I love this place so much. I go here frequently for two slices of their plain pizza and fountain Diet Coke. The pizza is consistently incredible... crust is crispy and has great flavor, and the cheese and sauce are delicious. The guys who work here are also so kind and welcoming every time I walk in or call. They create a friendly small-town atmosphere that feels nostalgic and like visiting family. Even their fountain sodas are somehow better than anywhere else! read more

Bartolo's Pizza - Hubs got the Sicilian pizza (amazing), and I got my usual veggie. This fed us all week! - Pizza Near Me - Palmyra, Pennsylvania

See all

At first the pizza looks like it's going to be a floppy mess, but the crust is legitimate. Wonderful crunch holds together well. Pizza has a pretty good flavor , solid experience. read more

Bartolo's Pizza - Medium sausage. - Pizza Near Me - Palmyra, Pennsylvania

This is the finest pizza by far in the surrounding area. This wonderful family only makes the finest Pizza and sandwich menu They are ALWAYS busy but still take the time to be kind. Thank you Bartolo family for your friendship and right way work. Clearly a step above! Shiara & Ena read more

Bartolo's Pizza - Loyal Bartolo customers forever. - Pizza Near Me - Palmyra, Pennsylvania

Any pizza or sub I've had here I can absolutely recommend. The service is generally quick. The gentlemen behind the counter aren't chatty, which is totally fine because I'm there for delicious food. The dining area is nothing to look at, but the tables are kept clean. read more

We ate here for the first time. Not impressed. We got a Sicilian and I was underwhelmed. The dough and sauce were just okay. I think the area has significantly better pizza options. read more

Quick service but pizza and cheesesteak were below average. Cheesesteak ingredients were minimal. The meat was probably enough for two bites but spread over the entire bun. Barely anything inside. The sauce was cold. Wtf! And the pizza toppings, barely covered the pizza and I threw out a ton of bread and dough from both. Way too skimpy on the ingredients . Never again. read more

We absolutely love their pizza! Have never had a bad meal from there! We eat there at least 1/2 times a month!

My boyfriend loves this place! He says it's the best pizza in pennsylvania of all time. I can't have it because i'm allergic to dairy and gluten but every time he gets there food it looks and smells amazing!! They do have incredible fries though. read more

My go to for pie when I am up that way. Sweet sauce is like no other in the area. Guys behind the counter are friendly and having fun. Still the same place I remember from high school when we walked over after the day was done. read more

Found this place while out of town. Loved their pizza and the old school look of the menu boards. Went back a week later to see a customers in town and picked up 7 pies and they all loved it too. read more

Amazingly great pizza! Great guys in there, too! Pizza is best if you eat it right there out of the oven.

Food is great! The guy behind the counter taking orders is awesome he is non stop busy and still had time for a smile We say thanks to them we go there to celebrate a leap year bday and alwats delish! read more

This place used to be great, but apparently they have fallen to the crunch of money in the last few months, and are becoming second rate. We used to go here at least 2 to 3 times a month and their pizza and Bartolos special sub, which used to be awesome, have gone downhill a LOT. It'a almost like they're using different ingredients and MUCH less meat than they used to. I will no longer be using them as there are far too many good places around here that have stepped up. I am not reviewing them lightly, as I do wish they'd go back to who they used to be! read more

Family has been ordering from here my whole life. Highly recommend! Ciabatta bread is so fresh and can never go wrong with the pizza. Never had a problem with my food, order, service in all my years as a customer. read more

Their food is amazing, hot, and really crispy. They have got to be the best pizza in Pennsylvania being my number 1.

Owner is a real good dude and the pizza (because of the sauce) is the best for 30 miles in any direction! Our #1 stop...

Best subs around!! Always fresh and stuffed with lots of meat and cheese! Pizza is awesome too.

Not my kind of pizza. Plain and doggy bottom. Service was good. Clean and people friendly.

