Visiting my granddaughter for the weekend. She says this is her favorite pizza place and she "knows the way to get there". The pizza was terrific and she's a pizza snob. Owners and staff are so very kind and efficient. Quick service even for the hungriest of five year olds. Small place but huge on taste. She prefers to eat in, as oppose to take-out. Thank you Fabio & Joe for the great pizza and hospitality. We'll be back again. read more

Fabio & Joe's - Italian Near Me - Palmyra, Pennsylvania

See all

tuna sub was kinda just bland and i kept getting creepy stares and sketchy vibes from one of the workers. The last time i went there was in January 2025. Haven't been back since. read more

I get lunch delivered from Fabio's every Friday, and I've literally never tasted anything that is NOT delicious! I don't know how they do it, but literally everything they make (and they have a massive menu) is great. I love their pizza, fresh cut fries, fried zucchini, and they also have this chocolate cake that I literally crave, it's so good!! read more

We ordered through DoorDash, and I think the problem was on the DoorDash end, but some items were missing from the pizza and salad dressing. The manager this evening (I didn't get her name on 04/10 around 7-8 pm) was very helpful and offered multiple solutions to resolve the issue. She did just that--Frank delivered my next pizza hot and delicious, and he was respectful. Both parties were apologetic about the problem, and I will definitely order again, but this time directly for delivery instead of through DoorDash. Best pizza I've found in palmyra!! read more

Everything service was fast. They were polite and delivery was precise time. I recommend them to anyone that wants to have good service and good food read more

Cozy atmosphere. Great plain pizza with "slightly burnt cheese" just the way I like it. Dough seems to be very fresh and homemade. The dough is the most important part, and they get that right, because it is soft and doughy, and it is not over-baked or hard. The cheese is the second most important, and they get that right too. Not too much cheese, and it is perfectly melted and even "burnt" (well done) in all the right places. This is a true New York or Philly style place. Also, I think the owner is 100% Italian, which helps make it even more authentic. Perfect spot for a winter pizza. Smells great when you walk in. read more

This place has great pizza!!! We ordered take out and were surprised by just how good it was. We also ordered buffalo chicken egg rolls and ended up with pizza rolls.. they were not very good.. but we would def order from this place again since the pizza was so good. read more

best pizza spot in town you'll love it to death! i bought the open sign with the pizza slice on it. i love the shop would highly recommend this spot if you're in the area or a little further best employees your going to ever find at a pizza shop read more

Order a Margherita pizza. Sub par. No sauce. Was essentially a white pizza with diced tomato's and basil. Over priced for what it is. Me and my 3 year old make pizzas and she makes better pizza than that. First slice I picked up had a piece of plastic that I bit into. Delivery driver forgot my drink, plates and cups. Although he did run back and get them so he's earned one of the stars. Not authentic. Wouldn't touch this place with the dog sh*t on the bottom of my shoe. read more

Fabio & Joe's - Margherita Pizza - Italian Near Me - Palmyra, Pennsylvania

Best pizza in the Palmyra/ Hershey area. many other options on the menu, but the pizza is so good I rarely order something else. I have used this restaurant for numerous work lunches including salads, Italian dishes and desserts. Never has an employee who didn't rave about their food. read more

I got the pizza special two slice and a bottle drink. Pizza was good. Employee was friendly. read more

See all

Ok so, we are visiting here in Hershey, PA and found this little pizza place. Let me say we weren't disappointed. My wrap and cannoli were amazing. My husband got the meat lovers pizza and he said it was amazing. I snuck a bite and omg so yummy. Highly recommend this place if you're looking for something yummy. read more

See all

We ordered a large pepperoni pizza and it was great! From the sauce to the dough, the pizza was just good!

I love their food it's always fresh. Especially the funnel cake fries. Deliveries are on time. Excellent food.

Great pizza, good salads. Run by Italian families so the quality and commitment to making good food is important. Definitely a must try place. read more

The buffalo chicken salad was SO good! The bread-garlic twisty thing that came with it make me audibly mmmmm happy food sounds (there may have been a happy dance in my seat as well.) The veal parm was just okay...is processed veal a thing? The kids hamburger was way better then it had any right to be at a pizza place, lol. We didn't get pizza, but I look forward to trying it, it looked and smelled amazing! Will absolutely be going back often! Can't wait to try the rest of the menu! read more

I used to love their hoagies, the bread seemed to be made fresh and was so soft; especially compared to the bread A&M's had. They had this bread since at least 2013 through early 2022, but I went the other day and it's now bought bread. Just isn't the same. Service is still quick. read more

Hands down the best pizza shop (in my opinion) in the surrounding area! We haven't had a single food item from here yet to disappoint! They have some of the greatest pizza shop cheesesteaks I've ever had. There pizza is super tasteful. The establishment is small. But the employees, seemed nice when we've been there. We are always ordering through Door Dash! read more

We order delivery from them all the time. The food is always delivered in a timely manner. And it is always good.

