Sopranos Added a wood fired pizza oven and make wonderful pizzas. They serve puttanesca with a spicy sauce that's a 10/10. Their shrimp fettuccine and gnocchi bolognese and seafood Fra Diablo are each perfection. A+. Bravo to Sopranos ! read more

Sopranos Pizza - Shrimp fettuccine - Italian Near Me - Palmyra, Pennsylvania

See all

The food was good. The servers were friendly, however ours seemed to forget about us. We were polite and no trouble, it she forgot our water refills and only came by 20 mins later to give us the check. Regulars seemed to be tended to quite often. read more

Sopranos Pizza - Chicken Marsala - Italian Near Me - Palmyra, Pennsylvania

See all

DO NOT GET a gluten free pizza from here. The crust is inedible. It comes in its own tin foil pan with its own wrapped pizza cutter to prevent cross contamination, but that is the only good thing about it. No texture. No taste. Just wrong on all counts. There are other pizza places that use the same brand. (Sals in Etown-Lazzaros in Palmyra) Obviously they buy it but never try it. And it's $6. For just the crust. The service was fine. Parking as always is difficult. read more

Came here for the first time with a couple friends. I ordered their white pizza and it was really good. It was a nice clean restaurant and atmosphere. The staff who work at Sopranos are really nice. I'll be coming back. read more

The Spaghetti Alla Puttanesca was excellent, Not spicy, but very enjoyable. The server was fantastic, ensured that the food and drinks were served and maintained. The restaurant had the feeling of a true trattoria, clean and well presented. Could have been back in Italy, except everyone speaking English. Though swamped the staff in and out of kitchen got the order right and kept up with the volume. I would return again and again, sadly only visiting the area. read more

Stopped in for lunch with family and friends. Staff was friendly, service was good. Restaurant was clean and pleasant. Menu was full of options. We ordered a bianco pizza which was fantastic. My son had a Cesar salad and a small margherrita pizza which he proclaimed was "awesome". Our friends had gnocchi, chicken wings, and spaghetti, which all looked amazing. Portions are generous! Prices were great too. Overall a great place for lunch or dinner. read more

Sopranos Pizza - Bianco pizza - Italian Near Me - Palmyra, Pennsylvania

Excellent food and quality pizza was excellent and the Italian subs were great with excellent meats and condiments

It's has goid flavor. But I'm not sure it's worth lighting up wood for. A little greasy and the dough favor bland. I wouldn't fire that oven up for nothing less thar a 14-inch pie. It's not Neapolitan. It's like the traditional pizza smaller with a little crisper crust. 6.9 read more

Sopranos Pizza - Small cheese wood fire pizza. - Italian Near Me - Palmyra, Pennsylvania

I went with a large group this past weekend. We arrived shortly after they opened and were greeted & sat immediately. I didn't catch the waitresses name but she was wonderful. Very nice and attentive to our party of 13. I tried to get pictures of a few dishes from our party since most of us selected different options. I got the tortellini which was delicious, just a little too saucy & slightly saltier for my preference. The dinners include a side salad & garlic bread which were both good. Overall, we all enjoyed our meals and felt the portions were very generous. This was my first time but I will be coming back to explore other options on the menu, definitely recommend giving them a try. read more

See all

I was visiting family in the area and every time we visit we always go to Sopranos, It has been a staple of ours for years. We have not been here in the last three years or so due to living across the country and Covid. Staff: The staff are always very attentive and friendly. Food: Best house dressing (for salad)!!! I ordered the Sinatra ( used to be Rigatoni Sinatra) and did not enjoy it. This has been my favorite meal from here for years and was so excited to order it but I am not sure if the recipe changed or perhaps it's a different cook from years before but it tasted very different. I missed having rigatoni (it was not an option), the chicken did not taste good and the sauce was different. I was really bummed but the others meals at our table were good. I still may come back when I visit but I'd order something different next time. **Thank you Angelo for your reply. I have updated my review to 4 stars because while I did not enjoy my meal this time, I have always enjoyed the food there and the other food at our table was delicious. read more

Sopranos Pizza - Italian Near Me - Palmyra, Pennsylvania

See all

Always a great meal here! Pastas are amazing! Never disappointed! A must try if you like pasta.

The Penne vodka sauce was absolutely amazing couldn't give it any critique. The sauces flavor was spot on and the service was amazing, same with the waitress who was super nice. Overall I would give this place a 10/5 if I could but can't go over 5, sad to see the bad reviews from years ago outweighing the 5 star reviews from recent. read more

Got many different pizzas for a party and loved them all. My favorites were the Bianca and Mona Lisa pizzas.