Absolutely the best hand tossed pizza in town! The Old World pizza choice is one of our favorites. Bartolo's is a weekly, must have for an easy, delicious meal. Fast, courteous service every time! read more

Great pie...sweet sauce. Great fries. Coke products! Restaurant itself felt dirty and dated. read more

Sat night: Ordered a medium cheese pizza with extra sauce. Outstanding! The crust was delicious. The pizza was hot and flavorful. Another great pie from the Bartolo's pizza team. read more

Took my boys in last evening for the first time to eat there. Great experience. Also knowing my oldest son wanted Boli and he only eats pepperoni and cheese Bolis which I knew it wasn't on the menu which it usually isn't anywhere but when I asked if they would make it for him they gladly accepted. It was amazing and everything else we got was good too! My son said it was the best Boli he has had. Thank you again Bartolo's! We will be back. read more

Food is always good here. One of our favorites for takeout pizza and sandwiches especially the cheesesteak.

Growing up in the area, I feel like everybody has their pizza place that's the most amazing in the world. This is mine. Don't let other reviews fool you, in my biased opinion their pizza is some of the best in Palmyra. Bartolo's is located along Campbelltown Road in south Palmyra off the square. They used to be in the old Redner's parking lot and near the Palmyra Pool. Bartolo's is a family owned and run business that has been so popular since it opened, it's never needed to advertise. It's a family favorite for many in the area and is loved by most of my friends. I grew up leaving high school on half-days and having lunch here. It was a family tradition to have their pizza every Sunday night. People who leave the town, always stop by for a pie or slice when in the area. Talk to the people working, they have great stories are always friendly. The owners grow tomatoes, other vegetables, and grapes in their quaint garden behind the restaurant. The sauce recipe is a family secret and one of the sweetest in the area. The dough is always soft and evenly done. Their homemade bread for sandwiches and cheesesteaks is just as delicious. All the toppings are fresh. Be sure to try the pizza plain to get the full flavor. Prices are very reasonable. They have a small dining room with around 10 booths and restrooms should you decide to dine in. Parking is ample. In the nice months, they have an outdoor seating area. They do not have delivery, it's take-out or eat-in only. Bartolo's is the pizza against which I measure all others. Some have come close, but this will always be my number one. Thank you guys for years of memories. read more

Delicious, authentic pizza. There was a mistake on my order and they fixed it -no problem at all! The kind of pizza you wish you had more leftovers of! read more

Love this pizza place! The sauce is slightly sweeter than the usual pizza sauce but delicious!! And the bread for the subs is sooo good.

This is my favorite pizza and sub place in Palmyra, and possibly in the whole world. I make it a point to eat here every time I travel back from Alaska to visit family. They just don't make bread like this on the West coast, and certainly not in AK. read more

Stopped for lunch. Shared a Sicilian pepperoni pizza. My friend is super choosy about her pizza, and she said it's the best Sicilian she's ever had. Also had an eggplant parm sandwich was very tasty, on good bread. One piece of the eggplant was a bit tough (hence, only four stars), but still a good sandwich. We will definitely return. read more

Absolutely the best pizza in the world! All the other food is great as well. We purposely order more pizza than we can eat so we have leftovers!! read more

Great pizza and subs. Their homemade bread for subs is phenomenal. Loved their fries hot out of the fryer. The pizza heats up great too. The service isn't always with a smile but the food makes up for it and I'll keep coming back. read more

Their stromboli had the least amount of cheese of all the places I ate. The sauce is a little salty but it's good. I think I'd rather get pizza from here then stromboli. read more

There is no way that there's a better pizza place within 20 miles. Once you taste their bread and sauce, you'll also be a believer! My wife and I eat here at least once a week, and we've tried every other pizza place in Palmyra and Hershey. Bartolo's is the best! read more

Sorry but, Bartolo's can BLOW ME! and mainly because the attitude of the 2 men behind the counter SUCKED when I came in to pick up my order. One was busy BSing with a patron and never gave me a glance, and the other was too busy struggling to breathe because he was so large, so I could imagine that would make one a lil grumpy. I approached the counter and gave my last name and phone number for my order. Granted, this was my very first (and last) time there; apparently I was supposed to tell them WHAT I ordered. As I gave my name and number, the rather portly man, probably named Sal, rudely replied, 'OK, that tells me nothing. WHAT did you order?' Right there was my chance to tell that 'barrel ass' to blow me, but I was picking up dinner for my sister and I and she was already throwing herself around because she was hungry. I didnt appreciate the rudeness just because A: I probably interrupted 'Sal' during his afternoon Butterfinger and/or B: I didnt know the ordering procedure. Not a thank you, come again, nothing when I left. There's a reason that was only my first time there afer all of the years it's been there. The pizza I got was edible, but A&M's is much better. read more

