The food, drinks and service were amazing!! Ameenah was amazing!!! I've never met a person so happy to be at her job. Very knowledgeable on the history of Fenicci's as well. We will for sure be back!! I highly recommend Fenicci's!! You won't be disappointed!! Ask to sit in Ameenah's section! read more

I was thoroughly surprised at the quality of food at Fenicci's! I was brought to town with a buddy in hopes of finding a nice pizza joint. Not only did Fenicci's supply was with two PHENOMENAL pies - we opened with their famous meatballs that were not only priced great, but tasted even better! The upside down pie is so unique and SO good. Very crispy crust and terrific cupped pepperoni - I left Hershey, PA missing this! Traditional pepperoni was nice, too, though I'd definitely recommend the upside down pie for someone feeling spontaneous. Nice, clean dining room with prompt service. Left us Hershey kisses after paying our bill. I will definitely be back next time I drive through PA. read more

Fenicci's of Hershey - Upside Down Pizza - Italian Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

Passing through and needed a last minute dinner unfortunately not many places were but generally Fenicci's was. We Ordered a large cheese pizza, and two kids meals . The kids meals were good but the pizza oh my was not good sadly. Didn't taste cooked enough . The staff was nice . The inside was clean , only the bar was open when we came. read more

We ate at Fenicci's after we tried Escape Room Hershey. We were sat near the bar on a Sunday evening, with lots of alcohol fueled football fans. The environment wasn't ideal for a family dinner, I'll say, but it ended up being okay. The food and service were okay, not great, but perfectly fine for our purposes. We started out with wings and mozzarella sticks as appetizers. The cheese sticks were really stretchy and melt. The wings were solid. The kiddos had baked penne, and I had an antipasti salad, which was packed with meat but a little too salty for my liking. The kids enjoyed their entrees, but we over ordered and had to take home boxes. Oops. Anyway, Fenicci's was just fine for a Sunday evening quick meal. But I would not go out of my way to return. read more

Fenicci's of Hershey - Antipasto Salad - Italian Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

See all

Samantha was amazing. The nicest most attentive server in all of Hershey. The food was delicious, and the ambiance was perfect! Definitely will return and request to be in Samantha's section! read more

When we arrived in Harrisburg/Hershey, I asked the lady at the hotel front desk about places to eat in the area. She said Fenicci's was the best. While taking the Hershey Trolley Tour, they spoke highly of Hershey's famous Fenicci's. That was enough for us to give it a try. We were able to make reservations very easily on Fenicci's website. We did a booth in the Lounge by the bar. Very comfortable booth. For starters, we had the Garlic Bread with melted provolone cheese & the Crispy Calamari. Both were outstanding! My daughters split a Pepperoni Pizza while my wife shared the Crab Tortellini with a Caesar salad. All 3 were amazing. Service was great. Food was amazing. Very cool spot that the locals rave about. Very easy to see why. read more

Fenicci's of Hershey - Crab Tortellini Alfredo (Chef's Pick) - Italian Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

See all

Mitch is the best bartender I've ever had. When my grandmas apartment building was burning down he single handedly ran into the building, ran up 7 flights of stairs and carried her all the way down. He is a hero in this community and makes the best drinks and holds the best conversation. Give him the medal Of honor !!! read more

Ambience: 2/5 The vibes here are mid. Does not feel like an Italian restaurant in the slightest. On a positive note, it's at an excellent location. Food: 1/5 Strike One. The ricotta skillet came out cold. I had to send it back, and I'm pretty sure they just reheated the same cheese. When hot, it was quite tasty but they gave us about 8 croutons to dip it in. This is definition of Shrinkflation. Strike Two. The upside-down pizza, which Fenicci's claims is one of their signature dishes, is supposed to go bread, cheese, then marinara sauce on top. Mine came out with no sauce at all. Crust was good. Strike Three. The clam pasta came with twelve shells but only six actual clams. It was average at best. Service: 0/5 Water and drinks took 30 minutes, salads took another 30, appetizer cold, forgot to put sauce on their signature pizza. Overall: 0 out of 5 stars. Do not recommend. read more

Fenicci's of Hershey - Upside Down Pizza - Italian Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

Before Phil bought this restaurant it was named DiAngelos. We have been visiting this location for over 50 years. We like their food and usually took one of their "upside down" pizzas home with us. We are sorry to see that Phil has passed away way before his time. Since his passing their pizzas are no longer the same. So was the sauce recipe changed or are they now using different cheese?? We're sorry to say that we will not be taking any of their pizzas home with us. read more