The food and service was awesome! Our server (maybe Amber?) was nice and even though it was very busy took the time to give us a rundown on what to order since it was our first time there! This place was a gem and we completely overlooked it! P.S. tell the chef to sell that sauce to go! read more

Everything that I've had here has been very good. The portions are sizable and quite generous given the prices charged.

We go here whenever in town visiting my in-laws. Always good Italian food. One of the best locations in town for food

Spaghetti Alla Norma dish made with eggplant and house made tomato sauce with small pile ricotta cheese sitting on top was best pasta I ever had!! My friend ordered angel hair pasta with sausage and marinara sauce, which she really liked. We both preferred our own dishes, as it should be. Meals came with salad and garlic bread. Waitress was friendly and provided good service. Restaurant is clean and decorated nicely with black and white photos. Will definitely be back. read more

Really disappointed in their Sicilian pizza. Crust and sauce were flavorless. There was no seasoning at all. Very skimpy on the cheese. The pepperoni and bacon were both raw and the onions and green peppers were in huge chunks, which made it very difficult to eat and it cost $32!!! Would not recommend. read more

Sopranos Pizza - Sicilian pizza - Italian Near Me - Palmyra, Pennsylvania

See all

Exceptional service and great pizza. Staff was very friendly and my food was ready quickly

Busy Italian restaurant in Palmyra. Food is excellent, and the portions are huge. Great spot outside of Hershey.

If you want real good Italian food, reasonable price this is the place. Hidden on a side street in a very small town they have excellent pizza and a great selection of Italian veal dishes that are all fantastic. service is always quick and friendly, and it also is a very small but casual place that you can BYOB!! read more

Always five stars. The marinara sauce is as good as my own--and that's saying a lot an Italian-American. Of course, the usual "complaint" is that the portions are way too big. I'm a big guy and the attached photo is all I could eat. Ongoing recommendation is to cut back the portion size and keep the menu price about the same. Still would be a bargain! Remains highly recommended. read more

Sopranos Pizza - Italian Near Me - Palmyra, Pennsylvania

Ordered the Gorgonzola salad. It was terrible drenched in dressing. Could not even finish was not worth the price. Not only was the salad drenched in dressing they also give you extra dressing on the side. I would've expected just the dressing on the side because that's how other pizza places do it. Won't be ordering from here again, and it appears the service has gone downhill quickly. read more

Great subs and nice atmosphere. They have very well rounded menu but a little pricey.

I have lived and/or worked in the Palmyra area for 14 years and this place has been a staple since I arrived. I was introduced to Sopranos by colleagues on a lunch break and have returned many, many times since. I appreciate the large portions and that there are options for vegetarians and vegans. Sopranos has been with me through all of my dietary changes. My favorite dish is the mushroom pasta dinner special. Great service! read more

The food is always very good. But the cutbacks have been disappointing and doesn't go unnoticed. Raise everything by 50 cents to make up for whatever you need to, but don't cut back on the food end. Give the customer the Full Meal you became well liked for. You have an exceptional restaurant, get back to the customer experience. read more

Food is good but service is terrible. The people who work the counter where you pay and also pick up pizza for carry out are rude and treat customers as if they are doing them a favor selling them pizza. I've witnessed this a few times. My last visit I told woman at counter (I think she's an owner but can't be sure) that this will be my last purchase because of the rude treatment. She smiled and said "sarcastically " that's fine." Too many other good pizza shops to tolerate this. It will eventually hurt their business. read more

We tried this restaurant because my in-laws live in Palmyra and we were there visiting. We went there that week in January when the temps were in the single digits. We walked in and were seated with a smile...it wasn't busy yet but it was still early for a dinner crowd. We ordered drinks and service was quick. I quickly took notice that we all had our coats on as the waitress returned with our drink order to take our food order. My in-laws got stromboli and seemed to like it. My husband got a sub which did not come with any sauce on it so he was highly disappointed. I ordered the gnocchi which I had high expectations for. Sadly the gnocchi was nothing special- the sauce tastes like it came from a can. I didn't finish it. Back to the coats- I asked the waitress to please turn up the heat as at this point I was shivering. She promptly replied with "we don't have heat". She left me literally speechless...she then went on to explain that the pizza shop- which by the way had one table I assumed was for waiting for your take-out order....that side is heated. I was honestly shocked...and I'm almost sure that this violates some health code or something like that. With the unimpressive food & no heat- chances are I won't be back. The service was decent and staff friendly. read more