Delicious pizza! Hit the spot. I ordered on "slice" and my order was ready at the time specified. I walked in and an employee helped me right away. It was really hot in there, so don't eat "in" in the summer read more

I've lived in Palmyra for about 2.5 years and have eaten here consistently. I've tried all the local pizza and this is definitely the best. Eggplant parm sub is a personal favorite. Icing on the cake is the friendly family that runs the place. Love Fabio and Joes! read more

Not handicapped accessible, not even handrails. But everything I've had to eat was fantastic. I haven't had their pizza in a while. I'll have it for dinner tonight. It's a short ten mile drive but worth the wait snd it's still hot when I get home. read more

After visiting Hershey Park on a 90 degree day and then being rained out in the evening, we didn't want to go out to dinner when we arrived back to our hotel. I did an online search for local pizza (we love New York style) that delivered and took a chance on Fabio and Joe's based on positive rating. We were not disappointed! The estimated wait time was 1+ hour. Our food arrived in ~30 minutes, piping hot, and it was absolutely delicious. read more

Stopped here for first time today for there special 2 cheese slice with drink for $5 , full sub with fries and drink for 6.99 and bowl soup for 3.99 .. The staff is very nice and polite .. I would suggest take out if your coming with alot of ppl it is a very small shop .. Pizza was excellent good temp .. The fries great the cheese steak was well i just wasnt a big fan of the meat alittle rubbery alao the sauce waa pretty tomato chuncky . the soup was pretty watered down so i wouldnt recommend that .. Again this waa my first time here .. But i would return for pizza forsure .. And i mean 4 star because what are pizza joints suppose to execute well .. We'll pizza read more

Fabio & Joe's - Pizza , sub fries and soup - Italian Near Me - Palmyra, Pennsylvania

Best onion rings I've had anywhere!! Pizza is very good,Italian sub, wonderful, but, not enough meat in steak sandwich,for me. I requested extra meat when ordering but barely any and I paid extra!! You can see mostly bun rather than meat.Everything else is great, friendly personnel. read more

The food here is excellent. Delivery was swift and courteous. I would choose Fabio & Joe's again for certain!

Visiting from out of town, we ordered for delivery at our hotel. The calling in process was pretty chaotic. I think I talked to 3 different people without knowing that they were passing me around. Delivery was quick, they said 45 min and that's exactly what it took. The delivery woman had a mask, no gloves and wasn't very kind by any means. The pizzas were huge! I got a boneless buffalo wings (very good), a large meat lovers pizza and a medium pepperoni pizza to feed 5 and we could have easily fed 8-9. Overall I'd give the pizza 7/10. The pizza has a lot of flop to it, likely due to the overall size and slice size. My biggest criticism was either the sausage or ham on the pizza tasted sweet. I couldn't tell if it was breakfast sausage or honey ham, either way it threw off the overall taste pretty significantly. read more

Tried this place for the first time a couple days ago. We got 2 large pizzas, and 2 personal pans. One of them was a combo, and that one was great. Very flavorful. Cheese was for the kids, and they seemed happy enough. Personal pan BBQ chicken was just OK. Personal pan Hawaiin was good, but a little scarce on the toppings. Only thing I will say is the person cutting the personal pan pizzas must have been drunk, because I did not end up with 4 even slices. No biggie on that one though. 4 stars, not 5, because it was quite pricy compared to other places in the area. read more

I ordered a buffalo chicken wrap and I was the only one inside the place. It took 34 minutes for them to make it. Didn't come with blue cheese as requested. No chips inside the place. The chicken was just an over cooked chicken finger dropped in the deep fryer. read more

I wish I had taken a picture of my amazing stromboli. I tried to order the medium but the waitress advised that it would be really big, so I got the personal size (still pretty big!). Stuffed with sausage, garlic, spinach and cheese with a side of marinara--so yummy. The spaghetti and meatballs was just ok - the sauce was a bit sweet for my taste and the meatballs on the small side. Stick with the pizza and you won't be disappointed! read more

Stopped for pizza. It was ok, just ok. Ingredients good, cookery good, but the dough was very tough. They should ditch the dough rollers. They squeeze all the air bubbles out and make a tough crust. Not from here. Jersey guy. Would try another pizza place if I had a do-over. read more

Margherita pizza was pretty good and the fries were good crinkle cut ones. The salads were also a decent size and had fresh ingredients. We were however disappointed to see that none of the staff had masks on so we did not feel the safest. Will be sticking to other pizza places until the pandemic is over. read more

Food is mediocre at best. None of the employees were wearing masks when I picked up food for a friend. Will not recommend or return.

The Buffalo Chicken pizza here is awesome, and I've been a returning customer, but I do have to complain that occasionally, you have to re-ask for a discount on their specials. For instance, they'll offer two one-topping pizzas for X amount. When I show up to pick them up, the total comes up higher. I ask about the discount, and they apply it... I don't know whether it's an honest mistake or forgetfulness, or whether it's dishonest practices. They've never not given the discount when asked, but I had someone else pick up and pay for our pizzas once, and she didn't know to ask again for the discount and ended up paying almost $6 more... wasn't too happy after that. read more

Great local "hole in the wall" pizza and pasta joint. Gluten free pizza was great. Spaghetti and meatball with house made vodka sauce could not have been better. Don't expect luxury in the small dining area but that adds to the lure. read more

Fantastic pizza joint! I'm sure the locals know about it, but give it a try if you're in town for Hershey.

Food is always good at Fabio & Joe's. Pizza is perfect and the subs are tasty. Seriously the best roast beef subs around. They use a high quality meat and it's always delicious. The pasta dishes are also delicious and you get a lot of food for the money. We frequent this place often since we are local. read more

Love these guys and their pizza. Discovered them a month ago when we moved to Palmyra after years of living in AZ and eating fake cheese pizza. PLUS they deliver. We order the White Pizza and the Special Pizza. read more

The best pizza in the area! The sauce and cheese are packed with flavor and the dough always fresh. Have ordered delivery a few times now over the past month and it always arrives faster than expected. Also the prices are reasonable for the quality of food. read more

Great bruschetta pizza. I have not tried other pizzas but I would image they would be good as well. read more

See all