I came to Fenicci's late while on a work trip to Hershey. We were very hungry and at 10:30 on a Tuesday night, it was open with only a small handful of other places. We had a mix of spaghetti, cheese dip, tomatoes, and I had the Veal Parmesan Hoagie. Everyone was friendly and service was efficient. The food was all pretty good. The atmosphere was an old school Italian feel. I would not say that it was fancy and felt fine dressed casually as we had just gotten in to Hershey. read more

Fenicci's of Hershey - Cheese dip and vread - Italian Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

See all

Came here before a hockey game and sat at the bar. Meagan was a great bartender and quick with refilling our drinks. The calamari and garlic bread was average but filled us up. Can't wait to come back again before another game!! Thank you, Meagan! read more

Service: Our waiter was very attention and offered his recommendations. We were stuck between the pizza or veal parm. Food: We walked in during the late night food menu. This consisted of appetizers, all of the salads, everything on the back of the menu, which was like the Strombolis, pizzas. And a separate menu, which had a few pastas listed. The majority of the food was just average. Stromboli came out undercooked. Needed more time in oven but I appreciate that it's made to order. The Italian wedding soup was something else, though. I enjoyed two cups by myself. read more

See all

Nice time watching Super Bowl at the bar. Good food, good drinks but can do without the young child allowed to sit at bar playing games and talking nonsense into his phone. Ruined the night... And yes I did notify the hostess. She did come into bar area but alas only to participate in football pool and not address issue. read more

The atmosphere was good. However, we had dirty plates sit by us our whole meal. Food took an hour to come out and my pasta was dry. No one checked in on our food. Our water was not re filled. I event logged a birthday in our reservation and all the deserts went to the wrong table read more

Fenicci's of Hershey - Chicken Picatta - Italian Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

The food was amazing. Our service was amazing everything was the best. And the ambiance was also amazing. read more

Fenicci's of Hershey - Ricotta Skillet - Italian Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

The food was delicious, drinks were amazing and the service was top notch!! Ameenah was phenomenal! She was very helpful, honest and super friendly! By far, the best service we've experienced during our entire visit to Hershey! read more

What a great dinner tonight at Fenicci's. We're celebrating our 37th wedding anniversary and wanted to go here because we have so many memories here from when we traveled for vacation from Virginia. It was perfect as always, our waitress Renee was outstanding, manager even stopped to check on us a Few times and the food was soooo good, we had a Great night!! read more

Made a reservation for 5pm on March 31 for 4. When we arrived, we were told they had no reservation for us. We were seated. Drinks ordered and were delivered with no ice. We were told they were out of ice. This only 1 hour past opening. Ordered 2 pizzas, a sausage sandwich and a salad. The pizza tasted like cardboard. The sandwich was cold. Ordered 2 pieces of peanut butter pie. The waitress brought them out and announced that the pie was frozen. It was hard as a brick. Besides the waitress being very pleasant, this was a total trainwreck of a dining experience. This is a highly rated restaurant supposedly. Not by any stretch of the imagination. Never going back and spreading the word to all I know. read more

We ate Fenicci's two years ago and it was wonderful, so it was an easy choice for us to dine here again. We dined at Fenicci's this evening, since we are back at Hershey. We were all looking forward to a nice dinner, however dinner was disappointing. The marinara for the chicken parm was not the best tasting sauce. I would have preferred the chicken to have been a little thinner than what was served. My children ordered the kids salmon and I will say the portion size they were given was huge. My children appreciated the large portion size, they devoured it. Our waitress was Ashely, she was a nice girl. You could tell she was busy, she was trying her best to be attentive to her tables. We are sadden that one of our go to places, isn't the same great tasting Italian that we had before. Bases on the reviews that I've read, it seems other diners also had similar experiences. read more

Maybe our palettes are used to authentic Italian cuisine, because this place is definitely NOT it. Overall the appetizers were meh. Meatballs were good. Crab Dip, Mozzarella Sticks and Arancini Balls were average to below average. Garlic Bread was terrible. A basic store bought sub roll slathered in garlic butter and cheese. No crusty fresh Italian bread.in sight. All appetizers were overpriced. Regarding entrees, the Gnocchi were terrible and had raw dough filled centers. Not light and pillowy as they are supposed to be. The red sauce was watery, as pointed out in another review. Fettuccine Alfredo sauce didn't taste homemade and was awful. As far as service, waitress would approach the table and just boldly interrupt conversation every time to check if we needed anything. She seemed like a bull in a china shop. No care in how customers were engaged at the moment. Was just going through the motions. Ambiance was nothing special. Tables in dining room were covered with white tablecloths and topped with paper, a small candle and condiments. Won't be back. read more