Average Italian food. 1980's decor. The pizza is not bad for this area but if you are willing to drive a little further toward Hershey there is much better selection. It's inconsistent. Sometimes you get cheese and sometimes there is almost none. The last 2 times we ordered chicken Parmesan take out the portions have shrunk considerably. We may mark this place off our list and go to Sorrento's. read more

Delicious! Always a favorite! Really like the atmosphere after they removed the ceiling fans! Try the baked ziti! read more

Just tried the Soprano Special cold sub, it was very good. A mix of tasty meats and cheese with oil and vinegar. Bread was a tad dry(day old?) which kept the 5th star. Inside was clean, staff was friendly and it was ready to go as promised for pickup. Will definitely be back again. read more

Sopranos Pizza - Sopranos Special - Italian Near Me - Palmyra, Pennsylvania

I've always liked this place but recently have been disappointed in their service and food. It was never amazing food but very good for this area. However they seem to keep changing their recipes. Chicken piccata no longer the traditional white wine sauce with capers...now it's got mushrooms no capers? It tastes good but it's not chicken piccata. The chicken itself is no longer the traditional breast pounded/tenderized...now it's chicken strips?? Why change a good thing? When I asked about the order they seemed oblivious to any issue and thought mushrooms were in chicken piccata... They are lucky they don't have much competition in this area. Given a choice I choose someplace else. I guess I'll have go back. read more

The owners aren't the friendliest and the food is below average-at best. However, I will say that there was a New Pizza guy that worked there a few weeks ago, who made incredible pizza. You could tell he knew what he was doing. He was so friendly and his pizza made Sopranos better, but he's not there anymore. I wonder if the cranky owners screwed that up too! read more

I don't think the owners care any more. Ordered a pizza and Stromboli...husband was given 2 pizzas that weren't even close. Service sucks. The woman that works the cash register always has a shitty attitude. DO NOT RECOMMEND read more

The worst owners of an establishment I've ever met. I will never frequent this place and I urge no one else to frequent this establishment. They were the rudest individuals I've ever met. They told me they didn't care about my business point blank to my face. I waited 40 minutes for a single slice of pizza for my son and they told me they were too busy and couldn't get to it but had no problem making entire pizzas to go in the meantime. They are despicable people who do not deserve your business! read more

Ordered a grilled chicken Caesar salad and a pizza. The chicken was dry and over cooked, and it cost almost $15.00. The pizza had too much sauce and the crust on the bottom was burnt which cost $11.00. Menu price's in general are very high for simple Italian food that really does not cost that much to make. read more

See all

I've always enjoyed this restaurant and stopped by for dinner. A rare treat since I am never in the Palmyra area. When I placed my order I told the attendant that the baked ziti should have NO MEAT because my mother, who wanted the meal, was a vegetarian. Fourth-five minutes later I arrived home and the first bite my mom took had meat all through it. I called Sopranos and asked them for a refund or if they could take my name and replace the meal the next time I was in town. The waitress told me to bring it back. I explained I lived 45 minutes away. She asked the cook, and he said to bring the meal back. I said, "Did you tell him I live in Lancaster?" She said yes. I said, "So am I supposed to keep the meal in my fridge until the next time I happen to be headed your way?" She said yes. (I was hoping they'd realize how ridiculous that request was.) Confused, I said, "Ok. That's really unorthodox, but that's what I'll do." It's not enough in this competitive restaurant market to just make good food. You have to have good customer service too. Sopranos doesn't. To ask me to drive 45 minutes there, in rush hour, get new food, and drive 45 minutes back home, for a mistake they made, is ridiculous. Gas nor time is cheap, and I already wasted $15 on a meat-filled dish when I said "no meat." read more

Went for an early Friday evening dinner with my wife and three kids on 7/20/2018. Has to be the LOUDEST restaurant I've been to in many years. And we go to lots of restaurants. You simply could not talk to people at your table, or the wait staff, without shouting- which of course makes the problem worse. Absolutely deafening inside. The food was about a 7 out of 10. Pizza was tasty- though the sauce was extra salty. Pasta and cheesesteaks were good. Prices on the upper end of acceptable for a casual and ridiculously LOUD dining experience. Owners- they make sound deadening and sound absorbing products for restaurants- please consider them. read more

I appreciate our small businesses that take pride in customer delight. Even though mistakes were made in our take out order, management was extremely apologetic. Super delicious food. read more

Great food. When there's an issue with the order, management does a great job of making things right. Looking forward to a future positive experience. read more