Amazing pizza and subs excellent prices and the garlic basil crust cheese pizza is to die for eaten 6 of them in the past 2 weeks just saying definitely you should try it you won't be disappointed.... read more

Pretty tasty Stromboli, Cajun fries work as well.....only things Ive ever really ordered from here dating back at least a decade or 2 ;). Wife likes their pizza.... read more

We enjoyed our Friday night takeout from Allen's Eatery last night! I got the American Chef Salad which had ham and cheese rolled up with hard boiled egg, beautiful whole bell pepper rings, sliced tomatoes, and oil and vinegar dressing. The rest of the family got pizza, which they enjoyed. We were told the stromboli is also very tasty--guess we'll have to go back! read more

Allen's Eatery - American Chef - Pizza Near Me - Lewisberry, Pennsylvania

Great little place to stop in for a bite to eat! The prices are so affordable, but the food is even better! I really enjoyed a ham and cheese on a pretzel bun with a side of fries, and my boyfriend loved his Italian grinder! The inside of the restaurant was simple, but comfortable, and the staff were very friendly. If I come back to the area, I know I gotta stop back in for another good meal! read more

The Stromboli and the anniversary style pizza are AMAZING! The owner and staff are friendly and helpful. read more

See all

Pizza is excellent boli rocks. Nice little hidden gem. Fast service, good people, go grab a slice! read more

Allen's Eatery - Pizza and Stromboli A+ - Pizza Near Me - Lewisberry, Pennsylvania

Been going to Allen's since I was a kid. Pizza is decent, I think it has gotten better over the last few years. Stromboli's are really good imop. Lots of nostalgia in this place for me so I'm biased. But overall it's a decent place to eat! read more

It seems like every single time I order from them some part of my order is wrong. I have lived in this area for 14 years and over the years have given them my business only to be disappointed over and over again. This last time I ordered eight pieces of chicken and six of them were burnt and then when they replaced them the chicken was extremely salty! Since you usually don't get salty fried Chicken I can only surmise that they did that on purpose because I made them make me more. I will never ever order from them again!!!! read more

I stopped at Allen's Eatery today because it is halfway between my Harrisburg and York offices. I needed to pick up lunch for work. Everyone was very accommodating! I ordered several Pizza's and Stromboli's. The quality is excellent! Everyone said it was delicious! The crust is flaky and very good. I will not hesitate to stop again! read more

I started eating Stromboli from Allen's when I was a little girl my daughter's age. Today, we traveled back to give her her first taste. Still as amazing as I remember!! An all around thin crust, tons of meat and cheese, and perfect marinara dipping sauce. Fried Cauliflower is also super delicious! read more

Allen's Eatery - World famous, in my eyes anyway, Stromboli! - Pizza Near Me - Lewisberry, Pennsylvania

I love this place. I've been eating here for 23 years. The Stromboli is by far the best I've ever had. When I'm away and I order Stromboli I am always so disappointed. Allen's boli is all meat and cheese! The crust is thin which I enjoy. Make sure you order a side of sauce so you can dunk your pieces in there marinara. Pizzas are very good as well, I always enjoy the pepperoni with extra cheese. Subs are good as well, however they are not fancy. Get sweet peppers, sweet peppers make everything taste great! read more

Do not, I repeat, do not order the wings here. I've never in my life received wings that were breaded and fried like chicken fingers. Terrible, horrible, awful, and only worthy of the garbage can. read more

Allen's Eatery - Breaded and fried wings. Do not order these! - Pizza Near Me - Lewisberry, Pennsylvania

Excellent food, well priced, and a friendly staff. Easy local take out choice. Everything even down to the apps and soups is great.

We have been ordering (as well as some of our neighbors) for years and we absolutely love the professionalism, the courtesy and prompt delivery. Our pizzas we order (always order extra crispy) are always delivered hot, prompt and always delicious!!! Ryan takes our order and always delivers what we request! We love Allen's Eatery.....THANK YOU!!! Look forward to our next delivery!!! The Love's read more

Really nice bathrooms. The sink had nice handles for easy and ergonomic handle for easy and comfortable use. The pizza were really good to. And the pizza crust was easy to grip to shove in my mouth. Altogether, really good, for stars read more

Yummy goodness. Get the fried ravioli! Our go to place. Everyone is very nice, professional, and the place is clean.

Pizza was alright, but the manager was so mean to the staff as well as customers. I went to go get hand sanitizer and he said "well you could ask next time?" I thought he was joking, so my friend went to try and get some and he said, "no, I'm serious." So, we left and will NEVER go back there;) read more

my god people...seriously?? i ordered your supreme pizza last night. around 7pm. i walked in and ordered. 2 hours after i ate it i was on the toilet with severe diarrhea. its 5am as i write this. im up early because i been vomitting pizza all morning. im also hunched over in severe heartburn pain.. thats from using a cheap generic canned sauce. i mean really? you can't make a fresh sauce????? im also guessing your ingredients were old. i should not be this sick from just canned sauce. i hate you guya forever...i will shout from rooftops to make sure people don't order from you...lord have mercy on children who eat there!! read more

This pizza place use to be my favorite pizza joint, but not now. It has gone down hill. The pizza use to be delicious, lots of cheese, yummy sauce and a nice dough. Now the dough is bland, barely any cheese and overall no flavor. My recommendation to the owner would be to go back to the way it was and fast. I won't be going back anytime soon. read more