Walking in the door, there was an odd smell filling the restaurant- which was not like food. The prices are reasonable and the menu is diverse. I started off with some garlic bread, which was a sub roll that was pressed down with some cheese in the middle. I enjoyed the Caesar salad. My pasta with the added steak ($12) was disappointing. The meat tasted as it was recently defrosted and very dry. I did not eat any of it. The pasta was ok, but again I was not able to complete the meal. Service was great, and they were super accommodating to our group that needed split checks. read more

Happened upon this joint while on travel in Hershey, and I'm glad I did! Great waitress recommended the lasagna, and I'm glad I took her guidance! Topped with mushrooms and wonderful layers of pasta, cheese, and meatballs...oh the meatballs! I controlled myself and only ate half, which is a quite a feat! I took a dessert recommendation from said waitress, and went with the peanut butter pie..loved it! Ambiance is secluded supper club, service was friendly and helpful, and prices are in line with the area. If I'm in the area, I'm coming back... this joint makes the list! read more

Fenicci's of Hershey - Peanut butter pie - Italian Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

See all

Good food awesome waitress n waiters beautiful place to eat love it wonderful service

Everything we ordered was terrible from the salad , the apps n the meals. The server was the only thing good in the entire place. Olive Garden is more Italian than this place and that says a lot read more

Decided to try this restaurant and we were not disappointed. We made a reservation so we didn't have to wait when we arrived. The host greeted us and brought us to our seats. We ordered the shrimp bruschetta, basil seafood pasta, and spaghetti. All 10/10. The restaurant was dimly lit which is a perfect environment for date night. I would recommend and def visit again. read more

Quaint restaurant in Hershey, the Italian food is good atmosphere is pleasing definitely beats out any of the big chain Italian restaurants. It's a local place with a local history that has good family food. read more

My wife and I visited Fenicci's in Hershey, PA, and had a generally pleasant experience. We were greeted and seated quickly, and our waitress was fantastic--attentive, friendly, and honest in her menu recommendations, which I really appreciated. We started with the calamari, which was disappointing. It was rubbery, lukewarm, and didn't seem freshly fried. While the flavor was decent, the marinara sauce tasted burnt, which didn't help. Next, we tried the 5 Star Pizza. It was a good pizza overall, though a bit on the salty side--possibly due to the prosciutto or cheese. Still, it was enjoyable. Lastly, we had the hot garlic wings. Unfortunately, like the calamari, the wings weren't crispy and seemed to have been cooked earlier and then tossed in sauce. However, the sauce itself was solid--classic buffalo with fresh garlic. Overall, Fenicci's had some hits and misses. The service was great, but the food could have been better, especially with freshness and texture. I'd rate it 3.5 out of 5. I gave it 4 stars since 3.5 wasn't an option, and I'd rather round up than round down. read more

Fenicci's is our go to place in Hershey. Food is always good. Service is great. Never are we disappointed with anything when we eat there. We were terribly saddened to hear of the death of Phil, the heart of Fenicci's and will miss seeing him when we go there, but I'm sure that the family and staff will continue to provide the top notch service and menu that Phil always ensured. His memory will live on. read more

They served a table of 12 with ease . All the food was great. I am sorry to hear about the passing of the owner . I hope that someone in the family can fill in for him and have the same energy and enthusiasm as he did . I will miss the replies of each review. . read more

We made a mistake on which entrance we were supposed to enter. Buuuut the staff helped us out and seated us quickly. The service wasn't the greatest. The server brought a pitcher of ice water then was absent for a bit then came and took our drink order. Our bread and salad came out but our beverages were still not there. We got our drinks the blackberry old fashioned was so so. It had only a muddled black berry in the bottom of the glass nothing special. The bread brought to the table was warm but was hard as a rock almost like croutons. The salad was good but could've used something better than shredded no flavor mozzarella. The entrées were good. It is more of a bar than restaurant. I saw good reviews so we decided to try it. We are from out of town and it was mediocre. read more

Fenicci's of Hershey - Drinks - Italian Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