Delicious pizza if you REALLY like sweeter sauce. The appetizers are just so-so, but always served piping hot. To echo one of the earlier reviews, the attitude of one of the gentlemen is indeed a huge turn-off. I've only seen the guy twice, and hopefully he's gone, but the first time I ate there I was treated in a poor manner as well. Unlike the other poster, I actually fired back with "Sorry, I was unaware your establishment had rules." The next time, my wife picked up the order and was treated the same way. Luckily, I haven't seen the overweight offender in quite some time. Hopefully, the owner decided that customer service was actually important to running a successful business and got rid of him. I will give these guys credit, they always abide by their word when they give you a time to pick up your dinner. I've never had them run late. That alone is always appreciated. read more

You must try the Sicilian! I think it's the sauce that makes this place stand out. Their neopolitan and sicilian pizzas are the BEST I've had in recent memory and I come from NJ where I've had amazing pizza. My only issue with this establishment is that I've gained nearly 15 pounds in 5 months and I think my weekly trips for the pizza along with my lack of willpower are to blame. Keep it up Bartolo's! I can't wait to try the subs. read more

I can't really speak to the pizzas on the menu (though I know they have a real white pizza, with real cheese and not some boxed sauce, so there's that), but the standouts here are their subs, and for that alone they get 4 stars from me. Something about their subs is a little better than many places I've tried in the Harrisburg-Hershey area... the ingredients seem to be fresher and tastier than what most shops serve. Even the turkey sub is great, and they're all made-to-order any way you like it. Fresh crumbled bacon and tangy sweet peppers and onions on fresh meats and a toasted sub bun make for a solid meal that I've come back for over and over again. The fried mozzarella sticks and fried zucchini are good, too, both served with a really decent marinara sauce. And as for the reviews citing "poor service," I've never had that problem in dozens of visits. The kitchen area is entirely open to view, and if I were a cook who had to take orders as well when things got busy, I might be brief with customers from time to time, but the rest of the staff are some of the friendliest guys I've met in town... couldn't be nicer, and I've never had to wait long for an order. A & M Pizza towards Hershey has a similar menu (and beer to go), but if you want a really good sub, call Bartolo's first. read more

My favorite pizza place in Central PA. The sauce is unique because it is sweet which I love. The dough is very nice. The only downside to this place is the people who run it, terrible customer service. If you call to order they give you an attitude like you are bothering them lol, always sound angry. I'd like to slap the terrible attitude out of them at times but who's gonna make my favorite pizza. read more

I often tell my friends it's the best pizza on six continents. I grew up in the Palmyra area so my opinion may be somewhat biased, but now over twenty years later and after I've moved away I long for the pizza that calls my name. If I'm ever within an hour's drive of Bartolo's, I always find myself stopping by for a pie. The pizza is a traditional New York style with a sauce that is the perfect balance of sweet and savory. The dough is always fresh and cooked to perfection. Bartolos is the humble small town pizza shop that will leave you wanting more. Run by a family that has served the Palmyra community for decades, Bartolos is certainly a lifetime favorite of mine. read more

Today's world requires consistency in served food. Bartolo's Pizza serves up quality food in generous portions at reasonable rates. An always helpful and courteous staff provide quick to the counter service, seating is available for eat in or take out service. Time sensitive orders can be assured that being in business now for more then 17 years has proven a winner. Parking is available in front of the store with more parking available past the curb on the south side. Outdoor seating is available on their very small patio with one picnic table, this is usually made accessible for Team Sports celebration parties etc. Bartolo's Pizza proudly sponsors youth Team Sports on a regular basis! I am a Regular Customer read more

Great pizza. Quick service even when there is a long order. We always call ahead and order has always been ready.