyone else had salads and a "not" burger and there were no complaints about the food or coffee with one exception. I'm told the espresso was so awful that he could not drink it. I tried a sip and it didn't seem that bad to me, but I am not enamored with espresso to begin with. read more

My husband and I decided to have a late dinner and it was nearing closing time, but we were treated well. The wait staff was attentive but not intrusive. I asked for a recommendation and the suggestion from our amazing waiter was try the brisket. I loved the brisket. I would have asked for a little less BBQ sauce on it because the horseradish sauce was so good too. I probably could have eaten my own weight in their mac and cheese too. It was perfectly smokey and fall apart good. My husband is a picky eater and did struggle a bit to find something on the menu where he would eat the sides as well. However, that is always the risk you take when doing farm to fork, you get what is in season and I think those were delicious. read more

Amazing staff. Stayed open late just for us. And served all the kids and parents after a soaked day in Hershey. Really pleasant and food was too notch. Good for kids and groups. read more

We went here for a birthday celebration. The prices are high, but it's a nice special occasion place. The staff is always very friendly and accommodating to dietary restrictions and the food is always delicious. read more

See all

Our waiter was hilarious! I had such a great time! The wait is worth it but I wish we had made reservations earlier. The wait was roughly an hour and that was during the week. I ended up with the salmon salad that was actually really GOOD for a salad. The appetizer was cute it was served in a Hershey kiss mold. read more

Salad was okay. Seafood entire was okay. Ribs were dried out and hard. I've heard decent things about The Mill, but it seems to me there's a lack of art and craft in their how they prep and cook their food. I could have hit it on a bad night, but even how the salad was prepared was sort of cartoonish. There were massive chunks of cucumber, it all looked sorta random. The ambiance was pleasant and the staff were kind and friendly. I don't plan on going back any time soon. It's a very big restaurant and it's hard to get everything perfect at that scale. read more

Service is always great. Food is always good. Pricey but worth it. Definitely would recommend for big parties. Loud and a little chilly. The restaurant always clean and nice. read more

Amazing. Sometimes a meal is transcendental. This place was almost that. The locale was beautiful, a mill from the 19th century that was rebuilt in 1914 and renovated for the restaurant. Service was knowledgeable and friendly. Attentive without being overbearing. Food was extraordinary. The brisket was to die for as was the crème brûlée. Definitely a must if you're in Hershey! read more

I ordered the crab cakes. I must say the dish did not meet my expectations especially after the waitress had emphasized it was broiled rather than fried. It had an underwhelming aftertaste unfortunately. Besides when I requested some lemons, I was shocked that a server brought them to my plate with his bar hands and placed two on my plate directly!!! I have never never encountered such behavior ever especially at a place that commands $39 for two crab cakes. read more

Everything was great. From drinks to appetizers to main course. Only complaint was there was a bit of soil on a plate. It happens, I used to be a dishwasher in 1971 read more