They served rolls with butter. What happened to Italian bread with oil? The bruschetta we ordered included slices of toasted bread and a separate bowl of chopped tomatoes. Huh? For our main dish we each had the piccata - one chicken and one veal. The meat was tough and the sauce was heavy and gelatinous. Huh? I would never recommend this place and the service was just ok. read more

Asked for my food that was brought to the table cold to be microwaved...came back on a different plate even colder than the first time. Why?? Food: zero stars. Service: 0-1 star? I don't think they sucked on purpose? Ambiance: one star. Too loud in the bar area...and it's time to take down the garland. (Late posting this, it was over a year ago but got lost in my drafts, sorry) read more

I came here with five friends, and from the very beginning, the bartender was shockingly rude, unprofessional, and downright disrespectful. She acted like she didn't want to serve us at all, and her attitude set the worst tone for the entire night. At one point, she called me and my friend over, and when my friend didn't come immediately, she actually said, word for word, "Is your friend slow or something?" That is one of the most offensive, inappropriate, and unprofessional things I've ever heard someone in customer service say. It completely crossed the line and put a bad taste in my mouth for the entire business. She wasn't just rude to me and my friend--she had an attitude with our entire group the whole time. It was so bad that we decided to leave without buying anything. Why would we spend money somewhere that allows a bartender to talk to customers like that? I was actually in shock when those words came out of her mouth. I hope the owners see this review and understands that this is how their bartender treats people. This kind of behavior is unacceptable. I will not be coming back here, and if I ever do, I will make sure I never deal with her again. read more

This place was disappointing for us, but perhaps it was because we got our food to-go? We ordered online and honestly the food was very mediocre and tasted like commercial pasta, if you know what I mean. It just didn't taste authentic or fresh. We got a seafood pasta, chicken parm and arancini and they came with salads. We were visiting Hershey Park and was given a recommendation for this place by a local. The options sounded good, but the food was expensive and just meh. I wouldn't be completely closed off to trying this place again if we were in the area and there was not many other options, but definitely not rushing back. read more

Service and food were excellent, the only thing i didn't like, the food was a tad too salty for me. Atmosphere is a little high end so I recommend business casual attire. I would come back! read more

See all

Went there yesterday, service was great and we are thankful we sat in the front room w all the windows....other rooms are dated. The food, well that needs help and I'm hopeful that the reason for our poor meal was bc they were in between service hours and prob had the dish washer cooking our meal. The calamari still had fresh bread crumbs all over it and the over cooked mozzarella stick appetizer and calamari was a sad portion and presentation. No flavor either. I got the Mediterranean Seafood bowl (pics on Yelp looked good) and the sauce was curdled when I got it. My wife's chicken parm was burnt (not a golden color, but brown) We stayed positive, left a 20% tip (our server was great) and went on with our marching band competition day. Sharing so ownership sees this (we had a reservation for 3 pm for 3), and works on getting the program back on track for future customers. Family member suggested this spot, so hopefully things turn around, esp during a weird dining time. read more

This was our first time at Fenicci's and we're already wanting to go back! In another post I said that I'm only so-so about Italian restaurants because their food tends to taste alike to me. NOT THE CASE with Fenicci's!!! It begins with the handmade pasta; so soft it melts in your mouth! Every entree is unique and surprising in its own way. I'm usually not a huge lasagna person, but theirs is truly one-of-a-kind. They offer a certificate of some kind to those who eat it in one sitting, but why would anyone do that and miss out on the leftovers, which are quite possibly better than the first time? Another draw for me is a list of beers that includes Guinness on tap! The combination of a smooth and rich beer with an even richer lasagna is truly divine! read more

Meagan is the ABSOLUTE BEST! She makes the whole experience worth it! Food is always top notch and service is A+++++++

Unfortunately I am unable to get a zero star review. I'm not sure what transpired in the bar prior to me and my friends arrival but the Blonde bartender couldn't have been more insensitive and disrespectful to the group we arrived with. It felt as if the moment we walked in to the establishment she had a vendetta to make sure we had the worst experience possible. She was calling individuals in our group names and purposely skipping our drink orders "because she couldn't hear us" even though we were literally two three feet away. Not sure what the blonde bartenders name is but I really hope action is taken against her before she gets the bar into trouble or they start to lose business. I hope we never see her in there again as my friends and I are people that really enjoy the bar and restaurant. read more

We had Paige as our waitress and she was WONDERFUL!!! The food, drinks, atmosphere and people around were great. We sat in the bar area which was totally fine. We had such a great time! Wish it was closer so we could go back more often. read more